Reported Decision:
59 ACSR 373
(2006) 24 ACLC 1308
New South Wales
Supreme Court
CITATION: Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Maxwell & ors [2006] NSWSC 1052
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.HEARING DATE(S): 6 February 2006, 20 February 2006, 23 February 2006
JUDGMENT DATE :
10 October 2006JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Brereton J DECISION: Declarations of contravention pursuant to Corporations Act, s 1317E; pecuniary penalty orders pursuant to s 1317G, injunctive relief pursuant to s 1324; compensation orders pursuant to s 1317H; and banning orders pursuant to s 206C, 206D and 206E: see Schedules A to H. CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS – Fundraising – Offers of securities – whether loan agreement was “debenture” within Corporations Act, s 9, and “security” for purposes of Chapter 7 - whether offer to enter into loan agreements was offer of securities for purposes of Part 6D.2 – whether offers to enter into loan agreements required disclosure under Part 6D.2 – conditions of availability of s 708(10) exemption - licensee’s satisfaction on reasonable grounds of matters in s 708(10)(b) is condition and requires that licensee sufficiently investigate experience of investor to form relevant opinion - whether advertisement of offers prohibited if disclosure not required by reason of s 708(1) – whether to make singular personal approach to acquaintance is to “publish” a statement referring to an offer – whether Corporations Act s 79 available to impose accessorial civil liability in respect of provisions which are not civil penalty provisions – Carrying on financial services business without a licence - “financial services business” - “financial service” - “financial product advice” – “financial product” – whether loan agreements were financial products - whether by issuing loan agreements, corporation issued, and thereby dealt in, financial products – whether corporation was carrying on a financial services business - whether licensee under old legislation pursuant to transitional provisions was to be treated as if it held an Australian Financial Services Licence under new legislation for purposes of s 708(10) - Misleading and deceptive conduct – where corporations engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct by publishing advertisements and distributing brochures – whether director “knowingly concerned” - where evidence does not implicate director in any relevant conduct after he is shown to have knowledge of matters which falsify representations - Directors duties – whether breached by director authorising, permitting or failing to prevent contraventions by corporation of provisions of Corporations Act (not being civil penalty provisions) – ss 180, 181 and 182 are not concerned with any general obligation owed by directors at large to conduct affairs of company in accordance with law generally or Corporations Act in particular, but with duties owed to company - relevant considerations – whether s 181 duty of good faith is contravened in absence of deliberate conduct known to be not in interests of company - where corporations were closely held proprietary companies in which interests of directors and shareholders were…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Maxwell and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWSC 1052
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case encompassed the interpretation and application of the Corporations Act, particularly sections related to securities, disclosure, and directors' duties. The court had to determine whether the loan agreements were securities and, therefore, subject to disclosure requirements. Additionally, the court needed to establish whether Maxwell's conduct, including his failure to prevent misleading advertisements and brochures, constituted breaches of directors' duties and misleading and deceptive conduct. The case also explored the availability of accessorial civil liability under the Corporations Act for provisions that are not civil penalty provisions and the applicability of disqualification orders.
The court concluded that the loan agreements were securities, and thus, the offers to enter into these agreements required disclosure. It held that Maxwell contravened the misleading and deceptive conduct provisions and breached his duties as a director by failing to prevent misleading advertisements and brochures. The court further found that Maxwell was not carrying on a financial services business without a license and that the old licensee under the transitional provisions should be treated as holding an Australian Financial Services Licence. The court found Maxwell liable for the contraventions and imposed penalties, injunctions, and disqualification orders.
The court made declarations of contravention against Maxwell, treating his conduct over a period as single contraventions of specific sections of the Act. It also ordered Maxwell to pay penalties and costs and issued injunctions prohibiting him from engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct. Additionally, the court disqualified Maxwell from managing corporations for a specified period. The court's decision was based on the evidence presented and the specific provisions of the Corporations Act that were contravened.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court as a result of proceedings initiated by ASIC against the corporations and Maxwell. ASIC filed proceedings alleging various contraventions of the Corporations Act, including breaches of disclosure requirements, carrying on a financial services business without a licence, misleading and deceptive conduct, and breaches of directors' duties. The corporations and Maxwell responded to the proceedings, and the matter proceeded through several stages of litigation, including interlocutory applications and hearings. The case was ultimately determined through consent orders, which were agreed upon by the parties. The court was asked to consider the effect of these consent orders on its discretionary powers in making further orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the loan agreement was a "debenture" and "security" within the meaning of the Corporations Act.
2. Whether the offer to enter into loan agreements was an offer of "securities" for the purposes of Part 6D.2 of the Corporations Act.
3. Whether offers to enter into loan agreements required disclosure under Part 6D.2 of the Corporations Act.
4. What conditions must be satisfied for the availability of the s 708(10) exemption.
5. Whether ASIC's advertisement of offers was prohibited if disclosure was not required by reason of s 708(1).
6. Whether making a singular personal approach to an acquaintance constituted "publishing" a statement referring to an offer.
7. Whether Corporations Act s 79 is available to impose accessorial civil liability in respect of provisions which are not civil penalty provisions.
8. Whether the loan agreements were financial products.
9. Whether by issuing loan agreements, the corporation issued, and thereby dealt in, financial products.
10. Whether the corporation was carrying on a financial services business.
11. Whether a licensee under old legislation pursuant to transitional provisions was to be treated as if it held an Australian Financial Services Licence under new legislation for purposes of s 708(10).
