ACCC v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allphones Retail Pty Limited (No 3) [2009] FCA 1075

EVIDENCE – whether the Court should exercise its discretion pursuant to s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) to rule on the admissibility of evidence in advance of that evidence being adduced – ruling made

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission should be released from the implied undertaking attributed to it in respect of documents produced using the compulsory processes of the Court – three sets of proceedings to be heard together – leave granted to use documents in all three actions

PRIVILEGE – whether investigative accountant’s reports and associated calculations prepared for settlement negotiations and a mediation are protected from being adduced in evidence by s 131(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – meaning of expression “in connection with” in s 131(1) – documents prepared for the purposes of settlement are protected – documents ruled inadmissible

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss 69, 76, 79, 131, 192A
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 51AC, 51AD, 52, 80, 87(1B), 155AAA

Allphones Retail Pty Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2009] FCA 980 cited
Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd(No 2) (2008) ATPR 42-240 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd(No 2) (2009) 253 ALR 324, [2009] ATPR 42-274 cited
Bailey v Beagle Management Pty Limited [2001] FCA 185 cited
Brown v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2002) 119 FCR 269 cited
CJ Redman Constructions Pty Ltd v Tarnap Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 173 followed
Commissioner of Australian Federal Police v Propend Finance Pty Ltd (1997) 188 CLR 501 cited and distinguished
Field v Commissioner for Railways for NSW (1957) 99 CLR 285 followed
Harman v Home Department State Secretary [1983] 1 AC 280 cited
Hearne v Street (2008) 235 CLR 125 cited
Korean Air Lines v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 3) (2008) 247 ALR 781 followed
Rabin v Mendoza & Co [1954] 1 All ER 247, [1954] 1 WLR 271 cited
Ringrow Pty Ltd v BP Australia Ltd (2003) 130 FCR 569 cited

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v ALLPHONES RETAIL PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 168 090), MATTHEW DONNELLAN, IAN HARKIN and ANTHONY BAKER

NSD 408 of 2008
NSD 869 of 2009

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v ALLPHONES RETAIL PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 168 090)

NSD 1567 of 2008

FOSTER J
23 SEPTEMBER 2009
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 408 of 2008

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

ALLPHONES RETAIL PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 168 090)
First Respondent

MATTHEW DONNELLAN
Second Respondent

IAN HARKIN
Third Respondent

ANTHONY BAKER
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 SEPTEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT:

1.Pursuant to s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), rules that:

(a)The two investigative accountant’s reports prepared by BDO Kendalls Corporate Finance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ACCC v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1075
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of ACCC v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 3), the primary issue was whether three specific documents—two BDO reports and a Supporting Calculations Document—were admissible as evidence in the proceedings NSD 408 of 2008, NSD 1567 of 2008, and NSD 869 of 2009. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) sought a preliminary ruling on the admissibility of these documents, while Allphones argued that the documents should be excluded on the grounds that they were not business records and that their tender was prohibited by section 131 of the Evidence Act. Furthermore, Allphones contended that the documents were subject to an implied undertaking as to their use and that the ACCC should be released from such an undertaking.

The court considered the arguments from both parties and evaluated the nature and purpose of the documents in question. It noted that the ACCC intended to use the copies of the documents provided to it by Allphones, rather than the originals. The court highlighted that the first BDO report, which contained conclusions by an expert accountant regarding levies, fines, and charges, was admissible as an exception to the opinion rule under the Evidence Act, provided the author or authors were called to testify. However, the court ruled that the second BDO report and the Supporting Calculations Document were not admissible at that stage. The court also ruled that the first BDO report, the second BDO report, and the Supporting Calculations Document were not admissible in evidence at that time, but granted the ACCC leave to use the documents for the purposes of all three sets of proceedings. The court clarified that its rulings applied to the admissibility of the documents at that time only, leaving open the possibility that they might be admissible at a future time under different circumstances.

The court concluded by granting the ACCC leave to use the specified documents in the proceedings, while Allphones substantially succeeded in resisting the ACCC's application for a preliminary ruling on admissibility. The court ordered that the ACCC pay Allphones' costs of and incidental to the present applications. The decision underscored the importance of evaluating the admissibility of documents on a case-by-case basis, considering both the specific circumstances of the case and the legal provisions governing evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. To the extent that the leave of the Court may be necessary, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission have leave to use for the purposes of proceedings NSD 408 of 2008, NSD 1567 of 2008 and NSD 869 of 2009, both of the said investigative accountant’s reports, the Supporting Calculations Document, all documents recording communications between Allphones and BDO relating to the said reports and the Supporting Calculations Document and all of BDO’s working papers relating to the preparation of the said reports and the Supporting Calculations Document, when produced.

3. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission pay the costs of Allphones of and incidental to the applications determined by Reasons for Judgment published today (23 September 2009).

Note:

2. To the extent that the leave of the Court may be necessary, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission have leave to use for the purposes of proceedings NSD 408 of 2008, NSD 1567 of 2008 and NSD 869 of 2009, both of the said investigative accountant’s reports, the Supporting Calculations Document, all documents recording communications between Allphones and BDO relating to the said reports and the Supporting Calculations Document and all of BDO’s working papers relating to the preparation of the said reports and the Supporting Calculations Document, when produced.

3. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission pay the costs of Allphones of and incidental to the applications determined by Reasons for Judgment published today (23 September 2009).

Background

Background to the litigation

These Reasons for Judgment address and determine whether Allphones’ resistance to an order ruling that the three documents in question are admissible on the grounds that, in any event, they are not business records and that the tender is prohibited by s 131 of the Evidence Act, should be upheld at this point in time. I will also deal with the question of whether the documents described in proposed Order 1 are subject to any implied undertaking as to their use and, if so, whether the ACCC should be released from that undertaking. THE FACTS In Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd(No 2) 253 ALR 324, [2009] ATPR 42-274, I dealt with an application for interlocutory injunctive relief made by the ACCC against Allphones in proceedings NSD 1567 of 2008. At [32]–[58] of that judgment, I described certain events leading up to the service of the Notice of Dispute. That description was based upon the evidence before me for the purposes of the application with which I was then dealing and, to some extent, may be controversial. But, allowing for these limitations, the description which I gave in those paragraphs of that judgment is a useful starting point for placing the Notice of Dispute into an appropriate context. Accordingly, I incorporate those paragraphs into these Reasons in order to provide some detail of the context in which the Notice of Dispute came to be issued. The Notice of Dispute was issued pursuant to the Franchising Code of Conduct and the contractual arrangements then in existence between Allphones and the franchisees upon whom it was served (the eligible franchisees). It was served upon all of Allphones existing franchisees who were not operating under its new Franchise Agreement or who had not released Allphones from past breaches of its old Franchise Agreement. The sending of the Notice of Dispute commenced a dispute resolution process in accordance with the provisions of the Franchising Code of Conduct and the contractual arrangements between Allphones and the eligible franchisees. The dispute resolution process commenced in this fashion was, if necessary, intended to culminate in a mediation. In the Notice of Dispute, Allphones raised ten issues to be addressed by negotiation and mediation with the eligible franchisees. The main issues may be conveniently grouped into four broad categories:(a)Whether Allphones was entitled to levy certain charges against its franchisees for services and/or capital improvements said to have been carried out by Allphones in the interests of the group generally;(b)Whether Allphones was entitled to levy penalties against its franchisees for non-compliance with the Franchise Agreement; (c)Whether Allphones had appropriately shared with its franchisees bonuses, rebates and other payments which it had received from telecommunications carriers and equipment suppliers; and(d)Whether Allphones had unjustifiably imposed Stock Hold or Commission Hold on certain of its franchisees.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The three sets of proceedings have been fixed for hearing together to commence on 23 March 2010. They are to be heard at the same time. The evidence in each set of proceedings is likely to be evidence in each of the others. To give an evidentiary ruling of the kind sought by the ACCC so far in advance of the trial would be unusual. There may be sound discretionary reasons for the Court declining to entertain the application even though it clearly has the power to make an order of the kind sought here (see s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (the Evidence Act). However, in the present case, a considerable amount of time, effort and money might be saved if the documents were ruled to be admissible now. After all, the documents were prepared on the instructions of Allphones and on the basis of information and documents provided by Allphones to BDO. They have been provided to franchisees with whom Allphones is in dispute and to the ACCC on the basis that the conclusions stated by BDO in the reports are correct and that the calculations made by BDO in the reports and in the Supporting Calculations Document are also correct. No suggestion has been made by Allphones at any time that the reports or the Supporting Calculations Document need to be qualified in any way. There is an air of unreality about Allphones’ resistance to the documents being ruled as admissible. The objections taken by Allphones to the making of proposed Order 2 are that the three documents in question cannot be tendered because to tender them would be to adduce evidence of settlement negotiations which, in the circumstances of the present case, is prohibited by s 131(1) of the Evidence Act and that, in any event, those documents are not business records within s 69 of the Evidence Act. There may be additional particular objections to parts of those documents which Allphones might also wish to take but these were not identified or argued in the present application. These Reasons for Judgment address and determine whether Allphones’ resistance to an order ruling that the three documents in question are admissible on the grounds that, in any event, they are not business records and that the tender is prohibited by s 131 of the Evidence Act, should be upheld at this point in time. I will also deal with the question of whether the documents described in proposed Order 1 are subject to any implied undertaking as to their use and, if so, whether the ACCC should be released from that undertaking. THE FACTS In Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd(No 2) 253 ALR 324, [2009] ATPR 42-274, I dealt with an application for interlocutory injunctive relief made by the ACCC against Allphones in proceedings NSD 1567 of 2008. At [32]–[58] of that judgment, I described certain events leading up to the service of the Notice of Dispute. That description was based upon the evidence before me for the purposes of the application with which I was then dealing and, to some extent, may be controversial. But, allowing for these limitations, the description which I gave in those paragraphs of that judgment is a useful starting point for placing the Notice of Dispute into an appropriate context. Accordingly, I incorporate those paragraphs into these Reasons in order to provide some detail of the context in which the Notice of Dispute came to be issued.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FOSTER J
I am conscious of the fact that I have ruled that the second BDO report and the Supporting Calculations Document are not admissible in any of the three sets of proceedings at this stage. However, my rulings in that regard addressed a different question from the present question. There are uses to which these documents may legitimately be put which are not prevented by my rulings in respect of their tender and admissibility at the present time. Those rulings do not constrain those uses. CONCLUSIONS For the above reasons, I rule that the first BDO report, the second BDO report and the Supporting Calculations Document are not admissible in evidence at this time. To the extent necessary, I grant leave to the ACCC to use the documents listed in proposed Order 1 for the purposes of all three sets of proceedings. I wish to make clear that the rulings which I have made apply to the admissibility of these documents at this time, and at this time only. Should a tender of any of these documents be made at some future time, that tender will need to be considered on its merits at that time. For example, Allphones may reconsider its attitude to the tender of these documents or there may be circumstances in play which are sufficiently different from those which were considered in the present application which nonetheless make the documents admissible at that future time.COSTS Allphones has substantially succeeded in resisting the making of the orders sought by the ACCC. I think that costs should follow the event and that the ACCC should pay Allphones’ costs of and incidental to the present applications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FOSTER J

