I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
GAUDRON, McHUGH, GUMMOW, KIRBY, HAYNE AND CALLINAN JJ

I & L SECURITIES PTY LTD  APPELLANT

AND

HTW VALUERS (BRISBANE) PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd
[2002] HCA 41
2 October 2002
B48/2001

ORDER

1.   Appeal allowed.

2.   Set aside the order of the Court of Appeal of Queensland dated 22 September 2000 and, in its place, order that the appeal to that Court be allowed, that the judgment entered by Williams J on 22 October 1999 and the order of Williams J made on 8 November 1999 be set aside, and that there be judgment for the plaintiff for $661,481.53.

3.   Respondent to pay the appellant's costs at first instance, in the Court of Appeal and in this Court.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Queensland

Representation:

P A Keane QC with J D McKenna for the appellant (instructed by Deacons Lawyers)

D F Jackson QC with P D T Applegarth SC for the respondent (instructed by Thynne & Macartney)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ. The issue in this appeal concerns the extent of the respondent's liability to the appellant, which suffered loss or damage by conduct of the respondent which contravened s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ("the Act"). The misleading or deceptive conduct involved an erroneous valuation of real estate over which a mortgage was to be given as security for a loan by the appellant. Relying upon the valuation, the appellant made the loan. The borrower defaulted, and the security, when realised, was insufficient to meet the borrower's liability. The appellant sued for the deficiency and related losses. The appellant was found to have failed to exercise reasonable care to protect its own interests, in that it did not take proper steps to investigate the credit-worthiness of the borrower. The principal question is whether the amount of the respondent's liability to the appellant should be reduced on that account. As the case was argued, and as it was decided in the Supreme Court of Queensland, the answer to that question depends upon the meaning and effect of ss 82 and 87 of the Act.

    The appellant's claim

  2. The borrower, Camworth Pty Ltd, owned land at Acacia Ridge, in Queensland, which it proposed to subdivide and develop.  It owed money to a financier and to a construction company.  During 1995, it sought re-financing.  On 2 March 1995, the borrower obtained, from the respondent, a valuer, a valuation of its land at $1.576m.  In July 1995, it sought a loan from the appellant of $950,000 on the security of a first mortgage over the land, and supplied the valuation report in support of its application.  The respondent wrote to the appellant advising that the valuation report could be relied upon in connection with the proposed loan.  On that basis, the appellant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] HCA 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to this appeal were I & L Securities Pty Ltd (the appellant) and HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd (the respondent). The dispute concerned the appellant's loss arising from a loan transaction where the respondent provided a misleading valuation of land used as security. The appellant alleged negligence, breach of contract, and contravention of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) by the respondent. The High Court of Australia was required to determine whether the appellant's failure to take reasonable care for its own interests could reduce the damages recoverable under section 82 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) for misleading or deceptive conduct.

The High Court considered the operation of Part VI of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) concerning enforcement and remedies. The central legal issue was whether a person who suffers loss or damage due to another's contravention of Part V of the Act could have their damages reduced because they did not exercise reasonable care to protect their own interests. A subsidiary issue involved the calculation of the appellant's loss. The court noted that the trial judge had found both the respondent's negligent valuation and the appellant's inadequate inquiries to be causes of the loss, apportioning responsibility on a two-thirds basis for the misleading and deceptive conduct.

The High Court reasoned that section 87 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) does not grant discretion to reduce damages otherwise recoverable under section 82. Furthermore, section 82 does not permit a court to apportion loss that is causally connected in the common law sense with a respondent's breach. The Court affirmed its previous decision in *Henville v Walker*, which held that contributory negligence is irrelevant for the purposes of section 82. The Court concluded that while the appellant's conduct contributed to its loss, section 82 does not allow for apportionment of loss based on the parties' culpability, as this approach is inconsistent with the policy of the legislation.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of Queensland and the judgment of the trial judge. The Court entered judgment for the appellant for $661,481.53 and ordered the respondent to pay the appellant's costs at first instance, in the Court of Appeal, and in the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the order of the Court of Appeal of Queensland dated 22 September 2000 and, in its place, order that the appeal to that Court be allowed, that the judgment entered by Williams J on 22 October 1999 and the order of Williams J made on 8 November 1999 be set aside, and that there be judgment for the plaintiff for $661,481.53.

