Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis (No 8)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis (No 8)
[2016] FCA 1023

File number: QUD 574 of 2010
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 26 August 2016
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – whether directors can be liable for contravention of s 180(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) where they are the only shareholders of a solvent company – nature and history of duty in s 180(1) – whether duty is a private duty owed only to corporation or whether it is also a public duty – circumstances in which directors can be liable for corporation’s breach of Corporations Act – “stepping stone” approach to liability of directors

CORPORATIONS – whether provision of financial advice by corporation contravened s 945A and s 1041E of the Corporations Act – elements which must be proved for a criminal offence by breach of s 945A or s 1041E of the Corporations Act – meaning of “subject matter of the advice” in s 945A – meaning of “likely to induce” in s 1041E – relevance of the absence of evidence of any actual inducement

CORPORATIONS – meaning of a “retail client” – whether investments by jointly advised clients can be aggregated for purposes of determining whether they are retail clients

CORPORATIONS – s 1317S of the Corporations Act – whether conduct of directors was honest and “ought fairly to be excused” – history and meaning of the expression “ought fairly to be excused”

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 13

Companies Act 1981 (Cth) ss 229(2), 535

Corporate Law Economic Reform Program Act 1999 (Cth) s 180

Corporate Law Reform Act 1992 (Cth) s 11

Corporations Act 1989 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Chs 2, 7; Divs 2, 3; Pts 7.5, 7.7, 7.9; ss 79, 179, 179(1), 180, 180(1), 180(2), 185, 206C, 206E, 206E(1), 206E(1)(a)(i), 588M, 588W, 727, 734, 761A, 761G, 761G(7), 761G(7)(a), 761G(10), 761GA, 763A(1)(a), 764A(1)(j), 766A(1)(a), 766B, 766B(1), 766B(3), 766B(4), 911A, 911B, 912A, 912A(1)(a), 912A(1)(c) 915C, 915C(1)(a), 916A, 916B, 916F, 920A, 920C(1), 941D, 944A, 944A(b), 945A, 945A(1), 945A(1)(a), 945A(1)(b), 945A(1)(c), 952E, 952G, 961M, 1012H, 1017G, 1021FA, 1021FB, 1021NB, 1021NC, 1041B, 1041E, 1041E(1),1041E(1)(a), 1041E(1)(b), 1041E(1)(c), 1041E(2), 1101B(1)(a)(i), 1308A, 1311, 1316HB, 1317E(1), 1317G, 1317GA, 1317H, 1317HA, 1317S, 1317S(1), 1317S(1)(a), 1317S(2), 1317S(3), 1324(1), 1324(6), 1318

Corporations Law (Cth) ss 232, 232(4), 232(6B), 1317DA, 1317DB, 1317EA(3), 1317EB, 1317FA, 1317JA, 1318

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 140(1), 140(2)

Financial Services Reform Act 2001 (Cth)

Financial Transaction Reports Act 1988 (Cth) s 31(1)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52

Criminal Code 1995 (Cth) Ch 2; Divs 4, 5, 6; ss 2.1, 3.1, 3.2, 4.1, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.4(4), 5.6(1), 5.6(2)

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) regs 7.1.17B, 7.1.18, 7.1.18(1), 7.1.18(3), 7.1.18(3)(a), 7.1.18(5), 7.1.19, 7.1.19(1), 7.1.19(3)(b), 7.1.19(5), 7.1.19(7), 7.1.19(8)

Explanatory Memorandum, Companies Bill (Cth) 1981

Explanatory Memorandum, Corporate Law Economic Reform Program Bill (Cth) 1998

Explanatory Memorandum, Corporate Law Reform Bill (Cth) 1992

Explanatory Memorandum, Corporations Amendment (Further Future of Financial Advice Measures) Bill (Cth) 2011

Explanatory Memorandum, Corporations Bill (Cth) 1988

Explanatory Memorandum,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimati... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1023
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) brought proceedings against Mr and Mrs Cassimatis, the directors of Storm Financial Services, in the Federal Court of Australia, alleging breaches of the Corporations Act 2001. The primary issues before the court were whether the directors could be held liable under section 180(1) for the corporation's actions, the interpretation of sections 945A and 1041E concerning the provision of financial advice, the aggregation of investments for determining "retail client" status, and whether the directors' conduct was honest and could be excused under section 1317S.

The court held that Mr and Mrs Cassimatis contravened section 180(1) of the Corporations Act by failing to prevent inappropriate financial advice being given to certain investors. The court found that these investors, who were nearing or in retirement with limited financial resources, were likely to suffer catastrophic consequences from such advice. The court also determined that Storm contravened sections 945A(1)(b) and 945A(1)(c) of the Corporations Act, identifying six instances of investors affected. However, the court found no criminal breach of sections 945A or 1041E. The court deferred submissions on penalties and other relief to a later hearing.

