Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kaur

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kaur [2023] FCA 599

File number: WAD 293 of 2020
Judgment of: JACKSON J
Date of judgment: 7 June 2023
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS - operation of unregistered managed investment scheme in contravention of s 601ED(5) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) - carrying on financial services business without an Australian Financial Services Licence in contravention of s 911A of the Corporations Act - investor funds advanced in the form of loans - investor funds were to be pooled and invested into real property projects managed by second defendant - some investor funds or scheme property used by first defendant for benefit of herself and other defendants - many investors not repaid - capital invested likely to have been lost - fourth defendant as director of second defendant breached duty of care and diligence - parties have agreed to entry of judgment against defendants and to facts of contravening conduct - winding up unregistered managed investment scheme - disqualification from managing corporations - appointment of receivers
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) Division 1, Part 3

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 19, 180, 206C, 206G, 459B, 461, 464, 601ED, 601EE, 761E, 763A, 763B, 764A, 766A, 766B, 766C, 911A, 1101B, 1311, 1317E, 1317H, 1317J, 1323, 1324

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) s 10

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1405

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v ActiveSuper Pty Ltd (No 2) [2013] FCA 234

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler [2002] NSWSC 483

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Elm Financial Services Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 1065

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hutchings [2001] NSWSC 522

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Managed Investments Ltd (No 10) [2017] QSC 96

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marco (No 6) [2020] FCA 1781

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Maxwell [2006] NSWSC 1052

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v McDougall [2006] FCA 427

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v MyWealth Manager Financial Services Pty Ltd (No 3) [2020] FCA 1035

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Pegasus Leveraged Options Group Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 310

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v White [2006] VSC 239

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Woolridge [2019] FCAFC 172

Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482

Daniels (formerly practising as Deloitte Haskins & Sells) v Anderson (1995) 37 NSWLR 438

Minister for the Environment, Heritage and the Arts v PGP Developments Pty Limited [2010] FCA 58; (2010) 183 FCR 10

Re Idylic Solutions Pty Ltd; Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hobbs [2013] NSWSC 106

Rich v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2004] HCA 42; (2004) 220 CLR 129

Sheahan v Verco [2001] SASC 91; (2001) 79 SASR 109

Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kaur and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 599
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns a proceeding brought by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) against multiple defendants for their involvement in an unregistered managed investment scheme. The defendants were engaged in a business where investor funds were pooled and invested into real property projects. However, many investors were not repaid, and it is likely that their capital was lost. The court had to decide several legal issues, including whether the defendants contravened certain sections of the Corporations Act, whether they breached their duties, and whether they should be disqualified from managing corporations. The court found that the defendants had indeed contravened the Corporations Act by operating the unregistered managed investment scheme and carrying on a financial services business without a licence. Additionally, the court determined that the fourth defendant breached their duty of care and diligence. Consequently, the court appointed receivers and liquidators, issued disqualification orders, and made asset preservation orders. The defendants have consented to the entry of judgment and the facts of the contravening conduct. The court also ordered that the defendants pay ASIC's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Receivership

5. Pursuant to s 1101B(1) and s 1323(1)(h) of the Corporations Act, David Hodgson and Andrew Hewitt, of Grant Thornton, be appointed as joint and several receivers and managers (Receivers), without security, of all property (as defined in the Corporations Act), whether within or outside the State of Western Australia, of:

(a) the first and fourth defendants; and

(b) the Scheme;

including, for the avoidance of doubt, the Commonwealth Bank account held in the name of the fifth defendant the account number for which ends in #1240 (Account #1240), the Commonwealth Bank account held in the name of the sixth defendant the account number for which ends in #4312 (Account #4312), and the property located at 4 Karimba Street Wanneroo in the name of the fifth defendant (Karimba St) (together, the Property).

6. Each of the first and fourth defendants are to immediately give over possession of all their property (as defined in the Corporations Act), whether within or outside the State of Western Australia, together with all books and records relating to that property, to the Receivers.

