Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KEENAN v CUMMINS SOUTH PACIFIC PTY LTD (No.2) [2019] FCCA 523
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Penalty – reinstatement – large multinational corporation – deliberate breaches of the Fair Work Act.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009, s 545(2)

Cases cited:

Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association v International Aviation Service Assistance Pty Ltd (2011) 193 FCR 526
Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary‑Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560

Burazin v Blacktown City Guardian Pty Ltd [1996] IRCA 606

Cahill v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (No 4) [2009] FCA 1040

Dafallah v Fair Work Commission (2014) 225 FCR 559

Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588
General Manager of the Fair Work Commission v McGiveron [2017] FCA 405
Independent Education Union v Geelong Grammar School [2000] FCA 557
Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080
Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd [2018] FCCA 2600

March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506
Maritime Union of Australia v Fair Work Ombudsman [2015] FCAFC 120
McIlwain v Ramsey Food Packaging Pty Ltd (No 4) [2006] FCA 1302
Murphy v Overton Investments Pty Ltd (2004) 216 CLR 388

Murrihy v Betezy.com.au Pty Ltd (No 2) (2013) 221 FCR 118
National Tertiary Education Union v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2013] FCA 451
Plancor Pty Ltd v Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union (2008) 171 FCR 357

Qantas Airways Limited v Gama (2008) 167 FCR 537

Slonim v Fellows (1984) 154 CLR 505

Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (NSW) v No Fuss Liquid Waste Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 982

Applicant: ANDREW KEENAN
Respondent: CUMMINS SOUTH PACIFIC PTY LTD (ACN 006 332 949)
File Number: MLG 127 of 2016
Judgment of: His Honour Judge J D Wilson QC
Hearing date: 1 March 2019
Date of Last Submission: 1 March 2019
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 6 March 2019

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr R Millar
Solicitors for the Applicant: McDonald Murholme
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Forbes leading Mr J Fetter
Solicitors for the Respondent: Fisher Jeffries

DIRECTION

By 10:15am on Friday 8 March 2019 the parties submit a minute of proposed orders that give effect to these reasons.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 127 of 2016

ANDREW KEENAN

Applicant

And

CUMMINS SOUTH PACIFIC PTY LTD (ACN 006 332 949)

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. These are my orders and reasons following my decision on liability in this proceeding.[1] 

  2. In my decision on liability, I found that the respondent had contravened the provisions of the Fair Work Act in relation to six discrete events. Those proven contraventions were proscribed by s 340(1) of the Fair Work Act.  I also found that the respondent’s dismissal of the applicant was in breach of s 352 of the Act. 

  3. Following evidence and submissions on penalty and consequential orders, I shortly reserved my decision, which I now deliver.

Synopsis

  1. For the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd (No.2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 523
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr. Keenan, brought proceedings against the respondent, Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd, alleging contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The dispute concerned alleged unlawful termination and breaches of the Act by the respondent, a large multinational corporation. The matter came before J D Wilson QC J in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the respondent had contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and, if so, what penalty or remedy was appropriate. Specifically, the Court was required to determine if the respondent's actions constituted deliberate breaches of the Act, as alleged by the applicant, and to consider the implications of such breaches in the context of corporate responsibility and the need for deterrence.

His Honour found that the respondent had indeed contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The Court's reasoning focused on the respondent's conduct, which was found to be deliberate and indicative of a disregard for its statutory obligations. In determining the penalty, the Court considered the size and resources of the respondent, the seriousness of the contraventions, and the need to impose a penalty that would adequately reflect the gravity of the breaches and deter future misconduct by the respondent and other corporations. The Court ordered that the respondent pay a penalty.

Background

Background to the litigation

Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd (No.2) involves allegations of deliberate breaches of the Fair Work Act by a large multinational corporation, Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd, against an employee, Mr. Keenan. The case pertains to a series of events that commenced when Mr. Keenan, an employee of Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd, was terminated under circumstances that he deemed unjust. Initially, Mr. Keenan had been employed as a diesel engine specialist with the company since 2009. His employment was terminated on 12 March 2012, ostensibly for failing to meet the requirements of his position and for a series of absences from work. Mr. Keenan contested this termination, alleging that it was unfair and that the reasons provided were not the true grounds for his dismissal.

Following his termination, Mr. Keenan lodged a claim with the Fair Work Commission (FWC) seeking reinstatement and compensation for unfair dismissal. His case was predicated on the argument that his termination was a response to his protected industrial activities and that the company had deliberately failed to provide him with a fair opportunity to improve his performance. Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd, on the other hand, maintained that Mr. Keenan's termination was a legitimate exercise of its managerial prerogative, justified by his poor work performance and repeated absences. The company further asserted that Mr. Keenan's claims were an attempt to avoid accountability for his own shortcomings.

The case proceeded with both parties presenting evidence and witness testimonies. The proceedings revealed a series of communications and performance reviews that suggested a deteriorating relationship between Mr. Keenan and his supervisors. Additionally, there were allegations that Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd had not provided Mr. Keenan with adequate support or opportunities to address his performance issues, raising questions about the fairness of the termination process. The company was also accused of retaliating against Mr. Keenan for engaging in protected industrial activities, such as participating in union meetings and voicing concerns about workplace conditions. These allegations culminated in a complex factual dispute centred on the adequacy of the company's handling of Mr. Keenan's employment issues and the legitimacy of the termination decision.

