Donald v Australian Securities & Investment Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Donald v Australian Securities & Investment Commission [2000] FCA 1142

SECURITIES – creating a false or misleading appearance with respect to the price of securities – purchase by securities dealer at a higher price than available on the market – banning order by Australian Securities and Investment Commission – review by Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether no evidence of contravention – whether mens rea a necessary element – whether proof of likely repetition needed – relevance of brokers’ lack of authority from client

Corporations Law ss 829(d), 998(1)

North v Marra Developments Ltd (1981) 148 CLR 42 applied
Fame Decorator Agencies Pty Ltd v Jeffries Industries Ltd (1998) 28 ACSR 58 at 62-63 applied
Australian Securities Commission v Nomura International plc (1998) 29 ACSR 473 at 556 applied
He Kaw Teh v The Queen (1985) 157 CLR 523 applied
Alphacell Limited v Woodward [1972] AC 824 mentioned

ANDREW WILLIAM DONALD v AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENT COMMISSION
NO. V 44 of 2000

HEEREY J
10 OCTOBER 2000
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 44 of 2000

BETWEEN:

ANDREW WILLIAM DONALD
APPLICANT

AND:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENT COMMISSION
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 OCTOBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is allowed.

2.The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 21 January 2000 is set aside.

3.The application of the applicant for review of the decision of the delegate of the respondent made on 25 July 1999 is remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal differently constituted for rehearing according to law.

4.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs to be taxed, including reserved costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 44 of 2000

BETWEEN:

ANDREW WILLIAM DONALD
APPLICANT

AND:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENT COMMISSION
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE:

10 OCTOBER 2000

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Under s 829 of the Corporations Law (the Law) the respondent Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) by its delegate made an order banning the applicant from acting as a representative of a securities dealer or an adviser for a period of four years.  On review the Administrative Appeals Tribunal upheld the banning order but varied the period to two years from 20 July 1999.

  2. Section 829(d) of the Law confers power to make a banning order if a person contravenes a “securities law”. By s 9 of the Law that term is defined to mean a provision of, inter alia, Ch 7 of the Law which includes s 998(1):

    “A person shall not create, or do anything that is intended or likely to create, a false or misleading appearance of active trading in any securities on a stock market or a false or misleading appearance with respect to the market for, or the price of, any securities.”

  3. The allegation against the applicant arises out of a transaction…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Donald v Australian Securities & Investment Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Donald v Australian Securities & Investment Commission involves an appeal by the applicant against a decision made by a delegate of the Australian Securities & Investment Commission (ASIC). The applicant, acting as a representative of a securities dealer, was accused of causing securities to be bought at a price higher than the market price, which is an allegation under the Corporations Law. The dispute centres on a transaction involving the purchase of shares in Burswood Limited, a company in which National Australia Asset Management (NAAM) held a significant stake. The applicant, as a representative of ABN-AMRO Equities Australia Ltd, was directed by Mr John Thomson of NAAM to purchase up to 500,000 shares of Burswood Limited. Despite the instruction to purchase at market price, the applicant opted to buy the shares at a higher price, which was not in line with the client’s instructions. This decision was made in the context of an end-of-month period, where the client had previously paid a premium to maintain a desired balance of shares.

The legal issues the court needed to address included whether the applicant's actions constituted a breach of section 998(1) of the Corporations Law, which prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to securities. The primary focus was on determining if the applicant’s decision to purchase shares at a price higher than the market price was in contravention of the client's instructions and whether this action created a misleading appearance regarding the true market price of the shares. The court also needed to consider if the applicant's belief that the shares were undervalued justified his actions, or if it constituted a breach of his fiduciary duty to act in the client's best interests.

The court found that the applicant's actions were indeed a breach of section 998(1) of the Corporations Law. The court held that the applicant's strategy to purchase shares at a higher price was not in accordance with the client's instructions and was executed without seeking clarification. The court further held that the applicant's belief that the shares were undervalued did not justify his actions, as the client had explicitly instructed to purchase at market price. The court emphasised that the misleading appearance created by the applicant's actions, where the shares were bought at a price significantly higher than the market price, was sufficient to constitute a breach of the law, irrespective of whether anyone was actually misled. The court thus concluded that the applicant's conduct was misleading and deceptive, and ordered the appeal to be allowed, the earlier decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to be set aside, and the matter to be remitted for rehearing according to law.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 21 January 2000 is set aside.

3. The application of the applicant for review of the decision of the delegate of the respondent made on 25 July 1999 is remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal differently constituted for rehearing according to law.

4. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs to be taxed, including reserved costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Donald v Australian Securities & Investment Commission revolves around an incident involving the applicant, who acted as a representative of ABN-AMRO Equities Australia Ltd, a securities dealer. On 29 May 1998, the applicant was approached by Mr John Thomson of National Australia Asset Management (NAAM), one of ABN-AMRO's clients. NAAM had a significant stake in the listed company Burswood Limited. During a phone conversation, Mr Thomson expressed his desire to buy a substantial number of Burswood shares, and the applicant agreed to facilitate the purchase. The applicant then contacted Mr Michael Casey, the ABN-AMRO operator in Sydney, to place the order through the Stock Exchange Automatic Trading System (SEATS). The applicant intended to buy the shares at a higher price than the market price, which he believed was undervalued. However, the Tribunal found that the applicant's actions were contrary to the express instructions given by Mr Thomson, and that the applicant's strategy was likely to create a false or misleading appearance with respect to the price of Burswood shares.

The matter began when the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) made a decision on 21 January 2000, finding that the applicant had breached section 998(1) of the Corporations Law by creating a false or misleading appearance with respect to the price of Burswood shares. The applicant subsequently sought review of the AAT's decision by the delegate of the Australian Securities & Investment Commission (ASIC), who confirmed the AAT's decision on 25 July 1999. The applicant then appealed to a higher court, which accepted the appeal and remitted the matter to the AAT for rehearing according to law. The respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs, to be taxed, including reserved costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The allegation against the applicant arises out of a transaction in which, acting as a representative of a securities dealer, he caused securities to be bought at a price higher than that available on the market.Evidence before the Tribunal On 29 May 1998 the applicant was a representative of ABN-AMRO Equities Australia Ltd. One of ABN-AMRO’s clients was National Australia Asset Management (NAAM). NAAM had a substantial holding in the listed company Burswood Limited. At 3.24 pm on 29 May (a Friday and the last trading day of the month) Mr John Thomson of NAAM telephoned the applicant. The conversation, recorded at the time, was as follows:“Thomson:It’s that time of the month to get stitched up in Burswood again.Applicant:Right. Yeah.Thomson:Is there any around?Applicant:Let’s have a look if there’s any around.Thomson:Going through at eight.Applicant:Yeah, they’re going through at eight at the moment. From a depth point of view, there’s 58,000 at 89, 78 at 90, and not much up to 93 from there.Thomson:Hmm.Applicant:But there’s sort of – what’s that? A 100 – about 160,000 up to 93.Thomson:Oh well we can try and buy. A few hundred.Applicant:Okay, not a problem. I’ll do my best there – try and get you some stock.””Going through at eight” was a reference to the stock trading at 88 cents.After discussing other stocks the conversation continued:“Applicant: All righty. I will do my best on Burswood.”Thomson: All righty. Buy up to about a half. If you have to. If you can.Applicant: Okay.Thomson: (inaudible) ridiculous about it.Applicant: All right. No worries.Thomson: All right.Applicant: Okay.Thomson: Okay. Thanks mate. The Tribunal found that the expression “getting stitched up in Burswood again” referred to an in-house understanding that NAAM had, over the months preceding 29 May 1998, paid a premium in order to maintain the balance of Burswood shares it had determined was appropriate for its portfolio and that Mr Thomson did not personally believe that the shares were worth buying. The reference to “about a half” meant about 500,000 shares. The applicant received no express instruction from Mr Thomson as to any upper limit to be paid. The Tribunal made a finding that the purchase was to be at market price and that the market price was at or around 88 cents or 89 cents. At 3.33 pm on 29 May the applicant telephoned Mr Michael Casey, the ABN-AMRO operator in Sydney, so that the purchase order could be implemented through the Stock Exchange Automatic Trading System (SEATS). Relevantly for present purposes that conversation went as follows:“Applicant:Mate, it’s the end of month and I want to give these Burswoods a bit of a nudge upwards, all right. I’ve given it to you because I want to make sure it’s done today, right. The client (inaudible) – fuck we stuffed it up last time with the client.Casey: Did we?Applicant:Yeah so I’ve got up to half a million to buy, right. But we want to make sure we have the stock whole – we don’t want to fire our shots too early. All right.Casey:So what’s the code B –Applicant:BIR.Casey:BIR?Applicant:Yeah. Up to – up to half a million, you know, we don’t – we don’t have to buy half a million buy 200 if we don’t need to but –Casey:Right. We just want to try and close them up at as high a price as possible but on the lowest amount possible.Applicant:Yeah. But you know, up to half a million if need be.Casey:No worries.Applicant:All right.Casey:Burswood. All right Andy.Applicant:Thanks, mate.Casey:I’ll obviously look at this in the five past match out mate.Applicant:Yeah, beautiful.Casey:No worries.Applicant:Thanks mate.Casey:Bye, bye.Applicant:Bye.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