7. Each of the fifth and sixth defendants are to immediately give all books and records relating to Account #4312 and Account #1240 to the Receivers.

8. The fifth defendant is to, on request of the Receivers, do all things necessary to effect the transfer to, and the taking of possession by, the Receivers of Karimba St, together with all books and records relating to Karimba St.

9. The Receivers have the following powers:

(a) the power to do all things necessary or convenient to be done, in Australia and elsewhere, for or in connection with, or as incidental to the attainment of the objectives for which the Receivers are appointed including, without limitation, for the identification, preservation and securing of all of the Property for the benefit of creditors;

(b) the powers under s 1101B(8) of the Corporations Act provided that wherever in that section the word 'financial services licensee' appears, it shall be taken to refer to the first defendant, the fourth defendant and the Scheme;

(c) the powers set out in s 420 of the Corporations Act provided that wherever in that section the word 'corporation' appears, it shall be taken to refer to the first defendant, the fourth defendant and the Scheme;

(d) the power to require, by request in writing, the first defendant and fourth defendant and any employee, agent, banker, solicitor, stockbroker, accountant, consultant or other professionally qualified person who has provided services or advice to the first defendant or the fourth defendant to provide such reasonable assistance (including access to any documents, books or records to which the first and fourth defendants have a right of access or control) to the Receivers as may be required from time to time.

10. Upon being called upon to do so, the Receivers must deliver up that part of the Property that is property of the Scheme to the liquidators appointed pursuant to paragraph 19 below.

Receivership remuneration and indemnity

11. The Receivers shall be entitled to reasonable remuneration properly incurred in the performance of their duties arising in connection with their appointment and in the exercise of their powers as may be approved by the Court on the application of the Receivers, together with all costs, expenses and disbursements.

12. The Receivers' remuneration is to be calculated on the basis of time reasonably spent by the Receivers and any partner or employee of the firm to which the Receivers are attached, at the standard rates of the Receivers' firm from time to time for work of that nature.

13. The Receivers' remuneration, costs, expenses and disbursements are to be paid from the Property.

14. The Receivers be indemnified from the Property against any claim, liability, proceeding, cost, charge or expense however arising and whether past, present or future, fixed or ascertained, actual or contingent, known (actually or contingently) or unknown which they may incur or be subject to as a result of or in connection with their appointment.

15. The above orders are not to affect the rights of any prior encumbrancer over the Property, including the rights of any secured creditor.

16. For the avoidance of doubt, the entitlement of the Receivers to be paid or indemnified from the Property pursuant to the orders above is not restricted or in any way limited by whether they are acting as receivers of property of the first defendant, the fourth defendant or the Scheme and they are entitled to treat the Property as a single combined pool of property for those purposes.

Winding up orders

17. Pursuant to s 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, the Scheme be wound up.

18. Pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act, the second defendant be wound up.

19. Pursuant to s 472(1) of the Corporations Act, the Receivers be appointed as joint and several liquidators (Liquidators) of:

(a) the Scheme; and

(b) the second defendant.

20. The asset preservation orders made on 16 December 2020 (as varied from time to time) in respect of the first, second and fourth defendants be vacated on the appointment of the Liquidators pursuant to paragraph 19 and the appointment of Receivers pursuant to paragraph 5.

21. Pursuant to s 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, and subject to any further orders of the Court:

(a) the winding up of the Scheme be conducted as if the Scheme were a 'company' or 'corporation' for the purposes of the Corporations Act and the provisions of Parts 5.4B, 5.6, 5.7B and 5.9 of the Corporations Act and Schedule 2 to the Corporations Act (Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations)) applied to the winding up (with such modifications as are reasonably necessary in the circumstances);

(b) the Liquidators of the Scheme have power to do, in Australia and elsewhere, all things necessary or convenient to be done for or in connection with the winding up of the Scheme, or incidental to the attainment of the winding up of the Scheme, including the functions and powers set out in Chapter 5 of the Corporations Act (as applicable) as if each reference there to a 'company' or 'corporation' was a reference to the Scheme (with such modifications as are reasonably necessary in the circumstances); and

(c) without limiting the above, the Liquidators of the Scheme shall have the power to investigate or cause to be investigated any deficiency in the Scheme and to exercise the powers under Part 5.9 Division 1 of the Corporations Act as if the Scheme were a 'company' or 'corporation' being wound up.

