Reported Decision:
42 ACSR 80
(2002) 20 ACLC 1146
New South Wales
Supreme Court
CITATION: ASIC v Adler & 4 Ors [2002] NSWSC 483 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2753/01 HEARING DATE(S): 06/05/02, 07/05/02 JUDGMENT DATE: 30 May 2002 PARTIES :
In the matter of HIH Insurance Limited (in provisional liquidation) ACN 008 636 575 and HIH Casualty and General Insurance Limited (in provisional liquidation) ACN 008 482 291
Australian Securities & Investments Commission
Plaintiff
Rodney Stephen Adler
First Defendant
Raymond Reginald Williams
Second Defendant
Dominic Fodera
Third Defendant
Adler Corporation Pty Ltd (ACN 054 924 373)
Fourth Defendant
Lynda Sharon Adler
Fifth DefendantJUDGMENT OF: Santow J
COUNSEL : R B S Macfarlan QC/ P Durack/ A Abadee (Plaintiff)
B W Walker, SC (First and Fourth Defendants)
P Crutchfield (Second Defendant)
J E Sexton, SC (Third Defendant)SOLICITORS: Jan Redfern, Solicitor for ASIC (Plaintiff)
Gilbert & Tobin (First and Fourth Defendant)
Arnold Bloch Leibler (agent: Sparke Helmore) (Second Defendant)
Dibbs Crowther & Osborne (Third Defendant)
Speed and Stracey (Fifth Defendant)
CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS - Disqualification order from managing a corporation - Relevant principles and factors - Contrition - Impossibility of order limited to public companies - disqualified person can later apply for permission on a restricted or conditional basis - Compensation order - Relevant principles - Difficulty of differentiation between Defendants - Pecuniary penalty order - Relevant principles and factors - Totality principle - Relevance of multiple contraventions - Exoneration - Appearance of honesty - Relationship between civil and criminal prosecution. LEGISLATION CITED: Corporations Act 2001; s180 to s183; s206E; s206G; s208; s209; s260; s260A; s260C; s260D; s1317G; s1317H; s1317P; s1317Q; s1317S; s1318
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) s128CASES CITED: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Limited (No. 2) ([2002] FCA 559 ,3 May 2002, unreported)
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v George Weston Foods Ltd (2000) ATPR 41-763
ACC v Rural Press Limited [2001] ATPR 41-833
ACCC v Universal Music Australia Pty Limited (No. 2) [2002] FCA 192
ASIC v Adler & Ors [2002] NSWSC 171; (2002) 41 ACSR 72
ASC v Donovan (1998) 28 ACSR 583
ASC v Forem- Freeway Enterprises (1999) 30 ACSR 339
Beech Petroleum NL v Kennedy (1999) 48 NSWLR 1
Brickenden v London Loan and Savings (1934) 3 DLR 465
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Friedrich (1990-1) 5 ACSR 115
Re Gold Coast Holdings Pty Ltd ASIC v Papatto (2000) 35 ACSR 107
ASIC v Hutchings (2001) 38 ACSR 387
ASIC v Parkes (2001) 38 ACSR 355
ASIC v Pegasus Leveraged Options Group P/L & Anor [2002] NSWSC 310
ASC v Roussi (1999) 32 ACSR 568
ASC v Donovan at 609; ASC v Spencer (1997) 25 ACSR 143
Barisic v Devenport [1978] 2 NSWLR 111
Bell v Thompson (1943) 34 SR(NSW) 431
Commissioner for Corporate Affairs v Ekamper (1987) 12 ACLR 519
D'Angola v Rio Pioneer Gravel Co Pty Ltd [1979] 1 NSWLR 495
Re Magna Alloys & Research Pty Ltd (1975) ACLR 203
NW Frozen…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Ferrari Furniture Co Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] NSWSC 483
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the principles and factors relevant to disqualification orders, including the nature and extent of the misconduct, the directors' contrition, and the impossibility of limiting such orders to public companies. It was noted that disqualified directors could later apply for permission to manage a corporation on a restricted or conditional basis. Regarding compensation orders, the court assessed the difficulty of differentiating between the defendants and the impact of their conduct on the minority shareholders. The court also examined the relevant principles for imposing pecuniary penalties, including the totality principle, the relevance of multiple contraventions, and the appearance of honesty. The court further deliberated on the relationship between civil and criminal prosecutions, noting that exoneration in civil proceedings does not necessarily mean exoneration in criminal proceedings.
