Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Ashley & Martin Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Ashley & Martin Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1436

File number: WAD 606 of 2017
Judge: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 4 September 2019
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW - Australian Consumer Law s 24(1) - unfair contract terms - where consumers sign contract for medical hair loss treatment - whether terms are unfair if they have the effect that consumers agree to undertake and pay for medical treatment program prior to receipt of medical advice - where consumers who terminate obliged to pay termination fees - whether contract terms create a significant imbalance - whether terms reasonably necessary to protect legitimate interests of respondent - consideration of proportionality and available alternative methods of protecting interests in assessing whether terms reasonably necessary - whether terms would cause financial or non-financial detriment to consumers if relied upon

CONSUMER LAW - Australian Consumer Law s 26 - whether terms define main subject matter of contract - whether terms set the upfront price - whether general terms describing obligations under contracts quarantined by s 26 from assessment as to unfairness

Legislation:

Australian Securities And Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 12BI, 12CB, 12CC

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 23, 24, 25, 26, 239

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACN 117 372 915 Pty Ltd (in liq) (formerly Advanced Medical Institute Pty Ltd) [2015] FCA 368

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chrisco Hampers Australia Limited [2015] FCA 1204; (2015) 239 FCR 33

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CLA Trading Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 377; (2016) ATPR 42‑517

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Get Qualified Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2) [2017] FCA 709

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1224

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt [2019] HCA 18

Chappel v Hart [1998] HCA 55; (1998) 195 CLR 232

Director General of Fair Trading v First National Bank plc [2002] 1 AC 481

Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd v Free [2008] VSC 539

NRM Corporation Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2016] FCAFC 98

Office of Fair Trading v Abbey National plc [2010] 1 AC 696

Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2015] FCAFC 50

Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] HCA 28; (2016) 258 CLR 525

Re Elsmore Resources Ltd [2016] NSWSC 856

Rogers v Whitaker (1992) 175 CLR 479

Turner v MyBudget Pty Limited [2018] FCA 1407

Date of hearing: 4 October 2018
Date of last submissions: 14 November 2018 (Joint)
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 219
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr DJ Jackson SC with Ms KR Lendich
Solicitor for the Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr MD Howard SC with Mr WAS Keane
Solicitor for…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Ashley & Ma... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1436
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Ashley & Martin Pty Ltd, alleging that certain terms of contracts entered into by consumers for medical hair loss treatment were unfair under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The contracts required consumers to agree to undertake and pay for a medical treatment program prior to receiving medical advice, and consumers who terminated the contracts were obliged to pay termination fees. The Federal Court was required to determine whether these contract terms were unfair under s 24(1) of the ACL, and whether any such unfairness was mitigated by s 26 of the ACL, which exempts certain terms from review. The court had to consider whether the contract terms created a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations, whether they were reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of Ashley & Martin, and whether they would cause financial or non-financial detriment to consumers if relied upon. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the contract terms defined the main subject matter of the contract or set the upfront price, as these terms are quarantined by s 26 from assessment as to unfairness.

The court considered the nature of the contract terms, the imbalance they created, and whether they were reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of Ashley & Martin. The court found that the contract terms created a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations, as consumers were required to agree to undertake and pay for the medical treatment program before receiving medical advice. The court also found that the contract terms were not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of Ashley & Martin, as there were alternative methods of protecting their interests that would not cause such significant detriment to consumers. The court considered the proportionality of the contract terms and the availability of alternative methods of protecting the interests of Ashley & Martin. The court also found that the contract terms would cause financial or non-financial detriment to consumers if relied upon, as consumers were required to pay for the medical treatment program before receiving medical advice, and were obliged to pay termination fees if they terminated the contracts. The court further found that the contract terms did not define the main subject matter of the contract or set the upfront price, and were therefore not quarantined by s 26 from assessment as to unfairness.

The court found that the contract terms were unfair under s 24(1) of the ACL, and were not exempted from review by s 26 of the ACL. The court issued an injunction prohibiting Ashley & Martin from entering into or relying on the impugned contract terms, and ordered that Ashley & Martin take steps to give effect to the injunction. The court also ordered that the parties file a minute of proposed orders to program a further hearing to address relief, and that the parties be heard as to costs. The orders were to be entered in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days the parties are to file a minute of proposed orders to program a further hearing to address relief.

2. The parties be heard as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Table of Contents

Introduction

[1]

Some procedural matters

[7]

Relevant facts

[10]

Initial consultation

[11]

The consultation with an Ashley & Martin doctor

[15]

The products used in the Medical Treatment Program

[20]

The Contracts - overview

[22]

Pricing

[32]

Legislative regime

[33]

Principles

[43]

Section 24 - general

[43]

Section 24 - significant imbalance

[45]

Section 24 - Reasonably necessary to protect legitimate interest

[48]

Section 24 - detriment

[60]

Section 24(2) - consideration of the contract as a whole

[65]

Section 26

[69]

Ashley & Martin's overarching 'no obligation' and 'supply term' submissions

[87]

The First Contract

[93]

First page acknowledgment

[94]

Terms and Conditions

[97]

Medical Treatment Program

[98]

Order, delivery and payment

[104]

Refunds/substitutions

[107]

Termination

[110]

Are the terms in any event excluded from review

[118]

Are the terms of the First Contract unfair (s 24 definition)

[128]

'No obligation' submission

[129]

The elements of unfairness

[137]

Significant imbalance

[138]

Reasonably necessary to protect legitimate interests

[161]

Detriment

[173]

The Second Contract

[183]

Are the terms excluded from review

[195]

Are the terms unfair

[197]

The Third Contract

[203]

Objections

[214]

Outcome

[216]

