FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Metz Holdings Pty Ltd v Simmac Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 981
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Metz Holdings Pty Ltd v Simmac Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] FCA 981
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the applicants' case against the respondents for misleading and deceptive conduct was substantiated, and the respondents' conduct was unconscionable. The applicants' struggle to achieve profit and remunerate the Metzes at an appropriate level was due to the misrepresentations made by the respondents. The court was prepared to make orders that reflect the substance of the proposed terms, but found it difficult to accept the applicants' submissions and to assess the sum for remuneration foregone. However, an appropriate sum greater than what the applicants had actually been paid must be allowed. The court took into account the financial structure the applicants adopted in financing the business, and allowed an additional or deemed sum of $255,000 by way of salary for the period to 30 June 2011.
The court recognised that the applicants cautioned against such an approach, citing the decision of Steytler J in Gardner Corp Pty Ltd v Zed Bears Pty Ltd. However, the court considered it appropriate to have regard to the financing position for the reason expressed above. The court concluded that the applicants necessarily struggled to achieve profit of the type that was represented and remunerate the Metzes at an appropriate level due to the misrepresentations made by the respondents. The court found it both difficult to accept the applicants' submissions and to assess this sum. However, an appropriate sum greater than what the applicants had actually been paid must be allowed. The court allowed an additional or deemed sum of $255,000 by way of salary for the period to 30 June 2011.
ORDERS:
1. The applicants bring forward a minute of proposed final Orders designed to carry forward the Orders proposed. Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The applicants bring forward a minute of proposed final Orders designed to carry forward the Orders proposed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Consideration of proposed orders: I am prepared to make orders that reflect the substance of those terms. However, so far as an allowance in respect of a deemed sum of remuneration for the full time employment of the second and third applicants in the business is concerned I find it both difficult to accept the applicants’ submissions and to assess this sum. However, an appropriate sum greater than what the applicants have actually been paid must be allowed. In my view, the misrepresentations I have identified meant that the applicants necessarily struggled to achieve profit of the type that was represented and remunerate the Metzes at an appropriate level. Not to allow an additional amount of salary on account of remuneration foregone would mean, in effect, that when the business is returned to the first respondent, they would get the business back without having to pay for the “caretaking” efforts of the Metzes in the period, effectively from 4 July 2008. However, the calculation of the amount that the Metzes have foregone cannot, in my view, simply be calculated by reference to what, prior to the purchase, Mr Sim and Ms McBrierty were paid by way of salary. Nor can it simply be calculated by reference to what people in businesses like this normally get – Mr Cook’s alternative proposal put forward by the applicants. For a start, the Metzes did not have the skills at the outset to justify what Mr Sim and Ms McBrierty were paid. Mr Sim, as an employee of the applicants, received about $65,000 per annum. Further, the financing arrangements to purchase the business put in place by the applicants with Westpac to differed significantly from those the respondents had in place to operate the business. This was bound to affect cashflow and affect the ability of the applicants to pay any extravagant, or even moderately high sum by way of salary to the Metzes. I consider taking all this into account, that the remuneration for each of the Metzes was bound to be less than it had been for the two old directors. I would, therefore, doing the best that I can, allow an additional or deemed sum of $255,000 by way of salary for the period to 30 June 2011, which is equal to an additional $85,000 per annum over three financial years to 30 June 2011. I recognise that I have, in mediating the allowance for remuneration foregone by the Metzes in this way, taken into account the financial structure they adopted in financing the business. The applicants caution against such an approach citing the decision of Steytler J in Gardner Corp Pty Ltd v Zed Bears Pty Ltd [2003] WASC 13 at [74]‑[83] where at [78] his Honour observed:[78]In this case, the whole of the loss claimed by Krishell would not have occurred but for the misrepresentation and there was no item of loss which could, in my opinion, properly be separated out and attributed to some other cause.His Honour there made reference to what Hayne J said in Henville at [160]. In my view, however, it is appropriate to have regard to the financing position for the reason expressed above.