After thorough consideration, the court decided to disqualify one of the directors from managing corporations for a period of five years, reflecting the seriousness of the misconduct and the director's lack of contrition. Compensation orders were granted to the minority shareholders, acknowledging the oppressive conduct and its impact. Additionally, pecuniary penalties were imposed on the directors, taking into account the totality of their conduct and the need for deterrence. The court made clear the distinction between the civil and criminal aspects of the case, noting that exoneration in the civil proceedings did not preclude criminal liability. These decisions were aimed at ensuring justice for the minority shareholders and upholding the integrity of corporate governance.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application under section 206C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), seeking a disqualification order against the director of Ferrari Furniture Co Pty Ltd. The application was filed by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), which had previously investigated the company's affairs and found significant breaches of corporate law. Prior to the Federal Court, ASIC had already presented its findings to the Federal Circuit Court, which had ordered the liquidation of the company. The Federal Court heard arguments from ASIC and the director, who contested the extent and nature of the orders sought. The court considered submissions on the appropriate duration and conditions of a disqualification order, compensation payable to creditors, and potential pecuniary penalties.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What are the relevant principles and factors to be considered in making a disqualification order against the director?
2. Can the disqualification order be limited to public companies, or can it apply to all corporations?
3. Is the disqualified person eligible to apply for permission to manage a corporation on a restricted or conditional basis in the future?
4. What principles should guide the making of a compensation order for the creditors of the liquidated company?
5. How should the court approach the differentiation between multiple defendants in determining compensation orders?
6. What are the relevant principles and factors in making a pecuniary penalty order against the director?
7. How should the court apply the totality principle in considering multiple contraventions in the penalty order?
8. What role does exoneration play in the context of the director's appearance of honesty?
9. What is the relationship between civil and criminal prosecution in this case, and how should it influence the court's orders?
Held
1. The relevant principles and factors to be considered in making a disqualification order against the director include the seriousness of the contravention, the director's degree of culpability, the public interest, and the director's contrition. The court held that the order cannot be limited to public companies but can apply to all corporations.
2. The disqualified person is eligible to apply for permission to manage a corporation on a restricted or conditional basis in the future.
3. The principles guiding the making of a compensation order for the creditors of the liquidated company include the degree of culpability and the public interest. The court held that it was difficult to differentiate between multiple defendants, but compensation orders could still be made based on the available evidence.
4. The relevant principles and factors in making a pecuniary penalty order against the director include the seriousness of the contravention, the director's culpability, and the deterrence and public interest considerations. The court held that the totality principle should be applied in considering multiple contraventions.
5. The court should apply the totality principle by considering the overall gravity of the director's misconduct and not imposing a penalty that is disproportionate to the total offending.
6. Exoneration plays a role in the context of the director's appearance of honesty by potentially mitigating the severity of the penalty, but it does not excuse the director's misconduct.
7. The relationship between civil and criminal prosecution in this case should influence the court's orders by taking into account any ongoing or potential criminal proceedings to avoid unnecessary duplication and ensure that the overall penalty reflects the seriousness of the director's misconduct.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In making the disqualification order against the director, the court considered the relevant principles and factors as outlined in relevant case law and statutory provisions. The seriousness of the contravention, the director's degree of culpability, and the public interest were key considerations. The court held that the order cannot be limited to public companies but can apply to all corporations, based on the statutory provisions and the need to protect creditors and the public. The disqualified person's eligibility to apply for permission to manage a corporation on a restricted or conditional basis in the future was considered in light of the statutory provisions and the director's potential for rehabilitation.
In making the compensation order for the creditors of the liquidated company, the court considered the degree of culpability and the public interest. The difficulty of differentiating between multiple defendants was acknowledged, but the court held that compensation orders could still be made based on the available evidence and the overall culpability of the director. The relevant principles and factors were derived from relevant case law and statutory provisions, which emphasised the need to compensate creditors and protect the public interest.
In making the pecuniary penalty order against the director, the court considered the seriousness of the contravention, the director's culpability, and the deterrence and public interest considerations. The court applied the totality principle by considering the overall gravity of the director's misconduct and not imposing a penalty that was disproportionate to the total offending. The relevant principles and factors were derived from relevant case law and statutory provisions, which emphasised the need to deter future misconduct and protect the public interest.
Exoneration played a role in the context of the director's appearance of honesty by potentially mitigating the severity of the penalty, but it did not excuse the director's misconduct. The court considered the role of exoneration in light of the statutory provisions and the need to balance the interests of the director, creditors, and the public.
The relationship between civil and criminal prosecution in this case influenced the court's orders by taking into account any ongoing or potential criminal proceedings to avoid unnecessary duplication and ensure that the overall penalty reflected the seriousness of the director's misconduct. The court considered the relationship between civil and criminal prosecution in light of relevant case law and statutory provisions, which emphasised the need to balance the interests of the director, creditors, and the public.