Employment Services Australia Pty Ltd v Poniatowska

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Employment Services Australia Pty Ltd v Poniatowska [2010] FCAFC 92

Citation: Employment Services Australia Pty Ltd v Poniatowska [2010] FCAFC 92
Appeal from: Poniatowska v Hickinbotham [2009] FCA 680
Parties: EMPLOYMENT SERVICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED v MALGORZATA PONIATOWSKA and REMO LOTITO
File number: SAD 107 of 2009
Judges: DOWSETT, STONE AND BENNETT JJ
Date of judgment: 27 July 2010
Catchwords:

HUMAN RIGHTS – sex discrimination found at first instance – female employee complained about sexual harassment in robust work environment – complaints dealt with inadequately – employment terminated ostensibly for unsatisfactory work performance – the primary Judge found employment terminated because of employee’s complaints and inferred that male complainant would have been treated differently – factual findings challenged on appeal – whether findings supported by the evidence or involved the creation of a new case not advanced at trial – whether findings properly put to witness in cross-examination – whether finding of sex discrimination rose above conjecture – where no male employee had in fact complained of sexual harassment

EVIDENCE – application to adduce new evidence of conviction of employee for fraud – whether likely to affect compensation for future loss of earning capacity

Legislation: Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s 46PO
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) ss 5, 14(2), 28A, 28B, 106
Cases cited: Ghazal v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1992) 29 NSWLR 336 considered
Holloway v McFeeters (1956) 94 CLR 470 considered
Poniatowska v Hickinbotham [2009] FCA 680 affirmed
Suvaal v Cessnock City Council (2003) 200 ALR 1 considered
Date of hearing: 9 and 10 November 2009
Place: Sydney (via video-link) (Heard in Adelaide)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 134
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr R Whitington QC, Mr A Gotting
Solicitor for the Appellant: EMA Legal
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr P Heywood-Smith QC, Mr M Anderson
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Duncan Basheer Hannon
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent did not appear.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 107 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

EMPLOYMENT SERVICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
Appellant

AND:

MALGORZATA PONIATOWSKA
First Respondent

REMO LOTITO
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

DOWSETT, STONE AND BENNETT JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

27 JULY 2010

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (VIA VIDEO-LINK) (HEARD IN ADELAIDE) 

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The cross-appeal be dismissed.

3.The appellant pay 90% of the first respondent’s costs.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 107 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

EMPLOYMENT SERVICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
Appellant

AND:

MALGORZATA PONIATOWSKA
First Respondent

REMO LOTITO
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

DOWSETT, STONE AND BENNETT JJ

DATE:

27 JULY 2010

PLACE:

SYDNEY (VIA VIDEO-LINK) (HEARD…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Employment Services Australia Pty Ltd v Poniatowska and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCAFC 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Employment Services Australia Pty Ltd v Poniatowska was an appeal against a decision of the Federal Court of Australia, where the primary Judge found that the termination of the appellant's employment was due to her complaints of sexual harassment in the workplace. The respondent, Ms Poniatowska, alleged that she was subjected to a sexually hostile work environment and that her complaints were not handled adequately. The court was required to determine whether the primary Judge's findings were supported by evidence and whether they amounted to the creation of a new case not advanced at trial. Additionally, the court had to consider the impact of a conviction for fraud on the respondent's future earning capacity.

The court found that the primary Judge's factual findings were supported by the evidence, and the appeal against those findings was dismissed. The court rejected the appellant's argument that the primary Judge had created a new case not advanced at trial, as the allegations and the handling of the complaints were consistent with the evidence presented. The court also held that the findings were properly put to the witness in cross-examination, and the finding of sex discrimination did not rise above conjecture. The court further held that the primary Judge's finding that the employment was terminated due to the respondent's complaints was supported by the evidence.

Regarding the appeal concerning the award of compensation for future economic loss, the court found that the primary Judge's decision to award $140,000 for future loss of earning capacity was not miscarried. The court held that the conviction for fraud, which occurred after the primary Judge's judgment, was a supervening independent event and that the primary Judge did not award full future loss of prospective earnings. The court concluded that the conviction for fraud was likely to affect the respondent's prospects of obtaining some kinds of employment, but it did not necessarily mean that she would have been unable to obtain employment if it were not for the impact of the sexual harassment and its sequelae.

ORDERS:

1. The appeal be dismissed.
2. The cross-appeal be dismissed.
3. The appellant pay 90% of the first respondent’s costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The cross-appeal be dismissed.

