Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller (No 4) [2022] FCA 105

File number: WAD 250 of 2019
Judgment of: JACKSON J
Date of judgment: 16 February 2022
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - hearing on remitter from appeal - principles to be applied on remitter - interpretation of remitting judgment - extent to which an order setting aside dismissal of a claim allows that claim - issue estoppel - Anshun estoppel - whether issue should have been raised at appeal level

CONSUMER LAW - misleading or deceptive conduct - remedies - statutory rescission relief sought under s 237 and s 243 of Australian Consumer Law - date of statutory rescission - relevance of date of statutory rescission to damages - date of statutory rescission to fulfil compensatory purpose - conditions on statutory rescission - unwinding of only part of a suite of transactions

CONSUMER LAW - misleading or deceptive conduct - remedies - damages sought under s 236 of Australian Consumer Law - valuation of lost opportunity - discount for contingency - deductions bringing benefits received to account - onus of proof in relation to deductions

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - pre-judgment interest on damages - interest rate applicable

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 2, 18, 236, 237, 243

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 28, 51A

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 37

Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth) ss 52, 87

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 39.05

Fair Trading Act 2010 (WA) ss 19, 24

Cases cited:

Alati v Kruger (1955) 94 CLR 216

Awad v Twin Creeks Properties Pty Ltd [2012] NSWCA 200

Badenach v Calvert [2016] HCA 18; (2016) 257 CLR 440

Barnes v Forty Two International Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 152

Bennett v Elysium Noosa Pty Ltd (in liq) [2012] FCA 211; (2012) 202 FCR 72

Champtaloup v Thomas [1976] 2 NSWLR 264

Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd (in liq) (rec & man apptd) [2018] HCA 12; (2018) 264 CLR 165

Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) v Pratt Holdings Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1247

Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd (No 2) [2001] FCA 479; (2001) 112 FCR 324

Demagogue Pty Ltd v Ramensky (1992) 39 FCR 31

E K Nominees Pty Ltd v Woolworths Ltd [2006] NSWSC 1172

Fernando v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCAFC 181; (2014) 231 FCR 251

GEC Marconi Systems Pty Ltd v BHP Information Technology Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 688

Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller (No 2) [2020] FCA 604

Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller [2020] FCAFC 229; (2020) 282 FCR 530

Henjo Investments Pty Ltd v Collins Marrickville Pty Ltd (No 1) (1988) 39 FCR 546

I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd [2002] HCA 41; (2002) 210 CLR 109

Investments (WA) Pty Ltd v City of Swan [2012] WASC 278

JAD International Pty Ltd v International Trucks Australia Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The hearing on remitter involved parties Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd, the applicants, and various respondents including Mr Tiller, Mr Nicoletti, and Dimension Agriculture Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to a series of property leases and subleases, and the relief available under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The Full Court of the Federal Court had previously set aside the dismissal of the applicants' claims and remitted the matter for determination of what, if any, relief should be granted under s 236 and s 237 of the ACL, and for resolution of any issues as to costs. The primary issues on remitter were whether the New Leases were void ab initio, whether Harvard should repay certain amounts to Dimension, whether damages should be awarded against Mr Nicoletti, the valuation of lost opportunity for the 2019 Fowler Lease, and the applicable interest rate for pre-judgment interest on damages.

The court considered the principles applicable on remitter, including the interpretation of the remitting judgment and the extent to which setting aside the dismissal of a claim allows that claim. The court noted that the Full Court had not found Mr Nicoletti liable for the misleading or deceptive conduct, and therefore issue estoppel and Anshun estoppel applied to prevent Mr Nicoletti from being held liable. The court also addressed the question of whether damages should be awarded against Mr Nicoletti, concluding that he was not liable for the misleading or deceptive conduct. Regarding the valuation of lost opportunity, the court held that the lost opportunity of the 2019 Fowler Lease should be valued on the basis of the 2019 Fowler Lease itself, and considered various deductions that should be made from the lost opportunity value. Finally, the court determined the applicable interest rate for pre-judgment interest on damages.

