Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 5

Appeal from:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCA 1488

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd (No 3) [2022] FCA 3

File number(s): NSD 20 of 2022
Judgment of: RARES, STEWART AND ABRAHAM JJ
Date of judgment: 8 February 2023
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – appeal by regulator against civil penalty imposed by primary judge for manifest inadequacy – where penalty discretion miscarried and may be re-exercised by appellate court – where errors in findings of primary judge – where cases with comparative penalties relevant but not highly useful

COSTS – whether costs discretion miscarried – where primary judge ordered mostly successful party to pay half of unsuccessful party’s costs – where primary judge misapplied principle that successful party generally entitled to costs unless their conduct warrants otherwise – where exercise of discretion miscarried – where penalty hearing necessary – where regulator obtained imposition of penalty – where otherwise successful party unsuccessful on application for injunctive relief – where mostly successful party entitled to its costs subject to discount for failed application  

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 137H; Sch 2 ss 29, 34, 48 and 224

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43

Cases cited:

AB v The Queen [1999] HCA 46; (1999) 198 CLR 111

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2018] HCA 3; (2018) 262 CLR 157

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; (2022) 399 ALR 599

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cabcharge [2010] FCA 1261

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited [2015] FCA 330; (2015) 327 ALR 540

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCA 1488

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd (No 3) [2022] FCA 3

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd [2021] FCAFC 142; (2021) 392 ALR 205

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCAFC 157

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1409

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 797; (2019) 136 ACSR 603

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCA 102

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1844; (2007) ATPR 42-200

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Oticon Australia Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1826

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reckitt Benckiser (Australia) Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 181; (2016) 340 ALR 25

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Samsung Electronics Australia Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 875

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2010] FCA 790; 188 FCR 238

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Viagogo AG (No 3) [2020] FCA 1423

Australian Competition and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCAFC 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) sought an appeal against a penalty imposed on Employsure Pty Ltd for misleading advertising practices, particularly the use of keywords in online ads that falsely suggested government affiliation. The appeal was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary judge had found Employsure liable for misleading advertising and remitted the case for a new penalty hearing. The primary judge's penalty of $500,000 was deemed manifestly inadequate by the ACCC, prompting the appeal.

The primary legal issues addressed by the court involved the adequacy of the penalty imposed and the appropriateness of the costs order. The court had to consider whether the penalty was consistent with penalties imposed in comparable cases and whether the primary judge's discretion in awarding costs was correctly exercised. The court found that the penalty discretion had miscarried due to errors in the primary judge's findings and the inappropriate application of the principle that a mostly successful party should generally be entitled to its costs. The court observed that while penalties in comparable cases could provide guidance, each case must be decided on its own facts. The court also found that the primary judge misapplied the principle regarding costs, ordering the mostly successful party to pay half of the unsuccessful party’s costs, despite their success on the primary issues.

The court allowed the appeal against the penalty and costs orders. It set aside the penalty of $500,000 and imposed a penalty of $3 million, considering the misleading nature of the ads and the need for deterrence. The court also set aside the costs order and ordered Employsure to pay the ACCC’s costs of the remitted penalty hearing and the appeal, subject to a discount for the failed application for injunctive relief.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. Order 1 made by the primary judge in NSD 2384 of 2018 on 29 November 2021 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia within 30 days a pecuniary penalty of $3 million pursuant to s 224 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), contained in Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), in respect of the contraventions of the ACL identified in Order 1 made by the Full Court on 27 August 2021.

3. Order 3 made by the primary judge in NSD 2384 of 2018 on 11 January 2022 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the Respondent pay the Appellant’s costs of and incidental to the remitted penalty hearing to be taxed, if not agreed.

4. The Respondent pay the Appellant’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

These orders were made by the primary judge following remittal after an appeal on liability for the contraventions was upheld in favour of the ACCC: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd [2021] FCAFC 142; (2021) 392 ALR 205 (Employsure FC).Factual background In summary, as explained in Employsure FC at [1]-[2], Employsure is a specialist workplace relations consultancy which advises employers and business owners across Australia in relation to the requirements of workplace relations and workplace health and safety legislation. It is a private company which has no affiliation with, or endorsement by, any government agency. Through Google LLC, Employsure arranged the publication of online advertisements promoting its free employment-related advice service (Google Ads), which appeared on the screens of computers, tablets or smartphones in response to Google searches made by persons over the period from 10 August 2016 to 31 August 2018 (the relevant period). Employsure was aware that search terms such as “fair work commission”, “fair work Australia”, “fair work”, “fwc” and “fair work ombudsman” were frequently used by consumers seeking to visit the websites of major government agencies, namely the Fair Work Ombudsman and the Fair Work Commission. It selected those search terms as “keywords” in its search engine marketing strategy. Its use of such keywords meant that when a person making a Google search used search terms such as “fair work ombudsman”, “fair work Australia”, “fair work commission”, “Australia government fair work” or “Australia fair pay”, some of those terms appeared in the headline of the Google Ad. For example, when a person made a Google search using the term, “fair work ombudsman”, the headline of the Google Ad that appeared as the first search result said “Fair Work Ombudsman Help - Free 24/7 Employer Advice”. If users clicked on the hyperlink in the Google Ads they were taken to a landing webpage operated by Employsure, and if they telephoned the number provided in some of the Google Ads, they reached an Employsure representative. None of the Google Ads, however, made any mention of Employsure. The fact that Employsure arranged the publication of the Google Ads, the contents of the advertisements, and the context in which the advertisements appeared on the pages of search results, was not contentious. The target audience of the Google Ads was business owners who are employers and who searched for employment-related advice on the internet: Employsure FC at [129]. The class of persons who own businesses and have at least some employees encompasses a wide cross-section of the public, which includes a broad range of individuals running a vast range of businesses: Employsure FC at [133]-[135]. The relevant facts are outlined in Employsure FC at [8]-[63] and [67]-[71], with each Google Ad depicted, and are unnecessary to repeat here. We note that salient features of the advertisements and the context in which they appear is further summarised in Employsure FC at [152]-[159].Procedural history