The court concluded that Mr and Mrs Cassimatis were liable under section 180(1) for the corporation's breaches of the Corporations Act, based on civil breaches of section 945A. The court held that the directors' conduct was not honest and ought not to be excused under section 1317S. The court ordered that the matter be listed for directions concerning penalties and other relief.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The matter be listed for directions for a hearing on penalties and other relief.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Any submissions concerning the fourth element were deferred to the remedies hearing.CONCLUSION My conclusion is that Mr and Mrs Cassimatis each contravened s 180(1) of the Corporations Act by exercising their powers in a way which caused or “permitted” (by omission to prevent) inappropriate advice to be given to the relevant investors. Those relevant investors were members of a class of investor, as pleaded by ASIC, who (in summary terms) were retired or close to retirement, had few assets, little income, and little or no prospect of rebuilding their financial position in the event of suffering significant loss. A reasonable director with the responsibilities of Mr or Mrs Cassimatis would have known that the Storm model was being applied to clients such as those who fell within this class and that its application was likely to lead to inappropriate advice. The consequences of that inappropriate advice would be catastrophic for Storm (the entity to whom the directors owed their duties). It would have been simple to take precautionary measures to attempt to avoid the application of the Storm model to this class of persons. ASIC brought its case on the basis that one precondition, or “stepping stone”, for a finding of contraventions by Mr and Mrs Cassimatis was that Storm also contravened the Corporations Act. I have serious doubt whether this assumption is correct. But I have proceeded on the basis that it is required because the parties had assumed this to be the case and conducted their case accordingly without submissions to the contrary. I have found that Storm contravened s 945A(1)(b) and s 945A(1)(c) of the Corporations Act. The relevant investors about whom I conclude that Storm breached its duties were the following 11 investors (six instances if couples are treated together): (i) Mr and Mrs Dodson (Part E investors); (ii) Mr and Mrs Herd (Part E investors); (iii) Mr and Mrs Higgs (Part E investors); (iv) Ms Knight (Schedule investor); (v) Mr and Mrs Madden (Schedule investors); and (vi) Mr and Mrs Walker (Schedule investors). My findings of contravention by Mr and Mrs Cassimatis are based only upon civil, not criminal, breaches of s 945A. No criminal breach of s 945A or s 1041E was proved. ASIC did not run any alternative case that in the absence of proof of such a criminal breach there was a real likelihood of such a breach. Although Mr and Mrs Cassimatis’ submissions anticipated the possibility of such a case, it is not necessary to address it. It suffices to say that such a case would have had a number of serious obstacles. Indeed, ASIC itself did not bring any prosecution or refer any brief of evidence to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions to consider a prosecution of Storm. This trial was concerned only with liability. All issues concerning remedies sought by ASIC against Mr and Mrs Cassimatis were deferred to a separate hearing. These subsequent issues include (i) the form of any declarations to be made; (ii) whether the contraventions were serious or materially prejudiced the interests of Storm (s 1317G) and, if so, the amount of any penalties; (iii) any disqualification orders to be made (including the alternative basis upon which such orders were sought under s 206E); (iv) any orders restraining Mr and Mrs Cassimatis from holding an AFSL or providing financial services; and (v) costs. The parties should now confer in relation to directions for the listing of a hearing in relation to these issues.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The workshop also compared different types of investments. With reference to comparative tables, Mr McCulloch would explain that, historically, shares performed better than both cash and property. He said that Mr Cassimatis trained him to talk about a unit in an index fund as a “supershare”, because it is a “truly diversified fund”, and “actually owns every share available on the ASX”. Mr McCulloch said that he was trained to say words to the effect of:So what Storm recommends is that you guarantee yourself the big stacks of coins by investing your money in one of these supershares. So how do you buy one of these supershares. You do it by pooling your money with hundreds or thousands of other investors’ money and putting it in a unit trust. That unit trust in turn will buy shares in every company that makes up the All Ords in the same proportion that its held within the All Ords… This is how we guarantee you the big stacks of coins, which is the average return….3. Confidential Financial Profile meeting and preparation of cash flowConfidential Financial Profile meeting After the education workshop, prospective clients who still wished to invest would generally have a one-on-one meeting with an adviser or adviser’s assistant. This was known as the Confidential Financial Profile meeting. At this meeting, the prospective client would be given a Financial Services Guide, and would be asked to complete a Confidential Financial Profile. The Confidential Financial Profile meeting involved obtaining from the prospective client a significant amount of financial information and documentation (including pay slips, bank statements, loan statements, superannuation statements and insurance documentation). Mr McCulloch would spend up to two hours completing a Confidential Financial Profile which recorded the client’s personal details, employment details, income, living and other expenses, and assets and liabilities. Mr McCulloch said that he was trained to say at the start of the meeting words to the effect of:Remember Storm isn’t here for everybody. The type of advice we’re going to give may make you feel uncomfortable, and we need to talk about what we talked about during the workshop. During the workshop, we showed you certain slides to deal with change, and remember we’re trying to get you to think logically, not emotionally. If you think emotionally, you’ll never put up with volatility. If you think logically, you’ll realise that people who make more money tend to put up with assets that can increase and decrease in value over time. In relation to risk and volatility, we talked about risk during the workshop and we talked about the fact that there are different types of risks, one being default risk, one being asset selection risk….You may still think that to get a high return you need to take a higher risk. That’s not Storm’s point of view. Storm’s point of view is that you need a higher volatile asset that gives you high returns without the risk of default.