Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Bettles

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Bettles [2023] FCA 975

File number: QUD 693 of 2019
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 18 August 2023
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – application under s 45-1 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations) (IPS), Sch 2 to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – application for cancellation of defendant’s registration as a registered liquidator – whether defendant breached duties in ss 180(1), 181(1) and 182(1) of the Corporations Act – whether defendant breached common law duties – accessorial liability – whether a person involved in a contravention of s 180 of the Corporations Act contravenes that Act – whether defendant was involved in contraventions of s 181(1) and s 182(1) of the Corporations Act – where primary contravenor is not a party to the proceeding – where the defendant relies on s 545(1) of the Corporations Act in relation to alleged breaches of duties as liquidator – whether defendant breached provisions of the Australian Restructuring Insolvency & Turnaround Association Code of Professional Practice– whether plaintiff has established matters to be taken into account for the purposes of s 45-1 of the IPS – whether defendant failed to discharge obligations as liquidator to obtain relevant books and records in relation to reports filed under s 533 of the Corporations Act – application dismissed
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, being Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 18

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 12DA(1), 12DB(1)(i) and 13

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 79, 180, 181, 182, 422, 438, 533, 536 (repealed) 1041H, 1308(2), 1317E

Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)

Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations), being Sch 2 to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1 and s 45-1 subs (4)(a), (b), (d) and (e)

National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) s 29 and s 30

Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth)

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) Sch 1 s 449-89(1D)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Treasury Laws Amendment (Strengthening Corporate and Financial Sector Penalties) Act 2019 (Cth) s 116

Estate Agents Act 1980 (Vic) s 12(1)

Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW) s 55

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v ActiveSuper Pty Ltd (in liq) (2015) 235 FCR 181

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Big Star Energy Ltd (No 3) (2020) 389 ALR 17; [2020] FCA 1442

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis (No 8) (2016) 336 ALR 209; [2016] FCA 1023

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dover Financial Advisers Pty Ltd (No 2) (2019) 140 ACSR 635; [2019] FCA 2151

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Drake (No 2) (2016) 340 ALR 75; [2016] FCA 1552

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Flugge (2016) 342 ALR 1; [2016] VSC 779

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Maxwell (2006) 59 ACSR 373; [2006] NSWSC 1052

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Mitchell (No 2) (2020) 382 ALR 425

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Bettles and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 975
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has filed an application against Mr Bettles for the cancellation of his registration as a liquidator. ASIC contends that Mr Bettles breached various statutory and common law duties while acting as liquidator for companies in the MA Group. Mr Bettles denies any wrongdoing. The primary legal issues in this case revolve around whether Mr Bettles breached his statutory duties under the Corporations Act and common law duties, whether he was involved in any contraventions of the Act by Mr Marlborough, and whether he failed to obtain relevant books and records in relation to reports filed under s 533 of the Corporations Act. The court examined the evidence and found that ASIC had not established any matters to be taken into account for the purposes of s 45-1 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations) (IPS). The court held that there were no grounds to cancel Mr Bettles’ registration as a liquidator. The proceeding was dismissed, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant’s costs. If either party wishes to apply to vary the order regarding costs, they should file submissions within the specified timeframe. Unless a party requests an oral hearing, any application to vary the costs order will be dealt with on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be dismissed.

2. The plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding.

3. If either party wishes to apply to vary Order 2 above, on or before 1 September 2023 that party should file and serve submissions, not exceeding five pages in length, setting out the orders sought and the reasons for seeking those orders.

4. If submissions are filed by a party pursuant to Order 3 above then the other party may file submissions in response, not exceeding five pages in length, such submissions to be filed on or before 15 September 2023.

