JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
TITLE OF COURT : THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)
CITATION: ENGLISH -v- VANTAGE HOLDINGS GROUP PTY LTD [2021] WASCA 47
CORAM: MURPHY JA
MITCHELL JA
VAUGHAN JA
HEARD: 16 OCTOBER 2020
DELIVERED : 23 MARCH 2021
FILE NO/S: CACV 144 of 2019
BETWEEN: MARK ANTHONY ENGLISH
First Appellant
PA AUDIT PTY LTD
Second Appellant
AND
VANTAGE HOLDINGS GROUP PTY LTD
First Respondent
RELIANCE FRANCHISE PARTNERS PTY LTD
Second Respondent
AUSTRALIAN RELIANCE PTY LTD
Third Respondent
AUSTRALIAN RELIANCE GROUP PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent
ANDREW PAUL DONNELLY
Fifth Respondent
KIMBERLEY JAMES HANSON
Sixth Respondent
HAWKSTONE GROUP PTY LTD
Seventh Respondent
INSUBI PTY LTD
Eighth Respondent
DFK PA PARTNERS PTY LTD
Ninth Respondent
ON APPEAL FROM:
Jurisdiction : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Coram: SMITH J
Citation: VANTAGE HOLDINGS GROUP PTY LTD -v- DONNELLY [No 4] [2019] WASC 398
File Number : CIV 1086 of 2016
Catchwords:
Practice and procedure - Pleadings - Auditor of company carrying on business with AFSL - Whether statement of claim discloses reasonable cause of action on statutory accessorial liability claims under corporations legislation - Whether statement of claim discloses reasonable cause of action on breach of contractual or tortious duties claims - Whether plaintiffs should have leave to replead - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 79(c), s 1317H
Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)
Result:
Leave to appeal granted
Appeal allowed on ground 1
Appeal allowed in part on grounds 2, 3 and 5
Leave to replead granted
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| First Appellant | : | M Feutrill SC & C MacMillan |
| Second Appellant | : | M Feutrill SC & C MacMillan |
| First Respondent | : | M L Bennett |
| Second Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Third Respondent | : | M L Bennett |
| Fourth Respondent | : | M L Bennett |
| Fifth Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Sixth Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Seventh Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Eighth Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Ninth Respondent | : | No appearance |
Solicitors:
| First Appellant | : | HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Perth) |
| Second Appellant | : | HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Perth) |
| First Respondent | : | Bennett + Co |
| Second Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Third Respondent | : | Bennett + Co |
| Fourth Respondent | : | Bennett + Co |
| Fifth Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Sixth Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Seventh Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Eighth Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Ninth Respondent | : | No appearance |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] NSWCA 131; (2003) 179 FLR 1
Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson [No 2] [2014] WASC 102; (2014) 48 WAR 1
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Investors Forum Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWSC 267; (2005) 53 ACSR 305
Bond Corporation Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd & Ors (1987) 14 FCR 215
Dow Hager Lawrance v Lord Norreys (1890) 15 App Cas 210
Forge v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2004] NSWCA 448; (2004) 213 ALR 574
Gold Coast City Council v Pioneer Concrete (Qld) Pty Ltd (1998)
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read English v Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] WASCA 47
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the plaintiffs had sufficiently pleaded the material facts necessary to establish a causal link between the alleged breaches or contraventions and the claimed loss. The legal issues revolved around the sufficiency of the pleadings to establish a reasonable inference of causation. The plaintiffs argued that the allegations in their statement of claim, along with the evidence material, were sufficient to establish a causal link. The defendants, however, contended that the pleadings failed to adequately link the alleged breaches to the claimed loss, and thus, the claim should be dismissed for being untenable.
In reaching its decision, the court emphasised that a cause of action should not be struck out solely on the basis of a tenuous causal link unless the allegation of causation is clearly untenable on the pleadings. The court held that the plaintiffs' statement of claim, read in conjunction with the particulars and the evidence material, did not sufficiently allege a causal connection between the defendants' actions and the claimed loss. The court found that the plaintiffs had not pleaded material facts capable of establishing a reasonable inference that the alleged breaches and contraventions caused the loss. Consequently, the plaintiffs' claim for loss resulting from the misapplication of funds was deemed untenable.
The court ordered that the plaintiffs' claim for loss due to the alleged misapplication of funds be dismissed. The dismissal was based on the insufficiency of the pleadings to establish a causal link between the alleged breaches and the claimed loss. The court did not strike out the entire claim but rather dismissed the specific part related to the misapplication of funds.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In short, as French J (as his Honour then was) said in a misleading conduct case, 'the material facts establishing the necessary causal link should be pleaded'. Moreover, it is necessary to plead material facts which give rise to a 'reasonable inference' that the breach or contravention and the alleged loss stand to each other 'in the relation of cause and effect'.[87][87] Bond Corporation Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd & Ors (1987) 14 FCR 215, 221 - 222 (referring to Dow Hager Lawrance v Lord Norreys (1890) 15 App Cas 210, 221). A number of similar authorities are collected by Bond J in Sanrus Pty Ltd v Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd (No 7) [2019] QSC 241 [17] - [21]. A cause of action should only be struck out as not being reasonable due to the absence of the requisite causal link where the allegation of causation is clearly untenable on the pleading. In this context the term 'reasonable' means reasonable according to law. The question of law stands independently of the facts giving rise to it. The court must proceed on the basis that the facts alleged in the pleading are established. The question is whether, on the facts as pleaded, there is a sufficient causative relationship alleged between the alleged breach (or contravention) and the alleged loss. Any question of causation is quintessentially a question of fact and degree. The question is fact sensitive and will be affected by the evidence. This accentuates the need to take a cautious approach in assessing whether a pleaded claim is untenable. Nevertheless, the basal requirement remains: the material facts as pleaded must be capable of being regarded as sufficient to establish that the required causal connection between a breach (or a contravention) and the loss exists. The SOC as pleaded does not disclose a reasonable cause of action in this respect. There is no loss so far as the trust account defalcations saw a misappropriation from Australian Reliance's trust account to its operating account. That is as far as the material facts pleaded in the SOC go. A somewhat wider case was alleged in the Particulars and the EM - as further explained by counsel for the plaintiffs - in terms of loss due to the misapplication by Australian Reliance for non-corporate purposes of the funds it so obtained in breach of trust. There are two difficulties with that wider case. First, the material facts are not pleaded. That shortcoming might be excused. The auditors did not rest on niceties; they were content to deal with the allegations as they appeared from the Particulars and the EM. Second, and more fundamentally, the paucity of the material allegations on the question of causation of loss reading the SOC, the Particulars and the EM as a whole are insufficient to establish - arguably or by reasonable inference - the required specific causal connection between the alleged contraventions or breaches and the loss said to be suffered. On the facts as alleged, while it may be said that the auditors' alleged contraventions and breaches were circumstances that were antecedent to the loss, they were not causative of the loss.