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons below, the appeal against those two judgments is allowed. We consider the appeal against each judgment in turn.PENALTY JUDGMENT Summary The primary judge summarised the parties’ respective cases on remittal. A detailed summary of the ACCC’s case is at [4]-[45], and Employsure’s at [46]-[54] (in lesser detail). The ACCC sought a pecuniary penalty of $5 million, and Employsure submitted it should be in the range of $500,000-$750,000. The primary judge explained that he had substantially adopted Employsure’s submissions in rejecting the ACCC’s case: at [46]. The primary judge referred to the relevant provisions at [55], and thereafter at [56]-[74]. Given the submissions advanced on the appeal, it is appropriate to note that the primary judge addressed imposing penalties for multiple contraventions at [60]-[67], with the issue of what constitutes a course of conduct addressed at [63]-[64], and totality at [65]-[67]. The primary judge concluded that characterising Employsure’s contravening conduct as a single course of conduct conformed with the findings of the Full Court and his earlier undisturbed findings, the technical context, and the manner in which the ACCC pleaded and ran its case below: at [76]. The primary judge recorded the submission of the ACCC that the difference between the parties should not be overstated, because even if it is a single course of conduct, the penalty can exceed the maximum for an individual contravention, and the fewer courses of conduct, “the greater the diversity and the richness of the individual contraventions contained within it”: at [77]. His Honour reasoned at [80]: The Courts’ findings: The Full Court found, and declared, that each of the six Google Ads conveyed the same misleading representation of affiliation with, or endorsement by, a government agency: ACCC v Employsure (FFC No 1) at [175]-[179] and order 1 of 27 August 2021. That will not always be the case in proceedings brought under ss 18 and 29 of the ACL — different representations may exhibit different misleading characteristics. For example, in [Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v] Coles Supermarkets [Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 330; 327 ALR 540], a representation “Baked Today” was found to convey a temporal representation that was false; while the representation “Baked Fresh” (and cognates) conveyed a representation about ingredients that was false. Here, however, the six Google Ads were all published on the same medium and were found to convey the same representation, on the basis of the same statements and omissions, albeit with reference to three government agencies: ACCC v Employsure (FFC No 1) at [150]. The primary judge at [81]-[83] referred to three applications of the principles concerning whether a group of representations can constitute a single course of conduct (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 797; (2019) 136 ACSR 603; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Oticon Australia Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1826; and Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Viagogo AG (No 3) [2020] FCA 1423 (Viagogo)) before observing at [84] that “[w]hat each of these cases demonstrate is that analysis of the course of conduct principle is a very fact-specific exercise.” At [85], the primary judge concluded:In the present case, there is no significant legal or factual separation in the six Google Ads. Each conveys the Government Affiliation Representation, albeit by reference to three government agencies (and noting that two of those agencies were effectively the same, because Fair Work Australia was replaced by the FWC). Furthermore, all six Google Ads were published on the same medium (unlike the position in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pental Limited [2018] FCA 491 at [60]-[67] per Lee J or Viagogo AG at [120]-[122] per Burley J).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Penalties imposed in comparable cases may be of assistance and provide guidance in assessing the appropriateness of the penalty imposed (or to be imposed) as there should be some consistency in the penalties imposed as similar contraventions should incur similar penalties. The consistency sought is not numerical consistency, but rather consistent application of relevant legal principles: The Queen v Pham [2015] HCA 39; (2015) 256 CLR 550 (Pham) at [28] citing Hili at [49]. These concepts have resonance to the imposition of civil penalties: see for example, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cabcharge [2010] FCA 1261 at [54]; Flight Centre Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 2) [2018] FCAFC 53; (2018) 260 FCR 68at [63]; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2010] FCA 790; 188 FCR 238 at [215]; Viagogo at [128]; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Samsung Electronics Australia Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 875 at [54]; and Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCA 102 at [46]. Care must be taken when considering other penalties imposed. It must be recognised that the previous penalties imposed do not establish a range which is the correct range, or that the upper or lower limits to the range are the correct upper and lower limits: Hili at [54]. Each case must turn on its own facts, and any reference to comparable cases must encompass the particular circumstances in which the penalty was imposed.Consideration: did the penalty discretion miscarry?The importance of deterrence in this case As apparent from even the brief description of Employsure’s conduct provided above, it involved publication of six different Google Ads, involving three different governmental bodies. The Google Ads arose from three advertisement groups that were designed by Employsure with different features and were activated for publication across different periods of time. The six Google Ads would have displayed to different groups of consumers conducting certain searches (owing to the differing keywords underpinning the Google Ads), different messaging at different periods of time (owing to the different activation periods), and created a false perception of an association with different government agencies listed in the headlines, being, “Fair Work Ombudsman”, “Fair Work Commission” and “Fair Work Australia”. As explained above, the facts that Employsure arranged the publication of the Google Ads, the contents of the advertisements, and the context in which the advertisements appeared on the pages of search results, were not contentious. Employsure in evidence during the liability hearing recognised that “the higher a website features in the search result, the more likely it is that it will be selected by [the] consumer”. Each Google Ad appeared as the first result on the page of search results: Employsure FC at [168]. The features of each Google Ad, and the circumstances in which it appeared are summarised in Employsure FC at [49]-[63]. Each of the Google Ads was a paid search result, being an advertisement created by or at the direction of Employsure, using the platform provided by Google.