5. Unless a party requests an oral hearing, any application made to vary Order 2 above will be dealt with on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1 ASIC’s pleaded case

[6]

2 Facts

[19]

2.1 Witnesses

[19]

2.2 ASIC commences an investigation

[24]

2.3 Mr Bettles – background

[25]

2.4 Worrells’ file management system

[28]

2.5 The MA Group

[35]

2.6 Mr MacVicar

[41]

2.7 The ATO serves statutory demands

[46]

2.8 Ramsden Lawyers

[48]

2.9 Pre-appointment meetings

[52]

2.9.1 8 July 2016 Meeting

[52]

2.9.2 14 July 2016 Email

[61]

2.9.3 14 July 2016 Meeting

[62]

2.9.4 16 July 2016 Meeting

[65]

2.9.5 Mr Bettles’ general recollections of discussions at the pre-appointment meetings

[67]

2.10 The WMS PowerPoint

[69]

2.11 Mr Bettles’ knowledge

[86]

2.11.1 Mr Bettles’ knowledge as at 8 July 2016 including the strategy

[86]

2.11.2 Mr Bettles’ knowledge as at 14 July 2016

[91]

2.11.3 Mr Bettles’ knowledge as at 16 July 2016

[95]

2.12 The Benchmark Group of companies

[99]

2.13 Mr Bettles’ appointment as external administrator of companies in the MA Group

[104]

2.14 Security interests granted to Ramsden Lawyers, WMS, entities associated with Mr Domingo and Crest Accounting

[114]

2.15 Iridium Holdings

[125]

2.16 The MA Group as a tax consolidated group

[129]

2.17 Labour hire companies in the MA Group

[157]

2.18 Progress Meetings

[161]

2.19 Management deeds

[164]

2.20 Provincial Property

[167]

2.20.1 Proposed management deed

[171]

2.20.2 Operation of Provincial Property’s bank accounts

[193]

2.20.3 Mr Marlborough’s involvement

[201]

2.20.4 Valuation of the Rent Roll

[204]

2.20.5 The requirement to hold a real estate agent’s licence

[208]

2.20.5.1 Victoria

[210]

2.20.5.2 New South Wales

[217]

2.20.5.3 Queensland

[220]

2.20.6 Marketing and sale of the Rent Roll

[222]

2.20.7 Disclaimer of the Provincial Property property management agreements

[227]

2.21 Management rights held by Airlie Beach

[230]

2.22 SS Residential

[249]

2.22.1 The SS Residential Deed

[254]

2.22.2 Payment of the Surrender Fee

[260]

2.22.3 The MacVicar Payment

[261]

2.22.4 The winding up of SS Residential

[282]

2.23 MM Prime

[289]

2.24 Elderton Transaction

[319]

2.25 Capricorn Securities and Iridium Financial Planning

[330]

2.25.1 Iridium Financial Planning and Capricorn Securities Management Deeds

[343]

2.25.2 Liaison with ASIC

[350]

2.25.3 Payments to Mr Marlborough

[365]

2.25.4 Sale of the Client Book

[367]

2.25.5 Winding up of Capricorn Securities and Iridium Financial Planning

[399]

2.26 Books and records of the companies in the MA Group and the s 533 reports

[402]

2.26.1 Books and records

[402]

2.26.1.1 MYOB files and other financial information

[402]

2.26.1.2 Hard copy books and records

[405]

2.26.1.3 Electronic Material

[410]

2.26.2 ASIC serves a notice for production of books

[411]

2.26.3 Section 533 reports

[414]

3 Statutory framework and legal principles

[422]

3.1 The IPS

[422]

3.2 Common law and statutory duties

[428]

3.2.1 Section 180(1) of the Corporations Act

[439]

3.2.2 Section 181(1) of the Corporations Act

[440]

3.2.3 Section 182(1) of the Corporations Act

[442]

3.2.4 Accessorial liability – “involved in”

[443]

3.3 Section 545 of the Corporations Act

[449]

3.4 The ARITA Code of Professional Practice for Insolvency Practitioners

[453]

4 Consideration

[457]

5 ASIC’s implementation case

[459]

5.1 The MacVicar Deed and the MacVicar Payment (9.5 FASOC)

[460]

5.1.1 Did Mr Bettles breach his duty owed to Iridium Holdings under s 180 of the Corporations Act and fail to meet Liquidator’s Duty No. 1 and Liquidator’s Duty No. 2?

