Poniatowska v Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

PONIATOWSKA v CHANNEL SEVEN SYDNEY PTY LTD & ANOR (No 4)

[2016] SASC 137

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

23 August 2016

DEFAMATION - STATEMENTS AMOUNTING TO DEFAMATION - PARTICULAR STATEMENTS - IMPUTATION - CRIMINAL

DEFAMATION - JUSTIFICATION - TRUTH

DEFAMATION - FAIR COMMENT - FOUNDATION OF FACT

DEFAMATION - PUBLICATION - GENERALLY - INTERNET PUBLICATIONS

This is an action for defamation brought by Ms Poniatowska against Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd and Channel Seven Perth Pty Ltd.

On 26 October 2011 the defendants broadcast a story about the plaintiff on the Today Tonight program. The plaintiff alleges that the story gave rise to a number of defamatory imputations including that the plaintiff had cheated Centrelink, was a fraud and was dishonest.

The story arose out of the conviction of the plaintiff for Centrelink fraud. The plaintiff had pleaded guilty to failing to report to Centrelink during the period from August 2005 to May 2007 of receipt of 17 payments she received while employed as a sales consultant with a building company. As a result the plaintiff received payments of the Parenting Payment Single benefit to which she was either not entitled or only partially entitled, totalling more than $20,000.

The conviction was set aside by the Full Court of the Supreme Court. That decision was upheld in the High Court. Following publication of the High Court judgment, the defendants broadcast the story on television in Sydney and Perth. The story was republished on the Channel 7 website. The plaintiff also claimed that the story was published on 33 other television stations around Australia by entities related to the defendants.

The plaintiff sought loss and damages on various bases in the sum of $1.1 million (plus interest). That included a claim for economic loss either on the basis that the plaintiff’s employment prospects were destroyed by reason of the damage to her reputation or because the publication greatly aggravated her pre-existing psychiatric condition.

The defendants accepted that publication was established although internet publication became an issue at trial. The defendants accepted the imputations in part and pleaded six grounds of defence including justification.

Held:

(1)  The plaintiff did receive the greater part of the mail sent to her by Centrelink including letters which stated her obligation to declare income.

(2)  The plaintiff did not receive the claimed advice from Centrelink, that she was not required to report her earnings from commission payments. The advice was a recent invention of the plaintiff. That plea is not an abuse of process.

(3)  There is no special reason operating in the present case to prevent the defendants from advancing a plea of justification to the imputation of fraud.

(4)  In light of findings that the plaintiff received notices from Centrelink requiring her to declare her income, the plaintiff could have been found guilty of many, if not all, of the charges brought against her for Centrelink fraud. On that basis she acted fraudulently in the legal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Poniatowska v Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 137
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ms Poniatowska commenced defamation proceedings against Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd and others in the Federal Circuit Court, seeking damages for defamatory publications made by the defendants. The dispute centred on a segment broadcast on the Today Tonight program, which allegedly defamed Ms Poniatowska by implying she had committed a serious crime. The defendants denied liability and raised several defences, including justification and fair comment. Ms Poniatowska sought to amend her pleadings to argue she was mentally unfit to enter a guilty plea, but the Court refused this amendment as it was not supported by the evidence.

The court had to determine whether the published material was defamatory and, if so, whether the defendants had valid defences. The court found that the published material was indeed defamatory, as it conveyed an imputation of criminal conduct against Ms Poniatowska. The defendants, however, successfully established the defence of justification, as the imputations were substantially true. Additionally, the defence of fair comment was upheld, as the comments were based on facts that were in the public interest.

