State of Queensland v Barney

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: State of Queensland & Anor v Barney [2013] QCATA 104
PARTIES:

State of Queensland
(First Appellant)

and

Wendy Petersen
(Second Appellant)

V

George Fleetwood Barney
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL418-12
MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

HEARING DATE: 15 April 2013
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Justice Alan Wilson, President
Mr Richard Oliver, Senior Member
DELIVERED ON: 1 May 2013
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE: The Appeal is refused.
CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – ANTI-DISCRIMINATION – DIRECT DISCRIMINATION – RACIAL VILIFICATION – VICARIOUS LIABILITY – COMPENSATION –DAMAGES – QUANTUM – ONUS OF PROOF – where the respondent was the victim of direct racial discrimination during the course of employment – where the respondent developed a depressive illness and took leave – where the respondent brought proceedings claiming compensation for loss and damage caused by the contravention of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 – where the Tribunal ordered the appellants to pay the respondent a total award of $76,704.81 – where the total award included general damages which were discounted by 30% – where the appellants appeal that decision – where the appellants contend the total award was excessive and assessed on wrong principles – where the appellants argue the respondent failed to establish that the acts of discrimination were a significant or material cause of the respondent’s illness and associated economic loss – where the appellants argue the Tribunal erred in placing the onus of proof on them to establish the illness was not wholly or partly the result of a pre-existing condition – whether the respondent adduced sufficient evidence to establish the illness was wholly or partly caused by the discriminatory acts – whether the total award was manifestly excessive – whether the appeal should be granted

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), s 204, s 209(1)(b)

Barney v State of Queensland & Anor [2012] QCAT 695, cited
March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506, confirmed
Purkess v Crittenden (1965) 114 CLR 164, cited
Watts v Rake (1960) 108 CLR 158, cited

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANTS: Mr S Keim SC instructed by Crown Law for both Appellants
RESPONDENT: Mr Barney on his own behalf

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Mr Barney is of indigenous heritage and actively involved in the indigenous community,[1] facts well-known to his fellow employees in the Department of Communities (‘the Department’) where he has worked for almost two decades. 

    [1]        The Butchulla people, from in and around the K’gari (Fraser Island)/Hervey Bay area.

  2. Mr Barney complained that he was the victim of racial discrimination in the course of his employment as a Residential Care Officer with the Department.  He brought proceedings claiming compensation for loss and damage against the State of the Queensland (‘the State’) and Ms Petersen, a fellow employee.

  3. A Member of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal heard the proceedings at Hervey Bay over five days between 22 February and 23 October 2012 and on 1 November delivered his decision, with written Reasons, that the State and Ms Petersen pay Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Queensland v Barney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCATA 104
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The State of Queensland and another party appealed against a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) that ordered them to pay Mr Barney a total award of $76,704.81 for compensation for loss and damage caused by contravention of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991. Mr Barney, the respondent, had been the victim of direct racial discrimination during the course of his employment, which led to the development of a depressive illness and subsequent leave from work. The Tribunal had ordered the appellants to compensate Mr Barney for the loss and damage caused by the contravention of the Act. The appellants contested the decision, arguing that the total award was excessive and assessed on wrong principles. They also argued that Mr Barney failed to establish that the acts of discrimination were a significant or material cause of his illness and associated economic loss. Moreover, the appellants argued that the Tribunal had erred in placing the onus of proof on them to establish that Mr Barney's illness was not wholly or partly the result of a pre-existing condition.

The court had to decide whether the respondent adduced sufficient evidence to establish that the illness was wholly or partly caused by the discriminatory acts and whether the total award was manifestly excessive. The court held that the learned Member of QCAT had avoided the error which lies at the heart of the appellants' complaint. The Member's conclusion that the cause of Mr Barney ceasing work was the effect of becoming aware of the incident regarding Ms Petersen and that her subsequent purported apology was a major contributing factor in him remaining off work was reasonably open on the evidence before him. Once that conclusion was reached, there was no apparent basis for reducing or discounting Mr Barney's claim for economic loss. Therefore, the appeal was refused.

The court found that the Tribunal had correctly assessed the onus of proof, and there was sufficient evidence to establish that the illness was wholly or partly caused by the discriminatory acts. The court held that the total award was not manifestly excessive, and the appellants' appeal was dismissed. The decision of the Tribunal was affirmed, and the appellants were ordered to pay Mr Barney the total award of $76,704.81.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Appeal is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

He then goes on to address the nub of the appellants’ complaints here: While the other factors would undoubtedly have impacted upon Mr Barney, there is insufficient evidence for the Tribunal to find that he would have ceased work when he did in the absence of the matters the Tribunal has found to be discriminatory, or that he would have been in a position to return to work any earlier, having not also been affected by the other issues which the Tribunal finds were not discriminatory… (emphasis added). It is the reference to ‘insufficient evidence’ in this passage, and its suggestion that some evidentiary burden lay upon the appellants which they failed to discharge, which has excited them. It is true that, in earlier passages in his Reasons[16] the learned Member had spoken in terms that might be construed as suggesting that, in his view, some evidentiary burden lay upon them to adduce evidence that would: … differentiate between Mr Barney’s incapacity so far as it related to the actions of Ms Petersen which the Tribunal accepts were discrimination, and the other actions complained of by Mr Barney.[17] [16] Barney v State of Queensland & Anor [2012] QCAT 695 at [137] – [140].[17] Ibid [137]. Those passages must be considered, however, in light of that part of the Reasons which precedes them, in which the learned Member referred to the appellants’ submission that:… if the comments made by Ms Petersen were found to constitute unlawful discrimination that their contribution to the economic loss suffered by Mr Barney would be minimal, and at best in the order of perhaps 5%. They say in relation to Mr Barney’s economic loss that the evidence presented to the Tribunal does not support the conclusion that that a 20 month absence from the workplace could be attributed to remarks by Ms Petersen outside Mr Barney’s presence. It must be conceded that, at some points in these passages in the Reasons, the learned Member may have expressed himself infelicitously in the sense that, taken out of context, what he said might be construed as suggesting the error for which the appellants contend. Once it is appreciated, however, that his remarks were made in the context of addressing the very heavy discounting of Mr Barney’s compensation for which the appellants contended both before the Member, and here; and that he had elsewhere correctly addressed, in appropriate terms, the question that was critical to causation – whether Mr Barney had discharged the onus of establishing a causal connection between his depressive condition and his absence from work, and the offending conduct – it can be seen that he avoided the error which lies at the heart of the appellants’ complaint. The learned Member’s conclusion that ‘…the cause of Mr Barney ceasing work was the effect of becoming aware of the incident… regarding Ms Petersen and that her subsequent purported apology was a major contributing factor in him remaining off work’ was reasonably open on the evidence before him. Once that conclusion was reached, there was no apparent basis for reducing or discounting Mr Barney’s claim for economic loss.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.