Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Blumenthal

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Blumenthal [2024] FCA 384

File number: NSD 1533 of 2023
Judgment of: STEWART J
Date of judgment: 12 April 2024 
Date of publication of reasons: 17 April 2024
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – where parties jointly seek agreed declarations and penalty orders in relation to admitted contraventions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – where contravening conduct concerned breaches by the defendant of his directors’ duties and provision preventing a person from creating a false or misleading appearance of active trading – where disqualification and pecuniary penalty sought – where contravening conduct serious – where application made for leave pursuant to s 206G of the Corporations Act for disqualified person to manage particular corporations – where suitable limitations proposed with respect to such leave
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 91, 93AA

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 912A, 180(1), 181(1), 206C, 206G, 1041B(1)(b), 1317E, 1317G, 1322

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Cases cited:

ACCC v Reckitt Benckiser (Australia) Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 181; 340 ALR 25

ASIC v Employsure Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 5; 407 ALR 302

ASIC v Forex Capital Trading Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 570

ASIC v Westpac Banking Corporation (No 3) [2018] FCA 1701; 131 ACSR 585

Australian Building & Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; 274 CLR 450

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2018] HCA 3; 262 CLR 157

Gillfillan v ASIC [2012] NSWCA 370; ACSR 460

Minister for Industry, Tourism and Resources v Mobile Oil Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 72; 26 ATPR 41-993

Nenna v ASIC [2011] FCA 1193; 198 FCR 32

Re HIH Insurance Ltd (in prov liq) and HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (in prov liq); ASIC v Adler [2002] NSWSC 483; 42 ACSR 80

Vines v ASIC [2007] NSWCA 126; 63 ACSR 505

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 72
Date of hearing: 11 April 2024
Counsel for the Plaintiff: G P Craddock SC
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Defendant: P English
Solicitor for the Defendant: Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan

ORDERS

NSD 1533 of 2023
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION

Plaintiff

AND:

ADAM BLUMENTHAL

Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

STEWART J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 APRIL 2024

RE ORIGINATING PROCESS DATED 15 FEBRUARY 2024

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.

On the facts stated in the amended statement of agreed facts (at annexure AIR-4 to the affidavit of Anna Inglis Ross affirmed 26 March 2024), pursuant to


s 1317E of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth), during the relevant period (18 March 2021 to 15 November 2021), the defendant contravened:

(a)the duties he owed as a director of EverBlu Capital Pty Ltd ACN 612 793 683, pursuant to s 180(1) of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Blumentha... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 384
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) brought proceedings against Mr. Blumenthal, a director of several corporations, regarding breaches of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The primary issues revolved around Mr. Blumenthal’s failure to adhere to his fiduciary duties and contravened provisions that prevent creating a false or misleading appearance of active trading. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether Mr. Blumenthal should be disqualified from managing corporations and whether a pecuniary penalty was warranted. Additionally, the court had to decide on an application for leave under section 206G for Mr. Blumenthal to manage certain corporations during his disqualification period.

The court examined the nature and seriousness of the breaches, which included Mr. Blumenthal’s involvement in entering, amending, and cancelling multiple client orders for Creso shares directly through client accounts despite internal policies prohibiting such actions. The court acknowledged the interrelated nature of the contraventions, the serious implications for the corporations involved, and Mr. Blumenthal’s cooperation with the regulator and remorse shown thereafter. The court concluded that the agreed quantum of $850,000 for the pecuniary penalty was appropriate, considering the seriousness of the contraventions, the period of misconduct, and the deterrent effect of the penalty. Furthermore, the court found that Mr. Blumenthal should be disqualified from managing corporations for five years.

In relation to the application for leave under section 206G, the court considered the proposed limitations on Mr. Blumenthal's management role over Phillip Street Holdings Pty Ltd and Oakphil Pty Ltd. The court accepted that the conditions imposed on these companies were sufficient to mitigate any risk of further contraventions and did not pose any appreciable prejudice or risk to the public interest. Consequently, the court granted Mr. Blumenthal leave to manage these companies during his disqualification period, subject to the specified conditions.

The court's final orders included disqualifying Mr. Blumenthal from managing corporations for five years and imposing a pecuniary penalty of $850,000. Additionally, the court granted Mr. Blumenthal leave to manage Phillip Street Holdings Pty Ltd and Oakphil Pty Ltd under specific conditions during his disqualification period, ensuring that these companies' activities were limited to maintaining their status as registered companies, buying, holding, and selling shares, and acting as trustees of their respective trusts.