Annexure A

Annexure B

Annexure C

Annexure D

Background

Background to the litigation

After the hearing Ashley & Martin provided an 'aide memoire' that compiled information as to the sums that might be paid by patients upon termination of the contracts in various scenarios based on the retail ('standard') cost of products to be supplied under the contracts. The information was checked and agreed by the parties. I have accepted the aide memoire as a submission.Relevant facts The following is based primarily on the statement of agreed facts.Initial consultation When a patient first approaches Ashley & Martin for treatment, the patient will speak to a receptionist by telephone and/or email a request for a consultation. That contact results in an appointment for the patient to see a 'hair loss consultant' for 60 minutes. Ashley & Martin then sends the patient an email to confirm the appointment. This appointment is known as the 'initial consultation'. The confirmatory email informs patients of the option to enrol on the day of the initial consultation and advises them to come to the initial consultation 'financially prepared'. It also appears from the annexures to the statement of agreed facts that an initial email is sent when an appointment is requested that states in two places that the first consultation is free. Hair loss consultants are not medical doctors or otherwise healthcare professionals. They are trained by Ashley & Martin's medical director on how Ashley & Martin wishes them to conduct the initial consultation. At the initial consultation the patient fills out a questionnaire and a checklist. The questionnaire includes questions about the reason for seeking treatment and the patient's medical history. The checklist requires a yes/no answer to a number of questions, including 'Do you understand what is involved with your program?', 'Have you been informed about our Maintenance program and the associated costs?' and 'Have you read, signed and received the Terms & Conditions?'. If the patient wishes to proceed with a Medical Treatment Program, the Ashley & Martin consultant completes the first page of the contract in front of the patient and the patient and the consultant sign the contract. Most patients who signed a contract did so at the initial consultation. These patients were usually provided with non-prescription goods - such as shampoos, conditioners, herbal supplements and multivitamins - at the initial consultation. They were provided with the quantity of the non-prescription goods that Ashley & Martin estimated they would require for the whole term of their Medical Treatment Program.The consultation with an Ashley & Martin doctor Generally at the initial consultation an appointment is made for the patient to see a medical doctor engaged by the respondent as an independent contractor. These doctors are referred to generally in communications as Ashley & Martin doctors. At the medical appointment an Ashley & Martin doctor meets with the patient for the first time. Ashley & Martin provides a protocol letter to the Ashley & Martin doctor that sets out its requirements and procedures for the contracted doctors. The information that the doctor must discuss under the protocol letter includes the risks to the patients of undertaking the Medical Treatment Program. Sample protocol letters were included in the tender bundle.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As the definition makes express, detriment may also be non‑financial.Section 24(2) - consideration of the contract as a whole Section 24(2) expressly provides that in assessing whether a term is unfair under s 24(1) the Court may take into account such matters as it considers relevant, but it must take into account the extent to which the terms are transparent and the contract as a whole. The meaning of 'transparent' is defined and self‑explanatory. As to having regard to the contract as a whole, it is in any event clear that an impugned term cannot be assessed in a vacuum which ignores the practical considerations which attach to the carrying out of contractual obligations: Turner v MyBudget Pty Limited [2018] FCA 1407 at [69]. It is appropriate to consider how impugned terms interact or how non-impugned terms might ameliorate the impact of the impugned terms: JJ Richards at [61], [63]. If terms were considered in isolation, then the purpose of s 23 might be defeated by the careful drafting of individual terms that might not be unfair alone but are unfair when read together. This provision has practical importance in this case where a number of different terms are impugned.Section 26 As to s 26, it appears the court has not yet had occasion to rule on its scope. An analogous provision in s 12BI(2) of the ASIC Act also has not been the subject of determination. As to 'the main subject matter of the contract', the Explanatory Memorandum states:[5.59]The exclusion of terms that define the main subject matter of a consumer contract ensures that a party cannot challenge a term concerning the basis for the existence of the contract.[5.60]Where a party has decided to purchase the goods, services, land, financial services or financial products that are the subject of the contract, that party cannot then challenge the fairness of a term relating to the main subject matter of the contract at a later stage, given that the party had a choice of whether or not to make the purchase on the basis of what was offered.[5.61]The main subject matter of the contract may include the decision to purchase a particular type of good, service, financial service or financial product, or a particular piece of land. It may also encompass a term that is necessary to give effect to the supply or grant, or without which, the supply or grant could not occur. Therefore, s 26(1)(a) implies that a distinction can be drawn between terms that define the main subject matter of the contract and other terms. As to 'the upfront price', the Explanatory Memorandum states:5.63 Consideration includes any amount or thing provided as consideration for the supply of a good, service, financial service, financial product or a grant of land. It would also include any interest payable under a consumer contract.5.64 The exclusion of upfront price means that a term concerning the upfront price cannot be challenged on the basis that it is unfair. Having agreed to provide a particular amount of consideration when the contract was made, which was disclosed at or before the time the contract was entered into, a person cannot then argue that that consideration is unfair at a later time. The upfront price is a matter about which the person has a choice and, in many cases, may negotiate.5.65 The upfront price covers the cash price payable for a good, service, financial service, financial product or land at the time the contract is made. It also covers a future payment or a series of future payments.…5.67 A key consideration for a court in considering whether a future payment, or a series of future payments, forms the upfront price may be the transparency of the disclosure of such a payment, or the basis on which such payments may be determined, at or before the time the contract is made.…5.69 Other consideration (that is, further forms of consideration which are not part of the upfront price) under the consumer contract that is contingent on the occurrence or non‑occurrence of a particular event, is excluded from the determination of the upfront price.5.70 Terms that require further payments levied as a consequence of something happening or not happening at some point in the duration of the contract are covered by the unfair contract terms provisions. Such payments are additional to the upfront price, and are not necessary for the provision of the basic supply, sale or grant under the contract.