The court declared that the New Leases were void ab initio and ordered the respondents to pay damages and pre-judgment interest to the applicants. The court also set out a timetable for the calculation of damages and pre-judgment interest, and for the filing of written submissions on the costs of the original proceeding and the remitter. The amended originating application was otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 237 and s 243(a) of the Australian Consumer Law, the following instruments made on 8 February 2019 are declared to have been void ab initio:

(a) Lease - Warriup between Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd, and Dimension Agriculture Pty Ltd and Simon Clifford Tiller; and

(b) Lease - Howick between Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd, and Dimension Agriculture Pty Ltd and Simon Clifford Tiller.

2. The first and second respondents jointly and severally must pay damages and pre‑judgment interest to the applicant in amounts to be determined in accordance with paragraph 3 of these orders.

3. By 4.00 pm AWST on 2 March 2022 the parties must file an agreed minute of calculation of damages and pre-judgment interest in accordance with the reasons for judgment or, failing agreement between them, separate minutes.

4. By 4.00 pm AWST 2 March 2022, the applicant must file and serve an outline of written submissions, no longer than five pages, in relation to the costs of the original proceeding and the costs of the remitter.

5. By 4.00 pm AWST on 16 March 2022, the respondents must file and serve an outline of written submissions, no longer than five pages, in relation to the costs of the original proceeding and the costs of the remitter, and indicating whether any oral hearing is sought.

6. By 4.00 pm AWST on 23 March 2022, the applicant must file and serve an outline of written submissions, no longer than three pages, in reply, indicating whether any oral hearing is sought.

7. The amended originating application dated 4 December 2019 is otherwise dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Table of Contents

Introduction

[1]

Background

[4]

The issues on remitter

[5]

The appeal

[15]

The grounds of appeal

[16]

The Appeal Judgment

[20]

Principles on remitter

[40]

First issue - the operative date of the order that the New Leases are void

[52]

The parties' positions

[53]

Rescission at common law or equity?

[71]

Principles in relation to statutory rescission

[73]

Consideration

[92]

Second issue - should Harvard repay to Dimension certain amounts?

[104]

Third issue - should damages be awarded against Mr Nicoletti?

[119]

Harvard's submissions

[119]

The respondents' submissions

[138]

Consideration

[145]

The Full Court did not say that Mr Nicoletti is liable

[145]

The Full Court did not uphold ground 1(b)

[147]

Setting aside the dismissal of the damages claim does not mean Mr Nicoletti is liable

[162]

Harvard did not advance ground 1(b) as originally framed

[172]

Issue estoppel and Anshun estoppel

[176]

The administration of justice

[184]

Conclusion

[190]

Fourth issue - damages

[191]

The parties' positions

[194]

Principles

[206]

Consideration

[210]

Valuing the lost opportunity of the 2019 Fowler Lease

[212]

Deduction of rent actually paid

[227]

Deduction for Mr Vaughan's leasing fee

[228]

Deductions for rental arrears and council rates

[232]

Deduction for landlord's improvements

[242]

Conclusion

[246]

Fifth issue - interest on damages

[247]

Costs

[258]