3. Respondent to pay the appellant's costs at first instance, in the Court of Appeal and in this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

In my opinion, the appeal should be allowed. Section 87 does not confer any discretion to reduce the damages to which an applicant would otherwise be entitled under s 82. Nor does s 82 permit a court to divide the responsibility for a loss that is causally connected in the common law sense with a respondent's breach of Pts IV or V of the Act[35]. In Henville v Walker[36], this Court held that, in awarding damages under s 82, a court cannot reduce the amount of an applicant's damages because of the applicant's contributory negligence. For the purpose of s 82, it is irrelevant that the conduct of an applicant was a cause of its loss unless the court can find that the loss or damage suffered is divisible into parts, and the respondent's conduct did not cause one or more of those parts. I & L's conduct undoubtedly contributed to its loss. But this Court's decision in Henville necessarily denies that under s 82 a court can apportion the loss or damage suffered by the applicant in accordance with the parties' culpability. That is not an approach that accords with the policy of the legislation. [35]After these proceedings were commenced in the Supreme Court of Queensland, s 82 was amended by the Trade Practices Amendment (Fair Trading) Act 1998 (Cth), Sched 1(5) and Sched 2(3) to include a breach of Pt IVB and s 51AC and by the Trade Practices Amendment Act (No 1) 2001 (Cth), Sched 1(18) to include a breach of Pt IVA. While for the purposes of this appeal the relevant version of the Act is that prior to these amendments, what is said in this judgment is equally applicable to the Act as amended.[36](2001) 206 CLR 459.The material facts I & L conducted a money lending enterprise using trust monies obtained from clients of a firm of solicitors who carried out the legal work on the loan transactions. The solicitors were directors of I & L. On 3 July 1995, I & L received an application from a broker on behalf of Camworth Pty Ltd ("Camworth"), a trustee company for the Didar Mohammed Family Trust. The broker sought a loan of $950,000 to re-finance an existing loan that would not be renewed when its term expired. The loan was to be secured over land of which Camworth was the registered proprietor. Brisbane City Council had approved the land being subdivided into 36 lots, and Camworth was in the course of carrying out a three-stage subdivision. The first stage involved the registration of 19 residential allotments. According to a letter from the company's chartered accountants that accompanied the application, however, neither the company nor the Trust had traded since the Trust was established on 20 December 1989[37]. [37]The letter was transmitted to I & L by the broker acting as intermediary between it and Camworth. Accompanying the application was a statement of assets and liabilities of Mr Mohammed. He disclosed his "share" in Camworth as an asset, which he valued at $1.576 million. He recorded that the company was indebted to the holders of first and second mortgages over the subject land in the sum of $938,000 and that he owed MasterCard $1,000. Mr Mohammed's statement did not disclose whether he had any source of income or any employment. Also attached to the application were two valuations by HTW. The first valuation, and the one in issue at the trial, was dated 2 March 1995.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ GAUDRON, GUMMOW AND HAYNE JJ HUGH J
The respondent contended that, at least in respect of the lost interest, the appellant's loss or damage should be regarded as caused by the appellant's failure to take reasonable care to assess the credit-worthiness of the borrower rather than by the respondent's misleading conduct. This contention must fail. There is no reason to distinguish between principal and interest in considering the loss to the appellant. The mortgage was taken to secure the totality of the borrower's obligations and the appellant, as a financier, lost both capital and income.Conclusion The appeal should be allowed with costs. The orders of Williams J and the Court of Appeal should be set aside. There should be judgment in the action for the appellant for $661,481.53. The respondent should pay the appellant's costs, of the proceedings at first instance and in the Court of Appeal. This appeal concerns the operation of Pt VI of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ("the Act") which deals with enforcement and remedies. The principal issue is whether the liability of a person who has contravened a provision of Pt V of the Act to pay damages to a person who suffered loss or damage by that conduct is affected if the latter person did not take reasonable care to protect his or her own interests. There is another, subsidiary question about the calculation of the loss suffered in this case by the appellant. The facts which give rise to the principal issue are simply stated. On 28 July 1995, the appellant, a money lender, lent $950,000 to Camworth Pty Ltd. The loan was secured by a mortgage. The respondent, a valuer, valued the land which was mortgaged at $1.576m and wrote to the appellant telling it that the valuation report the respondent had prepared was "suitable for your mortgage security purposes". The respondent acknowledged that the appellant intended to lend $950,000 relying on the valuation. The borrower did not make the first payment of interest due on the loan on 1 September 1995. That is, it defaulted in performance of its obligations barely more than one month after it had taken the loan. The appellant exercised its power to sell the mortgaged land. The land was sold for $610,000 and, after meeting the expenses of sale, the appellant recovered $592,367.69. It was not disputed that the valuation of $1.576m was arrived at negligently. The market value of the land at the time of valuation was much less than the value stated by the respondent and relied on by the appellant. The appellant would not have lent to the borrower had the valuation not stated a value of the land at least 50% larger than the amount to be lent. In addition, however, the appellant did not take reasonable care for its own protection. It was found at trial, and it is not now disputed, that the appellant did not make the inquiries about the borrower's capacity to meet interest payments which a reasonably prudent lender would have made. The appellant sued the respondent in the Supreme Court of Queensland alleging negligence, breach of contract and contravention of Pt V of the Act. The claim for breach of contract failed. The trial judge (Williams J) concluded that there had been two causes of the appellant's loss – the respondent's admitted negligence in preparing its valuation, the tender of which to the appellant, the respondent accepted, was misleading and deceptive conduct, and the appellant's (careless) conduct in approving the loan without adequate inquiry. The trial judge considered the negligent valuation to be the "major cause" of the appellant's loss and by an approach his Honour described as "broadly similar to that which would apply in determining apportionment of negligence" assessed the loss occasioned by the respondent's misleading and deceptive conduct as being two‑thirds of the appellant's total loss.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ, GAUDRON, GUMMOW AND HAYNE JJ, HUGH J