[461]

5.1.2 Did Mr Bettles act contrary to the ARITA Code of Conduct?

[474]

5.1.3 Was Mr Bettles involved in Mr Marlborough’s contravention of s 180 of the Corporations Act?

[487]

5.1.3.1 Is Mr Marlborough a necessary party?

[492]

5.1.3.2 Involvement in a breach of s 180 of the Corporations Act?

[495]

5.2 Entry into the Management Deeds (9.6-9.15 FASOC)

[509]

5.2.1 The pleaded case

[514]

5.2.2 Absence of Management Services and redirection of income streams

[524]

5.2.2.1 Were management services provided by the Benchmark Group?

[525]

5.2.2.2 Redirection of income streams

[539]

5.2.3 Did Mr Marlborough control the Benchmark Group

[545]

5.2.4 Did Mr Marlborough breach ss 180(1), 181(1) and/or 182(1) of the Corporations Act?

[553]

5.2.4.1 Section 180(1)

[554]

5.2.4.2 Section 181(1)

[555]

5.2.4.3 Section 182(1)

[565]

5.2.5 Mr Bettles’ alleged involvement in Mr Marlborough’s contraventions of s 181(1) and s 182(1) of the Corporations Act

[569]

5.2.6 Did Mr Bettles breach s 180(1) of the Corporations Act

[570]

5.3 The Elderton Transaction and MM Prime (9.16 FASOC)

[587]

5.3.1 Mr Bettles’ knowledge

[589]

5.3.2 Did Mr Bettles breach s 180(1) of the Corporations Act and/or Liquidator’s Duty No. 1, Liquidator’s Duty No. 2 and Liquidator’s Duty No. 4?

[598]

5.4 Sale of the Client Book (9.17 FASOC)

[606]

5.5 Provincial Property Rent Roll – disclaimer of onerous property (9.18 FASOC)

[655]

6 Other alleged breaches

[680]

6.1 Members’ voluntary windings up (10 FASOC)

[680]

6.2 Accepting appointments for SS Residential, Capricorn Securities and Iridium Financial Planning (11 FASOC)

[702]

6.3 DIRRIs, relevant relationships and indemnities (12 FASOC)

[710]

6.4 Failure to obtain books and records (13 FASOC)

[724]

7 The Bradford Marine Liquidation (Sch D to the FASOC)

[750]

7.1 Facts

[754]

7.1.1 Sale of Bradford Marine to Bradford Marine Services

[760]

7.1.2 The liquidation of Bradford Marine

[763]

7.1.2.1 Pre-appointment

[763]

7.1.2.2 Reports to Creditors

[773]

7.1.2.3 Investigations

[779]

7.1.2.4 Valuation of the Bradford Marine Business

[791]

7.1.2.5 Helicopter Aerial Surveys

[801]

7.1.3 The Bradford Marine Conduct

[813]

7.1.3.1 Offer by Mr Clark

[821]

7.1.3.2 Notification to Helicopter Aerial Surveys of conditional acceptance of offer

[832]

7.1.3.3 Engagement of CML

[839]

7.1.4 The Originating Application Conduct

[842]

7.2 Consideration

[848]

8 Relief sought by ASIC

[883]

9 Conclusion

[886]