Background

Background to the litigation

There was a two day hearing on that remitter, during which the parties adduced further affidavit and oral evidence, including by cross-examination, although in the end almost all of the issues to which that cross‑examination went fell away. The respondents ended up adducing affidavit evidence from Mr Nicoletti on one point only, and he was not cross‑examined. Ultimately, the scope of evidentiary dispute was limited and for the most part the resolution of the issues turned on legal arguments. It is not possible to summarise conveniently at this point the conclusions I have reached in the reasons below.Background The following summary at [1] of the Appeal Judgment sets out the background and main findings as to misleading or deceptive conduct in the Primary Judgment (all definitions adopted in this judgment):(1)The appellant [applicant] (Harvard) is a company controlled by Mr John Caratti.(2)Harvard was the registered proprietor of a farm in Western Australia known as 'Warriup Farm' and Mr John Caratti and his brother Mr Allen Caratti were the registered proprietors of another farm known as 'Howick Farm'.(3)Prior to January 2019, Harvard had leased Warriup Farm to Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd (Mammoth), a company of which Mr John Caratti was a director, which then subleased it to the first respondent, Mr Tiller and the fifth respondent, Mrs Tiller; Mr John Caratti and Mr Allen Caratti had also leased Howick Farm to Mammoth which also had subleased that property to Mr and Mrs Tiller.(4)A series of transactions then took place which included the surrender by Mr and Mrs Tiller of their subleases (Tiller Subleases) over Warriup Farm and Howick Farm (together, the Farms), the surrender by Mammoth of its lease over Warriup Farm and the assignment of Mammoth's head lease of Howick Farm to Harvard. These transactions were entered into to allow two new leases to be entered into (New Leases) being: (a) a lease of Warriup Farm by Harvard to Mr Tiller and to the second respondent, Dimension Agriculture Pty Ltd (Dimension); and (b) a sublease of Howick Farm by Harvard to Mr Tiller and Dimension.(5)Prior to entry into this series of transactions, in late January 2019, Mr Tiller and Dimension engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct. This conduct arose because although Dimension had one shareholder, the fourth respondent, Mr Bryce, and its directors were Mr Bryce and Mr Tiller, Dimension in fact was a vehicle of the third respondent, Mr Nicoletti, and had been structured in such a way as to prevent Mr John Caratti being aware of Mr Nicoletti's involvement. This was of significance because Mr John Caratti did not want to enter into a lease arrangement involving Mr Nicoletti. Mr John Caratti perceived Mr Nicoletti as 'bonded' to Mr Allen Caratti, a person against whom he bore a great deal of animosity, and Mr Nicoletti had the capacity to pay a significantly higher rent than the rent proposed under the New Leases (such that Mr Nicoletti's involvement would have 'put a very different complexion on a proposed lease for what was believed to be below market rent': PJ [364]).(6)The entry into the New Leases by Harvard took place in reliance upon a misleading and deceptive representation made by Mr Tiller and Dimension as to the involvement of Mr Nicoletti in Dimension.(7)When this ruse was discovered, by a letter from its solicitors dated 2 April 2019, Harvard asserted misleading or deceptive conduct and 'fraudulent misrepresentation' and notified Mr Tiller and Dimension that Harvard 'elected to rescind' the New Leases.(8)The Tiller Subleases having been surrendered and having given notice of rescission of the New Leases, on 17 April 2019, Harvard executed a lease of the Farms to companies associated with the Fowler family ([2019] Fowler Lease); this was to commence on 1 May 2019 but was subject to Harvard obtaining vacant possession of the Farms by 30 April 2019.(9)Unbeknownst to Harvard, subsequent to the entry into the New Leases, by deed (15 February Deeds) Mr Tiller assigned his interests in the New Leases to Dimension and agreed to have no involvement in pastoral activities on the Farms. The primary judge also found that the failure to disclose the 15 February Deeds amounted to misleading and deceptive conduct from 15 April 2019 onwards because, on that date, a letter had been sent by solicitors on behalf of Mr Tiller and Dimension which did not reveal the true position.The issues on remitter

