FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
General Manager of the Fair Work Commission v McGiveron [2017] FCA 405
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read General Manager of the Fair Work Commission v McGiveron and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCA 405
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the nature of the obligations contravened by McGiveron and Burton, focusing on whether their actions met the standards of care, diligence, good faith, and proper purpose as required by the Act. The penalties were determined based on the severity and frequency of the contraventions, as well as the maximum penalties allowable under the Act. The court found that McGiveron's contraventions occurred before 28 December 2012, thus attracting a maximum penalty of $6,600 per contravention, while Burton's contraventions occurred after this date, with a maximum penalty of $10,200 per contravention. The penalties were assessed in light of these maxima and the specific circumstances of each contravention.
The court imposed specific pecuniary penalties on McGiveron and Burton for their admitted contraventions, with the penalties varying according to the nature and extent of the breaches. The penalties were structured to reflect the seriousness of the contraventions and to provide appropriate deterrence. Additionally, the court ordered that the penalties be paid to the Commonwealth. The penalties were also subject to conditions, including stays on the operation of the penalties for certain periods to allow for payment. These detailed orders are set out in Schedules A and B to the court's decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
The First Respondent
1. Subject to Order 3 below, each penalty set out in the third column in the table in Schedule A to these orders be imposed on the first respondent in respect of the conduct correspondingly set out in the second column, being a contravention of the provision of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 (Cth), correspondingly set out in the fourth column in the table.
2. To the extent that Order 1 relates to a contravention numbered by an Arabic numeral in the first column in the table in Schedule A, the operation of that order be stayed for 60 days.
3. To the extent that Order 1 relates to a contravention numbered by a Roman numeral in the first column in the table in Schedule A, the operation of that order be stayed for 74 days.
4. Upon the payment, within 74 days, of the penalty for a contravention numbered by an Arabic numeral in the first column in the table in Schedule A, the operation of Order 1 be permanently stayed to the extent that it relates to the contravention or contraventions numbered by the Roman numeral or numerals of the same value in that column.
The Second Respondent
5. Subject to Order 7 below, each penalty set out in the third column in the table in Schedule B to these orders be imposed on the second respondent in respect of the conduct correspondingly set out in the second column in the table, being a contravention of the provision of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 (Cth), correspondingly set out in the fourth column in the table.
6. To the extent that Order 5 relates to a contravention numbered by an Arabic numeral in the first column in the table in Schedule B, the operation of that order be stayed for 60 days.
7. To the extent that Order 5 relates to a contravention numbered by a Roman numeral in the first column in the table in Schedule B, the operation of that order be stayed for 74 days.
8. Upon the payment, within 74 days, of the penalty for a contravention numbered by an Arabic numeral in the first column in the table in Schedule B, the operation of Order 5 be permanently stayed to the extent that it relates to the contravention or contraventions numbered by the Roman numeral or numerals of the same value in that column.
The First and Second Respondent
9. Pursuant to s 357(2) of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 (Cth), the pecuniary penalties be paid to the Commonwealth.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Schedule A
1
2
3
4
No.
Conduct
Penalty
Provision
1
Mr McGiveron’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU on or about 24 July 2012 by executing contracts to purchase two F350s and causing the TWU to pay deposits in the amount of $40,000 for each of the F350s, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr McGiveron believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$6,000
s 286(1)
(i)
Mr McGiveron’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU on or about 24 July 2012, by failing to do so with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the circumstances, in that Mr McGiveron executed contracts to purchase the F350s and caused the TWU to pay deposits in the amount of $40,000 for each of the F350s.
$5,000
s 285(1)
2
Mr McGiveron’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in or about July 2012, in relation to the adoption of a redundancy policy by the WA Branch of the TWU, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr McGiveron believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$5,000
s 286(1)
Schedule B
1
2
3
4
No.
Conduct
Penalty
Provision
1
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU on or about 26 March 2013 in purporting to act on behalf of the TWU in executing further contracts to purchase two F350s and on 2 April 2012 by causing a payment to be made from WA Branch funds of approximately $228,500 with respect to the F350s, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr Burton believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$9,000
s 286(1)
(i)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU, by failing to do so with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the circumstances, in that on or about 26 March 2013 Mr Burton purported to act on behalf of the TWU in executing further contracts to purchase the F350s and on 2 April 2013 he caused a payment to be made from WA Branch funds of approximately $228,500 with respect to the F350s.
$6,500
s 285(1)
2
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary or Acting Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU between October 2012 and February 2014 in failing to disclose the purchase of the F350s to the WA BCOM, the relevant WA Branch Finance Committee and/or the WA Branch auditors, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr Burton believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$9,000
s 286(1)
(ii)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary or Acting Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU between October 2012 and February 2014, by failing to do so with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the circumstances, in that Mr Burton failed to disclose the purchase of the F350s to the WA BCOM, the relevant WA Branch Finance Committee and/or the WA Branch auditors.
$6,500
s 285(1)
3
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as Branch Secretary or Acting Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in July 2013 in causing the TWU to transfer to Mr McGiveron from WA Branch funds the amount of $348,396.15 (gross) with respect to Mr McGiveron’s redundancy, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr Burton believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$6,000
s 286(1)
(iii)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as
Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in July 2013, in failing to do so with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the circumstances, in that Mr Burton caused the TWU to transfer to Mr McGiveron from WA Branch funds the amount of $348,396.15 (gross) with respect to Mr McGiveron’s redundancy.