In conclusion, the Court held that while the publications were defamatory, the defendants were justified in making them. The Court dismissed Ms Poniatowska's application for damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Poniatowska applied to amend her Reply following the close of evidence. The proposed amendment sought to plead that she was mentally unfit to enter the plea of guilty before the Magistrates Court. While I had previously refused permission for such an amendment it was now contended that the evidence given since the time of the earlier ruling had put it into issue her fitness to plead. I refused permission to make the amendment as it was not supported by the evidence.[6][6] Poniatowska v Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd & Anor (No 3) [2014] SASC 159.Ms Poniatowska’s Background Ms Poniatowska was born in Poland in 1967. She completed her schooling in Poland. She then studied law at Warsaw University. Ms Poniatowska practices the Catholic faith and regularly attends Mass. She married her former husband in 1989. He wanted to move to Australia. Although Ms Poniatowska was reluctant to leave her family in Poland, in 1991 she and her husband emigrated and settled in Adelaide. They separated in 2002 and were subsequently divorced in 2004. Since the separation, Ms Poniatowska has had the custody and care of the two children of the marriage. Her former husband now lives overseas.Professional Qualifications From 1986 to 1991 Ms Poniatowska studied towards university qualifications in Poland, being a Bachelor of Canon and Civil Law and a Master of Canon and Civil Law. After her move to Australia Ms Poniatowska undertook further study. In 1992 she completed a one year TAFE course in English. In 1993 she completed an information technology course and shorter courses in web design and word processing. In 1994 she completed a Graduate Diploma of Business (Administrative Management) at the University of South Australia. In 1995 she completed a small business management course sponsored by the State Government. Between 1996 and 2002 Ms Poniatowska took a break from study while she was raising her children and working. In December 2005 she completed a Master of Business (Administrative Management) at the University of South Australia. From August 2006 to 2009 she undertook a Bachelor of Laws at the University of Adelaide. In 2010 she obtained a Graduate Diploma of Legal Practice from the Law Society of South Australia. She was admitted as a practitioner of this Court on 12 December 2012.Work History While Ms Poniatowska resided in Poland she was not employed due to her fulltime study. In January 1996, after Ms Poniatowska and her husband had moved to Australia, she commenced work as an administrative services officers in the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs. She worked there until January 1998. Her duties were the processing of applications made to the Department under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). Ms Poniatowska then worked for the University of South Australia as a student advisor. She held this position from January 1998 to January 2000. She was responsible for responding to student enquiries about university services and providing information and advice about programs and admissions.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Burgess largely disagreed with the final summary offered by Mr Stillwell in his report that Ms Poniatowska would be seen as a “high-risk appointment”. Mr Burgess considered that she would be seen as more than a “high-risk appointment” and would be considered an inappropriate candidate for a law firm, other legal employer or large commercial entityFindings on evidence of employment experts I generally prefer the evidence of Mr Burgess to that of Mr Stillwell. Mr Burgess specialises solely in the recruitment of lawyers and operates extensively in the Adelaide market. While Mr Stillwell is undoubtedly a very successful management and executive employment consultant, legal recruitment comprises only a very minor proportion of his work. Mr Burgess spoke with much greater authority and knowledge about the approach taken by Adelaide law firms to the recruitment of recent graduates. Mr Stillwell suggested that the results of the psychological testing undertaken by his firm would be attractive to an employer. I prefer the evidence of Mr Burgess that the performance of Ms Poniatowska in the psychological assessment was generally less than that required to meet the needs of commercial law firms and major corporate employers in the commercial sector. I also recognise that Mr Burgess conceded that he was not able to assess other personal qualities that might attract an employer. I have inferred from the evidence of Dr Czechowicz that the psychological testing of Ms Poniatowska would have been adversely affected by her mental health at the time of testing. While it was not advanced as an explanation by either of the employment experts, some of the email messages sent by Ms Poniatowska and also her additions to statements prepared by Mr Lutt suggest the possibility to me that insufficient allowance may have been made for the fact that English is not her first language. Regardless of the explanation for her performance, an employer would rarely have capacity to allow substantial additional time for the completion of tasks, particularly a law firm using time based costing. That would also be true of major corporate employers. Ultimately, I do not consider that the results of the psychological testing would significantly affect Ms Poniatowska’s employment prospects one way or the other. I prefer the evidence of Mr Burgess that if law firms use psychological assessments at all, that would not occur until the final stages of the recruitment process. The problem for Ms Poniatowska is attracting initial interest from a prospective employer rather than the results of a psychological assessment. Mr Burgess was very critical of the quality of Ms Poniatowska’s job applications. I found his evidence to be a little pedantic in some respects, eg his criticism of her use of ideograms to depict a telephone number. Nevertheless, I accept the fundamental tenet of his evidence that her applications would not have sufficed to attract even initial interest from a legal or corporate employer. The quality of the applications was much below the expected standard for a person seeking employment in a highly competitive professional field.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Poniatowska also alleged in her Third Statement of Claim that an unknown woman approached her in a supermarket and called her a “cheating cow”. The demeanour of the woman caused her to fear that she might be assaulted. Once again, she merely restated the pleading in her evidence. There was nothing at all in her evidence to link this alleged incident to the publication by the defendants. She was the subject of extensive adverse publicity by others that might have prompted the woman’s alleged remark. Conclusion I find that the material referring to Ms Poniatowska in the Today Tonight story published by the defendants was defamatory. I also find that the defendants have made out the several defences upon which they rely, in particular the defence of justification. I dismiss the plaintiff’s application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established