Background

Background to the litigation

As is apparent from the summary set out above, ASIC contends that by his conduct Mr Bettles breached what it refers to as “Liquidators’ Duties” as set out in Sch C to the FASOC (see Annexure A to these reasons). 2. Facts2.1 Witnesses Although there was a significant volume of documentary evidence relied on, there were only four witnesses. ASIC led evidence from the following witnesses:(1)Paul Dunn who is employed as an investigator by ASIC. Mr Dunn conducts investigations into suspected contraventions of the laws regulated by ASIC and was in ASIC’s investigation into the MA Group, Mr Dunn was cross-examined;(2)Benjamin de Waard, who is employed as a computer forensic analyst by ASIC. Mr de Ward gave evidence about the nature of metadata and his review of the metadata of two documents. Mr de Waard was not cross-examined; and(3)Oliver Jones. Mr Jones is a solicitor. He was admitted to practice on 2 February 2009. Mr Jones practises primarily in commercial and corporate law including advising companies from time to time about insolvency issues. He has also undertaken some immigration and employment law. From early 2009 to mid-February 2017 Mr Jones worked as a solicitor at Ramsden Lawyers on the Gold Coast, Queensland, principally under the direction of the firm’s managing partner, John Ramsden. Mr Jones was involved in advising the MA Group in relation to transactions the subject of this proceeding. He was cross-examined. Mr Bettles gave evidence in support of his defence. His qualifications and background are set out below. Mr Bettles was cross-examined. It is convenient at this point to make some observations about his evidence. It was apparent that Mr Bettles did his best to assist the Court. In addition to his detailed affidavits he provided frank answers in cross-examination and was prepared to make concessions where appropriate. Overall Mr Bettles struck me as someone who endeavoured to do his best both professionally and in assisting the Court. As is clear from Mr Bettles’ evidence he has many years’ experience as an insolvency practitioner and registered liquidator. That said, my impression was that he had not had significant experience in large group insolvencies. A review of his evidence and the way in which he interacted with the director of, and advisors to, MA Group companies suggested a level of naivety on Mr Bettles’ part and a complete lack of scepticism. Mr Bettles was too trusting. While it is not my role to speculate, it was perhaps these qualities that ultimately caused Mr Bettles to manage the liquidations as he did. In short Mr Bettles did not strike me as someone who would act in disregard of his duties or statutory obligations. On the contrary, he struck me as someone who is earnest and attempted to “do the right thing” when it came to understanding his role as liquidator. 2.2 ASIC commences an investigation On 29 September 2016 ASIC commenced an investigation under s 13 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act) in relation to potential breaches of ss 184, 911A and 1041F of the Corporations Act and s 29 and s 30 of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) by Capricorn Securities and BPW. ASIC’s investigations subsequently expanded to include, among other matters, the conduct of the liquidators, Mr Bettles and Rajendra Khatri, appointed to companies in the MA Group.2.3 Mr Bettles – background