Liquidation remuneration and indemnity orders

22. The Liquidators shall be entitled to reasonable remuneration properly incurred in the performance of their duties arising in connection with their appointment and in the exercise of their powers as may be approved by the Court on the application of the Liquidators, together with all costs, expenses and disbursements.

23. The Liquidators' remuneration is to be calculated on the basis of time reasonably spent by the Liquidators and any partner or employee of the firm to which the Liquidators are attached, at the standard rates of the Liquidators' firm from time to time for work of that nature.

24. The Liquidators' remuneration, costs, expenses and disbursements are to be paid out of the assets of the Scheme and/or the second defendant.

25. The Liquidators be indemnified from the assets of the Scheme (including the Property) and the second defendant against any claim, liability, proceeding, cost, charge or expense however arising and whether past, present or future, fixed or ascertained, actual or contingent, known (actually or contingently) or unknown which they may incur or be subject to as a result of or in connection with their appointment.

26. The above orders are not to affect the rights of any prior encumbrancer over the assets of the Scheme, including the rights of any secured creditor.

27. For the avoidance of doubt, the entitlement of the Liquidators to be paid or indemnified from the assets of the Scheme pursuant to the orders above is not restricted or in any way limited by whether they are acting as liquidators of the Scheme or the second defendant and they are entitled to treat the assets of the Scheme as a single combined pool of assets for those purposes.

Injunctive relief

28. The first defendant be permanently restrained from:

(a) carrying on a financial services business in Australia; and

(b) operating an unregistered managed investment scheme in contravention of s 601ED(5) of the Corporations Act.

Disqualification order

29. Pursuant to s 206C of the Corporations Act:

(a) the first defendant be disqualified from managing corporations for life with effect from the date of this order.

(b) the fourth defendant be disqualified from managing corporations for 15 years from the date of this order.

Asset preservation orders

30. Paragraphs 6 and 7 made on 16 December 2020 (Principal Orders) (as varied from time to time) against the third, fifth and sixth defendant are vacated.

31. Until further order of the Court, pursuant to s 1323 of the Corporations Act and s 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth):

(a) the third defendant is to hold the amount of $80,000 in the ANZ Bank account held in its name, the account number for which ends in #3206, and is restrained from withdrawing, transferring or otherwise disposing of or dealing with those monies;

(b) subject to paragraph 32 below, the fifth defendant (by himself, his related entities or agent) is restrained from dealing in any property (as defined in the Corporations Act) in which he has any legal or equitable interest as at the date of this order, including, the property located at 3 Nelson Street, Inglewood and shares in Melvin Singh Super Pty Ltd and Auspicious Finance Pty Ltd (the Melvin Singh Property) by:

(i) removing, or causing or permitting the Melvin Singh Property to be removed from Australia;

(ii) selling, charging, mortgaging or otherwise dealing with, disposing of and/or diminishing the value of the Melvin Singh Property;

(iii) causing or permitting to be sold, charged, mortgaged or otherwise dealt with, disposed of, or diminish the value of the Melvin Singh Property;

(iv) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (i) to (iii) above, incurring new liabilities after the date of this order that are secured against the Melvin Singh Property including, without limitation, liabilities incurred either directly or indirectly, through the use of a credit facility, a drawdown facility or a re-draw facility against the Melvin Singh Property; and

(v) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (i) to (iv) above, withdrawing, transferring or otherwise disposing of or dealing with, any monies available in any account with any bank, building society or other financial institution (in Australia and elsewhere) as at the date of this order;

(c) the fifth defendant is to deposit the net proceeds of the sale of the business of Penguin (WA) Pty Ltd into a bank account in his name, which is subject to the above sub-paragraph (b); and

(d) the sixth defendant (by herself or her agent) is restrained from withdrawing, transferring or otherwise disposing of or dealing with, any monies available in any account with any bank, building society or financial institution in Australia, in which she has any legal or equitable interest as at the date of this order.

