Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 5) [2022] FCA 909

File number(s): VID 391 of 2021
Judgment of: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 4 August 2022
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – application by respondents to call further witness – whether evidence is responsive to applicants’ evidence – where new evidence not promptly notified – application refused
Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 26
Date of last submission/s: 3 August 2022
Date of hearing: 29 July 2022
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Butt with Mr C Dawlings and Mr A Marcou
Solicitor for the Applicants: Cornwalls
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr C Young QC with Mr T Jeffrie and Mr B House
Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison

ORDERS

VID 391 of 2021
BETWEEN:

JOEL KAPLAN

First Applicant

JANET ABADEE AS REPRESENTATIVE OF MATT KAPLAN, A MINOR

Second Applicant

SARIT COHEN AS REPRESENTATIVE OF GUY COHEN, A MINOR (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

STATE OF VICTORIA

First Respondent

RICHARD MINACK

Second Respondent

PAUL VARNEY

Third Respondent

DEMI FLESSA

Fourth Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MORTIMER J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 AUGUST 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application to call Leigh Sanders as a witness in this proceeding on behalf of the respondents is refused.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MORTIMER J:

  1. The respondents have sought leave to call a further witness, Leigh Sanders, in the proceeding. The respondents have so far called 12 witnesses (including the individual respondents) with 16 lay witnesses and one expert witness yet to be called. The next tranche of the hearing is not scheduled until mid-November 2022, due to various commitments of counsel and the Court.

  2. The respondents submit Mr Sanders’ evidence is responsive to the evidence of Jasmine Karro, a present student of Brighton Secondary College who gave evidence on behalf of the applicants on 16 June 2022. Relevantly to the respondents’ present application, the respondents nominate three pieces of evidence given by Ms Karro. The first two were said by the respondents to be that she:

    (a)saw “probably over 200” swastikas during her time at BSC; and

    (b)saw them carved into tables, drawn on walls and tables, in the bathroom areas of the toilets and “graffitied” in a lot of public spaces at the school.

  3. I note that these aspects of Ms Karro’s evidence about swastikas was not dissimilar to the evidence given by many of the other student witnesses, and by the applicants.

  4. However, Ms Karro gave some additional evidence not given, as I understand it, by any of the applicants or the other student witnesses. Certainly on this application the respondents did not suggest that any other student witnesses had given this evidence. The applicants did point to somewhat similar evidence having been given, though in much more general terms, at transcript p 426, ll 16-19…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 909
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kaplan v State of Victoria (No 5), the respondents sought to call additional witness evidence, specifically from Leigh Sanders, to counter the applicants' case. The matter was heard in the Federal Court, and the primary focus of the court was whether the respondents' proposed evidence was relevant and responsive to the existing case. The applicants argued that the respondents had not promptly disclosed this new evidence and that allowing it at this stage would be unfair.

The legal issues before the court involved the procedural fairness in allowing late disclosure of additional evidence and whether the proposed evidence was relevant to the matters already before the court. The court needed to determine if the respondents' application to call Leigh Sanders as a witness should be permitted under the circumstances. Given that the respondents did not promptly notify the applicants of this additional evidence, and considering the significant amount of evidence already presented by the applicants, the court found it would be unfair to allow the respondents to introduce a material addition to their evidence case at this stage.

The court reasoned that the respondents' application to call Leigh Sanders as a witness should be refused. The court emphasised that how counsel decide to deal with opposing party evidence is a tactical decision, and the respondents had ample opportunity to address the applicants' evidence directly. Allowing the new evidence would disrupt the fairness of the proceedings and the strategic decisions made by the applicants based on the disclosed evidence. Therefore, the application was dismissed.

In conclusion, the court refused the respondents' application to call Leigh Sanders as a witness, noting that the late disclosure of this evidence would be unfair and disrupt the procedural fairness of the proceedings. The court's final order was that the application to call Leigh Sanders as a witness on behalf of the respondents was refused, and entry of orders was to be dealt with in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application to call Leigh Sanders as a witness in this proceeding on behalf of the respondents is refused.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by the respondents to call a further witness, Leigh Sanders, in the proceedings. The application is to introduce evidence that was not promptly notified to the applicants. The applicants had provided extensive evidence about maintenance and cleaning activities around the school, including specific questions to Mr Minack about painting and repainting activities. Mr Minack was cross-examined on this evidence. Despite the opportunity, the respondents did not directly address Ms Karro’s evidence with Mr Minack during the trial. The applicants argued that allowing the respondents to introduce new evidence at this stage would be unfair.

The matter came before the court on an application by the respondents to call Leigh Sanders as a witness. This application was made after the applicants had already provided significant evidence and were in the process of being cross-examined on that evidence. The court was tasked with deciding whether to permit the respondents to introduce additional evidence that was not previously disclosed. The decision involved assessing whether the new evidence was responsive to the applicants' evidence and whether it was fair to allow the respondents to introduce it at such a late stage in the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Minack answered this question, and further questions, about painting and repainting of the school over several pages of transcript, again mentioning Mr Sanders expressly at transcript p 1162, l 29 and by implication at transcript p 1163, l 22. As far as I can ascertain, Ms Karro’s evidence was not put directly to Mr Minack. However, there was an opportunity to do so. How counsel decide to deal with the evidence given by an opposing party is a forensic decision. In this case, Mr Minack was asked to, and gave, a significant amount of evidence about maintenance and cleaning activities around the school. The applicants then cross-examined Mr Minack on the basis of that evidence, and on the basis of the remainder of the respondents’ evidence case as disclosed by the outlines. It would be wholly unfair to allow the respondents to now introduce a material addition to that evidence.Conclusion The respondents’ application is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided by the witness Leigh Sanders and assessed its responsiveness to the applicants' evidence. It was found that Mr Minack had addressed several pages of transcript about painting and repainting of the school, mentioning Mr Sanders expressly and by implication. The court acknowledged that there was an opportunity for the applicants to question Mr Minack about Ms Karro’s evidence but determined that the decision on how to handle opposing party evidence is a strategic choice for counsel. Given that Mr Minack had already provided substantial evidence about maintenance and cleaning activities, and the applicants had cross-examined him based on that evidence, the court ruled it would be unfair to allow the respondents to introduce additional material evidence at this stage of the proceedings. This decision aligns with the principle that allowing new evidence at a late stage can be considered unfair and disruptive to the trial process. The ratio decidendi established by the decision is that courts should refuse applications to call additional witnesses when the evidence is not promptly notified and its introduction would be unfair at the given stage of the proceedings.