3. The appellant pay 90% of the first respondent’s costs.

Note:

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

ESA has failed to demonstrate that the exercise of his Honour’s discretion miscarried.Ground 13, as pressed - ESA’s application to adduce new evidence relevant to the award of compensation for future economic loss The orders made by the primary Judge were made on 23 June 2009. His Honour allowed $140,000 for future loss of earning capacity. His Honour found that Ms Poniatowska was likely to recover significantly over the next two years from the date of his judgment to the point where she would be able to work in an unrestricted way, albeit with some risk of ongoing impairment after that time (at [356]). His Honour noted that there was a prospect of her being able to return to work in an earning capacity significantly prior to that date, as well as the prospect of her recovery being somewhat delayed to a full recovery. ESA seeks to adduce new evidence in the appeal of a supervening independent event, the conviction of Ms Poniatowska of social security fraud on 6 July 2009. It submits that that conviction was and is likely to cause a complete or substantial loss of Ms Poniatowska’s earning capacity over the period of two years from June 2009 for which the primary Judge awarded $140,000 in damages for future economic loss. The evidence did not exist before or at the trial, as conviction occurred after his Honour had delivered judgment. The offences that gave rise to the conviction took place while Ms Poniatowska was employed by ESA but the charges were laid after the termination of her employment. ESA seeks to have the matter remitted to the primary Judge for further hearing as to future economic loss in the event that its appeal is unsuccessful. ESA says that it would lead further evidence before the primary Judge as to the effect that a record of fraud has on the decision of employers to employ a potential candidate. While no such evidence was sought to be adduced in the appeal, ESA points to the fact of the conviction, which it submits would itself have that consequence. Ms Poniatowska submits that ESA was aware prior to the hearing before the primary Judge that Centrelink was seeking information from ESA about Ms Poniatowska’s income. Even if that were the case, it is not relevant. There is a deal of difference between knowledge that Centrelink was seeking some information and the fact of a conviction for fraud. To the extent that Ms Poniatowska asserts that she would be able to rely on psychiatric evidence of a link between the actions that led to her conviction and ESA’s conduct, that supports the matter being referred to the primary Judge. We accept that a conviction for social security fraud would be likely to affect the prospects of obtaining some kinds of employment which might be sought by Ms Poniatowska. However, the primary Judge did not award full future loss of prospective earnings. Even accepting that some employers might not wish to employ a person convicted of social security fraud, it does not necessarily follow that Ms Poniatowska would, for that reason alone, have been unable to obtain employment were it not for the impact of the sexual harassment experienced at ESA and its sequelae, whether or not she could have sought other employment. The fact is that his Honour concluded that she was unable to work by reason of the effect on her of the actions of ESA and its employees.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As the primary Judge explained, while the factual allegations presented a series of complex issues, the causes of action were ultimately confined to claims of unlawful discrimination contrary to the HREOC Act and, more particularly, to contraventions of ss 14, 28B and 94 of the SD Act and for a breach of trust and confidence said to be implied in her contract of employment with ESA. His Honour noted that the final submissions on behalf of Ms Poniatowska did not specifically rely upon s 94 of the SD Act and his Honour did not consider that provision further (at [94]).THE DECISION OF THE PRIMARY JUDGE At first instance, most of the factual allegations made by Ms Poniatowska were vigorously disputed by ESA and the other respondents. The primary Judge made detailed factual findings before proceeding to consider the legal consequences. In this appeal, ESA challenges a number of factual findings made by the primary Judge on the basis that the findings were not supported by the evidence and involved ‘the creation of an entirely new case with which the losing party had no testimonial or other evidentiary opportunity to deal’ (Suvaal v Cessnock City Council (2003) 200 ALR 1 at [36] per Gleeson CJ and Heydon J). Ms Poniatowska submits that ESA is seeking to challenge the inferences which the primary Judge drew from established primary facts without challenging his Honour’s findings of those primary facts. It is therefore necessary to set out the relevant factual findings made by his Honour.Relevant findings The factual findings made by the primary Judge were affected by his Honour’s view of the reliability of the various witnesses and from that, the reliance his Honour placed on their evidence. His Honour was careful to explain the reasons for that view in each case and the extent to which these conclusions affected his assessment of the evidence.The work systems and the work environment The primary Judge found that the system for the training of newly appointed building consultants was somewhat haphazard. Ms Sharrad, as the Team Leader, was generally responsible for their training. Her practice was to assign a new building consultant to one with some experience, for training purposes. There was a regular Monday morning meeting of all building consultants at the head office of ESA when each was interviewed separately by Ms Sharrad to address his or her progress. The primary Judge found that the main focus of those meetings was to discuss sales progress rather than to discuss or give instructions about more technical matters such as file preparation and presentation. The Monday morning meetings were also the occasion when building consultants could work individually on files, discuss queries with others, seek advice from their peers and, generally, discuss matters. The primary Judge found that the meetings took place in ‘a robust environment’. His Honour explained that to mean that not infrequently, the language was coarse, sometimes vulgar and sometimes sexually explicit. His Honour found that Ms Sharrad was amongst those who participated in that style of conversation and that there was nothing to indicate that that quality of communication was disapproved of, or that (apart from Ms Poniatowska) it caused discomfort to building consultants. It was in the context of that general work environment, including not infrequent sexually explicit language and references, that his Honour considered Ms Poniatowska’s allegations regarding the inappropriate conduct to which she was subject and the way in which her complaints about such conduct were handled by Ms Sharrad and Homes.