Trackem Pty Ltd v Revenue Partners

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   TRACKEM PTY LTD (ACN 168 532 269) -v- REVENUE PARTNERS (A PARTNERSHIP) [2021] WASC 245

CORAM:   ARCHER J

HEARD:   20 MAY 2021 & 8 JUNE 2021

DELIVERED          :   26 JULY 2021

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2426 of 2019

BETWEEN:   TRACKEM PTY LTD (ACN 168 532 269)

Plaintiff (First Defendant by Counterclaim)

TRACKEM HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 621 879 150)

Second Defendant by Counterclaim

KASHIF SALEEM

Third Defendant by Counterclaim

AND

REVENUE PARTNERS (A PARTNERSHIP)

First Defendant

REVENUE PARTNERS PTY LTD (ACN 622 084 673)

Second Defendant (First Plaintiff by Counterclaim)

REVENUE PARTNERS CONSULTING PTY LTD (ACN 625 055 941)

Third Defendant (Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim)

STEPHEN PATRICK McNALLY

Fourth Defendant (Third Plaintiff by Counterclaim)

KEYT JOHN ATKINSON

Fifth Defendant (Fourth Plaintiff by Counterclaim)


Catchwords:

Application to strike out parts of pleading - Factual foundation - Sufficient particularity - Ambiguity as to fraud

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Application granted, parts of pleading struck out

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff (First Defendant by Counterclaim) : Mr M L Bennett & Mr M Pullen
Second Defendant by Counterclaim : Mr M L Bennett & Mr M Pullen
Third Defendant by Counterclaim : Mr T J Porter
First Defendant : Mr M Holler
Second Defendant (First Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Mr M Holler
Third Defendant (Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Mr M Holler
Fourth Defendant (Third Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Mr M Holler
Fifth Defendant (Fourth Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Mr M Holler

Solicitors:

Plaintiff (First Defendant by Counterclaim) : Bennett + Co
Second Defendant by Counterclaim : Bennett + Co
Third Defendant by Counterclaim : Barry Nilsson Lawyers
First Defendant : Greg  Carter  Barrister & Solicitor
Second Defendant (First Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Greg  Carter  Barrister & Solicitor
Third Defendant (Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Greg  Carter  Barrister & Solicitor
Fourth Defendant (Third Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Greg  Carter  Barrister & Solicitor
Fifth Defendant (Fourth Plaintiff by Counterclaim) : Greg  Carter  Barrister & Solicitor

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

3meg.com Pty Ltd v TM & SM Pike Pty Ltd [2012] WASCA 128; (2012) 43 WAR 350

AVWest Aircraft Pty Ltd v Bombardier Inc [No 2] [2020] WASC 392

Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority [2006] WASC 281; (2006) 33 WAR 82

Commissioner of Taxation v Auctus Resources Pty Ltd [2021] FCAFC 39

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Lafferty [2017] WASC 257

English v Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd [2021] WASCA 47

F & G Nominees Pty Ltd v Verdell Pty Ltd [2003] WASCA 290

Forrest v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2012] HCA 39; (2012) 247 CLR 483

Jingellic Minerals NL v Abigroup Ltd (1992) 7 WAR 566

Metaxas v Legal Profession Complaints Committee [2020] WASCA 27

Murphy v State of Victoria & Anor [2014] VSCA 238; (2014) 289 FLR 337

National Australia Bank Limited v Rowe [2018] WASC 330

Oldfield Knott Architects Pty Ltd v Ortiz Investments Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 255

Patrick Jebb as trustee for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trackem Pty Ltd v Revenue Partners and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASC 245
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Trackem Pty Ltd v Revenue Partners, the plaintiff, Trackem, sought to have certain parts of the defendant's pleadings struck out on the basis that they were legally insufficient and ambiguous. The case was heard in the Supreme Court, where the defendants had filed a Sixth Defence and Counterclaim, challenging Trackem's entitlement to a research and development tax offset. Trackem argued that the defendants' pleadings were insufficiently particularised, and that they contained ambiguous statements regarding fraud. The defendants, however, argued that the conclusive evidence provision did not prevent them from proving Trackem was not entitled to the R&D offset.

The court was required to decide whether the defendants' pleadings were legally sufficient and particularised enough to establish a cause of action in misleading or deceptive conduct. The court had to consider the scope of the conclusive evidence provision, which provides that a notice of assessment is conclusive evidence that an assessment was properly made, and that the amounts and particulars in the assessment are correct. The court also had to consider whether the defendants had adequately pleaded a cause of action in misleading or deceptive conduct.

The court found that it was unnecessary to determine the scope of the operation of the conclusive evidence provision at that stage of the proceedings. The court held that the pleading of Trackem Representation 15 in the Sixth Defence and Counterclaim was plainly embarrassing and impossible to discern how Trackem's representation that it would receive an R&D tax offset could constitute misleading or deceptive conduct when Trackem did receive the R&D tax offset. The court found that the pleading was embarrassing even without having regard to the conclusive evidence provision. The court therefore granted the application and struck out the challenged pleadings.

