Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 3) [2022] FCA 728

File number(s): VID 391 of 2021
Judgment of: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 21 June 2022
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – admissibility – objection to tender of expert report – trial conducted by way of oral evidence – nature of instructions given to expert – where expert not provided with specific factual assumptions – where expert provided with witness outlines – where method of instruction results in expert expressing conclusions on matters of material fact – tender of expert report rejected
Cases cited:

Arnotts Ltd v Trade Practices Commission [1990] FCA 660; 24 FCR 313
HG v The Queen [1999] HCA 2; 197 CLR 414
Trilogy Funds Management Ltd v Sullivan (No 2) [2015] FCA 1452; 331 ALR 185

Heydon J D, Cross on Evidence (13th ed, LexisNexis, 2021)

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 29
Date of hearing: 21 June 2022
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Butt with Mr C Dawlings and Mr A Marcou
Solicitor for the Applicants: Cornwalls
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr C Young QC with Mr T Jeffrie and Mr B House
Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison

ORDERS

VID 391 of 2021
BETWEEN:

JOEL KAPLAN

First Applicant

JANET ABADEE AS REPRESENTATIVE OF MATT KAPLAN, A MINOR

Second Applicant

SARIT COHEN AS REPRESENTATIVE OF GUY COHEN, A MINOR (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

STATE OF VICTORIA

First Respondent

RICHARD MINACK

Second Respondent

PAUL VARNEY

Third Respondent

DEMI FLESSA

Fourth Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MORTIMER J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 JUNE 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The tender of the expert reports of Stephen Paul dated 8 May 2022 and 17 June 2022 be rejected. 

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MORTIMER J:

  1. The applicants seek to tender and rely upon two expert reports prepared by Stephen Paul, an educational consultant. There was no challenge to Mr Paul’s expertise. He worked as a senior educational administrator for a period of 27 years. During that time he was employed as both a deputy principal and principal, the largest portion of his working life in this period as a principal. He held those positions at both government and independent schools. This included a period as principal of the largest K-12 school in Queensland, which he describes in his report as “one of the largest in the country with an enrolment of 2,500 students”. Mr Paul retired in 2008, but states that after his retirement he:

    has continued to play an active role in the educational sector providing a range of consultancy services to schools, systems and other industry bodies as well as being appointed as chair of a number of education industry boards.

  2. Mr Paul’s primary report was filed on 13 May 2022. A supplementary report, addressing some of the additional policies…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 728
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 3), the dispute primarily involved the admissibility of an expert report tendered during the proceedings. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with Kaplan as the plaintiff and the State of Victoria as the defendant. The crux of the dispute was whether the expert report, authored by Stephen Paul, could be admitted into evidence given the manner in which the expert was instructed and the subsequent conclusions drawn.

The court was tasked with determining whether the expert's report could be admitted into evidence, especially considering the nature of the instructions provided to the expert. A significant issue was whether the expert was given specific factual assumptions upon which to base his report or if he was merely provided with witness outlines. The court had to evaluate whether the lack of specific factual assumptions led to the expert expressing conclusions on matters of material fact, which in turn rendered the report inadmissible.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the method by which the expert was instructed and the resultant conclusions. It was determined that the expert was not provided with specific factual assumptions, which is a crucial component in ensuring that an expert's opinion is based on a sound factual foundation. As the expert's report contained conclusions on material facts without the benefit of specific factual assumptions, the court found that the expert report could not be admitted. Consequently, the tender of the expert reports dated 8 May 2022 and 17 June 2022 was rejected.

The court's final order, in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, was to reject the tender of the expert reports of Stephen Paul dated 8 May 2022 and 17 June 2022. This decision underscores the importance of proper instruction to experts to ensure the admissibility of their reports in legal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The tender of the expert reports of Stephen Paul dated 8 May 2022 and 17 June 2022 be rejected.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 3) revolves around the admissibility of expert reports in the context of a trial conducted by way of oral evidence. Stephen Paul was engaged as an expert witness by the plaintiff, Kaplan, to provide reports on matters pertaining to the case. The plaintiff sought to tender two reports by Mr. Paul, dated 8 May 2022 and 17 June 2022. However, the nature of instructions given to Mr. Paul raised concerns. Specifically, Mr. Paul was not provided with specific factual assumptions, but rather, he was provided with witness outlines. This method of instruction resulted in Mr. Paul expressing conclusions on matters of material fact, which was deemed problematic by the court. The court had to consider whether these reports could be admitted into evidence given the nature of the expert's instructions and the conclusions reached.

The procedural history of this case involves the plaintiff, Kaplan, attempting to tender expert reports in the course of litigation against the State of Victoria. The trial was conducted by way of oral evidence, and the admissibility of the expert reports became a central issue. The court had to determine whether the reports could be admitted given the way the expert was instructed and the conclusions drawn. The plaintiff argued for the admissibility of the reports, while the defendant raised objections. The court's decision focused on the specific instructions provided to the expert and the impact of these instructions on the conclusions reached in the reports.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the tender of the expert reports of Stephen Paul dated 8 May 2022 and 17 June 2022 should be rejected due to the nature of instructions given to the expert, which did not include specific factual assumptions and instead relied on witness outlines, resulting in the expert expressing conclusions on matters of material fact.

Held
1. The court held that the tender of the expert reports of Stephen Paul dated 8 May 2022 and 17 June 2022 should be rejected. The court concluded that the nature of the instructions given to the expert did not include specific factual assumptions and instead relied on witness outlines. This method of instruction resulted in the expert expressing conclusions on matters of material fact. Therefore, the tender of the expert reports was rejected.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the process by which the expert, Stephen Paul, was instructed to prepare the expert reports. It noted that the expert was not provided with specific factual assumptions but instead relied on witness outlines. This method of instruction led to the expert drawing conclusions on matters of material fact, which are typically the province of the trier of fact, in this case, the court. The court relied on established principles that an expert's role is to provide an opinion based on facts assumed or found by the court, not to determine the facts themselves. The court cited relevant case law to reinforce this principle, holding that experts should not venture into areas that are reserved for the trier of fact. In light of this, the court found that the expert reports did not adhere to the proper role and function of an expert in the judicial process, and thus, the tender of the reports was appropriately rejected. The binding legal principle established in this case is that expert reports must be based on specific factual assumptions provided by the court and should not include conclusions on matters of material fact, which are to be determined by the trier of fact.