Orders

Orders of the court

8. Pursuant to s 206G(1) of the Corporations Act, and subject to the conditions below, the defendant has leave during the period of disqualification the subject of Order 2 above to manage the affairs of the following two companies:

(a) Phillip Street Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 615 424 783) as trustee for the Phillip Street Trust (and no other trust), provided that Phillip Street:

(i) continues to act only as trustee for the Phillip Street Trust;

(ii) does not engage any employees;

(iii) does not incur any debt for the purposes of its permitted activities, including investing in listed and unlisted companies, save where Stewart J’s reasons for judgment in these proceedings and Court Enforceable Undertaking 031914829 dated 14 December 2023 have been provided in advance to any prospective lender; and

(iv) the eligible beneficiaries of the Phillip Street Trust are limited to the defendant and members of his immediate family;

(b) Oakphil Pty Ltd (ACN 674 979 170) as trustee for the Oakphil Family Trust (and no other trust), provided that Oakphil:

(i) continues to act only as trustee for the Oakphil Family Trust;

(ii) plays no role in managing the affairs of Oakley Capital Partners Pty Ltd (ACN 663 165 839); and

(iii) the eligible beneficiaries of the Oakphil Family Trust are limited to the defendant and members of his immediate family.

9. Until such time as the defendant is no longer disqualified from managing corporations under Pt 2D.6 of the Corporations Act, the defendant’s ability to manage the affairs of Phillip Street and Oakphil:

(a) is limited to the following activities:

(i) those required by, or incidental to, maintaining their status as a registered company;

(ii) buying, holding and selling shares; and

(iii) acting as trustee of the relevant trust and doing things that are reasonably incidental to so acting; and

(b) does not extend to:

(i) providing Financial Services;

(ii) carrying on a Financial Services business; or

(iii) performing any function which would amount to the defendant being involved in the carrying on of a Financial Services business (including as an officer, manager, employee, contractor or a Responsible Manager of an entity carrying on a Financial Services business).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