32. Paragraph 31(b) above does not:

(a) apply to property (as defined in the Corporations Act) purchased, secured or otherwise obtained by the fifth defendant after the date of this order;

(b) apply to any income, salary, bonus, dividends or interest or any other amount distributed to, or received or earned by the fifth defendant after the date of this order;

(c) prevent the fifth defendant from opening a new bank account;

(d) prevent the fifth defendant from causing Penguin (WA) Pty Ltd to complete the sale of its business;

(e) prevent any bank, building society or financial institution from exercising any right of set-off which it may have in respect of a facility afforded by it to each or any of the defendants prior to the date of this order;

(f) prevent the fifth defendant from incurring any liability after the date of this order;

(g) prevent the fifth defendant offering any property (as defined in the Corporations Act) purchased, secured or otherwise obtained by the fifth defendant after the date of this order as security for any liability;

(h) apply to any dealing in any property (as defined in the Corporations Act) of the third defendant or Futuristic Construction Pty Ltd (Company Property);

(i) prevent the third defendant or Futuristic Construction Pty Ltd from, or prevent the fifth defendant from causing or being involved in the third defendant or Futuristic Construction Pty Ltd:

(i) removing, or causing or permitting any Company Property to be removed from Australia;

(ii) selling, charging, mortgaging or otherwise dealing with, disposing of and/or diminishing the value of any Company Property;

(iii) causing or permitting to be sold, charged, mortgaged or otherwise dealt with, disposed of, or diminish the value of any Company Property;

(iv) incurring new liabilities including, without limitation, liabilities incurred either directly or indirectly, through the use of a credit facility, a drawdown facility or a re-draw facility against any Company Property;

(v) withdrawing, transferring or otherwise disposing of or dealing with, any monies available in any account with any bank, building society or other financial institution (in Australia and elsewhere); or

(vi) paying income, salaries, bonuses, dividends or interest to any person; or

(j) prevent MPS (WA) Pty Ltd as trustee for the MPS Trust from, or the fifth defendant from being involved in, distributing to any beneficiary of the MPS Trust any dividends or other amounts paid to MPS (WA) Pty Ltd as trustee for the MPS Trust by the third defendant or Futuristic Construction Pty Ltd.

Costs

33. The first, second and fourth defendants pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings, as taxed or agreed.

Other

34. The plaintiff must provide to the Receivers/Liquidators all documents obtained by the plaintiff during its investigations, including but not limited to:

(a) documents produced to the plaintiff in response to notices issued pursuant to s 19, s 30 and s 33 of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act);

(b) transcripts of examinations conducted by staff of the plaintiff pursuant to s 19 of the ASIC Act; and

(c) (to the extent permitted, reasonable and/or appropriate) documents otherwise produced voluntarily to the plaintiff during its investigations or obtained by the plaintiff through the exercise of some other power.

35. The Receivers, the Liquidators and the parties have liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves allegations that the first defendant, Harbans Kaur, operated an unregistered managed investment scheme in contravention of section 601ED(5) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Investor funds were advanced in the form of loans and were intended to be pooled and invested into real property projects managed by the second defendant, Paradise Property Pty Ltd. The first defendant, along with other defendants, allegedly used some of the investor funds or scheme property for their personal benefit. Many investors were not repaid, and it is likely that their capital has been lost. The fourth defendant, as a director of Paradise Property Pty Ltd, is alleged to have breached the duty of care and diligence. The parties have agreed to the entry of judgment against the defendants and to the facts of the contravening conduct.

