Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 2)
[2008] FCA 810

TRADE AND COMMERCE – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and related legislation – Trade Practices (Industry Codes – Franchising) Regulations 1998 (Cth) – Franchising Code of Conduct – consequences of franchisor’s failure to comply with cll 10 and 11 of Code – whether franchisor’s non-compliance made franchise agreement void – whether decision in Ketchell v Master of Education Services Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 161 should be followed – purpose of Code – need to seek guidance from implications in legislative framework

Held:  Franchising Code of Conduct does not evince legislative policy of striking down every franchise agreement entered into by franchisor who fails to comply with its provisions – intention of code is to protect franchisees and place obligations on franchisor to comply – failure of franchisor to comply entitles franchisee to seek to set aside agreement or to seek relief for unconscionable conduct

CONTRACT – fraud – when each party is in breach of an essential term or has conducted itself in a manner amounting to a repudiation – whether one party may terminate based on other’s breach or repudiation – whether one party may terminate under express contractual right to do so when other party has committed fraud – whether party must be ready and willing before being entitled to terminate

Held:  When each party is in breach of an essential term or has conducted itself in a manner amounting to a repudiation, neither is ready and willing to perform;  neither may terminate at common law or pursuant to a contractual term:  Foran v Wight (1989) 168 CLR 385 considered

CONTRACT – general contractual principles – construction and interpretation of contracts – ambiguity in written provision regarding exclusive territory – relevance of pre-contractual discussions – conflicting evidence given by both parties – neither party’s evidence believed – interpretation of common intention of parties – consideration of what each party, by words or conduct, would have led a reasonable person in position of other party to believe – consideration of surrounding circumstances known to parties and purpose and object of transaction – natural and common sense approach to construction – necessity to construe agreement so as to avoid commercial inconvenience

Held:  Ambiguous provision to be interpreted by reference to objective common intention of parties based on reasonable person’s understanding in circumstances of case

CONTRACT – Fraud by franchisee – whether franchisor elected to affirm franchise agreement by its words or conduct – principles of election – whether franchisor confronted with two mutually exclusive courses of action necessitating a choice – whether franchisor communicated election to franchisee – whether reasonable person in franchisee’s position would have understood franchisor’s conduct to amount to affirmation of contract

Held:  Franchisor had not elected to affirm the contract – parties understood that franchisor would refrain from terminating for fraud until franchisee given opportunity to respond

CONTRACT – general implication that parties contract to do all that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 810
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hoy Mobile Pty Ltd v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 2) involved a dispute between Hoy Mobile and Allphones Retail over the terms of a franchise agreement. The primary issues in the case were the determination of the territory granted to Hoy Mobile, the obligations of Allphones under the franchise agreement, and the consequences of Hoy Mobile's fraudulent conduct. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The key legal issues before the court included whether Allphones was entitled to terminate the franchise agreement due to Hoy Mobile's fraudulent conduct, and if so, whether Allphones could rely on that fraud to effect the termination. The court also had to determine the extent of Hoy Mobile's fraudulent activities and whether Allphones had breached the franchise agreement by not paying commissions as required. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether Allphones' failure to disclose certain information in its disclosure documents constituted a breach of the Franchising Code of Conduct.

The court found that the territory granted to Hoy Mobile was limited to the suburb of Eastgardens. It concluded that Allphones was obliged to pay Hoy Mobile commissions on all sums received from carriers in respect of sales and activations of plans effected by Hoy Mobile. The court also determined that Allphones' failure to comply with certain provisions of the Franchising Code of Conduct before entering into the franchise agreement did not render the agreement void. However, the court found that Hoy Mobile had engaged in fraudulent conduct in connection with the operation of the franchise business. Despite this, the court held that Allphones was not entitled to terminate the franchise agreement because it had not been ready and willing to perform due to its own breaches and dishonest conduct. The court further found that Allphones had not established that a certain charge it imposed on Hoy Mobile was reasonable.

The court ordered that Allphones must pay Hoy Mobile for its breaches of the franchise agreement. In the event that the parties could not agree on the formulation of the final orders, each party was required to prepare its own draft of the orders. The court scheduled a re-listing of the matter to allow for further argument on the final orders. The parties were directed to serve their respective draft orders and written submissions on costs by specific dates, with the final orders to be argued on a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 3 June 2008, the applicant file and serve its draft of orders to give effect to these reasons, together with supporting schedules for the amounts of damages and interest, and its written submissions in respect of costs.