12. Whether the corporations engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct by publishing advertisements and distributing brochures.
13. Whether the director was "knowingly concerned" in the contraventions.
14. Whether directors' duties were breached by authorising, permitting, or failing to prevent contraventions by the corporation of provisions of the Corporations Act.
15. When the operation of s 206D is attracted.
16. What is the effect of agreement of parties on Court's discretionary powers.
17. Whether injunctions are appropriate to make orders prohibiting the respondent from engaging in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or which is likely to mislead or deceive.
18. Whether declarations of contravention should treat as a single contravention of s 180, and as another single contravention of s 181, the whole course of conduct as director of Group of companies over a period, rather than particular acts or omissions.
19. Whether it is appropriate to make declarations of involvement (under s 79) in contravention by corporations (being contraventions of provisions which are not civil penalty provisions and do not make provision for accessorial civil liability).
20. What are the relevant considerations for making disqualification orders.
Held
1. The loan agreement was not a "debenture" and "security" within the meaning of the Corporations Act.
2. The offer to enter into loan agreements was not an offer of "securities" for the purposes of Part 6D.2 of the Corporations Act.
3. Offers to enter into loan agreements did not require disclosure under Part 6D.2 of the Corporations Act.
4. The availability of the s 708(10) exemption requires the licensee to be satisfied on reasonable grounds of matters in s 708(10)(b), which necessitates a sufficient investigation into the investor's experience to form a relevant opinion.
5. ASIC's advertisement of offers was not prohibited if disclosure was not required by reason of s 708(1).
6. Making a singular personal approach to an acquaintance did not constitute "publishing" a statement referring to an offer.
7. Corporations Act s 79 is not available to impose accessorial civil liability in respect of provisions which are not civil penalty provisions.
8. The loan agreements were financial products.
9. By issuing loan agreements, the corporation did issue, and thereby dealt in, financial products.
10. The corporation was carrying on a financial services business.
11. A licensee under old legislation pursuant to transitional provisions is to be treated as if it held an Australian Financial Services Licence under new legislation for purposes of s 708(10).
12. The corporations engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct by publishing advertisements and distributing brochures.
13. The director was not "knowingly concerned" in the contraventions.
14. Directors' duties were breached by authorising, permitting, or failing to prevent contraventions by the corporation of provisions of the Corporations Act.
15. The operation of s 206D is attracted when the corporations were closely held proprietary companies in which interests of directors and shareholders were identical, the director was young and inexperienced, his role was to provide building and construction expertise while others were responsible for the fund-raising role, and the directors obtained legal and accounting advice.
16. The agreement of parties does not limit the Court's discretionary powers under s 1324 of the Corporations Act.
17. Injunctions are appropriate to make orders prohibiting the respondent from engaging in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or which is likely to mislead or deceive.
18. Declarations of contravention should treat as a single contravention of s 180, and as another single contravention of s 181, the whole course of conduct as director of a group of companies over a period, rather than particular acts or omissions.
19. It is not appropriate to make declarations of involvement (under s 79) in contravention by corporations (being contraventions of provisions which are not civil penalty provisions and do not make provision for accessorial civil liability).
20. Relevant considerations for making disqualification orders include the nature and gravity of the contraventions, the culpability of the individual, and the need for deterrence and protection of the public interest.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court found that the loan agreements did not constitute "debentures" or "securities" under the Corporations Act, thereby not subject to the disclosure requirements of Part 6D.2. The court emphasised that the term "securities" in Part 6D.2 does not include loan agreements. Additionally, the court held that the exemption under s 708(10) requires the licensee to sufficiently investigate the experience of the investor to form a relevant opinion on reasonable grounds, which the corporation had not done. Regarding ASIC's advertisement of offers, the court concluded that it was not prohibited if disclosure was not required under s 708(1). The personal approach to an acquaintance was deemed not to constitute "publishing" a statement referring to an offer, as it was not a public dissemination.
The court held that Corporations Act s 79 does not extend to impose accessorial civil liability for provisions that are not civil penalty provisions. It also ruled that the loan agreements were financial products, and by issuing them, the corporation dealt in financial products and was carrying on a financial services business. Under the transitional provisions, a licensee under the old legislation is treated as holding an Australian Financial Services Licence for purposes of s 708(10). The court found that the corporations engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct through their advertisements and brochures. However, the director was not "knowingly concerned" in the contraventions as there was no evidence implicating him in any relevant conduct after he was shown to have knowledge of matters that falsified the representations.
The court held that directors' duties were breached by authorising, permitting, or failing to prevent contraventions by the corporation. It clarified that ss 180, 181, and 182 of the Corporations Act pertain to duties owed to the company rather than a general obligation to conduct affairs in accordance with the law. The court found that s 181's duty of good faith was contravened in the absence of deliberate conduct known to be not in the interests of the company. The operation of s 206D was attracted due to the closely held nature of the companies, the director's limited role, and the reliance on legal and accounting advice.
Regarding consent orders, the court noted that the agreement of parties does not limit its discretionary powers. It held that injunctions are appropriate to prevent misleading or deceptive conduct. The court concluded that declarations of contravention should cover the whole course of conduct as director over a period rather than particular acts or omissions, treating them as single contraventions of s 180 and s 181. It found it inappropriate to make declarations of involvement under s 79 for contraventions that are not civil penalty provisions and do not provide for accessorial civil liability. Relevant considerations for disqualification orders include the nature and gravity of the contraventions, the individual's culpability, and the need for deterrence and public protection.