This case came before the court following an application by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) for various orders to address the illegal activities of the defendants. The matter involved a winding-up application for the unregistered managed investment scheme and Paradise Property Pty Ltd, the appointment of receivers and liquidators, and the seeking of asset preservation orders. The defendants have consented to the entry of judgment and the facts as outlined by ASIC. The court has considered the submissions and agreements made by the parties in making its orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ASIC also seeks asset preservation orders under s 1323 of the Corporations Act in respect of property of Paradise Property Pty Ltd, Melvin Singh and Ms Lee. There is evidence that they may have received some investor funds. The asset preservation orders sought are less restrictive than those currently in place and the relevant defendants have consented to them. It is appropriate to make them in order to give the liquidators and receivers time to investigate what may have become of investor funds and whether recovery action should be taken.Conclusion Orders as set out at the beginning of this judgment will be made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court was tasked with determining various orders sought by ASIC in relation to the contravention of the Corporations Act by the defendants. The court considered the statutory provisions and legal authorities applicable to each order. Firstly, in relation to the appointment of receivers and managers, the court found that it was appropriate to make such an order to identify, preserve, and secure the property for the benefit of creditors. The court relied on s 1101B(1) and s 1323(1)(h) of the Corporations Act, which provide for the appointment of receivers and managers in cases of insolvent trading or contravention of the Act. The court noted that the receivers and managers would have broad powers to investigate and manage the property of the defendants and the Scheme.

Secondly, regarding the winding up of the Scheme and the second defendant, the court found that winding up was necessary to protect the interests of creditors and to ensure that the Scheme and the second defendant were not able to continue their activities in contravention of the Corporations Act. The court relied on s 601EE(2) and s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act, which provide for the winding up of unregistered managed investment schemes and companies in certain circumstances. The court also appointed the receivers as joint and several liquidators to manage the winding up process.

Thirdly, the court vacated certain asset preservation orders in light of the new orders. The court found that the new orders were less restrictive and had the consent of the relevant defendants. The court relied on s 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, which provides for the making of asset preservation orders to prevent the disposal or dealing with of specified property and funds.

Fourthly, the court permanently restrained the first defendant from carrying on a financial services business and operating an unregistered managed investment scheme. The court found that the first defendant had contravened s 601ED(5) of the Corporations Act by operating an unregistered managed investment scheme. The court relied on s 601ED(5) of the Corporations Act, which prohibits the operation of unregistered managed investment schemes.

Fifthly, the court disqualified the first defendant from managing corporations for life and the fourth defendant from managing corporations for 15 years. The court found that the first and fourth defendants had contravened their duties of care and diligence as directors, and their conduct warranted disqualification. The court relied on s 206C of the Corporations Act, which provides for the disqualification of persons from managing corporations.

Sixthly, the court imposed asset preservation orders on certain defendants to prevent the disposal or dealing with of specified property and funds. The court found that the defendants had received some investor funds and that it was necessary to prevent the disposal or dealing with of the specified property and funds. The court relied on s 1323 of the Corporations Act and s 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), which provide for the making of asset preservation orders.

Finally, the court ordered the first, second, and fourth defendants to pay ASIC's costs of the proceedings, as taxed or agreed. The court found that the defendants had acted in contravention of the Corporations Act and that it was appropriate to order them to pay ASIC's costs. The court relied on the inherent jurisdiction of the court to order costs in cases where a party has acted vexatiously, oppressively, or without real prospects of success.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court has the power to make a range of orders in cases of contravention of the Corporations Act, including the appointment of receivers and managers, winding up of companies and schemes, permanent injunctive relief, disqualification of directors, and asset preservation orders. The court will consider the statutory provisions and legal authorities applicable to each order and will make an order if it is appropriate in the circumstances. The court will also consider the need to protect the interests of creditors and the public and to ensure that the defendants are not able to continue their activities in contravention of the Corporations Act.