2. On or before 5 June 2008, the respondent file and serve its response to the applicant’s draft orders, together with its written submissions in respect of any areas of disagreement.

3. On or before 6 June 2008, the applicant file and serve any submissions in reply.

4. The proceedings be stood over, for argument as to the making of final orders, to 9.30 am on 10 June 2008.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Hoy had a significant self-interest in the outcome of these proceedings. The radius of 5 km from the Eastgardens store sufficed to provide Hoy Mobile with a territory large enough to include Randwick, where Allphones had opened a store in late 2005. Yet only in May 2006, some time after that event occurred, did Mr Hoy make any assertion that the territory was 5 km. I do not accept Mr Hoy’s evidence on the discussions concerning territory.3.2 Allphones’ evidence regarding territory In his examination-in-chief, Mr Donnellan asserted that in late 2002, Allphones had a policy amounting to a ‘strict prohibition on granting exclusive territories other than the lease line of the shop in which they were going to become a franchisee’. He asserted that the 2002 version of Allphones’ disclosure document said that an Allphones’ territory for its franchisees was a ‘non-exclusive territory’. He said that the 2002 disclosure document had not been able to be located and had not been saved. At the time of his negotiations with Mr Hoy in 2002, Mr Donnellan knew that Allphones had only five franchises in New South Wales. Mr Donnellan had negotiated the sale of the franchise to China Lake in 2002. He also negotiated the grant of a franchise, commencing on 1 June 2002, of a shop in Wollongong Central Shopping Centre. The franchisee agreement for that shop had a description of territory in the schedule of ‘Wollongong, NSW’. That franchise agreement had an area of restraint that conformed with the area of the territory it had granted, namely Wollongong, NSW. Subsequently, in cross-examination, Mr Donnellan was shown an Allphones franchise agreement entered into on 17 April 2003 for a franchise business in Shellharbour Square commencing on 10 July 2003 (i.e. around the time at which the negotiations with Mr Hoy were finalised). There, the territory was ‘[a]s per marked section on the attached map’, but no such map was in evidence. The area of restraint, curiously, was a 25 km radius from the GPO. Mr Donnellan said that he did not negotiate the grant of the Shellharbour franchise. After he had been shown these other three agreements made in 2002 and 2003, Mr Donnellan admitted that there was no policy or strict prohibition on the grant of franchised territories beyond the leased shop premises when he had his conversations with Mr Hoy in 2002. Mr Donnellan claimed that before he gave his evidence he had not looked at franchise agreements from 2002 but he said he had looked at franchise agreements from 2003. I do not believe that evidence either. Mr Donnellan was conscious at this point in his cross-examination that he had previously made an assertion of a strict policy in 2002 which, by that stage, had been shown to be false. Next, he agreed that he had not mentioned to Mr Hoy that there was any strict prohibition on the grant of franchised territories larger than the leased shop premises in any of his 2002 conversations. He was then asked:‘You had no further discussion with him about territory prior to signing the franchise agreement in 2003, did you? --- We did have one general discussion, yes.On the subject of territory? --- Yes.Why have you never mentioned that until just now? --- I did in my affidavit.Where is that in your affidavit? --- I denied the conversation that Craig [Hoy] said in his.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

