FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 8) [2023] FCA 1092
File number(s): VID 391 of 2021 Judgment of: MORTIMER CJ Date of judgment: 14 September 2023 Catchwords: HUMAN RIGHTS – racial discrimination – s 9(1) and s 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) – right to security of person and protection – right to education – right to preserve Jewish identity – where applicants are Jewish former students at Victorian public secondary school – alleged failure to protect Jewish students from antisemitic bullying and harassment – swastika graffiti – application allowed in part – speech by principal to full school assembly did not contravene s 18C
NEGLIGENCE – school principal’s duty of care – non-delegable duty – vicarious liability
DAMAGES – orders for compensation under s 46PO(4) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) – aggravated damages – whether appropriate to order an apology or apologies
Legislation: Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) ss 49PO(4), 49PO(4)(d)
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) ss 22(1)(b), 24(1)(b)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 136, 140, 140(2)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 79
Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) ss 3(3), 6, 9, 9(1), 9(1A), 9(2), 18A, 18A(2) 18C, 18C(1)(a), 18(1)(c)(b)
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) ss 14(2), 28B, 28B(6)
Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld)
Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW) s 8
Crown Proceedings Act 1958 (Vic) s 23(1)(b)
Equal Opportunity Act 1985 (Vic) s 87
Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic) ss 86(1)(b), 87(1)
Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic) ss 92, 93
Racial and Religious Tolerance Act 2001 (Vic) s 7
Summary Offences Amendment (Nazi Symbol Prohibition) Act 2022 (Vic)
Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) Pts VBA, X, ss 28LB, 28LC(2)(a), 28LE
Convention on the Rights of the Child, opened for signature 20 November 1989, 1577 UNTS 3 (entered into force 2 September 1990) arts 8, 8(1), 12, 14, 19, 29(1)(c), 30
International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, opened for signature 21 December 1965, 660 UNTS 195 (entered into force 4 January 1969) arts 5, 5(b), 5(e)(v)
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, opened for signature 16 December 1966, 999 UNTS 171 (entered into force 23 March 1976) arts 9(1), 24(1)
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, opened for signature 16 December 1966, 993 UNTS 3 (entered into force 3 January 1976) art 13
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, GA Res 217A (III), UN GAOR, UN Doc A/810 (10 December 1948) art 26
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, General Comment 11, UN Doc E/C.12/1999/4 (10 May 1999)
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, General Comment 13, UN Doc E/C.12/1999/10 (8 December 1999)
Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, General Recommendation 20 on Article 5, UN Doc CERD/48/Misc.6/Rev.2 (8 March 1996)
Human Rights Committee, General Comment No 35, UN Doc CCPR/C/GC/35 (16 December 2014)
John Tobin (ed), The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Commentary (Oxford University…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 8) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 1092
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court determined that the State of Victoria was liable under the RDA for failing to protect the students from racial discrimination. It held that the school principal owed a non-delegable duty of care to the students, and vicarious liability applied. Regarding compensation, the court awarded damages to the students, considering the emotional and psychological harm they suffered. It also ordered the State to provide apologies to the students, stipulating a timeline for negotiation and requiring case management if an agreement could not be reached. The court declined to order specific training, finding it would likely lead to further disputes and did not enhance the finality of the case. The court also struck out certain paragraphs of the statement of claim that were deemed unnecessary.
The final orders included the removal of certain litigation representatives, partial allowance of the originating application, payment of compensation to the students, and a requirement for the State to propose and negotiate apologies. The court capped the costs awarded to the applicants and invited further proposals for additional orders from the parties.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Paragraphs [367], [368], [369(b)] and [369(c)] (to the extent it relates to [369(b)]) of the statement of claim dated 22 July 2021 be struck out.
2. Paragraph [373] of the statement of claim dated 22 July 2021 be struck out.
3. Paragraphs [116]-[122] of the statement of claim dated 22 July 2021 be struck out.
Removal of litigation representatives
4. Subject to any further or other order, Janet Abadee be removed as litigation representative of Matt Kaplan.
5. Subject to any further or other order, Sarit Cohen be removed as litigation representative of Guy Cohen.
6. Subject to any further or other order, Natalie Snelling be removed as litigation representative of Zack Snelling.
Disposition of the originating application
7. The originating application dated 16 July 2021 be allowed in part.
Compensation
8. Pursuant to s 46PO(4)(d) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) the first respondent pay compensation to Joel Kaplan in the total sum of $63,780.
9. Pursuant to s 46PO(4)(d) of the AHRC Act the first respondent pay compensation to Matt Kaplan in the total sum of $60,000.
10. Pursuant to s 46PO(4)(d) of the AHRC Act the first respondent pay compensation to Guy Cohen in the total sum of $55,000.
