Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority v El Sheik

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority v El Sheik
 [2000]  FCA 931

NEGLIGENCE – personal injuries claim – injury suffered by schoolboy when kicked by schoolmate during lunchtime “playfight” – adequacy of supervision of pupils – whether there was a causal relationship between any inadequacy of supervision and injury suffered by plaintiff.

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 27

Commonwealth of Australia v Introvigne (1982) 150 CLR 258
Petreski v Cargill (1987) 18 FCR 68
Minister for Immigration v Hamsher (1992) 35 FCR 359

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY SCHOOLS AUTHORITY v EL SHEIK
A71 of 1999

WILCOX, SPENDER and HIGGINS JJ
CANBERRA
DATE:     11 JULY 2000


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

 A71 of 1999

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY SCHOOLS AUTHORITY
Appellant

AND:

EL SHEIK
Respondent

ROMEL EL SHEIK
Cross Appellant

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY SCHOOLS AUTHORITY
First Cross Respondent

RAYMOND LIVERMORE
Second Cross Respondent

JUDGES:

WILCOX, SPENDER and HIGGINS JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

11 JULY 2000

WHERE MADE:

CANBERRA

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be upheld.

2.Orders 1, 4 and 5 made by Miles CJ in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory in matter SC190 of 1999 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

(i)Judgment be entered for the first defendant against the plaintiff; and

(ii)The plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs.

3.The cross appeal be dismissed.

4.The respondent, Romel El Sheik, pay the costs of the Australian Capital Territory School Authority and Raymond Livermore of the appeal and cross-appeal.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

 A71 of 1999

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY SCHOOLS AUTHORITY
Appellant

AND:

EL SHEIK
Respondent

ROMEL EL SHEIK
Cross Appellant

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY SCHOOLS AUTHORITY
First Cross Respondent

RAYMOND LIVERMORE
Second Cross Respondent

JUDGES:

WILCOX, SPENDER and HIGGINS JJ

DATE:

11 JULY 2000

PLACE:

CANBERRA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. WILCOX J:  This is an appeal by Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority (“the Authority”) against a decision of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory (Miles CJ) in an action for negligence brought by the respondent, Romel El Sheik, against the Authority, Raymond Livermore and Tony Esposito in respect of an incident that occurred at Melba High Technology School on 18 September 1991.  Mr Livermore was the principal of the school at that time.  Mr El Sheik and Mr Esposito were pupils and, apparently, friends.  Mr El Sheik was then aged 15 years and 9 months.  Mr Esposito was apparently about the same age.

  2. It appears from the reasons of the trial judge that Mr Esposito was not able to be served with process.  Accordingly, the trial proceeded only as against the Authority and Mr Livermore.  The proceeding failed against…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority v El Sheik and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 931
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority v El Sheik, the plaintiff, Romel El Sheik, brought a personal injury claim against the Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority and Mr Raymond Livermore, a school principal, following an incident where El Sheik was kicked by a schoolmate, Mr Tony Esposito, during a lunchtime playfight. The incident resulted in significant injury to El Sheik due to an undiagnosed medical condition, thrombocytopenia, which caused him to suffer severe internal bleeding from what would otherwise have been a minor injury. The central issue before the court was whether the school authorities were negligent in their supervision of the students during lunchtime, thereby contributing to the injury El Sheik sustained.

The court was required to determine if there was a causal relationship between the alleged inadequate supervision by the school and the injury El Sheik suffered. The respondent argued that a higher ratio of supervisors to students, such as the 1:50 ratio suggested by an expert witness, Dr Ewens, would have prevented the incident. However, the court found that there was no clear causal link between the supervision ratio and the injury, as the incident occurred almost immediately and there was no evidence that a different supervision ratio would have enabled the teacher present to intervene more effectively. The court also noted that Mr Livermore, the principal, had provided a differing opinion on the adequacy of supervision, which was not adequately addressed in the lower court's judgment.

The court concluded that El Sheik had not established a causal connection between the alleged breach of duty—the failure to provide adequate supervision—and the injury he suffered. The reasoning hinged on the fact that the injury occurred almost instantaneously, and there was no indication that a different supervision ratio or a more prompt response from the supervising teacher would have made a difference. The appeal by the school authority was upheld, and the cross-appeal by El Sheik was dismissed. Consequently, the orders made by the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory were set aside, and judgment was entered in favour of the school authority with costs awarded against El Sheik.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be upheld.

2. Orders 1, 4 and 5 made by Miles CJ in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory in matter SC190 of 1999 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

(i) Judgment be entered for the first defendant against the plaintiff; and

(ii) The plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs.

3. The cross appeal be dismissed.

4. The respondent, Romel El Sheik, pay the costs of the Australian Capital Territory School Authority and Raymond Livermore of the appeal and cross-appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

