Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure Pty Ltd
[2020] FCA 1409

File number: NSD 2384 of 2018
Judge: GRIFFITHS J
Date of judgment: 1 October 2020
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – alleged contraventions of ss 18, 29(1)(b), 29(1)(h) and 34 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) – whether Employsure, a workplace relations consultancy, conveyed contravening representations in certain Google Ads that it was affiliated with and/or endorsed by a government agency such as the Fair Work Ombudsman or Fair Work Commission – whether Employsure’s use of keywords and the design of its Google Ads amounted to contravening conduct – whether Employsure’s representations that it provided a “free advice” telephone helpline amounted to contravening conduct – no contravention established

CONSUMER LAW – unconscionable conduct – whether Employsure engaged in conduct contrary to s 21 of the ACL with respect to its dealings with three small businesses – unconscionability claims rejected

CONSUMER LAW – unfair contract terms – whether certain clauses in Employsure’s standard form small business contract were unfair contract terms in contravention of ss 23 and 24 of the ACL – no unfair contract terms established

EVIDENCE – whether Jones v Dunkel principle triggered by Employsure’s failure to call witnesses – whether particular evidence should be accepted or inferences of fact drawn – Jones v Dunkel not applicable

Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), s 12CB(1)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 ss 18, 21, 23, 24, 29, 34

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51AB, 52, 53

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Accounts Control Management Services Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1164

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd(No 2) [2009] FCA 17; 253 ALR 324

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Ashley & Martin Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1436

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chrisco Hampers Australia Ltd [2015] FCA 1204; 239 FCR 33

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 634; 317 ALR 73

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v J J Richards & Sons Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1224

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lux Distributors Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 90

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Optell Pty ltd [1998] FCA 602

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Quantum Housing Group Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 802

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; 250 CLR 640

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v We Buy Houses Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 915

Australian Competition and Consumer Commissioner v Geowash Pty Ltd (subject to a deed of company arrangement) (No 3) [2019] FCA 72; 368 ALR 441

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2) [2017] FCA 709

Australian Securities & Investments Commission v National Exchange Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 226

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Employsure... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1409
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) commenced proceedings against Employsure Pty Ltd, a workplace relations consultancy, in the Federal Court, alleging various contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The ACCC claimed that Employsure contravened sections 18, 29(1)(b), 29(1)(h), and 34 of the ACL through representations in Google Ads suggesting affiliation or endorsement by government agencies such as the Fair Work Ombudsman or Fair Work Commission. Additionally, the ACCC argued that Employsure’s use of keywords, the design of its Google Ads, and representations that it provided a "free advice" telephone helpline amounted to contravening conduct. The ACCC further contended that Employsure engaged in unconscionable conduct with respect to its dealings with three small businesses and included unfair contract terms in its standard form small business contracts.

The court had to decide whether Employsure contravened the ACL through its representations, use of keywords, and design of Google Ads. The court also had to determine if Employsure engaged in unconscionable conduct with the three small businesses and whether certain clauses in its standard form small business contract were unfair contract terms. Moreover, the court considered whether the principle in Jones v Dunkel applied to Employsure’s failure to call witnesses and whether particular evidence should be accepted or inferences of fact drawn.

The court concluded that Employsure did not contravene the ACL through its Google Ads or telephone helpline representations. The court found no evidence that Employsure's conduct was misleading or deceptive, or that it engaged in unconscionable conduct. Regarding the contract terms, the court found that Employsure had demonstrated that the impugned clauses were necessary to protect its legitimate interests. The court also found that the terms were transparent, clearly disclosed, and expressed in plain English. Therefore, the ACCC's claims were dismissed, and the court tentatively indicated that costs should follow the event, pending further submissions from the parties on the issue of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The amended originating application be dismissed.

