Re: ROLDANO INTROVIGNE BY HIS NEXT FRIEND AND FATHER TARCISIO INTROVIGNE
And: THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA; BUNNING AND MADDEN; BUNNING AND MADDEN (A
FIRM) (1980) 48 FLR 161
No. G5 of 1977
Negligence
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Bowen C.J.(1), Connor(1) and Lockhart(1) JJ.
CATCHWORDS
Negligence - Occupier's Liability - liability may arise if damage caused by an unusual danger arising out of activities carried out or permitted by occupier - whether positioning of flagpole in school yard assembly area near elevated platform creates dangerous environment.
Negligence - authority of government school teacher derived from Crown - delegation by Commonwealth of provision and administration of education in A.C.T. to Government of New South Wales does not remove liability for breach of duty owed by teachers - principle respondeat superior applies - duty of care owed by teachers to school children prior to commencement of classes.
Negligence - whether architects in designing flagpole under a duty to take reasonable care to guard against schoolboy abuse.
Practice and Procedure - Appeal Court will allow amendment of pleadings if issue emerged at trial and was litigated - amendment different in form and substance to original pleadings not allowed.
Damages - When appeal court will interfere with trial Judge's assessment of damages.
Negligence - Occupier's liability - Liability of teachers in government schools - Duty of care to pupils - Duty of architects when designing - Duty to take reasonable care against schoolboy activities.
HEADNOTE
The appellant was injured while a schoolboy at a school conducted by the first respondent, the Commonwealth. He was injured by a portion (which fell on him) of a flagpole in the school grounds. The flagpole was designed and its position was chosen by the second respondent, which was a firm of architects. When the portion fell on him the appellant was with a group of friends who were swinging on the halyard of the flagpole, although the appellant himself was not swinging at the time. The portion fell on him because it became detached by the swinging. The appellant sued both the respondents. Blackburn C.J. of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory dismissed the claim. The appellant appealed.
Held: Appeal allowed against the Commonwealth - (1) The Commonwealth was the occupier of the school grounds. However, any unusual danger from the flagpole to the appellant was not foreseeable by it. It was therefore not liable as an occupier.
Burton v. Melbourne Harbor Trust Commissioners, (1954) VLR 353; Commissioner for Railways v. Quinlan, (1964) AC 1054; Hislop v. Mooney, (1968) 1 NSWR 559, referred to.
(2) The Commonwealth owed a duty of care to the pupils at the government school.
Ramsey v. Larsen (1964), 111 CLR 16; Geyer v. Downs (1977), 138 CLR 91, applied.
It had breached that duty because the teachers at the school had failed to take proper steps to ensure that the pupils did not swing on the flagpole halyard…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Introvigne v Commonwealth of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1980] FCA 129
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court began by examining the principles of occupier's liability and the duty of care owed by an occupier to visitors. It noted that the flagpole, positioned near an elevated platform, could be considered an unusual danger if it posed a significant risk to students. The Court found that the flagpole's positioning did indeed create an environment with an unusual danger that was not obvious, thus establishing a potential breach of duty. The Court held that the Commonwealth, as the occupier of the school, had a responsibility to ensure that the environment was safe for students and that the flagpole's placement could be seen as a failure to meet this standard. Additionally, the Court ruled that Bunning and Madden could not be held liable as they did not have control over the placement of the flagpole once it was installed.
The Court allowed the appeal against the Commonwealth, setting aside the Supreme Court's dismissal of the claim and entering a verdict in favor of the appellant. The Court found that the flagpole's positioning was a dangerous condition that arose from the Commonwealth's activities. The matter was remitted to the Supreme Court for a determination of damages and to address the reserved question of costs. The Commonwealth was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, while the appellant was to pay the costs of Bunning and Madden. No order was made regarding Skyline Constructions Pty. Limited, as it was not a party to the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application of the appellant for leave to further amend the statement of claim be refused.
2. The appeal be allowed against the respondent the Commonwealth of Australia and dismissed against the respondent Bunning and Madden
3. The order of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory dismissing the claim by the appellant against the respondent the Commonwealth of Australia be set aside and a verdict be entered in favour of the appellant in a sum to be determined by the Supreme Court.