11. Pursuant to s 46PO(4)(d) of the AHRC Act the first respondent pay compensation to Zack Snelling in the total sum of $244,968.31.
Damages
12. The first respondent pay to Liam Arnold-Levy:
(a) the sum of $10,000 by way of damages for non-economic loss pursuant to the exception in s 28LC(2)(a) of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic); and
(b) the sum of $1,532.43 by way of damages for economic loss.
Apology
13. On or before 4.00 pm on 6 October 2023, the first respondent serve on the applicants a proposed form of apology by the first respondent to each of the applicants, in a form that is compatible with the Court’s reasons for judgment in this proceeding.
14. The applicants and the first respondent are to attempt to negotiate, in good faith, an agreed form of apology or apologies by the first respondent to each of the applicants, in a form that is compatible with the Court’s reasons for judgment in this proceeding, including agreement about when and in what form the apologies will be given.
15. In the absence of the Court being notified on or before 4.00 pm on 13 October 2023 that the parties have agreed on a form of apology to each applicant, the proceeding will be listed for case management, at a date to be fixed in consultation with the parties, for the Court to consider whether it should prescribe a form of apology, or relieve the first respondent of any obligation to deliver an apology to one or more of the applicants.
16. The parties may request the assistance of a Judicial Registrar of the Court in their negotiations pursuant to order 14 of these orders.
Costs
17. The first respondent pay the applicants’ costs, capped in accordance with the Court’s orders dated 27 October 2021 in the sum of $130,000.
Further orders or variations
18. On or before 4.00 pm on 6 October 2023, the parties each file any proposed further orders, or variations to orders already made in the proceeding, including any proposed orders in relation to interest, accompanied, if necessary, by supporting submissions of no more than 5 pages.
19. As far as possible the parties are to agree on the form of any further orders, or variations to orders already made in the proceeding, including any proposed orders in relation to interest.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicants included Liam Arnold-Levy, Joel Kaplan, Matt Kaplan, Guy Cohen, and Zack Snelling, with their families also involved in the proceedings. The respondents were the State of Victoria and the principal of BSC. The trial included extensive evidence from numerous lay and expert witnesses, along with a significant number of documents. The applicants aimed to prove that the school's handling of the incidents was inadequate and that it failed in its duty to protect the applicants from racial discrimination and bullying.
The matter came before the court as an originating application, seeking various forms of relief from the school. The case had been through several interlocutory applications and hearings before reaching the final hearing. Prior decisions and procedural steps included rulings on the admissibility of evidence, the striking out of certain claims, and negotiations over the form and content of potential apologies and compensation. The court considered the evidence presented, including expert opinions on the impact of the bullying and the adequacy of the school's response, and deliberated on the appropriate legal and equitable remedies.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I do not consider Mr Varney should be compelled to apologise to Guy. He did not accept he engaged in much of the behaviour alleged. Any apology from him would not be sincere, and I did not get any sense Guy wanted one. Declaration The respondents submit that there is no basis for the declaration sought by the applicants. Either, they submit, the applicants succeed on their negligence claims and the declaration serves no additional purpose or, alternatively, the applicants fail in their negligence claims and the declaration has no basis to be made. The applicants made no discernible substantive submissions on this point that were separate to their submissions regarding the applicants’ claims in negligence. Without any justification advanced on behalf of the applicants for declaratory relief in relation to their negligence claims, I accept the respondents’ submissions that declaratory relief is unnecessary. However, as I did in Wotton, I consider it is appropriate to grant declaratory relief under the RDA.Training As to orders regarding training, the respondents submit that such orders are unnecessary, as the Court has heard evidence that the school has implemented training in relation to antisemitism at the school, particularly arising out of the implementation of the recommendations of the Worklogic report. The applicants instead submit, without reference to any specific evidence, that the evidence of the respondents’ witnesses suggests that the orders need to be implemented and they remain pressed. There was no evidentiary foundation laid by the applicants’ counsel to press for this kind of relief. The evidence did demonstrate that the implementation of the Worklogic recommendations had some effect at BSC. No doubt the publication of these reasons for judgment will also have an effect. Orders about training are likely to involve some level of supervision by the Court, and reporting, and to lead to further disputes about adequacy. I do not consider they are likely to enhance the finality that final orders should bring to matters between the parties. None of the applicants remain at BSC. The Court can be confident the State will carefully consider the Court’s findings. What it then does in terms of practices at State secondary schools – whether at BSC or more widely – is a matter for it.CONCLUSION There will be orders in accordance with these reasons. The applicants are entitled to a costs order, capped in accordance with the Court’s orders of 27 October 2021. If the parties seek any further orders, or variations to the orders made, the Court will consider any proposed additional or varied orders. The parties will be given 15 working days to file any proposals, supported by submissions of no more than five pages.