Downey and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 89 min read

Downey and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2017] AATA 958 (26 June 2017)

Division:TAXATION & COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:           2016/4361

Re:Anthony Downey

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Dr C Kendall

Date:26 June 2017

Place:Perth

DECISION

The Tribunal:

a)    sets aside the decision of the respondent dated 15 August 2016; and

b) substitutes a decision that the applicant is banned under s 920A of the Corporations Act 2001 for a period of four (4) years commencing on 15 August 2016.

..................[sgd]......................................................

Deputy President Dr C Kendall

CATCHWORDS

CORPORATIONS LAW – six year banning order – whether conduct misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive – factors to be taken into account when imposing a banning order – duration of banning order – decision under review is set aside – applicant banned under s 920A of the Corporations Act 2001 for a period of four years

LEGISLATION

Australian Securities and Investments Act 2001 – section 1(2)(b)
Corporations Act 2001 – sections 761A, 913B, 920A(1)(e), 920A(2), 920B(1), 920B(2),1041H(1) and 1041H(2)

Migration Regulations 1994 – regulations 1.03 and 5.19B

CASES

Donald v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2000) 104 FCR 126
ASIC v Adler (2002) 42 ACSR 80

Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Pty Ltd v Puxu Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 191 at 197

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Regulatory Guide 98 - Licensing: Administrative action against financial service providers – regulations 98.44 and 98.45

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr C Kendall

26 June 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. This matter requires the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) to determine whether it should impose a banning order against Anthony Downey that prohibits him from providing any financial services and, if so, the length of time that banning order should apply. 

  2. On 28 June 2016, a delegate for the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”) sent a notice to Mr Downey advising him that ASIC might make a banning order against him (the “Notice”). 

  3. On 21 July 2016, legal representatives for Mr Downey provided submissions and documents on Mr Downey’s behalf.  Mr Downey chose not to appear before the delegate, as was his right.

  4. On 15 August 2016, a banning order was imposed and Mr Downey was prohibited from providing any financial services for a period of six years. 

  5. The delegate found that Mr Downey had not complied with a financial services law. Specifically, he was found to have engaged in conduct, in relation to a financial product or a financial service, that was misleading or deceptive or was likely to mislead or deceive (as per section 1041H(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (the “Act”)). 

  6. The conduct that was found to have been misleading or deceptive or was likely to mislead or deceive related to the provision of letters bearing Mr Downey’s signature and addressed to his client and the Australian Government containing information that was found to be false.  The nature of this false information and the events leading up to the relevant letters being sent is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Downey and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 958
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Downey against a decision by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to impose a banning order. The dispute arose from Mr Downey's involvement in establishing the Silvergum Fund, intended to be a "complying investment" for the Significant Investor Visa program. ASIC alleged that Mr Downey engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in relation to financial products and services. The case was heard by Deputy C Kendall P of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the power to make a banning order against Mr Downey was enlivened, and if so, whether a banning order should be made and for what duration. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether Mr Downey's conduct in relation to the Silvergum Fund, which did not hold an Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL), contravened section 1041H(1) of the Corporations Act 2001, which prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to financial products or services. The Tribunal also had to assess the appropriate length of any banning order, considering ASIC's submission for a six-year ban and Mr Downey's arguments.