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that I am not satisfied that there are any matters to be taken into account for the purposes of s 45-1 of the IPS. Therefore there will be no requirement for the matter to proceed to a hearing for remedies and sanctions. 9. Conclusion Given my findings, the proceeding should be dismissed with costs. If either party wishes to make any application in relation to the costs of the proceeding, they should do so by filing submissions, not exceeding five pages in length, within 14 days. If submissions are filed then the other party has leave to file any submissions in reply, not exceeding five pages in length, within 14 days thereafter. Unless the parties request an oral hearing, any application made in relation to costs of the proceeding will be determined on the papers. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Jones did very little talking during the meeting. His role was to take notes, which he did on his iPad. Mr Jones’ notes comprise six pages. Although he cannot now recall who said what at the meeting, by reference to his notes he recalls that:(1)as reflected on the first page of the notes, there was discussion about:(a)the assets which remained within various companies in the MA Group, which in many cases were trail commissions being received under various agreements;(b)checking with Liam Young, the general legal counsel of the MA Group and the sole director of BPW, BPW Holdings and Young Corporation (NSW) Pty Ltd, about whether any companies on which a statutory demand had been served were complying with payment arrangements, including checking those companies with “Image” in their names;(c)a company called “Iridium Home Loans” and determining if the trail agreements would cease upon certain events occurring, such as liquidation;(d)financial reports in relation to various of the MA Group companies which were reviewed during the meeting;(e)various trail commissions being received by companies in the MA Group;(f)Capricorn Securities, which held an AFSL, and Iridium Financial Planning, which was an authorised corporate representative under that AFSL, that a statutory demand for about $70,000 had been issued to Capricorn Securities, concern that the trailing commissions received by Capricorn Securities would cease if it went into liquidation based on that demand and whether the statutory demand should be paid in order to avoid that consequence;(g)JP Downey of Downey and Co and MA Human Resources, which was in receivership;(h)Iridium Home Loans paying the statutory demand, selling off its assets and putting that company into administration to effect the sale of assets or perhaps entering into a deed of company arrangement (DOCA);(i)Airlie Beach, including that it had management rights to certain properties located at Airlie Beach which David Domingo, a director of various companies in the MA Group, wanted, that Mr Marlborough had not allowed Mr Domingo to take these management rights because he had already taken an asset worth $3 million, which concerned the Prime Securities Income Trust, and that Mr Domingo was aware that Mr Bettles would likely try to recover the $3 million asset once he was appointed liquidator;(j)the taxation liability of the MA Group, that the MA Group was a consolidated group for tax purposes under a tax sharing arrangement which meant that there was joint and several liability for tax debts and whether the ATO would make a decision to treat the MA Group as a group for taxation purposes. In cross-examination Mr Jones accepted that the effect of the discussion was that payroll tax would likely be consolidated but that it was not known at that time whether other taxation liabilities would be consolidated by the ATO;(k)the trail book of Capricorn Securities and Iridium Financial Planning and, if it was not sold before those companies went into liquidation, the book would not have any value if sold by liquidators because liquidation would mean loss of the AFSL and would result in the trail providers no longer paying the trail commission;(l)the NewCo arrangement. The notes state “Richard’s son will create new entity with Liam as sole director and shareholder. Ownership of the trustee co, will also be Liam”. This was a reference to Braiden, Mr Young and the NewCo arrangement as referred to at [50(2)] above;(m)Provincial Property and that it had rental property management rights to a large number of properties in certain regional cities; and(n)Mellow Brae, a company associated with Mr Domingo, and a second mortgage book relating to the Prime Securities Income Trust;(2)as reflected on the second page of the notes, there was discussion about:(a)the transaction with Mr Domingo concerning the Prime Securities Income Trust;(b)a $4 million asset which was the same asset as referred to at [59(1)(i)] above. During the discussion that asset was variously referred to as being worth between $3 and $4 million;(c)MM Prime which had an asset in relation to certain work in progress from property development and that Mr Marlborough wanted to buy this business in order to collect the work in progress. I note that in his notes Mr Jones recorded that:Richard will want to buy this business and carry on but Richard needs $500K to get them to continue business so can collect WIP. Only way to pull out is the below $400K from the planning business but that will take 90 days. Every day there is settlements that said.(d)various options for the liquidation of the companies in the MA Group; and(3)as reflected on the third page of the notes, there was discussion about:(a)the current employees of the MA Group and that Mr Marlborough would employ some of them in NewCo;(b)Mr Lavell being prepared to accept $130,000 or $140,000 in satisfaction of the outstanding amount of $165,000 owing to WMS for fees; (c)what Mr Bettles could do once appointed as liquidator of Iridium Holdings, the sole shareholder of companies in the MA Group. Mr Ramsden noted that Mr Bettles could wind up each of the subsidiary companies;(d)whether the liquidator could access funds held in trust. There was $450,000 available which could be used to pay WMS’ outstanding fees with the balance, of $350,000, available for use by Mr Bettles in the liquidation; (e)a deed with the NSW government concerning a payment to SS Residential;(f)ensuring that Capricorn Securities kept its AFSL by paying its debts and avoiding going into liquidation, the need to keep the responsible manager in order to maintain the AFSL and that he may need to be paid;(g)tax liability, as to which Mr Bettles made a comment about the tax liability for the consolidated group;(h)WMS’ and Ramsden Lawyers’ fees. This included a detailed discussion about how WMS’ past fees could be secured and Mr Ramsden’s suggestion, in relation to Ramsden Lawyers’ fees, that a security interest provision be inserted into its fee agreement which would make all of the MA Group companies liable for the fees and allow Ramsden Lawyers to register a security interest. The reference in Mr Jones’ notes to “Getting $450 once deed is signed” was a reference to an amount of about $450,000 which SS Residential expected to receive once the deed with the NSW government was signed; and(i)the obligation of other MA Group members to pay Ramsden Lawyers’ fees. Mr Jones explained that his file note refers to issuing a demand to SS Residential or Airlie Beach because those companies had an asset upon which demand could be made.