Hawcroft and Australian Securities & Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Hawcroft and Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2024] AATA 3596 (9 October 2024)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/1914

Re:Maree Narelle Hawcroft

APPLICANT

Australian Securities and Investments CommissionAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D K Grigg

Date:9 October 2024

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

...............................[SGD].........................................

Senior Member D K Grigg

Catchwords

ASIC - FINANCIAL SERVICES - BANNING ORDER - Banning order under s 920A of the Corporations Act - applicant banned by ASIC from providing financial services for one year - whether applicant “fit and proper” under s 920A(1)(d) - whether new question of whether applicant “adequately trained” and “competent” under s 920A(1)(da) can be raised on review - relevance of competency and training to fitness - decision affirmed

Legislation

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler [2002] NSWCA 483; 42 ACSR 80

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCAFC 185; 181 FCR 130

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Forex Capital Trading Pty Limited, in the matter of Forex Capital Trading Pty Limited [2021] FCA 570

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Healey [2011] FCA 717; 196 FCR 291

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hutchison [2020] FCA 978

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v McCormack [2017] FCA 672; 160 ALD 155

Australian       Securities       and     Investments    Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCAFC 185; 181 FCR 130

Bevan v Tax Agents’ Board of New South Wales [2007] AATA 1162

David Hickie and ASIC [2013] AATA 853

Downey and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2017] AATA 958

Grubisa v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) [2023] AAT 3328

Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2019] HCA 16

Hayes v ASIC [2006] AATA 1506; (2006) 93 ALD 494

Hughes and Vale Pty Ltd v New South Wales (No.2) (1955) 93 CLR 127

Karamian and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2024] AATA 2006

Norfolk Ridge Vineyards Ltd and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2005] AATA 1234

Norman and Tax Practitioners Board [2021] AATA 848

Rainbow Legend Group Pty Ltd and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] AATA 665

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Re HIH Insurance Ltd (in prov liq); Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler [2002] NSWSC 483; 42 ACSR 80

Re Howarth and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2008) 101 ALD 602; (2008) 48 AAR 10; [2008] AATA 278

Re Slee and Australian Prudential Regulation Authority [2006] AATA 206; 14 ANZ Ins Cas ¶61–704

Re Su and Tax Agents’ Board of South Australia (1982) 61 FLR 1

Rich v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2004) 220 CLR 129

Rich v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2004] HCA 42; 220 CLR 129

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hawcroft and Australian Securities & Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3596
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Ms Maree Hawcroft against a banning order issued by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). ASIC had banned Ms Hawcroft from controlling or performing any function involved in carrying on a financial services business for a period of one year. The dispute arose from alleged misstatements made by Ms Hawcroft in a Statement of Personal Information (SPI) provided to ASIC, which ASIC considered indicated she was not a "fit and proper" person to be involved in the financial services industry.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Ms Hawcroft was a "fit and proper" person under section 920A(1)(d) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). ASIC also sought to introduce a new ground for the ban, arguing that Ms Hawcroft was not adequately trained or competent to provide financial services, or perform relevant functions, under section 920A(1)(da) of the Corporations Act. The Tribunal was required to determine if this new ground could be raised on review and, if so, whether it supported the banning order.

The Tribunal considered Ms Hawcroft's admissions that she had made errors in the SPI, which she attributed to genuine human error and misplaced reliance on her former legal advisors. While acknowledging her responsibility for the form, Ms Hawcroft denied any dishonesty and highlighted her prompt notification to ASIC of the errors. ASIC contended that the misstatements demonstrated a lack of diligence and professionalism, supporting the finding that Ms Hawcroft was not fit and proper. The Tribunal also considered ASIC's submission that Ms Hawcroft's lack of specific financial services background, as evidenced by her own statements about shares and shareholdings being a "foreign language" to her, could also support the new ground of inadequate training and competence.

The Tribunal affirmed ASIC's decision to issue a banning order against Ms Hawcroft. The Tribunal found that Ms Hawcroft was not a fit and proper person, and also found that she was not adequately trained or competent to perform the functions in question, thereby supporting the ban under section 920A(1)(da) of the Corporations Act. Consequently, the banning order for one year was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