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller [2020] FCAFC 229; (2020) 282 FCR 530 (Appeal Judgment or AJ), the Full Court set aside the orders dismissing the application, and remitted the matter to me on the question of what, if any, relief should be granted under s 236 and s 237 of the ACL, and for resolution of any issues as to costs. There was a two day hearing on that remitter, during which the parties adduced further affidavit and oral evidence, including by cross-examination, although in the end almost all of the issues to which that cross‑examination went fell away. The respondents ended up adducing affidavit evidence from Mr Nicoletti on one point only, and he was not cross‑examined. Ultimately, the scope of evidentiary dispute was limited and for the most part the resolution of the issues turned on legal arguments. It is not possible to summarise conveniently at this point the conclusions I have reached in the reasons below.Background The following summary at [1] of the Appeal Judgment sets out the background and main findings as to misleading or deceptive conduct in the Primary Judgment (all definitions adopted in this judgment):(1)The appellant [applicant] (Harvard) is a company controlled by Mr John Caratti.(2)Harvard was the registered proprietor of a farm in Western Australia known as 'Warriup Farm' and Mr John Caratti and his brother Mr Allen Caratti were the registered proprietors of another farm known as 'Howick Farm'.(3)Prior to January 2019, Harvard had leased Warriup Farm to Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd (Mammoth), a company of which Mr John Caratti was a director, which then subleased it to the first respondent, Mr Tiller and the fifth respondent, Mrs Tiller; Mr John Caratti and Mr Allen Caratti had also leased Howick Farm to Mammoth which also had subleased that property to Mr and Mrs Tiller.(4)A series of transactions then took place which included the surrender by Mr and Mrs Tiller of their subleases (Tiller Subleases) over Warriup Farm and Howick Farm (together, the Farms), the surrender by Mammoth of its lease over Warriup Farm and the assignment of Mammoth's head lease of Howick Farm to Harvard. These transactions were entered into to allow two new leases to be entered into (New Leases) being: (a) a lease of Warriup Farm by Harvard to Mr Tiller and to the second respondent, Dimension Agriculture Pty Ltd (Dimension); and (b) a sublease of Howick Farm by Harvard to Mr Tiller and Dimension.(5)Prior to entry into this series of transactions, in late January 2019, Mr Tiller and Dimension engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct. This conduct arose because although Dimension had one shareholder, the fourth respondent, Mr Bryce, and its directors were Mr Bryce and Mr Tiller, Dimension in fact was a vehicle of the third respondent, Mr Nicoletti, and had been structured in such a way as to prevent Mr John Caratti being aware of Mr Nicoletti's involvement. This was of significance because Mr John Caratti did not want to enter into a lease arrangement involving Mr Nicoletti. Mr John Caratti perceived Mr Nicoletti as 'bonded' to Mr Allen Caratti, a person against whom he bore a great deal of animosity, and Mr Nicoletti had the capacity to pay a significantly higher rent than the rent proposed under the New Leases (such that Mr Nicoletti's involvement would have 'put a very different complexion on a proposed lease for what was believed to be below market rent': PJ [364]).(6)The entry into the New Leases by Harvard took place in reliance upon a misleading and deceptive representation made by Mr Tiller and Dimension as to the involvement of Mr Nicoletti in Dimension.(7)When this ruse was discovered, by a letter from its solicitors dated 2 April 2019, Harvard asserted misleading or deceptive conduct and 'fraudulent misrepresentation' and notified Mr Tiller and Dimension that Harvard 'elected to rescind' the New Leases.(8)The Tiller Subleases having been surrendered and having given notice of rescission of the New Leases, on 17 April 2019, Harvard executed a lease of the Farms to companies associated with the Fowler family ([2019] Fowler Lease); this was to commence on 1 May 2019 but was subject to Harvard obtaining vacant possession of the Farms by 30 April 2019.(9)Unbeknownst to Harvard, subsequent to the entry into the New Leases, by deed (15 February Deeds) Mr Tiller assigned his interests in the New Leases to Dimension and agreed to have no involvement in pastoral activities on the Farms. The primary judge also found that the failure to disclose the 15 February Deeds amounted to misleading and deceptive conduct from 15 April 2019 onwards because, on that date, a letter had been sent by solicitors on behalf of Mr Tiller and Dimension which did not reveal the true position.The issues on remitter

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.