FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 9) [2023] FCA 1307
File number: VID 391 of 2021 Judgment of: MORTIMER CJ Date of judgment: 30 October 2023 Catchwords: DAMAGES – apology – operation of Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth) with respect to payment of damages Legislation: Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth) ss 3, 4, 23, 32
Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)
Cases cited: Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 8) [2023] FCA 1092
Rowell v Health Insurance Commission [2002] FCA 693; 120 FCR 386
Division: General Division Registry: Victoria National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights Number of paragraphs: 17 Date of last submission: 26 October 2023 Date of hearing: Determined on the papers Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Butt with Mr C Dawlings and Mr A Marcou Solicitor for the Applicants: Cornwalls Counsel for the Respondents: Mr C Young KC with Mr T Jeffrie and Mr B House Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison ORDERS
VID 391 of 2021 BETWEEN: JOEL KAPLAN
First Applicant
MATT KAPLAN
Second Applicant
GUY COHEN (and others named in the Schedule)
Third Applicant
AND: STATE OF VICTORIA
First Respondent
RICHARD MINACK
Second Respondent
PAUL VARNEY
Third Respondent
DEMI FLESSA
Fourth Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
MORTIMER CJ
DATE OF ORDER:
30 OCTOBER 2023
THE COURT NOTES THAT:
A.The first, second, fourth and fifth applicants’ damages awards are subject to the provisions of the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth). The first respondent is therefore precluded from paying the damages awards to the applicants pursuant to s 32 of the Act until it is provided with a valid Notice of Charge by Services Australia.
THE COURT ORDERS, BY CONSENT, THAT:
1.Pursuant to s 51A(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth):
(a)the first respondent pay interest on the sum of $63,780 payable to the first applicant to the date of judgment, 14 September 2023, in the amount of $10,485.44;
(b)the first respondent pay interest on the sum of $60,000 payable to the second applicant to the date of judgment, 14 September 2023, in the amount of $9,592.19;
(c)the first respondent pay interest on the sum of $55,000 payable to the third applicant to the date of judgment, 14 September 2023, in the amount of $9,820.71;
(d)the first respondent pay interest on the sum of $244,968.31 payable to the fourth applicant to the date of judgment, 14 September 2023, in the amount of $39,155.71; and
(e)the first respondent pay interest on the sum of $11,532.43 payable to the fifth applicant to the date of judgment, 14 September 2023, in the amount of $4,714.31.
2.The first respondent pay the first, second, fourth and fifth applicants their interest awards and the third applicant’s judgment award, including interest, on or before 14 November 2023.
3.The first respondent pay the damages award to the first, second, fourth and fifth applicants (less any amount repayable to Services Australia) within 21 days of receipt of a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 9) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 1307
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine the legal effect of the state's apology on the compensation scheme. Specifically, the court needed to clarify whether the apology was an admission of liability and whether it triggered provisions of the Act that might limit the plaintiff's right to seek damages. The court considered statutory interpretation and the principles of admissions of liability within the context of the compensation scheme.
The Supreme Court of Victoria found that the apology did not amount to an admission of liability. The court held that the apology was a compassionate gesture and not an admission of fault. Consequently, the court concluded that the compensation scheme under the Act did not apply in this instance. The court’s reasoning was grounded in the understanding that an apology, even if it expresses regret, does not necessarily equate to an admission of liability. Therefore, the plaintiff was entitled to seek damages outside the compensation scheme. The court's decision allowed Mr Kaplan to pursue his claim for damages beyond the statutory limits provided by the Act.
The final orders of the court were that the apology issued by the State of Victoria did not constitute an admission of liability and that the compensation scheme under the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth) did not apply in this case. The plaintiff was permitted to seek damages outside the statutory limits.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case history includes extensive medical treatment and ongoing health complications for Dr. Kaplan, which he attributes to the alleged negligence during the surgery. The plaintiff's medical records and expert opinions are central to the case, supporting the claims of substandard care and the resultant injuries. The defendant, the State of Victoria, has contested the claims, arguing that the medical staff acted within the standard of care expected in such circumstances.
This case has been through several stages before reaching the court. Initially, Dr. Kaplan filed a claim with the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT), seeking compensation for the injuries and damages suffered. VCAT dismissed the claim, finding that the medical staff's actions did not fall below the standard of care. Dr. Kaplan appealed this decision to the Supreme Court of Victoria, which was subsequently transferred to the Federal Court of Australia for interpretation of Commonwealth legislation. The Federal Court heard the appeal and considered the operation of the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth) with respect to the plaintiff's claims.
The procedural history includes several interlocutory applications and submissions, primarily focused on jurisdictional matters and the interpretation of the relevant legislation. The case has also involved detailed submissions on expert medical evidence and the standard of care applicable to the circumstances of the surgery.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth) applies to the claims made by Dr. Kaplan.
2. Whether the medical staff's actions during the surgery fell below the standard of care, resulting in compensable damages.
3. If applicable, what amount of damages should be awarded to Dr. Kaplan under the Act.
Held
1. The court concluded that the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth) applies to the claims made by Dr. Kaplan.
2. The medical staff's actions during the surgery did fall below the standard of care, resulting in compensable damages.
3. The court awarded Dr. Kaplan $100,000 in damages under the Act.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In determining whether the Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995 (Cth) applies, the court examined the statutory framework and its jurisdictional scope. It found that Dr. Kaplan's claims related to medical treatment provided by state health services, thereby falling within the purview of the Act. The court considered the Act's purpose to provide a framework for compensation for harm caused by medical treatment, and concluded that the claims were appropriately governed by this legislation.
Regarding the standard of care, the court assessed whether the medical staff's actions during the surgery were below the acceptable professional standard. The evidence presented demonstrated that several critical errors were made, which directly contributed to Dr. Kaplan's injuries. The court relied on expert medical testimony to establish the requisite standard of care and compared the defendants' actions against this benchmark. The conclusion was that the medical staff's actions were indeed substandard and breached the duty of care owed to Dr. Kaplan.
The court then moved to the issue of damages. It considered the nature and extent of Dr. Kaplan's injuries, as well as the emotional and financial impact on him. The court also took into account the value of an official apology, which it deemed significant in this context. It awarded Dr. Kaplan $100,000, reflecting the totality of his losses and the need for accountability. The court noted that the amount was not excessive and was within the range of compensation typically awarded in similar cases under the Act.