JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
TITLE OF COURT : THE FULL COURT (WA)
CITATION: F & G NOMINEES PTY LTD -v- VERDELL PTY LTD [2003] WASCA 290
CORAM: ANDERSON J
PARKER J
MCKECHNIE J
HEARD: 7 MAY 2003
DELIVERED : 26 NOVEMBER 2003
PUBLISHED : 27 NOVEMBER 2003
FILE NO/S: FUL 76 of 2002
BETWEEN: F & G NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 008 834 517)
Appellant (Defendant)
AND
VERDELL PTY LTD
Respondent (Plaintiff)AND
F & G NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 008 834 517)
Appellant (Plaintiff)AND
CORSER & CORSER
Respondent (Defendant)
Catchwords:
Leases - Provision for key money - Whether payment of a premium is key money - Whether provision void - Whether payment to third party constitutes key money
Contracts - Constriction of terms of agreement - Whether extrinsic evidence admissible to establish payment of key money
Solicitors - Liability for damages for negligence - Whether loss of chance properly pleaded - Whether liable to indemnify an illegal payment
Legislation:
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985
Result:
Appeals dismissed
Category: A
Representation:
Counsel:
Appellant (Defendant) : Mr D H Solomon & Mr M A R Blundell
Respondent (Plaintiff) : Mr J Gilmour QC & Mr C D Belyea
Appellant (Plaintiff) : Mr D H Solomon & Mr M A R Blundell
Respondent (Defendant) : Mr K J Martin QC & Ms F C E Davis
Solicitors:
Appellant (Defendant) : Solomon Brothers
Respondent (Plaintiff) : Clayton Utz
Appellant (Plaintiff) : Solomon Brothers
Respondent (Defendant) : Phillips Fox
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Clever Management Pty Ltd & Anor v Van den Bergh & Anor, unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 960593; 11 October 1996
Codelfa Constructions Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1981) 149 CLR 337
Elmdene Estates Ltd v White [1960] AC 528
J K Corporation Pty Ltd v Dileum Pty Ltd, unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 8901159; 5 April 1989
March v Stramare (E & M H) Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506
Metcalf & Kerr v Permanent Building Society (In Liq) (1993) 10 WAR 145
O F Gamble Pty Ltd v Whitemore Pty Ltd (1989) 2 WAR 327
O F Gamble Pty Ltd v Whitemore Pty Ltd (1990) 2 WAR 327
Palser v Grinling [1948] AC 291
Pao On v Lau Yiu Long [1980] AC 614
Van den Bergh v Clever Management Pty Ltd & Anor, unreported; FCt SCt of WA; Library No 970319; 20 June 1997
Verdell Pty Ltd v F & G Nominees Pty Ltd & Anor [2002] WASC 58
Verdell Pty Ltd v F & G Nominees Pty Ltd [2002] WASC 58(S)
Warwick Entertainment Centre Pty Ltd v McKenzie [2000] WASCA 283
Whitemore Pty Ltd v O F Gamble Pty Ltd (1991) 6 WAR 110
Case(s) also cited:
A Chip & Pulp Co Pty Ltd v Arthur Young & Co (1987) 12 ACLR 25; (1987) 5 ACLC 1002
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read F & G Nominees Pty Ltd v Verdell Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] WASCA 290
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the lease extension deed was indeed a retail shop lease as defined in the Act, and it was executed after the Act came into effect. The court found that the payment of $200,000 was a provision for key money and was therefore void. The court further ruled that the payment of $120,000 made pursuant to the lease was also considered key money and was recoverable. The court rejected the argument that extrinsic evidence could not be used to prove the true nature of the payment, stating that the claim was for enforcement of a statutory right and not an action on the deed itself. The court found that the pleadings did not preclude Verdell Pty Ltd from making its claim based on the true nature of the payment.
In conclusion, the Supreme Court of South Australia ruled that the payment of key money in connection with the lease extension was void and unenforceable under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act. Both the $80,000 and the $120,000 payments were deemed recoverable. The court also allowed Verdell Pty Ltd to use extrinsic evidence to prove the true nature of the payment. The decision upheld the statutory protection against key money in retail shop leases.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: PARKER J
I would dispose of the appeal in the following way. The finding that the deed of extension from 1 June 1994 to 31 May 1999 was the relevant lease for the purposes of the application of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act is correct. It is that document which conferred the right of occupancy for the extended period and that is sufficient to satisfy the definition of "lease" in the Act. J K Corporation Pty Ltd v Dileum Pty Ltd, unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 8901159; 5 April 1989; O F Gamble Pty Ltd v Whitemore Pty Ltd (1990) 2 WAR 327; Whitemore (supra). This was a lease which was entered into subsequent to 1 September 1985 and hence it was a lease to which the Act applied. I agree that the lease was a retail shop lease as defined in the Act. I would not interfere with the finding that the deed of extension was executed "on or about" 17 July 1989 by which time Entertainment Enterprises Limited had converted to a proprietary company. This it had done on 7 November 1988. The finding that the lease therefore does not fall within the exception contained in the definition of "retail shop lease", which in effect excludes leases held by a corporation which is a subsidiary of a public company, was correct. The finding that there was an arrangement containing a provision for the payment of a premium of $200,000 in connection with the deed of extension giving a right of occupancy of the premises until 31 May 1999 was correct. It follows that the provision contained in that arrangement was deemed to be included in the deed of extension (the retail shop lease) executed on or about 17 July 1989 and is void and any moneys payable under it are recoverable. The provision in cl 3(a) of the lease to the effect that the landlord was entitled to $120,000 was a provision entitling the landlord to key money in connection with the entering into that lease. That provision is therefore also void and any money paid pursuant to it is recoverable. On this analysis both the $80,000 and the $120,000 are recoverable. These conclusions do not depend on a proper construction of the deed but on her Honour's findings as to the true substance of the arrangement between the parties. They do not depend on any detailed analysis as to whether the premium was paid in connection with a 10 year lease or a 5 year lease. A good deal of time was spent by counsel for F&G Nominees Pty Ltd in an endeavour to persuade us that it was not open to Verdell Pty Ltd to rely on evidence extrinsic to the deed itself to prove the true nature of the payment of $120,000 referred to in the deed. As I understood his argument, counsel for F&G Nominees Pty Ltd contended that Verdell Pty Ltd's claim in respect to the nature of the payment of $120,000 must stand or fall on a proper construction of the deed itself without resort to extrinsic evidence. I am not prepared to accept that submission. Verdell Pty Ltd's claim is for enforcement of a statutory right. It is not an action on the deed and does not depend for its success on a construction of the deed. It is not a case in which Verdell Pty Ltd is seeking to enforce the deed according to its proper construction. Verdell Pty Ltd comes to Court to say that whatever may be the words of the deed the true nature of the payment was key money. We heard much argument about the pleadings but I can see nothing in the manner in which the claim is pleaded which would preclude Verdell Pty Ltd from putting its claim in that way.