It was put to Ms Hawcroft that as a director of the company, she should have knowledge about the ownership of the company. Ms Hawcroft agreed and explained that in company meetings:[54]… “if [she did not] understand something, I get it broken down. I understand it. Once I understand it, if it’s an area that I’m not as strong in, I don’t hold that information as well as I hold information in other areas. And that’s what partnerships are about. They’re about – some people have strengths in certain and they have weaknesses in areas… There are areas that I am weak in and this is one of them. And if I needed and understanding of this at any given moment, I would Google it; I would ask a professional around me; I would check my notes…… Shares and shareholdings, they are a foreign language to me. I don’t have a strong background in financial services, which we’ve already identified.[Tribunal emphasis][54] Tr, p 12. Ms Hawcroft accepted she did not have a strong background in financial services. She acknowledged she did not consider herself “highly skilled” in law, capital raising, “shareholding”, “higher levels of accounting and taxation law”.[55] Later Ms Hawcroft said what she meant was that she did not have a law degree, or “the same level of skill as a specialised expert the particular [sic] niche areas such as an admitted legal professional or a capital raising specialist”.[56] In Ms Hawcroft’s opinion, her “general knowledge of the legal aspects and the capital raising aspects are sufficient to be a director.”[57][55] Tr, p 13. [56] TB2, p 2239, Applicant Third Affidavit, para 16. [57] TB2, p 2239, Applicant Third Affidavit, para 16. Ms Hawcroft stated:[58](a)she had daily round-table meetings where all current matters and compliance issues were discussed;(b)her “experience grew alongside the organisation and due to the rapid sharing of ideas, close-knit working circumstances, and the support structure of having close working relationships with highly skilled professionals”; and(c)she never felt she was operating outside the scope of her understanding.[58] TB2, p 2238, Applicant Third Affidavit, para 9-11. Ms Hawcroft stated her key responsibilities as CFO included:[59][59] TB2, p 2239-2240, Applicant Third Affidavit, para 19.(a)providing financial reports for the quarterly board meeting for the AFSL;(b)reporting to the Executive Committee regarding any areas of concern or interest with regards to our financial position;(c)ensuring the risk and compliance management framework is embedded and operational for the group in my internal processes;(d)training my direct reports to ensure work is of a high standard and compliance needs are understood and being met;(e)financial Budgeting and Forecasting;(f)cash Flow Management;(g)accounts payable / Receivable;(h)payroll (both setting up staff and running payroll); and(i)working with key personnel in the business to understand the financial components of their business needs (for example a standing desk or ongoing programming support through an external provider).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This involves a consideration of whether Ms Hawcroft is not a “fit and proper” person pursuant to s 920A(1)(d) of the Corporations Act.EVIDENCE All witnesses provided witness statements in addition to their oral evidence. The following evidence was before the Tribunal: No witnesses were called by ASIC.Maree HawcroftStatement of Personal Information ACN127 and ISG had engaged Law Firm A to act on their behalf in regulatory matters. Ms Hawcroft states she relied on those lawyers to prepare the SPI which she signed. Ms Hawcroft states:[43]…the trust and reliance that I put in [Law Firm A] was misplaced, as I did discover an error in the form, asked a person at [Law Firm A] to fix it, and to re-send the form (by DocuSign) for me to execute electronically. That form was incorrect, as I have noted above.I mention the above, not as an excuse, but by way of a background as to how the error occurred. I accept that it is my responsibility to read all forms and make sure they are correct. I sincerely regret missing this error on the form. The consequences from this mistake have been, and have the future potential, to be enormous for me.[43] TB, p 73, Applicant First Affidavit, p 5, para 29-36. Ms Hawcroft repeated her evidence given at the ASIC hearing that she had no specific recollection of completing the SPI other than as follows:[44]a. I received the Statement on or about the morning of 14 October 2022. The Statement was pre-filled by [Law Firm A];b. At least one of the answers that had been pre-filled (which is one of the errors the subject of the Notice) struck me as being incorrect;c. I telephoned [Law Firm A] after receiving the pre-filled form. On the basis of my review of emails received from [Law Firm A] (which privilege I explicitly do not waive), I believe that I spoke with a man whom I now know to be [NAME REDACTED], a [REDACTED] at [Law Firm A]. I called and queried the effect of the suspension of the AFSL (amongst other things). I was assured that the Statement was correct, which caused me to doubt my judgment in relation to the form and accept that [Law Firm A] had correctly completed the form;d. MNHT at pages 126-127 to this affidavit is a copy of a redacted extract of my phone records. The two items highlighted green (item 45 and item 47) are two phone calls made to number "[REDACTED]' which I believe to be [NAME REDACTED] of [Law Firm A]. I did not speak with [NAME REDACTED] during the first call, on the basis of the duration of the call, but I able to say that I spoke to him in the second call, which had a duration of some 112 seconds.e. My recollection of the conversations regarding this form is that I was either assured it was correct, or when I asked for other changes to be made that I was told that this would occur before the form was resent to me for signing. I trusted these statements when I signed the Statement. My expectation was that my lawyers would get the form correct, particularly after I queried it.[44] TB, p 74, Applicant First Affidavit, p 6, para 32.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 13 March 2023, following the hearing, the ASIC delegate made a banning order.