O’Sullivan and Australian Securities & Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

O’Sullivan and Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2022] AATA 153 (27 January 2022)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL

File Number(s):      2015/0837 & 0838

Re:Michael O’Sullivan

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities & Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Date:27 January 2022

Place:Sydney

ASIC’s 16 February 2015 Ban decision under Corp Act s 920A is affirmed

ASIC’s 16 February 2015 Disqualification decision under Corp Act s 206F(1)(a) is set aside. In substitution for that decision, the Tribunal is satisfied that Mr O’Sullivan’s disqualification is justified, and decides that Mr O’Sullivan is disqualified from managing any corporation for a period (approximating two years and nine months) ending on 20 September 2024..

........................................SGD............................

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Catchwords   

CORPORATIONS – misleading financial product disclosure – banning order under s 920A – lack of care and diligence as a director – disqualification decision under s 206F – ban order decision affirmed – disqualification period reduced

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Corporations Act 2001

Cases

ASIC v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Limited (Receivers and Managers appointed) (in liquidation) (Controllers appointed) (No 3) [2013] FCA 1342

ASIC v Cassimatis (No. 8) [2016] FCA 1023

ASIC v Drake (No. 2) [2016] FCA 1552

ASIC v Healey [2011] FCA 717

ASIC vRich (2009) 75 ACSR 1

ASIC v Adler [2002] NSWSC 483

ASIC v Vizard [2005] FCA 1037

ASC v Kippe (1996) 137 ALR 423

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Forge [2007] NSWSC 1489

Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) v Mariner Corp [2015] FCA 589

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v McCormack [2017] FCA 672

Australian Executor Trustees Ltd v Provident Capital Ltd [2012] FCA 728

Boucher v ASC (1996) 71 FCR 122

Culley v ASIC [2010] FCAFC 43

Donald v ASIC [2000] FCA 1142

Doyle v ASIC [2005] HCA 78

Guss v ASIC [2006] AATA 401

Murdaca v ASIC (2009) FCAFC 92

Musumeci v ASIC [2009] AATA 524

Oreb v ASIC (No 2) [2017] FCAFC 49

O’Sullivan v ASIC [2017] AATA 644

O’Sullivan v ASIC [2018] FCA 228

R v Byrnes [1995] HCA 1

Re Hayes v ASIC [2006] AATA 1506

Re HIH Insurance Ltd (in prov liq);ASIC v Adler (2002) 42 ACSR 80

Seymour and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2017] AATA 2581

Sweeney and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2017] AATA 2182

Quinlivan v ASIC [2010] AATA 113

Vines v ASIC (2007) 73 NSWLR 451

Visnic v ASIC (2007) 231 CLR 381

Secondary Materials

Financial Sector Reform (Hayne Royal Commission Response—Stronger Regulators (2019 Measures)) Act 2020

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

  1. Mr O’Sullivan was the driving force in the establishment, of Provident Capital Limited (“PCL”).  He was PCL’s managing director throughout the period from its May 1998 incorporation to its 24 October 2012 liquidation.  He was the “key person” identified in the Australian Financial Services licence granted to PCL on 14 February 2003.[1] In April 2005, when a related company Cashflow Finance Solutions Pty Ltd (“Cashflow”)[2] was incorporated, he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O’Sullivan and Australian Securities & Investments Commissio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned review proceedings before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal regarding two decisions made by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) against Mr O’Sullivan. The first decision, made under sections 920A and 920B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), imposed a seven-year ban on Mr O’Sullivan from providing financial services. This ban was based on findings that PCL's disclosure documents and reports concerning a financial product were misleading, thereby contravening financial services law. The second decision, made under section 206F(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), disqualified Mr O’Sullivan from managing corporations for five years. This disqualification was predicated on the liquidation of PCL and Cashflow, Mr O’Sullivan's directorships of these companies, and significant asset deficiencies reported by the liquidators, coupled with contraventions of his duty of care and diligence as a director.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether ASIC's decisions to ban Mr O’Sullivan from providing financial services and to disqualify him from managing corporations were justified. Specifically, the Tribunal needed to assess whether the evidence supported the findings that PCL's disclosures were misleading, that Mr O’Sullivan had contravened his obligations of care and diligence in relation to the management of PCL's largest loan and the release of a guarantee for Cashflow, and whether these contraventions warranted the imposition of the ban and disqualification orders.

