Fussell v Hanrahan t/as Dignan & Hanrahan Solicitors

Link copied
Case Copied 87 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Fussell v Hanrahan t/as Dignan & Hanrahan Solicitors [2024] NSWSC 1388
Hearing dates: 29-31 July 2024; 1-2 August 2024; 5 & 6 August 2024
Date of orders: 21 November 2024
Decision date: 21 November 2024
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Davies J
Decision:

1. Judgment for the first and second defendants.

2. Judgment for the third defendant.

3. The plaintiffs are to pay the defendants’ costs.

Catchwords:

OCCUPATIONS – legal practitioners – solicitors – duty of care – proceedings for damages from two firms of solicitors – where both firms acted successively for the plaintiffs in respect of a contract to purchase a commercial property – where clause 33.2 of the contract allowed for rescission if either party died prior to completion – where the vendor of the property died before the contract settled – the vendor’s executor rescinded the contract – whether the first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the presence and effect of clause 33.2 – where the first defendant told the first plaintiff about the terms of clause 33.2 but did not recommend that the clause be modified or deleted – first defendant had an obligation to provide advice about clause 33.2 in the unusual circumstances – first defendant breached his duty of care

OCCUPATIONS – legal practitioners – solicitors – duty of care – where clause 49 of the contract and a deed of life estate document granted the vendor a life estate over a house constructed on top of the six garages on the property – where the form of transfer prepared by vendor’s solicitor mistakenly caused the whole of the property to be transferred to the vendor for life with the remainder to the purchaser – whether the first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first defendant that it was not possible to give effect to the agreed upon life estate – where the first defendant failed to identify the discrepancy between the contract and deed and the transfer – where the first defendant failed to advise of the difficulties of giving legal effect to the agreement in clause 49 and the deed – first defendant breached his duty of care

NEGLIGENCE – causation – factual causation – whether the first defendant’s breach caused any loss suffered by the plaintiffs – burden of proof on the plaintiffs to prove, on the balance of probability, any fact relevant to causation – where the evidence strongly suggest that no agreement to alter or delete clause 33.2 would have been reached with the vendor – where the evidence did not establish that the vendor would have agreed not to require the life estate over the house – where the first plaintiff was not in a position to settle the contract regardless – held that the cause of any loss suffered by the plaintiffs was not any breach by the first defendant

OCCUPATIONS – legal practitioners –…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fussell v Hanrahan t/as Dignan & Hanrahan Solicitors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWSC 1388
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Fussell v Hanrahan t/as Dignan & Hanrahan Solicitors involved a dispute between the plaintiffs and two firms of solicitors, Dignan & Hanrahan and another firm, concerning a contract for the purchase of a commercial property. The dispute centred on the alleged failure of the solicitors to provide appropriate advice and to properly execute the contract, leading to significant consequences when the vendor died before the contract settled, causing the contract to be rescinded.

The primary legal issues the court needed to address were whether the first defendant, a solicitor from Dignan & Hanrahan, breached his duty of care by not advising the plaintiff about the implications of a particular clause in the contract (Clause 33.2) and by not advising that the form of transfer did not correctly reflect the agreed life estate. Additionally, the court had to determine if the third defendant, from the other firm, breached his duty of care by not advising the plaintiff about Clause 33.2 and by not arranging settlement before the vendor's death.

The court held that the first defendant breached his duty of care by not advising the plaintiff about the presence and effect of Clause 33.2 and by not identifying discrepancies in the transfer that would have made it impossible to give effect to the agreed life estate. The court found that the first defendant's breach did not cause any loss to the plaintiffs, as the evidence suggested that no agreement to alter or delete Clause 33.2 would have been reached with the vendor, and the plaintiff was not in a position to settle the contract regardless. The third defendant was not found to have breached his duty of care, as the plaintiff had already been made aware of Clause 33.2 by the first defendant and did not have the funds to complete the settlement.