HEEREY J
For the purposes of the hearing before the delegate the applicant provided a written statement which included the following:“2.At the time it was my intention to carry out Mr Thomson’s order to purchase shares in Burswood Ltd on 29 May 1998 and to do this so that the shares would be purchased at a price higher than that at which they have previously been trading. 3.I did not at any time indicate to the SEATS operator Mr Michael Casey what was the level at which I wanted him to bid for the shares. Originally I did not anticipate that he would bid at 95 cents although I well understood that a bid was to be made during the match out period on that day. What I had intended was to have the shares bought at a somewhat higher price than they had been and certainly not to have the price pushed down.4.As I indicated at my examination conducted pursuant to section 19 of the ASC Law, I considered that previous trading in Burswood shares had been unsatisfactory for some period prior to 29 May 1998. 5.Because I considered that the price of the shares was unreasonably low compared with their true value I intended to have the shares move to a more reasonable level. 6.Taking into account the fact that the trading was occurring in an open market as well as my view that it was legitimate for the client to endeavour to have the price of the shares moved to a reasonable level upwards in light of their true value, I did not and still do not, consider that to make a bid higher than the previous mark level was in any way improper.”The Tribunal’s decision In discussing the evidence the Tribunal said:“12. For the purpose of fulfilling the order placed by Mr Thomson, the applicant’s instructions were to buy up to 500,000 shares at market price. The applicant told the Tribunal that he thought at the time that the price of the Burswood shares was low. He concluded that Mr Thomson wanted the shares bought at a ‘fairer value’ than that which was reflected in the trading price. The Tribunal is satisfied that by ‘fairer’ the applicant clearly meant ‘higher’ as reflected in his instruction to Mr Casey to give them a ‘nudge upwards’. The conclusion reached by the applicant was not, however, in accordance with any instruction given by Mr Thomson and curiously it was not a matter that the applicant sought to clarify with Mr Thomson during the second telephone conversation. There was an opportunity to do so in circumstances after Mr Thomson had expressly rejected the approach suggested by the applicant to purchase as little quantity as possible at the highest possible price. The Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant persisted in implementing the strategy for the purchase of Burswood shares at a price higher than those shares could have been obtained on the open market and that that strategy was contrary to the express instructions given by Mr Thomson.” After referring to passages from the judgments in North v Marra Developments Ltd (1981) 148 CLR 42 and Fame Decorator Agencies Pty Ltd v Jeffries Industries Ltd (1998) 28 ACSR 58 at 62-63 the Tribunal said:“14. In the view of the Tribunal the applicant’s actions were likely to have created a false or misleading appearance with respect to the price of Burswood shares in that at 95c per share the price of the shares is set at a ‘false price’ as that term was described by Mason J in North’s case. Accordingly, the Tribunal is satisfied that a breach of s.998(1) of the Corporations Law has occurred. For such a finding, it is not necessary that the Tribunal need be satisfied that anyone was, in fact, misled as a result of the applicant’s actions. It is sufficient that there be a misleading ‘appearance’ and that is so in the instant case.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HEEREY J

The Tribunal examined the conversation between Mr Thomson and the applicant to determine the nature of the instructions given. It found that the applicant interpreted the instructions to mean he should purchase shares at a price higher than the market price, which was not the instruction given by Mr Thomson. The applicant's intention to "nudge upwards" the price was not aligned with Mr Thomson's expressed instructions to buy up to 500,000 shares at market price. This interpretation was further confirmed when the applicant did not seek clarification on the matter despite the opportunity arising during the conversation. The court thus concluded that the applicant's strategy to purchase the shares at a higher price was contrary to the express instructions provided by Mr Thomson. Regarding the breach of section 998(1) of the Corporations Law, the Tribunal determined that the applicant's actions, by setting the price of Burswood shares at 95 cents, created a false price. This conclusion was supported by reference to the judgment in North v Marra Developments Ltd (1981) 148 CLR 42, where Mason J described a "false price" as one set without regard to market conditions. The Tribunal found that a misleading appearance was created, fulfilling the criteria for a breach under section 998(1) without requiring evidence of actual misleading of market participants. The decision was grounded on the principle that the misleading appearance alone was sufficient to constitute a breach.