9+
| JUDGMENT No. .!.gOxze | ..,, | l . | , | , |
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA | ) | ||
| QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY |
| ||
| GENERAL DIVISION | ) |
BETWEEN : TERESA LIDDLE
Applicant
| AND | COLONIAL MUTUAL LIFE ASSURANCE SOCIETY LIMITED and PETER MORLEY |
First ~es~ondent'
| AND | HUMAN RIGHTS AND EOUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION |
Second Respondent
| CORAM | : | Spender J |
| PLACE | : Brisbane |
| DATE: | 16 December 1994 |
MINUTES OF ORDER
THE COURT ORDERS THAT the costs of the first respondents be paid by the applicant, together with all reserved costs and including any costs reserved in respect of any notice of motion, those costs to be taxed if not agreed.
| m: | Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules. |
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA | ) | ||
| OUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY |
| ||
| ) |
BETWEEN : TERESA LIDDLE
Applicant
AND c
SOCIETY LIMITED and PETER MORLEY
First Respondents
| AND : | HUMAN RIGHTS AND EOUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION |
Second Respondent
| CORAM | : | Spender J |
| PLACE | : Brisbane |
| DATE: | 16 December 1994 |
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
This is an application for costs by the first respondents, Peter Morley and the Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited, in respect of proceedings QG38 of
1994. The history of the matter is contained in the various
reports of listings, and the position is that MS Liddle has throughout acted for herself, although there have been attempts by her in the course of those proceedings to have legal representation obtained in respect of the formulation of what her case was and the material on which she relied in support of that application.
There were, as those records of listings show, a
series of hearings where attempts were made to permit
MS Liddle to formulate an application with affidavit material.
2
Notwithstanding the repetition of appearances before the court, no actual resolution of that primary question was ever achieved, and on 12 August 1994 the court directed that an amended application and supplementary affidavits be filed and served by 15 September 1994. The court further ordered that if the amended application and affidavits were not filed as the court directed, then the proceedings would stand dismissed.
This guillotine order, of course, is one of last resort, and is only made against a background where, in its absence, injustice would be caused to the other parties to the litigation. It was a considered order having regard to the interests of all the parties in the litigation and the detailed history of the litigation as it stood at that time.
For reasons which are perhaps understandable but nonetheless which are of no comfort to the respondents, MS Liddle was unable to file the amended application and affidavits that the court had directed wlthin the time the court ordered, and, as a consequence, those proceedings stand dismissed.
Today an application is made by the first respondents for their costs of those proceedings. The order for costs is resisted by MS Liddle, and she has…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Liedig v Commissioner of Taxation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1994] FCA 1058
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue in this case was whether the first respondents, Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited and Peter Morley, were entitled to be reimbursed for the costs they incurred during the litigation. The court needed to consider the circumstances surrounding the proceedings, including the applicant's failure to file the amended application and affidavits as directed by the court. Additionally, the court had to evaluate the applicant's arguments against the respondents' request for costs and assess whether the ordinary rule regarding costs should apply in this case.
Spender J, the presiding judge, determined that the ordinary rule concerning costs should apply in this case. The judge found that no compelling arguments were presented to deviate from the standard practice of awarding costs to the prevailing party. The judge also reassured the applicant that no Federal Court records related to the proceedings would be tampered with, destroyed, or interfered with, addressing the applicant's concerns about potential consequences due to the court records.
The court ordered that the first respondents, Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited and Peter Morley, would be reimbursed for their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs. These costs were to be taxed if not agreed upon. The judge did not consider it necessary to address the application for costs by the second respondent, the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, as no such application was made.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia in the Queensland District Registry under the General Division. The case was presided over by Spender J and took place in Brisbane on 16 December 1994. This hearing was an application for costs by the first respondents in respect of the proceedings QG38 of 1994. The history of the matter, as noted in various reports of listings, showed a series of hearings where Teresa Liddle attempted to formulate an application with affidavit material, but no actual resolution was achieved. The court had previously directed that an amended application and supplementary affidavits be filed by a certain date, and when this was not done, the proceedings were dismissed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the first respondents, Peter Morley and the Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited, are entitled to their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs.
2. Whether there are any circumstances that should prevent the application of the ordinary rule as to costs in this case.
Held
1. The first respondents, Peter Morley and the Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited, are entitled to their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs.
2. There are no circumstances that should prevent the application of the ordinary rule as to costs in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Court considered the application for costs by the first respondents, Peter Morley and the Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited, in the case of Liedig v Commissioner of Taxation. The court ordered that the applicants were to be awarded their costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs, to be taxed if not agreed. This order followed the ordinary rule regarding costs, as no circumstances were presented that would prevent its application. The court dismissed the applicant's case after it failed to comply with a guillotine order, which was a last resort to prevent injustice to the other parties involved. Despite the applicant's concerns about tampering with court records, the court assured that no documents or records relating to the proceedings would be destroyed, tampered with, or interfered with. The court did not find any merit in the applicant's diffuse submissions, as they did not affect the correctness of the order concerning the costs of these proceedings.