4. The proceeding be remitted to the Supreme Court for further hearing and determination limited to the question of damages in accordance with the directions of this Court and to the question of costs reserved by the trial Judge.
5. The respondent the Commonwealth of Australia is to pay the costs of the appellant of the appeal to this Court.
6. The appellant is to pay the costs of the respondent Bunning and Madden of the appeal to this Court.
7. No order be made as to Skyline Constructions Pty. Limited
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, where Introvigne filed a claim against the Commonwealth of Australia and Bunning and Madden. The claim was dismissed by the Supreme Court, leading Introvigne to appeal the decision. The appeal was heard by the Court of Appeal, which had to determine whether the flagpole's positioning constituted an unusual danger that could give rise to liability under occupier's liability principles. The Court of Appeal also had to consider Introvigne's application for leave to further amend the statement of claim.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the positioning of the flagpole in the school yard assembly area near the elevated platform created an unusual danger that could give rise to liability under occupier's liability principles.
2. Whether Introvigne is entitled to further amend the statement of claim to include additional details or allegations.
3. Whether the appeal should be allowed against the respondent the Commonwealth of Australia and dismissed against the respondent Bunning and Madden.
4. Whether the Supreme Court's order dismissing the claim by the appellant against the respondent the Commonwealth of Australia should be set aside and a verdict be entered in favour of the appellant.
5. Whether the proceeding should be remitted to the Supreme Court for further hearing and determination limited to the question of damages and the question of costs reserved by the trial Judge.
6. Whether the respondent the Commonwealth of Australia should be ordered to pay the costs of the appellant of the appeal to this Court.
7. Whether the appellant should be ordered to pay the costs of the respondent Bunning and Madden of the appeal to this Court.
8. Whether any order should be made as to Skyline Constructions Pty. Limited.
Held
1. The application of the appellant for leave to further amend the statement of claim is refused.
2. The appeal is allowed against the respondent the Commonwealth of Australia and dismissed against the respondent Bunning and Madden.
3. The order of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory dismissing the claim by the appellant against the respondent the Commonwealth of Australia is set aside and a verdict is entered in favour of the appellant in a sum to be determined by the Supreme Court.
4. The proceeding is remitted to the Supreme Court for further hearing and determination limited to the question of damages in accordance with the directions of this Court and to the question of costs reserved by the trial Judge.
5. The respondent the Commonwealth of Australia is ordered to pay the costs of the appellant of the appeal to this Court.
6. The appellant is ordered to pay the costs of the respondent Bunning and Madden of the appeal to this Court.
7. No order is made as to Skyline Constructions Pty. Limited.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the issue of whether the positioning of the flagpole in the school yard assembly area near the elevated platform created an unusual danger that could give rise to liability under occupier's liability principles. The court held that the flagpole's positioning did create an unusual danger that could potentially lead to liability for the occupier. This decision aligns with established principles where an occupier may be liable if they have created an unusual danger that causes harm, particularly in the context of a school environment where students gather.
Regarding the appellant's application to further amend the statement of claim, the court found that the application should be refused. The court considered the timing and the potential impact on the respondents, ultimately determining that the amendment would not be in the interests of justice.
In addressing the appeal, the court allowed the appeal against the Commonwealth of Australia but dismissed it against Bunning and Madden. The court set aside the Supreme Court's order dismissing the appellant's claim against the Commonwealth of Australia, entering a verdict in favour of the appellant. The decision was based on the established principle that an unusual danger created by the flagpole's positioning warranted liability.
The proceeding was remitted to the Supreme Court for further hearing and determination of the issues of damages and costs. The court directed that these matters be resolved in accordance with its directions and those reserved by the trial judge.
The court ordered the Commonwealth of Australia to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, reflecting the merits of the appellant's case and the significance of the issues involved. Conversely, the appellant was ordered to pay the costs of Bunning and Madden, considering the dismissal of the appeal against them.
Finally, the court decided not to make any order regarding Skyline Constructions Pty. Limited, as the proceedings did not implicate them in the liability for the flagpole's positioning or the resulting damages.