When the matter came on for hearing before us, we indicated to counsel our desire to hear submissions relating to liability in advance of any submissions concerning quantum of damages. After hearing and considering submissions from both parties, in respect of the liability of both the Authority and Mr Livermore, we intimated that we proposed to allow the appeal and dismiss the cross appeal concerning the liability of Mr Livermore. Accordingly, we did not propose to deal with the issue of adequacy of damages. We stated we would publish reasons in due course and, at that time, make formal orders. These are my reasons for concluding that Mr El Sheik has failed to establish the liability of either the Authority or Mr Livermore.The facts There appears not to be any dispute that, at about 12.30pm on 18 September 1991, the respondent received an injury when he was kicked by Mr Esposito in what the respondent described as “play fight that got serious”. Under normal circumstances, it seems, the injury would have been trivial; perhaps consisting of no more than a contusion with momentary pain. Unfortunately, however, and unbeknown both to the school authorities and (apparently) Mr Esposito, the plaintiff had a congenital condition known as thrombocytopenia, which the primary judge described as “a tendency to bleed internally which gives rise to risk of serious lasting injury from relatively minor trauma”. No doubt because of this condition, the injury inflicted on the respondent by Mr Esposito has had what the primary judge described as “near disastrous consequences of what, in other circumstances, and for other persons, would be almost trifling injury”. Immediately before the incident involving the respondent and Mr Esposito, they had lunched together in the school canteen. They then walked towards the oval area, where at the time some 80 to 100 pupils were engaged in various forms of recreational activity; probably including informal soccer and rugby league games. The primary judge described what then happened:“Suddenly, ‘out of the blue’ Tony Esposito said, ‘Come on, let’s fight’. Tony Esposito started kicking the plaintiff. The plaintiff, caught by surprise, responded, ‘What are you talking about? No’. The plaintiff turned away. Tony Esposito kicked the plaintiff on the right leg. The plaintiff fell to the ground. Tony Esposito continued to kick the plaintiff on the right calf and a crowd of boys gathered. The plaintiff noticed a teacher in the vicinity. Somehow Tony Esposito was brought to the ground. The plaintiff held Tony Esposito down and told him to stop. Tony Esposito said ‘Okay’. The plaintiff got to his feet and turned to walk away. Tony Esposito resumed kicking the plaintiff hard on the leg. The other boys were shouting encouragement (to whom is not clear, probably both). The plaintiff grabbed Tony Esposito and brought him to the ground. Again he told Tony Esposito to stop and Tony Esposito agreed. The plaintiff said ‘Make sure this time’. The plaintiff released the other boy and got to his feet. He noticed that his leg was hurting and that he was limping. It was time to go into class. He went to the classroom and told the teacher ‘My leg hurts, I want to go to a doctor’. The teacher, identified in cross-examination as Mr Walker told him to go to the sick bay but the plaintiff, contrary to instruction, went to the Florey Medical Centre which was adjacent to or opposite the school.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In their outline of submissions counsel for the respondent did not address the matter of causation. When asked about this during the course of oral submissions, counsel responded that it was logical to conclude that an increase in the number of teachers in the area would have lessened the possibility of risk-creating behaviour; therefore the injury suffered by the respondent may be regarded as a consequence of the Authority and the principal not providing a greater number of supervisors.Conclusions on the appeal The trial judge’s liability finding against the Authority is expressed in elliptic language. His Honour commenced para 50 of his reasons by saying that he found the evidence of Dr Ewens “of little assistance”. Yet he went on to base his finding on that evidence. Presumably, therefore, the first sentence must be understood as meaning that Dr Ewens’ evidence was of some assistance, although perhaps to a limited degree. This is consistent with the following sentence in which his Honour observed that the evidence “confirms that there were ways in which the first defendant might have ensured that reasonable care was taken for the safety of the plaintiff by the provision of proper supervision”. In saying that, Miles CJ must have been referring to adoption of a 1:50 ratio; that was the only suggestion made by Dr Ewens in respect of “provision of proper supervision”, as distinct from comment on the reaction to the incident of the teacher who observed it. Miles CJ did not say why he was prepared to adopt the 1:50 ratio. Nor did he discuss the view of Mr Livermore that the level of supervision was adequate. Mr Livermore had relevant qualifications at least matching those of Dr Ewens. At the time of giving evidence he was a lecturer in education and education management at the University of Western Sydney. From 1965 to 1995 he was actively engaged in school teaching in the Australian Capital Territory, apart from five years between 1979 and 1984 when he was Principal Education Officer for the Authority, concerned with curriculum development for the Territory. Mr Livermore must have had considerable experience, probably exceeding that of Dr Ewens, in pupil management, including during recreation periods. Of course, Mr Livermore was a defendant. Any opinion expressed by him would need to be considered with that in mind. However, Miles CJ seems to have been prepared to accept Mr Livermore in relation to other matters. So it is surprising there was no discussion in his Honour’s reasons about his view that the level of supervision was adequate. However, it seems to me unnecessary to form an opinion as to whether his Honour erred in accepting Dr Ewens’ 1:50 ratio. In my view there was a fatal defect in the respondent’s case: the respondent failed to establish a causal connection between the alleged breach of duty – the failure to provide supervisors in a ratio of 1:50 to pupils – and the injury suffered by him. Under some circumstances it might be possible to establish a causal connection between a failure to provide adequate supervision and an injury. Introvigne was such a case. Closer to home, it might have been different if Mr El Sheik had been injured in an incident that went on for a significant period of time, the injury occurring after the time by which the incident should have been stopped, if proper supervision had been provided; or if the injury was sustained from a cause that could have been foreseen and prevented by reasonable supervision. Similarly, the ratio of supervisors might be important if the level of supervision was so low that, during an incident, no supervisor was on duty in the relevant area, or the nearest supervisor was too far away, or so distracted by other duties, as to be unable to respond quickly to the incident. The ratio might have been relevant in the present case if it were shown that the manner in which the teacher dealt with Mr Esposito’s conduct was affected by the burden placed on her as sole supervisor in the oval area. But none of these things was shown.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.