The Tribunal found that Mr Downey had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, agreeing with ASIC on this point. However, the Tribunal differed from ASIC regarding the intent behind Mr Downey's actions and the appropriate duration of the banning order. While ASIC contended that Mr Downey intentionally conspired to deceive, the Tribunal concluded that his conduct, though misleading, was more accurately characterised as extraordinarily reckless, bordering on incompetent, rather than malicious. Applying this assessment, the Tribunal determined that a four-year banning period was more appropriate than the six years sought by ASIC, finding that this duration would achieve the objective of the banning order.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside ASIC's original decision and substituted its own. Mr Downey was banned under section 920A of the Corporations Act 2001 for a period of four years, commencing on 15 August 2016. This order prohibited him from providing any financial services during that period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In the circumstances, the Tribunal finds that a banning period of six years is excessive. Instead, a four year term is appropriate. FACTS A detailed overview of the facts relevant to this matter was provided by ASIC in a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 11 November at paragraphs 2.1 to 2.57. Mr Downey also provided a well written and detailed overview at paragraphs 1 to 50 in a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 16 January 2016. An accurate summary of the non-disputed facts relevant to this matter is also provided in reasons provided by the delegate dated 15 August 2016 at paragraphs 10 to 60. The Tribunal notes as follows in this regard.Significant Investor Visa The Australian government offers non-Australians the opportunity to apply for a Business Skills (Provisional) visa (“Significant Investor Visa” or “SIV”) (T7 at 71). Under this investment scheme, SIV applicants are required to invest at least $5 million in a "complying investment" in Australia. A "complying investment" is defined under regulation 1.03 and 5.19B of the Migration Regulations 1994 as including a particular type of "managed fund" (T7 at 71). A "managed fund" is defined under regulation 1.03 of the Migration Regulations 1994 as, relevantly, an investment comprising an interest in a managed investment scheme within the meaning of the Act, where the issue of the interest in the managed investment scheme is covered by an Australian Financial Services Licence ( an “AFSL”) issued under s 913B of the Act.Mr Downey’s Directorships Mr Downey:a)was a director of Platinum Mortgage Securities Ltd ACN 158 339 372 (“Platinum”) (previously known as Platinum Mortgage Securities (Vic) Ltd) from 14 May 2012 to 3 June 2015 (T18); b)has been a director of Silvergum Capital Pty Ltd ACN 169 621 998 (“Silvergum”) since 29 April 2015 (T19); andc)was a director of Ark Asset Management Australia Ltd ACN 604 775 573 (“Ark”) from 16 March 2015 to 5 August 2015 (T20). Silvergum and the Silvergum Fund Francis Chu is a migration lawyer and the principal lawyer of Avia Lawyers (T16). He is also a director of the Silvergum First Mortgage Income Fund (the “Silvergum Fund”). In either 2014 or 2015, Mr Downey was asked by Mr Chu to establish the Silvergum Fund. It was intended that the Silvergum Fund would be a managed investment scheme and would meet the "complying investment" requirements for SIV purposes. The target investors for the Silvergum Fund were SIV applicants. The Silvergum Fund did not hold an AFSL and has never held an AFSL (T15 at 261). Mr Downey intended that Silvergum would be the investment manager for the Silvergum Fund and that Platinum would act as the responsible entity of the Silvergum Fund (T15 at 261). Mr Downey was made responsible for the appointment of a responsible manager for the Silvergum Fund and the registration of the Silvergum Fund with ASIC (T16). Mr Downey claimed before the delegate and before this Tribunal that it was always intended that Platinum would be appointed as the responsible manager for the Silvergum Fund (T16 at 308).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As correctly outlined by ASIC in a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 11 November 2016, the Tribunal is required to determine:a) whether or not the power to exercise the discretion to make a banning order against the Mr Downey is enlivened;b) if the Tribunal is satisfied that the power is enlivened, whether or not a banning order should be made against Mr Downey; and c) if the Tribunal decides to make a banning order against Mr Downey, the duration of that banning order.EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL This matter was heard in Perth on 27 March 2017. Mr Downey appeared in person and was self-represented. ASIC was represented by counsel, Ms Hodgson. The Tribunal had before it a 526 page set of T Documents at T1 to T35 (R1). The T Documents included all evidence relied on by the delegate charged with determining whether a banning should apply in relation to Mr Downey. The Tribunal also had before it the following submissions and evidence:·A Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions from ASIC dated 11 November 2016 (R3);·A Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions from Mr Downey dated 16 January 2017, with various attachments identified as A-J (A1);·An email dated 4 May 2015 (R2);·Final Written Submissions from ASC dated 26 April 2017;·Final Written Submissions from Mr Downey dated 12 May 2017; and·Final Written Submissions in Reply from ASIC dated 25 May 2017. Mr Downey also gave oral evidence before the Tribunal. Somewhat unusually, Mr