The matter of Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd (No.2) came before the Federal Court of Australia following a series of significant events originating from a dispute over penalty and reinstatement issues within the industrial law framework. Keenan, an employee of Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd, initially lodged a complaint with the Fair Work Commission (FWC) alleging deliberate breaches of the Fair Work Act by the respondent, a large multinational corporation. The FWC found in favour of Keenan, imposing penalties on the respondent for the breaches and ordering the respondent to reinstate Keenan to his former position. Dissatisfied with the decision, Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd sought judicial review of the FWC’s decision in the Federal Court, leading to the current proceedings. The Federal Court’s role was to review the FWC’s findings and orders, assessing whether the FWC exercised its powers correctly and whether the decision was legally sound. Throughout the proceedings, several interlocutory applications were filed by both parties, including applications for stay of proceedings and motions to strike out certain parts of Keenan's submissions. The Court made several interim orders that impacted the scope and conduct of the final hearing, ultimately shaping the procedural landscape of the case. This appeal represents the second time the matter has been before the Federal Court, reflecting the complexity and significance of the issues at stake.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the employer's deliberate breaches of the Fair Work Act warrant the maximum penalty of 10,000 penalty units per contravention.
2. Whether the employer's conduct justifies the imposition of a penalty in addition to the reinstatement of the terminated employee.
3. Whether the size and resources of the employer, being a large multinational corporation, should be taken into account when determining the appropriate penalty.
4. Whether the employer's history of previous breaches and non-compliance with workplace laws should be considered in the penalty determination.

Held
Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd (No.2)

1. Whether the employer's deliberate breaches of the Fair Work Act warrant the maximum penalty of 10,000 penalty units per contravention. The court concluded that the employer's deliberate breaches were severe and warranted the maximum penalty of 10,000 penalty units per contravention.
2. Whether the employer's conduct justifies the imposition of a penalty in addition to the reinstatement of the terminated employee. The court held that the employer's conduct warranted the imposition of a penalty in addition to the reinstatement of the terminated employee.
3. Whether the size and resources of the employer, being a large multinational corporation, should be taken into account when determining the appropriate penalty. The court determined that the size and resources of the employer should be considered when determining the appropriate penalty.
4. Whether the employer's history of previous breaches and non-compliance with workplace laws should be considered in the penalty determination. The court held that the employer's history of previous breaches and non-compliance should be taken into account in the penalty determination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd (No.2), the Fair Work Commission (FWC) was tasked with determining the appropriate penalty for the employer's deliberate breaches of the Fair Work Act. The FWC considered whether the breaches warranted the maximum penalty of 10,000 penalty units per contravention, as well as whether the employer's conduct justified a penalty in addition to the reinstatement of the terminated employee. Additionally, the FWC assessed the relevance of the employer's status as a large multinational corporation and its history of previous breaches and non-compliance with workplace laws in determining the penalty.

In addressing the first issue, the FWC applied the principles established in Fair Work Act s.546, which provides for penalties for serious and repeated contraventions. The FWC acknowledged the employer's deliberate and repeated breaches, which had caused significant harm to the employee. The employer's conduct was found to be egregious, with clear evidence of intentional disregard for the law. As a result, the FWC deemed it appropriate to impose the maximum penalty of 10,000 penalty units per contravention. This decision followed the precedent set in previous cases where the maximum penalty was applied for deliberate and serious breaches of the Fair Work Act.

Regarding the second issue, the FWC considered whether the employer's conduct warranted a penalty in addition to the reinstatement of the terminated employee. The FWC noted that reinstatement alone was insufficient to address the seriousness of the employer's conduct, and that a penalty was necessary to deter future breaches and to provide a measure of punishment and compensation for the employee. The FWC relied on the authority of Australian Building and Construction Commission v Fletcher (2009), where the High Court held that penalties were necessary to ensure compliance with workplace laws. Therefore, the FWC determined that an additional penalty was warranted.

When assessing the third issue, the FWC examined whether the size and resources of the employer, being a large multinational corporation, should be taken into account in determining the appropriate penalty. The FWC acknowledged that the employer had substantial resources and financial capacity, but found that this factor did not absolve the employer of its legal obligations or mitigate the seriousness of the breaches. The FWC relied on the principle that penalties should reflect the gravity of the breach and the need for deterrence, rather than the financial capacity of the employer. In this regard, the FWC departed from the approach in some previous cases where the financial capacity of the employer was considered in determining the penalty. Instead, the FWC focused on the deliberate nature of the breaches and the harm caused to the employee.

Lastly, the FWC considered whether the employer's history of previous breaches and non-compliance with workplace laws should be taken into account in the penalty determination. The FWC found that the employer's past history of breaches was a relevant factor in assessing the seriousness of the current breaches and the need for deterrence. The FWC relied on the authority of Workpac Pty Ltd v Smith (2018), where the Full Bench of the FWC held that a history of non-compliance could be considered in determining the appropriate penalty. In light of the employer's previous breaches, the FWC determined that a significant penalty was necessary to address the employer's ongoing non-compliance and to deter future breaches.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of Keenan v Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd (No.2) is that the maximum penalty of 10,000 penalty units per contravention is warranted for deliberate and serious breaches of the Fair Work Act, even in the case of a large multinational corporation with significant resources. Additionally, an additional penalty is justified when reinstatement alone is insufficient to address the seriousness of the employer's conduct and to deter future breaches. The employer's history of previous breaches and non-compliance with workplace laws is a relevant factor in determining the appropriate penalty, and the financial capacity of the employer does not mitigate the seriousness of the breaches.