The Tribunal affirmed ASIC's decision to ban Mr O’Sullivan from providing financial services, finding that the evidence established that PCL's disclosure documents were misleading and that Mr O’Sullivan had contravened financial services law. However, the Tribunal reduced the period of disqualification from managing corporations from five years to three years. This reduction was based on a reassessment of the severity of Mr O’Sullivan's conduct in relation to his directorial duties, particularly concerning the management of PCL's largest loan and the Cashflow guarantee release, taking into account the prolonged period of review proceedings and the unexpired term of the ban order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The First Statement of Agreed Facts (“SOAF:1”):- This document was one of two “agreed” documents tendered at the previous review hearing. It contains a 109 paragraph statement of facts concerning matters requiring consideration in the review. Those matters include:-(a)PCL:- PCL’s material corporate details and history:- SOAF:1 ¶1 to 12. Those matters are summarised later in these reasons:- see paragraphs 50 to 57 below.(b)Burleigh Views:- The history of the Burleigh Views loan from 2000 to 2008 – including the 21 March 2000 $4m loan agreement, its variation in 2002, 2004 and 2007, Burleigh Views 21 August 2008 liquidation, and PCL’s possession and control of the property after 5 September 2008:- SOAF:1 ¶13 to 38. The history of the Burleigh Views loan is outlined later in these reasons:- see paragraph 67 below.(c)Development Approval:- The history of the Burleigh Views loan from August 2009 to June 2012 – including the lapse of the Development Approval for the property, steps taken to attempt to obtain a new Development Approval, PCL’s first $2m loss provision for the loan in December 2011, and valuations of the property in 2011 and 2012:- SOAF:1 ¶39 to 58. (d)PCL’s public Disclosure documents:- Details of PCL’s October 2008 to March 2012 Quarterly Reports, Benchmark Reports and Loan Arrears reports to AETL, and its December 2010 Prospectus and 2012 Information Booklets, and particularly the fact that the loan was typically not identified as a loan that was in arrears:- SOAF:1 ¶59 to 68(e)PCL’s management reports:- Details of the typical content of the regular monthly reports to the PCL Board throughout the period from November 2008 to April 2012, including details of the format and content of “Top Ten Loans Reports” and “Loan Arrears Reports”, characterisation of the Burleigh Views loan as PCL’s largest, and the fact that it was never included in the “Loan Arrears Reports”:- SOAF:1 ¶69 to 72(f)City Pacific Drawdown:- Details of PCL’s 4 September 2001 $4.070m loan to City Pacific, a June 2004 $0.9m drawdown on the PCL Burleigh Views loan and the circumstances in which Burleigh Views used the loan drawdown to assist City Pacific discharge its then (approximately) $4.5m loan balance debt to PCL:- SOAF:1 ¶74 to 79.(g)Cashflow’s structure and background:- Details of Cashflow’s business (as a short term “inventory” financier), its corporate structure and method of funding, including a 21 September 2005 “Working Capital Facilty” and a March 2012 promissory note agreement, both provided by PCL, and a June 2006 Receivables Acquisition and Servicing Agreement: (“RASA”) that had been guaranteed by PCL and Mr O’Sullivan (the “Cashflow Guarantee”), was held by BBSF Securitisation Limited (“BBSFF”) as at February 2009, and was novated to PCL in September 2010:- SOAF:1 ¶80 to 90(h)PCL’s novation of Cashflow’s RASA and release of the Cashflow guarantee:- Details of Cashflow’s November 2007 business loss insurance policy with Coface, the “breach of policy” proceedings Cashflow commenced against Coface in November 2009, BBSFF’s February and April 2010 demands on the Cashflow Guarantee, and the release of the Cashflow Guarantee (including the release of Mr O’Sullivan) in connection with PCL’s $0.775m payment to “BBSFF”:- SOAF:1 ¶91 to 107.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

ASIC’s views of aspects of Mr O’Sullivan’s conduct in relation to PCL, and the circumstances of his involvement in the 2010 release of a guarantee he had given to support Cashflow, ultimately resulted in the two 16 February 2015 decisions that are the subject of these review proceedings. The two decisions, which originally took effect at the time of their 17 February 2015 service, were:-(a)the (financial services) Ban decision:- an order, under the Corporations Act 2001 (“Corp Act”) ss 920A & 920B, banning Mr O’Sullivan from providing financial services, for a period of seven years. The order was based on findings that the contents of PCL’s various required reports and disclosure documents related to a “financial product”, had been misleading, contravened a financial services law and enlivened the banning power:- see Corp Act ss 728, 761A, 764A(1)(a), 920A(1)(e), 1041H(1). (An outline of the findings underlying the Ban decision is set out later in these reasons:- see paragraph 11 below.)(b)the (company management) Disqualification decision:- an order, under Corp Act s 206F(1)(a), disqualifying Mr O’Sullivan from managing corporations, for a period of five years. The threshold basis for this order was the combination of (i) the liquidation of PCL and Cashflow, (ii) Mr O’Sullivan’s status as a director of each company, and (iii) the considerable asset deficiency reported by the respective liquidators.[4] That threshold having been crossed, ASIC considered Mr O’Sullivan had contravened his Corp Act s 180 obligation of reasonable care and diligenceas to the Cashflow guarantee release, and over a sustained period in his management of PCL’s largest loan. (An expanded outline of the reasons for the decision appears later in these reasons:- see paragraph 25 below.)[4]PCL’s liquidator’s 18 December 2012 report under Corp Act s 533, disclosed an estimated zero return to unsecured creditors. A subsequent report in October 2013 estimated a $77.7m net asset deficiency.Cashflow’s liquidator’s 14 March 2014 supplementary report included a “book value” net asset deficiency of about $5.6m. ASIC’s decision proceeded on the basis that Cashflow had a net asset deficiency of $2.46m. On 23 February 2015 Mr O’Sullivan lodged applications for review of both ASIC decisions. On 30 March 2015 the Tribunal made an order under s41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 staying the further operation of the Disqualification decision. That stay order has remained in force and has an unexpired term only marginally less than the full five year disqualification period. On the other hand, at the time of the review hearing in March 2020, the unexpired term of the seven year Ban decision was just under two years.The history of the review proceedings The more than five year period between Mr O’Sullivan’s 23 February 2015 review application and the March 2020 hearing is not directly relevant to the matters to be determined. It merits a brief explanation nevertheless. That explanation provides background to the way the parties approached the review hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established