FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NRM Corporation Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2016] FCAFC 98
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read NRM Corporation Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consume... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FCAFC 98
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the primary Judge did not err in making findings outside the scope of the pleadings as the issues canvassed at the hearing were sufficiently broad to encompass the matters decided by the primary Judge. It was also determined that the primary Judge's findings regarding the lack of clinical evidence supporting the efficacy of the medications were supported by the evidence presented. The court emphasised the importance of viewing the findings in their full context rather than in isolation. Regarding the remuneration of salespeople and the use of high-pressure sales techniques, the court held that the findings were adequately supported by the evidence and were integral to the primary Judge's reasoning on unconscionability. The court was satisfied that the primary Judge's conclusions were properly drawn from the evidence and that there was no error in the findings that led to the ultimate conclusion of unconscionability.
The appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs. The court's decision reinforced the importance of transparency in business practices and the need for businesses to avoid exploiting the vulnerability of consumers, particularly when it comes to health-related services and products.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The Appellants are to pay the costs of the Respondent.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Ground 10 makes reference to para [905] of the reasons for decision of the primary Judge, which states as follows:[905] The failure to disclose the basis of the remuneration of salespeople was dishonest and exploitative, it was sharp practice and deceptive, particularly in the circumstances when men believed they were consulting a medical practice which characteristically make patient welfare a primary concern. It was an unfair tactic, which is a possible marker of unconscionable conduct referred to in s 51AB(2)(d) of the TPA, s 21(2)(d) of the ACL operating between 1 January 2011 and 1 January 2012, and s 22(1)(d) of the ACL in operation after 1 January 2012.This conclusion follows para [903], which states as follows:7.2.3 Remuneration of salespeople by commission[903] The salespeople were told by AMI and NRM in scripts and training materials not to disclose to patients that they were paid by commission. Payment by commission meant that the salespeople had an interest in selling higher priced programs. Had they disclosed that they were paid on commission, patients may have been alerted to the interest of the salespeople in selling higher priced programs. It may also have alerted patients to the fact that they were not consulting a traditional medical practice. The written submissions filed on behalf of the Appellants contend that the “implicit finding” in para [903], that patients were unaware that they were not consulting a “traditional medical practice”, was speculative. The submissions further state that none of the lay witnesses called by the ACCC gave evidence that they understood NRM to be “a traditional medical practice”. The difficulty confronted by this Ground is that it matters not what the expectations of the patients were when they consulted AMI or NRM. That which is of relevance is not their expectations but rather the fact that the salespeople failed to disclose the basis of their remuneration. There was no error in the finding of fact that the salespersons failed to disclose the basis of their remuneration. It was that failure to disclose which was central to the reasoning of the primary Judge at para [905] that patients were otherwise to assume that their welfare was the primary concern of the AMI and NRM practices. Ground 10 of the Further Amended Notice of Appeal is rejected. To the extent that Ground 10 seeks to challenge the findings of the primary Judge that the failure to disclose was “dishonest and exploitative”, and hence a step in the primary Judge’s reasoning to an ultimate finding of unconscionability, Ground 10 cannot be divorced from Grounds 11 and 12. High pressure sales techniques – Grounds 11 & 12 Grounds 11 and 12 of the Further Amended Notice of Appeal challenge the findings of the primary Judge in respect to the “high-pressure sales techniques” used by the salespeople. The findings made included the following: 7.2.2 High-pressure sales techniques[893] AMI and NRM salespeople were trained to use high-pressure sales techniques to sell the treatment programs. They were instructed in methods which were likely to frighten men into agreeing to the treatments offered by AMI and NRM.[894] The salespeople were trained to tell men that if they did not agree to treatment, they would suffer adverse medical consequences, including shrinkage of the penis and psychological impotence. There was no scientific basis established before the court for these claims. The salespeople were instructed to say that the treatment for ED would reduce the chance of heart attack or stroke. They were also instructed to inform patients that their partners may suffer from depression if they did not take the treatments. The threat of dire medical and social consequences placed pressure on men to accept the treatments.[895] The salespeople also told men that the medications would be effective not just to treat, but to cure their problems. This offered a further inducement to agree to treatment. And the men were reassured that if the treatment did not work they would be entitled to a refund.[896] This technique of selling was prone to rob men of independent judgement of the need for, and value of, the treatment, and induce them to enter into agreements which they would not otherwise have accepted if the pressure had not been applied.[897] The technique of frightening men by telling them of the dire adverse consequences of not agreeing to treatment and assuring them that the treatment was effective was part of the business system of AMI and NRM. It was formulated by management and imparted in an organised fashion through scripts and training sessions.The importance of these findings is that they form part of the reasoning later embraced by the primary Judge in reaching his conclusion as to unconscionability in para [939] of his reasons for decision. It is the finding at para [893] which is expressly the subject of challenge in Ground 11 of the Further Amended Notice of Appeal.