Subsequently, the parties have been unable to reach any agreement as to the use that may be made of the contentious documents in the three sets of proceedings to which I have referred at [1] and [7] above. At one point, Allphones hinted that it may be prepared to allow the two BDO reports to be tendered by the ACCC in the proceedings. However, it made no firm commitment about this. CONSIDERATION AND DECISIONThe Admissibility RulingThe Parties’ Submissions The ACCC has applied for a preliminary ruling in advance of the trial as to the admissibility of three documents: the two BDO reports and the Supporting Calculations Document. The ACCC has not called the authors of the documents to give evidence in support of the orders which it seeks. The ACCC submitted that all of the documents are business records of Allphones and also of BDO and, accordingly, are admissible under s 69 of the Evidence Act. It also submitted that Allphones has failed to prove that any of the three documents fell within either subs (1)(a) or sub s(1)(b) of s 131 of the Evidence Act. All three documents were said to be admissible. It was said that there is no need for the ACCC to establish any of the exceptions dealt with in s 131(2). By way of further explanation of these submissions, the ACCC contended that:(a)For a communication or a document to have the necessary connection with the postulated dispute, the substantial or dominant purpose for the making of the communication or the creation of the document must be an attempt to settle an identified dispute. Attempting to settle that dispute cannot be an incidental or secondary reason or one of several primary reasons for the making of the communication or the creation of the document; and(b)That purpose must be discerned in respect of the documents provided to the ACCC by Allphones. That is to say, the ACCC intends to tender the particular copy of each of the three documents in question which was provided to it by Allphones via Phillips Fox (not the originals of those documents). The admissibility ruling which it seeks relates to the copies only. Allphones challenged all of these submissions. In particular, Senior Counsel for Allphones submitted that Allphones had proven the facts necessary to engage subs (1) of s 131 of the Evidence Act and that the ACCC had failed to bring the case within any of the exceptions found in subs (2) of s 131. He also submitted that the documents in question were not business records.The First BDO Report It is clear from the ACCC’s submissions that it seeks a ruling in respect of the copy of the first BDO report sent to it on 26 September 2008 (not the original). The first BDO report is a report in which the expert accountant retained by Allphones expresses certain conclusions as to the quantum of levies, fines and charges debited to franchisees over various periods between 1 January 2005 and September 2008. The evidence of an expert accountant in relation to matters within that person’s expertise is admissible as an exception to the opinion rule under the Evidence Act (as to which see s 76 and s 79). To be admissible on this basis, the author or authors of the report would need to be called in order to prove the report. The report does not prove itself. The expert opinions expressed by the author or authors are based upon analyses of Allphones’ primary records and upon other assumptions, none of which have yet been proven. The conclusions expressed in the report were heavily qualified (as to which see s 5 of the report).