The appeal in I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd hinged on the interpretation and application of various sections of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The central issue was whether the liability of a party who has contravened provisions of Part V of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) to pay damages to another party who suffered loss or damage by that conduct is mitigated if the latter party did not take reasonable care to protect their own interests. The Court held that the liability of the respondent, HTW Valuers, for damages under Section 82 was not affected by the appellant's failure to take reasonable care. This conclusion was grounded in the understanding that the respondent's misleading conduct was the primary cause of the appellant's loss. The Court rejected the argument that the appellant's failure to make reasonable inquiries about the borrower's creditworthiness could diminish the respondent's liability, affirming that the respondent's negligent valuation was the predominant cause of the loss.

Further, the Court addressed whether Section 87 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) confers any discretion to reduce the damages to which an applicant would otherwise be entitled under Section 82. The Court held that Section 87 does not provide such discretion, thereby upholding the principle that damages awarded under Section 82 are not reducible due to the applicant's contributory negligence. This interpretation aligns with the legislative intent to ensure that those who suffer loss due to misleading or deceptive conduct can seek full compensation. The Court's decision was influenced by its previous ruling in Henville v Walker, which established that under Section 82, a court cannot apportion damages based on the applicant's contributory negligence.

The Court also examined whether a court can reduce the amount of an applicant's damages under Section 82 due to the applicant's contributory negligence. This issue was resolved by reiterating the principles from Henville v Walker, where the Court held that contributory negligence does not reduce the damages awarded under Section 82. This principle was deemed necessary to uphold the policy of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), which aims to protect consumers from misleading conduct. The Court emphasized that under Section 82, it is irrelevant that the conduct of the applicant contributed to their loss unless the loss can be divisible into parts, and the respondent's conduct did not cause one or more of those parts.

Additionally, the Court explored whether it is permissible under Section 82 for a court to apportion the loss or damage suffered by the applicant in accordance with the parties' culpability. The Court concluded that Section 82 does not allow for such apportionment. This decision was based on the reasoning that apportioning damages according to the parties' culpability does not align with the statutory policy of providing full compensation to victims of misleading or deceptive conduct. The Court's ruling in this regard was consistent with its earlier decision in Henville v Walker, which underscored the importance of not reducing damages due to contributory negligence.

Finally, the Court addressed the method of calculating the loss suffered by the appellant in this case. The Court found that the valuation provided by HTW Valuers was negligently prepared and significantly overstated the land's market value. This negligent valuation was a major cause of the appellant's loss. The Court held that the appellant's failure to make reasonable inquiries about the borrower's capacity to meet interest payments did not diminish the respondent's liability. Instead, the Court affirmed that the appellant's total loss was recoverable under Section 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), without reduction for contributory negligence. The Court's decision underscored the principle that the respondent's misleading conduct was the primary cause of the appellant's loss, and therefore, the full amount of damages should be awarded to the appellant.