My reasons draw heavily on the statement of agreed facts and the joint written submissions filed by the parties.The material facts During the relevant period, Mr Blumenthal was one of two directors of EverBlu Capital Pty Ltd. The other director was not resident in Australia and was not active in EverBlu. Mr Blumenthal was also the chairman and an Authorised Representative and Responsible Manager of EverBlu. He oversaw and participated in the corporate advisory and stockbroking services provided by EverBlu as holder of an Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL). He was also indirectly, through a corporate vehicle owned by him, a part owner of EverBlu and, with the other director, the controlling mind of EverBlu. Anglo Menda Pty Ltd was a corporation of which Mr Blumenthal was the sole director and shareholder. Anglo Menda was an Authorised Representative of EverBlu. Creso Pharma Ltd (now known as Melodiol Global Health Ltd) was listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) from 20 October 2016 to 12 June 2023, ie covering the relevant period. During the relevant period, Mr Blumenthal was a substantial shareholder, non-executive director and chairman of Creso. As at 28 February 2021, Mr Blumenthal’s total shareholding in Creso – which was indirectly held through various corporate vehicles owned by him – was valued at approximately $30 million. From at least July 2017, EverBlu provided corporate advisory services to Creso. EverBlu led Creso’s initial public offering. EverBlu maintained a suite of internal policies that included procedures directed towards compliance with its AFSL and the general law. By those policies, Mr Blumenthal was prohibited from providing general advice or accepting client instructions in relation to a company of which he was a director and accepting client instructions in relation to a company under “Restriction”. Creso was a company under “Restriction” during the relevant period. On 23 March 2021, Mr Blumenthal was placed on the “Chinese Wall” Register (which recorded EverBlu’s representatives in possession of non-public information and imposed strict limitations and conditions on the use of that information) with respect to Creso. The addition of Mr Blumenthal to that register generated an automated “Chinese Walls Register Entry Acknowledgement”, which required him to acknowledge that he would, amongst other things, not take orders from clients to buy or sell Creso shares and, in the event of receiving such an order, he would “pass the phone to another adviser”. Contrary to several of EverBlu’s policies, Mr Blumenthal personally and through a Designated Trading Representative (DTR) entered, amended and cancelled multiple client orders for Creso shares directly through client accounts. He also directed the DTR to enter, amend and cancel multiple client orders for Creso shares through the Suspense Account and subsequently book the resulting trades from the Suspense Account to one or more client accounts, each of which was held in the name of individuals known to Mr Blumenthal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The failure to put the Creso board in a proper position to make an informed choice as to Mr Scholz’s engagement is compounded by Mr Blumenthal’s failure to inform the board that he had a direct conflict of interest with respect to Mr Scholz given that Creso’s payments to Mr Scholz enhanced Mr Scholz’s capacity to repay loans advanced by Anglo Menda (the sole director and ultimate shareholder of which was Mr Blumenthal). Mr Blumenthal also failed to exclude himself from the approval of Mr Scholz’s invoices by the Creso board.Conclusion As mentioned, Mr Blumenthal agrees that he should be disqualified from managing corporations for five years and I am satisfied that an order to that effect should be made. Thus, the risk of further contraventions by him during that period is mitigated. This consideration should be considered together with that of the extra-curial consequences to which Mr Blumenthal is subject, namely his enforceable undertaking to not provide financial services, carry on a financial services business or perform any function involved in the carrying on of a financial services business, for a period of five years, arising from the same factual circumstances. The parties agreed, and I am satisfied, that the circumstances of the case necessitate more than disqualification. The contraventions are serious and interrelated, including because the contravention of s 180 relating to Mr Blumenthal’s role as a director of EverBlu enabled the contraventions of s 1041B(1)(b), which contraventions involved contravention of s 180(1) and s 181(1) by Mr Blumenthal as a director of Creso. There is also the object of general deterrence that must guide the proper outcome. I am satisfied that the agreed quantum reflects a balancing of relevant factors including (1) the seriousness of the contraventions, (2) the period of contravening conduct, (3) the difficulty of detection of such contraventions, (4) the risks posed to the two corporations, one of which was listed, (5) Mr Blumenthal’s cooperation with the regulator once the contraventions came to light and the remorse he has since shown, and (6) the extra-curial measure of deterrence represented by Mr Blumenthal’s entry into the enforceable undertaking. That quantum, ie $850,000, is within an acceptable or appropriate range in all the circumstances.Exception to disqualification under s 206G Section 206G(1) of the Corporations Act states that “a person who is disqualified” may apply for leave to manage a corporation. In order to seek orders under s 206G contemporaneously with the hearing of the principal proceeding, Mr Blumenthal sought relief pursuant to s 1322 of the Corporations Act from the requirement of s 206G(2) that the application be served on ASIC at least 21 days prior to commencing the proceeding for s 206G relief. ASIC did not oppose that relief. Such relief is competent in these circumstances: Nenna v ASIC [2011] FCA 1193; 198 FCR 32 at [43]-[44]. Mr Blumenthal provided ASIC with both an application and an affidavit in support of the application in draft in advance of the hearing for ASIC’s consideration. The parties agreed that leave pursuant to s 1322 is justified and that Mr Blumenthal’s proposed s 206G orders are appropriate. No purpose would be served in not granting the relief, and there is no appreciable prejudice or risk in doing so. I am accordingly satisfied that it should be granted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court examined the admitted contraventions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by Mr Blumenthal, including breaches of his directors’ duties and the provision preventing the creation of a false or misleading appearance of active trading. The Court considered the seriousness of the contraventions, the period of the conduct, and the extra-curial consequences to which Mr Blumenthal was already subject. It was noted that the contraventions were serious and interrelated, with the contravention of section 180 enabling other contraventions under sections 1041B(1)(b), 180(1), and 181(1). The Court balanced these factors against Mr Blumenthal’s cooperation with the regulator, his remorse, and the deterrence effect of the enforceable undertaking he had entered into.

The Court then turned to the issue of the appropriate penalty, finding that the agreed quantum of $850,000 was within an acceptable range considering all relevant factors. This included the seriousness of the contraventions, the difficulty of detection, the risks posed to the corporations, and the extra-curial measures of deterrence already in place.

Finally, regarding the application for leave to manage specific corporations during the disqualification period, the Court noted that section 206G of the Corporations Act allows a disqualified person to apply for leave to manage a corporation. The Court found that Mr Blumenthal’s application was justified and that the proposed limitations on his management activities were appropriate. The Court concluded that there was no appreciable prejudice or risk in granting the relief, and thus, the application should be granted.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases where a disqualified person seeks leave to manage specific corporations during their disqualification period, the Court will consider the proposed limitations and the suitability of those limitations in the context of the seriousness of the contraventions and the deterrence objectives of the disqualification order.