The court's reasoning and outcome in this case are significant for future cases involving the conclusive evidence provision and pleadings in misleading or deceptive conduct cases. The court's decision highlights the importance of particularity and clarity in pleadings, and the need for parties to ensure that their pleadings are legally sufficient and particularised enough to establish a cause of action. The court's decision also highlights the importance of the plain meaning of the words in the conclusive evidence provision, and the need for parties to consider the purpose of the provision when pleading causes of action in misleading or deceptive conduct cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Result:

Application granted, parts of pleading struck out

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

By s 350-10(1) item 2 of the TAA, a notice of assessment is conclusive evidence that an assessment was properly made, and, except in proceedings under Part IVC of the TAA in a review or appeal relating to the assessment, that the amounts and particulars in the assessment are correct (conclusive evidence provision). Given the passage of time, the assessment in this case could now only be amended if the Commissioner is of the opinion that there has been fraud or evasion. The defendants have expressly disavowed an allegation of fraud. The defendants submitted, however, that the conclusive evidence provision does not prevent them from proving Trackem was not entitled to the R&D offset. They submitted that the provision only operates in proceedings involving the recovery of tax. The parties filed, with leave, 'short' submissions on this point after the hearing on 8 June 2021. In broad terms, the defendants emphasised the purpose of the provision, relied on statements that had been made in the context of judicial review proceedings, sought to distinguish Re Tomker, and asserted that a broader operation would lead to a manifestly absurd result. The Trackem parties emphasised the plain meaning of the words, sought to distinguish the judicial review cases, and submitted Re Tomker was a clear example of a broader operation of the provision. Mr Saleem submitted, in effect, that it did not matter. First, he submitted that the issue in these proceedings is whether an entitlement to an R&D tax offset exists, as between the taxpayer and the Commissioner. He pointed out that there is no dispute that an entitlement presently exists and that the entitlement cannot be disturbed unless the Commissioner is of the opinion that there has been fraud or evasion. He pointed out that fraud or evasion is not alleged. Second, he submitted that, regardless of the operation of the conclusive evidence provision, the defendants have not adequately pleaded a cause of action in misleading or deceptive conduct because they have not pleaded material facts that, if found, are capable of establishing that the entitlement does not exist. I have reached the view that it is unnecessary, at this stage, to determine the scope of the operation of the conclusive evidence provision. I intend no disrespect to the helpful submissions filed by the defendants and the Trackem parties on that issue. It may become necessary to deal with the point in the substantive hearing, depending on what is ultimately pleaded. However, it is not necessary for the purposes of resolving the current application. As will be seen, I consider that the pleading is embarrassing even without having regard to the conclusive evidence provision. In short, I agree with Mr Saleem's submissions. The pleading of Trackem Representation 15 in the Sixth Defence and Counterclaim was plainly embarrassing. It was impossible for the reader to discern how Trackem's representation that it would receive an R&D tax offset could constitute misleading or deceptive conduct when Trackem did receive the R&D tax offset.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The background to the litigation is set out in my judgment on the strike out application (Strike Out Decision). These reasons should be read in conjunction with that decision. However, for convenience, I will set out here, or summarise, relevant parts of the decision. On 16 November 2018, Trackem lodged a writ of summons in the District Court. On 20 March 2019, a Statement of Claim was filed. On 10 June 2019, a defence and counterclaim was filed. On 17 July 2019, the matter was remitted to the Supreme Court by consent. Multiple amendments to the defence and counterclaim followed. The matter was admitted to my CMC List on 9 July 2020. On 24 December 2020, the Trackem parties filed an application to strike out parts of the defendants' fifth defence and counterclaim.[78][78] Third Further Amended Defence and Third Further Amended Counterclaim filed 20 July 2020. On 10 February 2021, the defendants filed a minute of what would be their sixth defence and counterclaim (Sixth Defence and Counterclaim).[79] [79] Minute of Fourth Further Amended Defence and Fourth Further Amended Counterclaim filed 10 February 2021. To accommodate the changes reflected in the Sixth Defence and Counterclaim, the Trackem parties filed an amended strike out application on 18 February 2021 (Application). The pleading challenged in the Application was as follows:1.Trackem and Mr Saleem represented that Trackem was entitled to a research and development tax offset (R&D tax offset) which would be around $213,000 (Trackem Representation 14);2.Trackem and Mr Saleem represented that Trackem would receive an R&D tax offset of $205,529 (Trackem Representation 15); The Application was listed for 29 May 2021. During the hearing, counsel for the defendants submitted that the challenged pleading did not involve any allegation of fraud. He submitted that Trackem's claim to have conducted R&D activities could have been wrongly made through carelessness, inattention to detail, lack of supervision, or lack of understanding of the requirements. Counsel explained that the point of the allegation was not directed to whether or not Trackem was a company that did substantial research and development. The defendants were not alleging that they would not have invested in a company unless it was engaged in substantial research and development. Rather, the defendants' case was that they would not have invested in a company that had poor processes and systems. The defendants' case was, in effect, that, having been told that Trackem was entitled to, and would receive, an R&D tax offset, if they had known that it was not so entitled, they would have known that the company had poor processes and systems and would not have wanted to invest in it. In the Strike Out Decision, I used the expression 'competent company' to mean a company with proper processes and systems. I noted:In the context of the tax legislation, it is difficult to see how the defendants will prove that Trackem was not entitled to the offset. However, this is a matter for trial, not pleading.What is a matter for pleading is that none of this could be gleaned from the Sixth Defence and Counterclaim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.