$3,000
s 285(1)
4
Mr Burton’s improper use of his position as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU to gain an advantage for himself, gain an advantage for others and to cause detriment to the TWU, by, in May 2013 by incurring an expense of $486.90 from the Rockpool Bar and Grill in Perth and causing this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds.
$650
s 287(1)
(iv)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as
Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in May 2013 in incurring an expense of $486.90 from the Rockpool Bar and Grill in Perth and causing this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr Burton believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$650
s 286(1)
(iv)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as
Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in May 2013, by failing to do so with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the circumstances, in that Mr Burton incurred an expense of $486.90 from the Rockpool Bar and Grill in Perth and caused this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds.
$650
s 285(1)
5
Mr Burton’s improper use of his position as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU to gain an advantage for himself and to cause detriment to that union, by, in September 2013, incurring an expense of $535.76 with respect to the hire of a vehicle and causing this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds.
$1,650
s 287(1)
(v)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as
Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in September 2013 in incurring an expense of $535.76 with respect to the hire of a vehicle and causing this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr Burton believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$1,650
s 286(1)
(v)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as
Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in May 2013, by failing to do so with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the circumstances, in that Mr Burton incurred an expense of $535.76 with respect to the hire of a vehicle and caused this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds.
$1,650
s 285(1)
6
Mr Burton’s improper use of his position as Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU to gain an advantage for himself, gain an advantage for others and to cause detriment to that union, by, in September 2013, incurring an expense of $1,634.44 with respect to a function at the WAFL Grand Final and causing this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds.
$1,000
s 287(1)
(vi)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as
Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in September 2013 in incurring an expense of $1,634.44 with respect to a function at the WAFL Grand Final and causing this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds, that exercise of powers and discharge of duties having been done neither in good faith in what Mr Burton believed were the best interests of the TWU, nor for a proper purpose.
$1,000
s 286(1)
(vi)
Mr Burton’s exercise of his powers and discharge of his duties as
Branch Secretary of the WA Branch of the TWU in May 2013, by failing to do so with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the circumstances, in that Mr Burton incurred an expense of $1,634.44 with respect to a function at the WAFL Grand Final and causing this to be paid by the TWU from WA Branch funds.
$1,000
s 285(1)
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It might be observed in passing that this is not a high maximum penalty. The maximum pecuniary penalty that can be imposed under provisions analogous to s 285 and s 286 concerning officers and directors of a corporation under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), namely s 180 and s 181 is $200,000 for an individual. All of the contraventions admitted by Mr McGiveron occurred prior to 28 December 2012, and so the maximum penalty that can be imposed for each of his admitted contraventions is $6,600. All of the contraventions admitted by Mr Burton occurred after, or substantially after, 28 December 2012 and so attract a maximum penalty in each case of $10,200.NATURE OF OBLIGATIONS CONTRAVENED So far as the three relevant provisions are concerned, it is useful to set out exactly what obligations or duties they create. Section 285 of the RO Act requires an officer to exercise powers with care and diligence, in the following terms:An officer of an organisation or a branch must exercise his or her powers and discharge his or her duties with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise if he or she:(a)were an officer of an organisation or a branch in the organisation’s circumstances; and(b)occupied the office held by, and had the same responsibilities within the organisation or a branch as, the officer. Section 285 of the RO Act is in relevantly the same terms as s 180 of the Corporations Act that deals with directors and other officers of a corporation. The test for determining a contravention of s 285(1) is objective. It does not import a mental element. See Chew v The Queen (1992) 173 CLR 626 at 642 (Dawson J); [1992] HCA 18, citing Byrne v Baker [1964] VR 443 at 450. It requires a court to ask what an ordinary person of ordinary prudence, with the knowledge and experience of the officer, might be expected to have done in all of the circumstances at the relevant time of the conduct if he or she were acting on his or her own behalf. See Daniels v Anderson (1995) 37 NSWLR 438 at 504-505; Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Vines (2003) 48 ACSR 322 at [38] (Austin J); [2003] NSWSC 116, referred to with approval in Vines v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2007) 62 ACSR 1 at 27 [109] (and see at 115 [593] (Santow JA)); [2007] NSWCA 75; Re HIH Insurance Ltd (in prov liq) and HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (in prov liq); Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler (2002) 41 ACSR 72 at [372(4)]; [2002] NSWSC 171, applied in Morley v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2010) 81 ACSR 285 at [807]; [2010] NSWCA 331; Diamond Hill Mining Pty Ltd v Huang Jin Mining Pty Ltd (2011) 84 ASCR 616 at [90] (Croft J); [2010] VSC 288; Parker v Tucker (2010) 77 ACSR 525 at [70] (Gordon J); [2010] FCA 263; Diakyne v Ralph (2009) 72 ACSR 450 at [84], [121]; [2009] FCA 721. Section 286(1) requires an officer to exercise powers in good faith and for a proper purpose, in the following terms:(1)An officer of an organisation or a branch must exercise his or her powers and discharge his or her duties:(a)in good faith in what he or she believes to be the best interests of the organisation; and(b)for a proper purpose.Note: This subsection is a civil penalty provision (see section 305).