FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 4) [2022] FCA 897
File number(s): VID 391 of 2021 Judgment of: MORTIMER J Date of judgment: 1 August 2022 Catchwords: EVIDENCE – objections to passages in expert report – relevance – whether passages amount to speculation – objections upheld in part Legislation: Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) Cases cited: Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 3) [2022] FCA 728 Division: General Division Registry: Victoria National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights Number of paragraphs: 24 Date of hearing: 29 July 2022 Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Butt with Mr C Dawlings and Mr A Marcou Solicitor for the Applicants: Cornwalls Counsel for the Respondents: Mr C Young QC with Mr T Jeffrie and Mr B House Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison ORDERS
VID 391 of 2021 BETWEEN: JOEL KAPLAN
First Applicant
JANET ABADEE AS REPRESENTATIVE OF MATT KAPLAN, A MINOR
Second Applicant
SARIT COHEN AS REPRESENTATIVE OF GUY COHEN, A MINOR (and others named in the Schedule)
Third Applicant
AND: STATE OF VICTORIA
First Respondent
RICHARD MINACK
Second Respondent
PAUL VARNEY
Third Respondent
DEMI FLESSA
Fourth Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
MORTIMER J
DATE OF ORDER:
1 AUGUST 2022
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.Subject to order 2, the applicants have leave to tender and rely upon the further report of Stephen Paul dated 22 July 2022.
2.The objections of the respondents to the further report be determined as follows:
(a)the objections to [5]-[9] and one sentence in [20] of the further report be overruled;
(b)the objection to the second sentence in [20] of the further report be upheld; and
(c)the objections to one sentence in [39] and two sentences in [40] of the further report be upheld.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
MORTIMER J:
On 21 June 2022, I held that two expert reports filed on behalf of the applicants by Stephen Paul were inadmissible: see Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 3) [2022] FCA 728.
In another example of a party taking advantage of the fact that this proceeding is now being conducted in tranches due to the trial wholly exceeding the parties’ estimates, during the break between that decision and the next tranche of evidence in the trial, the applicants instructed Mr Paul to prepare a further report. That further report is dated 22 July 2022 and was filed on the same date. The applicants were granted leave to file the further report, on the basis that the respondents would be given an opportunity to consider whether they objected to the applicants being granted leave to rely upon the report, or alternatively whether the respondents objected to the whole report, or only parts of it.
On 28 July 2022, senior counsel for the respondents informed the Court that the respondents did not object to the further report being tendered, and made no objection to the whole of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 4) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] FCA 897
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the passages in question were relevant to the applicants' claims and whether they constituted speculative evidence. The respondents argued that the passages were not relevant as the applicants had not pleaded that the failure to conduct restorative justice sessions was contrary to the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) or negligent. The applicants countered that the topic had been addressed in the questioning of some witnesses and that the concept of restorative justice was pertinent to their allegations of negligence and failure to take appropriate action.
The court found that while there was no challenge to the expert's expertise, the passages in question were speculative and not directly related to the applicants' pleaded issues. The court ruled that the objections to certain parts of the expert report were upheld, as they amounted to speculation and were not relevant to the issues in dispute. However, the objections to other parts of the report were overruled as they were considered relevant and not speculative.
The court ordered that the applicants had leave to tender and rely on the further report of Stephen Paul, dated 22 July 2022, subject to certain objections being overruled or upheld. The objections to specific passages in the report were determined, with some being overruled and others upheld based on their relevance and speculative nature.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Subject to order 2, the applicants have leave to tender and rely upon the further report of Stephen Paul dated 22 July 2022.
2. The objections of the respondents to the further report be determined as follows:
(a) the objections to [5]-[9] and one sentence in [20] of the further report be overruled;
(b) the objection to the second sentence in [20] of the further report be upheld; and
(c) the objections to one sentence in [39] and two sentences in [40] of the further report be upheld.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case has proceeded through various stages, including the filing of statements of claim, responses, and expert reports. The latest development involves objections by the respondents to certain passages in an expert report submitted by the applicants. The respondents argue that some parts of the expert report are not relevant to the issues in dispute as pleaded in the applicants' statements of claim and concise statement. The applicants counter that the evidence is relevant, particularly to their claims of negligence and failures to take appropriate action and implement restorative justice practices.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the objections to the further report of Stephen Paul, focusing on whether certain passages were relevant to the issues in dispute. The respondents argued that the passages were not relevant because the applicants did not plead in their statement of claim or concise statement that any failure to conduct restorative justice sessions was contrary to the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) or negligent. However, the applicants argued that some witnesses had been questioned on the topic without objection and that some of the policies the respondents relied upon referred to restorative justice.
The court found that there was no challenge to Mr Paul’s expertise or the matters within his area of expertise. Mr Paul’s evidence in [5]-[9] covered several distinct matters, including the concept of "restorative justice" in a high school setting, his own use and experience of it, opinions about it being "standard industry practice" and its effectiveness, and his opinion on the employment of restorative justice at Brighton Secondary College.
The court found that the passages in [5]-[9] were relevant because they addressed the concept of restorative justice, which was connected to the applicants' allegations of negligence and failures to take action and stop or modify the behaviour of offending pupils. The applicants' statement of claim and concise statement referred to failures to take action, discipline, and educate, which could objectively encompass restorative justice approaches to student behaviour management. Therefore, the objections to [5]-[9] were overruled.
However, the court upheld the objection to the second sentence in [20] of the further report because it expressed Mr Paul's personal opinion on the concerning nature of the employment of restorative justice at BSC, which was not directly related to the applicants' pleadings. Additionally, the objections to one sentence in [39] and two sentences in [40] of the further report were upheld because they contained speculative opinions not supported by the evidence presented.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while expert evidence on restorative justice was relevant to the applicants' allegations of negligence and failures to take action and stop or modify the behaviour of offending pupils, certain speculative opinions not supported by the evidence should be excluded from the report. The court distinguished between relevant expert opinion and speculative opinion in determining the admissibility of evidence in the further report.