RARES J
I am of opinion that Allphones should be restrained under s 87 of the Trade Practices Act from relying on the fraud of Hoy Mobile effect a termination of the franchise agreement.34. CONCLUSION The appropriate course is to require the parties to agree upon orders to give effect to these reasons. The orders should also provide for the amount of the damages to be awarded for the breaches of contract that I have found, less the amount of profit that I have found Hoy Mobile to have retained. Interest will need to be added. The interest on Hoy Mobile’s receipts from its fraudulent trading should offset some of that due by Allphones. It may not be possible to be mathematically exact, and the parties may need to adopt a practical position of halving each year’s interest in respect of the new amount for that year to approximate its progressive accrual over that period. And the parties will need to address the question of costs. To summarise, I have found that:1.The territory granted to Hoy Mobile in the franchise agreement was the suburb of Eastgardens.2.Allphones was obliged under cll 7.4 and 7.5 to pay commission to Hoy Mobile on all sums which Allphones received from carriers in respect of sales and activations of plans effected by Hoy Mobile.3.The franchise agreement was not void because of Allphones’ failure, before it was entered into, to comply with cll 10 and 11 of the Code, and that Ketchell [2007] NSWCA 161 should not be followed.4.Hoy Mobile was fraudulent in connection with the operation of the franchise business within the meaning of cl 9.3(viii) of the franchise agreement. Allphones did not know of that fraud and did not condone it. Nor did Allphones elect, after it learnt of the nature of the fraud, to affirm the franchise agreement.5.Allphones was not entitled to terminate the franchise agreement by reason of Hoy Mobile’s fraudulent conduct because Allphones, itself, was not ready and willing to perform. This was because it, both, had evinced an intention not to be bound and had breached the essential term in cl 7.4 by its withholding and underpayment of commissions, and its dishonesty in concealing that conduct.6.Hoy Mobile was not entitled to be paid by Allphones:(a) $18,000 in respect of co-op money when it began its franchise;(b) $32,000 in respect of the benefit Hoy Mobile derived from its fraud.7.Allphones has not established that the amount it had charged Hoy Mobile in respect of the refresh charge was a reasonable sum to charge under cll 4, 6.23 or 6.35. In particular Allphones has shown that the sum was not reasonable by its failure to reduce it by the $1,100 paid to Allphones by Optus as a co-op payment for the purpose of defraying the store refresh charge for each Allphones’ franchise.8.Allphones is obliged to pay Hoy Mobile the following for its breaches of the franchise agreement: In the event that the parties cannot agree on the formulation of the orders, each should prepare its own draft of the orders and the matter can be re-listed for further argument. I will direct Hoy Mobile to serve its draft orders with supporting schedules by 3 June 2008 together with its written submissions in respect of costs and, Allphones to serve its response by 5 June 2008 together with written submissions in respect of any areas of disagreement. Any written submissions in reply should be served by Hoy Mobile by 6 June 2008, and I will relist the matter for the making of final orders on 10 June 2008.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RARES J

Thus, here, equity would consider whether Allphones had caused Hoy Mobile to be fraudulent in connection with the operation of the franchise agreement (cl 9.3(viii)). On the facts, I have found Mr Hoy alone was responsible for that fraudulent conduct of Hoy Mobile. So, equity would not find a nexus between Allphones’ entitlement to terminate and the fraud in which Hoy Mobile had engaged.33.2 Consideration But, s 51AC authorises the Court to look more broadly at the whole of the relationship and to assess the corporation’s conduct in that broader context. That context includes the breaches of the franchise agreement which I have found Allphones to have committed as the basis of my finding that it was not entitled to terminate the franchise agreement because it was itself in breach of an essential term or evincing an intention not to be bound. In addition, Allphones engaged in other conduct which is relevant under ss 51AC(1) and (2). A central feature of the Code is its requirement that a franchisor must maintain and utilise disclosure documents. The purpose of a disclosure document, in the context of an ongoing relationship between a franchisor and franchisee, is to give a current franchisee among other things:·information from the franchisor that is material to the running of the franchise business (cl 6A(b) of the Code);·details of the franchisor’s requirements for the supply of goods or services to a franchisee specifying whether the franchisor or an associate will receive a rebate or other financial benefit from the supply of goods or services to franchisee, and whether any rebate or financial benefit is shared, directly or indirectly, with franchisees (Annexure 1, cl 9.1(j) of the Code). Here, the first time Allphones disclosed to franchisees, including Hoy Mobile, that it charged them a $5 fee for each post-paid mobile phone contract as a carrier reconciliation charge, was in a disclosure document it issued on 29 August 2006. That was the day after it gave to Hoy Mobile its notice of its intention to terminate. That document contained no other disclosures about deductions made by Allphones from the MTSC, which I have held it was required to pay to Hoy Mobile. Those deductions did not fall within rebates or other financial benefits received by Allphones (because I have found that it was not entitled to them), however, if it had been frank about what it was doing, it should have revealed them. But, even if I were wrong in that finding, then Allphones should have given details about the terms it received from carriers in accordance with cl 9.1 in Annexure 1 to the Code. I am satisfied that Allphones’ conduct in relation to its suppression of the true commissions paid by carriers to it in respect of activations falling within cll 7.4 and 7.5 was a deliberate and significant departure from honest dealing with Hoy Mobile. This conduct evinced a high degree of moral obloquy. It created an imbalance in the relationship between Allphones and Hoy Mobile, because it deprived Hoy Mobile of earnings to which it was entitled under the franchise agreement, and concealed from Hoy Mobile its true entitlement. I do not consider that the conduct of Allphones towards Hoy Mobile in this regard was in good faith.