[37] The banning order provides (Banning Decision):… that under s 920A of the Corporations Act 2001 [ASIC] prohibits Maree Narelle Hawcroft from: i.Controlling, whether alone or in concert with one or more other entities, an entity that carries on a financial services business; andii.performing any function involved in carrying on a financial services business (including as an officer, manager, employee, contractor or in some other capacity),for one year.[37] TB, p 670 (419). A copy of the Banning Decision was sent to Ms Hawcroft as required by s 920A(4) of the Corporations Act. Appeal to the Tribunal On 27 March 2023, Ms Hawcroft applied to this Tribunal for review of the Banning Decision. In addition, Ms Hawcroft filed two interlocutory applications: (a)a stay of ASIC’s Banning Decision pending the hearing and decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“AAT Act”); and (b)confidentiality and non-publication orders under s 35(2) and (3) of the AAT Act. A stay order was made on 1 August 2023. The application for non-publication orders and confidentiality orders was withdrawn. Between the date of the Banning Order and the stay, Ms Hawcroft has to date served approximately five months and three weeks of her total banning period of one year. In her application to the Tribunal Ms Hawcroft contended the answers provided on the SPI were the result of “genuine human error” and acknowledged that she should have answered “yes”.[38] [38] TB, p 664 (413). The Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the Banning Decision pursuant to s 25 of the AAT Act and s 1317B of the Corporations Act.ASIC’s Additional Ground ASIC originally contended Ms Hawcroft’s conduct in relation to the SPI contravened s 920A(1)(d) of the Corporations Act, asserting Ms Hawcroft was not a fit and proper person as a result of the erroneous SPI. Subsequent to the making of the Banning Decision, ASIC contends there are further grounds to support the finding that Ms Hawcroft is not a fit and proper person, and to support a new ground to support a ban. Following cross-examination of Ms Hawcroft on the first day of the hearing, ASIC raised a new ground in support of its contention that Ms Hawcroft should be banned. ASIC contends that in addition to not being a “fit and proper” person, Ms Hawcroft is not adequately trained, or is not competent, to provide financial services; or perform functions as an officer of an entity that carries on a financial services business; or control an entity that carries on a financial services business, pursuant to s 920A(1)(da) of the Corporations Act.[39] [39] TB, p 713 (462). ASIC referred to several decisions it submits supports it ability to add this new statutory ground - Bolton and ASIC [2018] AATA 976 (“Bolton”), Schroeder and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2021] AATA 3519 (“Shroeder”) and Betalli and ASIC [2023] AATA 3073 (“Betalli”).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Based on the answers given by Ms Hawcroft in the SPI, ASIC informed Ms Hawcroft it was considering whether she should be banned from being a director under s 920A of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act).[13][13] TB, p 225 (147). Following its investigation, on 24 November 2022 ASIC issued a notice to Ms Hawcroft stating it had concerns about whether she should be banned from providing financial services, controlling an entity that carries on a financial services business or performing any function involved in the carrying on of a financial services business.[14][14] TB, p 681 (430). On 19 December 2022 ISG, through new lawyers, wrote to ASIC to inform ASIC it was aware of errors in the documents lodged on ISG’s behalf by Law Firm A and advised ASIC the declaration had been completed incorrectly and the responses to questions 12, 13 and 17 should have been “yes”.[15][15] TB, p 672. ASIC invited Ms Hawcroft to appear at a hearing to demonstrate why she should not be banned.[16] [16] TB, p 681 (430). Ms Hawcroft provided written submissions and witness statements to ASIC for the ASIC hearing. ASIC was concerned, given the alleged misstatements in the SPI, that Ms Hawcroft had acted dishonestly, or lacked the diligence and professionalism needed of someone in her position as director of two financial services licencees.[17][17] TB, pp 670 (419), p 684 (433). For the ASIC hearing Ms Hawcroft declared:(a)she had no specific recollection of the SPI;[18](b)her former lawyers “pre-filled” the SPI;[19](c)she telephoned a paralegal/law clerk at Law Firm A and queried whether the answer to the first question was correct, to which the clerk assured her it was;[20](d)she had trusted the advice of the law clerk;[21](e)she “did not appropriately register the other two errors”;[22](f)she acknowledged she was responsible for the form;[23](g)the situation had caused great personal distress;[24] and(h)she had no intention to mislead ASIC.[25][18] TB, p 217 (139).[19] TB, p 217 (139).[20] TB, p 217 (139).[21] TB, p 217 (139).[22] TB, p 217 (139).[23] TB, p 217 (139).[24] TB, p 217 (139).[25] TB, p 217. Ms Hawcroft “absolutely” denied any dishonesty.[26][26] TB, p 217 (139). Ms Hawcroft told the ASIC delegate (Delegate): (a)she only became aware of the three errors when she was served with ASIC’s notice of hearing on 17 December 2022;[27] and(b)she instructed Law Firm A to correct the record on the next business day.[28][27] TB, p 213 (135).[28] TB, p 213 (135). Ms Hawcroft submitted: (a)the errors were “human error” and did not reflect a “gross lack of the requisite diligence and professionalism required of someone occupying a key role in a financial service”;[29] and(b)her conduct in notifying ASIC of the errors promptly, “demonstrates that she is diligent” and “accepting of her responsibilities”.[30][29] TB, p 213 (135).[30] TB, p 213 (135). Following the ASIC hearing, the Delegate found that: ASIC’s power to make a banning order under s 920A(1) of the Corporations Act had been enlivened because Ms Hawcroft was not “fit and proper” considering the requirements in s 920A(1A), and 913BB(2)(k) of the Corporations Act.