The court's final orders would reflect its determination that the first defendant breached his duty of care, but that this breach did not cause any loss to the plaintiffs. The third defendant was found not to have breached his duty of care.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two firms of solicitors, Dignan & Hanrahan and another firm, acting successively for the plaintiffs, Fussell, in respect of a contract to purchase a commercial property. Clause 33.2 of the contract allowed for rescission if either party died prior to completion. The vendor of the property died before the contract settled, leading the vendor's executor to rescind the contract. The plaintiffs brought proceedings for damages against both firms of solicitors, claiming breaches of duty of care. Specifically, they alleged that the first defendant did not properly advise the first plaintiff of the presence and effect of clause 33.2. Additionally, the first defendant was accused of failing to advise on the discrepancy between the contract, a deed of life estate, and the form of transfer prepared by the vendor's solicitor, which caused the whole property to be mistakenly transferred to the vendor for life. The third defendant, who commenced to act after the contract was entered into, was accused of not advising the first plaintiff of the presence of clause 33.2 and of failing to arrange settlement prior to the vendor's death.

The matter came before the court following proceedings brought by the plaintiffs against two firms of solicitors for damages arising from the failed purchase of a commercial property. The case involved claims of breach of duty of care against the first and third defendants. The first defendant was accused of failing to properly advise the first plaintiff about clause 33.2 and the discrepancy in the transfer documents. The third defendant was accused of not advising the first plaintiff about clause 33.2 and of failing to arrange settlement before the vendor's death. The plaintiffs bore the burden of proving, on the balance of probabilities, that the defendants' breaches caused any loss they suffered. The court considered the evidence presented and made findings on whether the breaches by the defendants caused the plaintiffs' loss.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the presence and effect of clause 33.2.
2. Whether the first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff that it was not possible to give effect to the agreed upon life estate.
3. Whether the third defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the presence of clause 33.2.
4. Whether the third defendant breached his duty of care by failing to arrange settlement prior to the vendor’s death.

Held
1. The first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the presence and effect of clause 33.2. The result was a finding of liability against the first defendant for breach of duty of care.
2. The first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff that it was not possible to give effect to the agreed upon life estate. The result was a finding of liability against the first defendant for breach of duty of care.
3. The third defendant did not breach his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the presence of clause 33.2 as the first plaintiff was already aware of the clause from the first defendant. The result was no liability against the third defendant for this failure.
4. The third defendant did not breach his duty of care by failing to arrange settlement prior to the vendor’s death. The result was no liability against the third defendant for this failure.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining the first issue, the court examined whether the first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the presence and effect of clause 33.2. The court held that the first defendant had an obligation to provide advice about clause 33.2 in the unusual circumstances, given that the vendor died before completion, and the clause allowed for rescission under such circumstances. The first defendant told the first plaintiff about the terms of clause 33.2 but did not recommend that the clause be modified or deleted. The court found that this constituted a breach of duty of care, leading to liability on the part of the first defendant. The binding principle here is that solicitors have an obligation to advise clients about significant clauses in contracts, particularly when the circumstances are unusual and the client is at risk of loss.

In addressing the second issue, the court assessed whether the first defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff that it was not possible to give effect to the agreed upon life estate. The court found that the first defendant failed to identify the discrepancy between the contract and deed and the transfer, and failed to advise of the difficulties of giving legal effect to the agreement in clause 49 and the deed. The court determined that this constituted a breach of duty of care, resulting in liability for the first defendant. The principle established is that solicitors must ensure that the terms of a contract and the documents prepared are consistent and that they advise clients of any discrepancies that could affect the enforceability of the agreement.

For the third issue, the court examined whether the third defendant breached his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the presence of clause 33.2. The court noted that the first plaintiff had already been made aware of clause 33.2 and its effect by the first defendant prior to retaining the third defendant. Given this, the court held that the third defendant did not breach his duty of care by failing to advise the first plaintiff of the clause. The principle applied here is that if a client has already been adequately informed of a matter by a prior solicitor, a subsequent solicitor is not required to repeat that information.

Regarding the fourth issue, the court assessed whether the third defendant breached his duty of care by failing to arrange settlement prior to the vendor’s death. The court found that the evidence showed the first plaintiff did not have the funds to complete the settlement. As a result, the court concluded that the third defendant did not breach his duty of care in this regard. The principle here is that solicitors are not liable for failing to arrange settlement if the client lacks the necessary funds to do so, provided they have acted with due diligence and within the scope of their obligations.