Chu was not called as a witness. LEGISLATIONIntroduction Section 1(2)(b) of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 requires that ASIC “promote the confident and informed participation of investors and consumers in the financial system”. As correctly noted by counsel before this Tribunal, this objective is also fundamental to the Tribunal’s exercise of its review powers, in which it “stands in the shoes” of ASIC. ASIC’s powers under the Act are supplemented by policy guidelines issued by ASIC. The Tribunal notes, in particular, “Regulatory Guide 98 - Licensing: Administrative action against financial service providers” (RG 98). The Tribunal has regard to these guidelines, as it must. Legislation The provisions in Division 8 of Part 7.6 of Chapter 7 of the Act set out the circumstances in which ASIC may disqualify or ban a person from providing financial services. Subdivision A of Division 8 deals with banning orders. A banning order is a written order that prohibits a person from providing any financial services or specified financial services in specified circumstances or capacities: s 920B(1) of the Act. A banning order may be permanent or for a specified period: s 920B(2) of the Act. Subsection 920A(1)(e) of the Act provides that ASIC may make a banning order against a person if the person has not complied with a financial services law. Section 761A, in turn, defines ‘financial services law’ to include relevantly Chapter 7, including section 1041H(1). Pursuant to section 1041H(1), “a person must not, in this jurisdiction, engage in conduct, in relation to a financial product or a financial service, that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive.” Pursuant to section 1041H(2)(a) the reference in subsection (1) to engaging in conduct in relation to a financial product includes (but is not limited to) dealing in a financial product.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the evidence, the Tribunal finds that a banning period of four years achieves this objective. DECISION For the reasons outlined above, The Tribunal:a)sets aside the decision of the respondent dated 15 August 2016; andb)substitutes a decision that the applicant is banned under s 920A of the Corporations Act 2001 for a period of four (4) years commencing on 15 August 2016. The Tribunal notes that the effect of its decision is that, under ss 920A(1)(e) and 920B of the Corporations Act 2001, the applicant is prohibited from providing any financial services during the above period.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In light of the above, the Tribunal agrees with ASIC’s submissions and finds that a banning order is indeed appropriate. Banning order: what duration? Throughout these proceedings, Mr Downey has vehemently argued that he never intended to mislead Mr Li Ling or any government official. To his mind, the letters relevant to this matter were drafts and were never supposed to be sent out. The ASIC delegate disagreed, finding that the letters were in final form and were intended to mislead others into believing that a deposit into the Platinum Fund had been made in circumstances when no deposit had in fact been made. In submissions before this Tribunal, counsel for ASIC summarised ASIC’s position as follows:While the Applicant stated he understood the letters to be in draft and did not intend the letters to be sent to the Australian government until the $3million was transferred to the Platinum account;(i)Each of the 29 May 2015 Letters, the 1 June 2015 Letters and the Victorian Government Letter were in final form including bearing the Applicant’s signature;(ii)The 29 May 2015 Letters were backdated to the date the Applicant knew was the critical date for investors making a ‘complying investment’;(iii)Both on the date of the letters and the date the letters were signed, the information contained in them was false, in that the investment was not made in Platinum and the $3million was not transferred into the Platinum account;(iv)The Applicant knew the information was false in that he knew the $3million investment by Ms Li Ling was not transferred to the Platinum account;(v)On 2 June 2015 at 12.50pm, the Applicant was informed by email that the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (through Ms Joyce So of DFAT) understood that Ms Li Ling had made a $3million investment into a complying investment, namely the Platinum Fund; and(vi)Despite knowledge of the erroneous belief held by the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the Applicant provided the Victorian Government Letter under cover of email dated 3 June 2015, but backdated to 1 June 2015 regarding Platinum’s ''Economic contribution to Victoria.' The Tribunal has reviewed all of the evidence before it and has heard directly from Mr Downey, who was extensively cross examined. Mr Downey struck the Tribunal as an honest and credible witness, albeit clearly distressed by what has happened. He has paid a considerable personal price for his actions and that is to be expected. ASIC believes that a banning order of six years is appropriate because Mr Downey intentionally conspired to deceive Ms Li Ling and government officials. It is here that the Tribunal and ASIC differ. The Tribunal believes a banning order of four years is more appropriate on the facts of this case. The Tribunal accepts that Mr Downey engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and has so found. It does not believe, however, that, he did so with malice or with any clear intention to deceive anyone. Rather, his actions are more appropriately described as extraordinarily reckless, bordering on incompetent. This then goes to the length of any banning order the Tribunal decides to impose.