2. Within 21 days hereof, the parties are to seek to agree costs. If they are unable to reach such an agreement, within that time each should file and serve an outline of submissions on costs not exceeding three pages in length. Unless either of the parties can demonstrate the need for a further oral hearing, the issue of costs will be determined on the papers and without a further oral hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The ACCC claimed that, contrary to ss 23 and 24 of the ACL, Employsure included unfair contract terms in three versions of its standard form contract in the period from 12 November 2016 to October 2018. The terms related to the clauses of those contracts concerning no provision for early termination, unilateral price increases on automatic renewal and a penalty provision. PART B: AGREED FACTS RELATING TO THE OPERATION OF THE GOOGLE SEARCH ENGINE The parties were able to agree many facts relating to the operation of the Google search engine. Although the statement of agreed facts is lengthy, it is desirable to set it out in full (save for the single footnote and annexures) given the central significance of Google advertising in this proceeding. The statement of agreed facts is Annexure A to these reasons for judgment. PART C: THE EVIDENCE AND FINDINGS OF FACT The parties tendered a large volume of documentary evidence. The ACCC led evidence from several witnesses, including representatives of the three small businesses who had dealings with Employsure, which dealings underpinned the ACCC’s claims of unconscionability and unfair contract terms. Although Employsure filed affidavits from six witnesses, including several of its employees whose conduct lies at the heart of the ACCC’s claims, Employsure ultimately called only two witnesses. The first was Employsure’s chief executive officer, Mr Edmund Mallett. The other was Employsure’s finance director, Mr Steven Nicholson, who affirmed two affidavits. The ACCC contended that the principle in Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; 101 CLR 298 is triggered by Employsure’s failure to call the employees referred to at the beginning of [48] above. I will now summarise the parties’ evidence and state my relevant findings of fact. (a) The ACCC’s witnesses’ evidence summarised The ACCC’s witnesses were in two broad categories. The first category broadly relates to evidence which describes the steps taken to access copies of the Google Ads and other materials which are the subject of the ACCC’s claims. The ACCC also called a FWO employee, who described the services provided by that government agency. The second category comprises witnesses involved in the three small business operations who had dealings with Employsure. (i) Accessing the Google Ads Evidence was given by Mr Mark McCarthy, an ACCC senior investigation officer, as to how he “captured” various screenshots linked to Employsure’s marketing. Mr McCarthy’s evidence was uncontroversial and he was not required for cross-examination. I accept his evidence in its entirety. Similar evidence was given by Mr Sam Spirou, another ACCC senior investigator. Again, his evidence was uncontroversial and he was not required for cross-examination. I accept his evidence in its entirety. Similar evidence was given by another ACCC senior investigation officer, Ms Rachel Waye. Ms Waye described the steps she took to capture still images of search engine results and website screen captures. Her evidence was also uncontroversial and she was not required for cross-examination. I accept her evidence in its entirety.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Parkes described how in December 2013 the FWO launched a Small Business Helpline as an aspect of the Fair Work Infoline. It too is federally funded and provides free advice and assistance on matters such as wages, conditions of employment and termination of employment. I accept Ms Parkes’ evidence. (ii) The evidence of some small business owners and their dealings with Employsure It is convenient to summarise this evidence by reference to the three relevant small businesses.(A) Blue Print Painting (BPP) Ms Kerri-Ann Richardson was called as a witness by the ACCC. Like all the witnesses who were called to give evidence in the proceeding, Ms Richardson gave her evidence by video link. From 2013 to 2018, Ms Richardson was the owner of The Trustee for GKC Family Trust, trading as BPP, which ceased business in May 2018. Ms Richardson’s evidence in chief may be summarised as follows. BPP, which Ms Richardson established together with her husband in August 2013, operated a domestic and commercial painting business. At the relevant times, it had five employees. Ms Richardson had responsibility for staff payments, accounts and other administrative responsibilities. Prior to August 2015, Ms Richardson had called the FWO and the Department of Fair Trading on several occasions to inquire about pay rates or loadings. She estimated that she called those agencies approximately three times a year. She said that whenever she needed to call the FWO, she used Google to find a telephone number. Around 13 August 2015, Ms Richardson performed a Google search. She wanted to obtain information from the FWO regarding overtime payments. She had not heard of the business called Employsure and she did not use the word “Employsure” in her Google search. Under cross-examination Ms Richardson acknowledged that she could not recall the precise words she used in her Google search. They may have been any of “Fair Work Ombudsman”, “Department of Fair Trading”, “Fair Work” or “award wages”. She said that upon entering her Google search she either saw a phone number in the Google search results or found the phone number by clicking on one of the first search results displayed. In preparing her affidavit, Ms Richardson listened to an audio recording of the approximately 15 minute conversation she had with a man called Ross. She reiterated that she thought she was speaking to someone at the FWO and did not appreciate that she had actually called Employsure. The Employsure representative answered her call by saying “Fair Work help, Ross speaking”. At no time during the conversation did Ross tell her that he worked for Employsure. Ms Richardson asked Ross for advice regarding overtime payments, to which he replied by asking whether she had any agreements with her staff. When she said she did not, she recalled that “it made me feel as if I was doing something wrong that I wasn’t aware of – and that there was something I had to do”. She thought she was speaking to someone from the government who was telling her that that was something she needed or had to do.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For all these reasons, I find that the ACCC’s claim that each of the impugned terms is an unfair contract term has not been established. I find that Employsure has discharged its burden of demonstrating that each of the clauses was necessary to protect its legitimate interests. Moreover, in concluding that the terms were not unfair, I also take into account all the terms of the standard contract during the relevant period. Moreover, it is relevant that each of the impugned terms was undeniably transparent, in the sense that each was clearly disclosed in the contract under the heading “Further Terms”. None of the impugned terms would have caught any consumer by surprise, assuming that the consumer took the time properly to understand and reflect upon the provisions as they reasonably ought to have done prior to entering into a legally binding contract. It is also relevant to note that the impugned terms are expressed in plain English and no complaint is raised that they are incoherent or incomprehensible. PART E: CONCLUSION For these reasons, the amended originating application should be dismissed. The parties sought an opportunity to be heard on the question of costs after they had the opportunity to read these reasons for judgment. As matters stand at present, I can tentatively state that I see no reason why costs would not follow the event. In the absence of any material to the contrary, the Court should assume in the ACCC’s favour that it has acted consistently with its obligations as a model litigant. In particular, it should be assumed that the ACCC acted upon legal advice when it commenced these proceedings and that it considered, at that time, that it had reasonable prospects. In my view, however, the position changed during the course of the hearing. That is because, despite the searching cross-examinations of Mr Mallett and Mr Nicholson, both impressed the Court with their veracity and sound professional judgement. In contrast, the limitations of some of the evidence given by witnesses called by the ACCC in their capacity as representatives of the relevant small businesses was tellingly exposed in cross-examination. Without doubting the essential honesty of any of those witnesses, it was frequently apparent that each of them had only a patchy recollection of their dealings with Employsure. Putting to one side the audio recordings of relevant telephone conversations with Employsure’s representatives I have highlighted above, these witnesses’ recollections of face-to-face meetings with Employsure which were not recorded were not always reliable. These witnesses did not live up to the ACCC’s pre-hearing expectations. For completeness, I will not repeat what is set out above as to why I have rejected the ACCC’s reliance upon the principle in Jones v Dunkel in relation to Employsure’s failure to call representatives of the company who engaged with those small businesses. As requested, the parties will be given an opportunity to seek to agree orders for costs within 21 days hereof. If they fail to reach agreement, each should within that time file and serve an outline of submissions on costs no exceeding three pages in length. The issue of costs will then be determined on the papers and without a further oral hearing, unless either of the parties can demonstrate a need for such a hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established