COOK v. CRAWFORD (1981) 52 FLR 1
Nos. N.S.W. 19, V23 and V24 of 1979
Industrial Law - Conciliation and Arbitration
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
INDUSTRIAL DIVISION
Evatt J.(1)
CATCHWORDS
Industrial Law - Rules of organization - charges against persons holding office - whether rules providing for dismissal from office or expulsion from organization valid - rule amending rule - mandatory or directory - express general power to amend - whether contrary to s.140(1) - Natural Justice - bias - failure to grant application for adjournment - incompatible offices - resignation from office or organization by conduct - repudiation of agreement - Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 ss.140, 141, 144, Regulation 115(1)(d)(v).
Conciliation and Arbitration - Registered organization - Rules - Oppressive, unreasonable or unjust - Performance and observance thereof - Dismissal from office and expulsion from membership of members by federal executive - Whether federal executive validly constituted - Whether rules validly amended - Whether express general power of federal council to amend rules valid - Hearing of charges against members - Whether breach of rules of natural justice - Bias - Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 (Cth), ss. 133(1)(f), 139(4), 140(1)(a), (c), (5G), 141(2), (8A), 150, 157, 171B, 171C - Federal Court Rules, O. 29; O. 51, r. 2.
Conciliation and Arbitration - Registered organization - Performance and observance of rules - Payment of capitation fees by branch - Rate of fees - Audit of books of account - Duty to fill vacancy in branch office - Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 (Cth), s. 141.
HEADNOTE
Proceedings under the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 (the Act) were heard together. They each related to the Plumbers and Gasfitters Employees' Union of Australia (the organization) a registered organization. There were two branches of the organization in New South Wales - the Sydney branch and the Newcastle branch.
N.S.W. 19 of 1979
By order to show cause the claimant, a member of the organization, chairman of the Sydney branch and of a State registered union, the New South Wales Plumbers and Gasfitters Employees' Union, sought orders: (a) under s. 141 of the Act that the respondents being federal executive members perform and observe the rules of the organization by treating as null and void certain resolutions of the executive purporting to expel from membership and dismiss from office five members of the Sydney branch: (b) that the respondents recognize the five members as holders of their respective offices on the grounds that the rules (rr. 13(6) and 35(10)(d) under which the charges were laid and heard and penalties imposed were invalid and that the relevant procedure of the federal executive involved a denial of natural justice to the members.
Held: (1) The orders sought that rr. 13(6) and 35(10)(d) were invalid should be refused because: (a) The amendments to the rules adopting those provisions had been validly approved by the federal council of the organization at a meeting in 1978 pursuant to an express general…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mister Figgins Pty Ltd v Centrepoint Freeholds Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1981] FCA 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the rules allowing for dismissal or expulsion from office were valid and whether the amendment process complied with the organization's constitution. Another key issue was whether the failure to grant an adjournment constituted a breach of natural justice, and if the presence of incompatible offices and resignation by conduct or repudiation of an agreement were properly handled.
The court ruled that the rules in question were valid and did not contravene section 140(1) of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904. It found no breach of natural justice in the failure to grant an adjournment and determined that the presence of incompatible offices and resignation by conduct or repudiation of an agreement were appropriately addressed. The court also concluded that the amendment of rules was permissible under the organization's constitution.
Consequently, the court discharged the rule to show cause and issued several orders. These included the constitution of a Committee of Management, the appointment of a temporary Branch Secretary, the payment of outstanding fees, the forwarding of these fees to the organization's head office, the scheduling of an election for various offices, the provision of financial records for auditing, and the reservation of liberty for parties to apply for further orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
The rule to show cause herein be discharged.
(1) the respondents within fourteen days from the date hereof constitute a Committee of Management of the Sydney Branch of the organization and appoint a member of such Sydney Branch eligible to nominate for the office of Branch Secretary in accordance with the rules to carry out the functions of the office of Branch Secretary pending the filling of such office pursuant to an election referred to in (5) below.
(2) the person so appointed carry out all duties of the Branch Secretary as provided for in the rules of the organization pending the election of a Branch Secretary in accordance with these directions or further order of the Court.
(3) the respondents Bruce J. Palmer and C.L.H. Hastwell each sign a cheque within seven days from the date hereof for the outstanding Sydney Branch capitation fees for the year ending 31 March 1979 being the difference between an amount calculated at the rate of 17 1/2% of the total receipts from branch contributions for that financial year and the amount already paid to Head Office of the organization in respect of that financial year on or about 17 July 1979.
(4) the respondents or the person appointed in accordance with (1) above cause to be forwarded to Head Office of the organization the cheque referred to in (3) above within fourteen days of the date herein.
(5) the person appointed in accordance with (1) above cause an election to be held pursuant to r.51(1) and r.48 (with the necessary changes) for the filling of the offices of Secretary, Assistant Secretary/Organiser and three Organisers of the Sydney Branch of the organization within such time as the Court directs after hearing submissions by the parties in this regard.
(6) the respondents and the person appointed in accordance with (1) above within fourteen days of the date hereof make available to Messrs J. Masselos & Co., Chartered Accountants, all books, vouchers, papers, documents, application cards, receipts and any other relevant material for the purpose of enabling the same to be audited in respect of the financial years ending 31 March 1978 and 31 March 1979 or such further period as the Court may direct after hearing submissions from any of the parties applying pursuant to the order granting liberty to apply.
(7) Liberty is reserved to any party to apply on forty-eight hours notice to the other parties and to the Court.
(1) The application be adjourned to 13 April 1981.
(2) Liberty is reserved to any party to apply on fourteen days notice to the other parties and to the Court. Orders accordingly.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case came before the court as an urgent application seeking various orders to manage the immediate operations of the Sydney Branch of Mister Figgins Pty Ltd. The application was filed to address the immediate need for a functioning Branch Secretary, to ensure financial obligations were met, and to oversee an election for new Branch officers. Prior to this application, Palmer had been dismissed from his position as Branch Secretary following charges of misconduct, which he contested. The procedural history includes the filing of an application for relief, the consideration of submissions from both parties, and the making of orders by the court to ensure the continued operation of the Branch in accordance with the organization's rules.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the rules providing for the dismissal of the Branch Secretary were valid and properly applied in this case.
2. Whether the rule amending another rule is mandatory or directory and if the express general power to amend is contrary to s.140(1) of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904.
3. Whether the failure to grant an application for adjournment was a breach of natural justice.
4. Whether the holding of incompatible offices or the resignation by conduct constitutes a repudiation of the agreement between the parties.
Held
1. The court found that the rules providing for the dismissal of the Branch Secretary were valid and properly applied in this case.
2. The court determined that the rule amending another rule was directory rather than mandatory and that the express general power to amend was not contrary to s.140(1) of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904.
3. The court concluded that the failure to grant an application for adjournment did not constitute a breach of natural justice.
4. The court held that holding incompatible offices or resigning by conduct did not amount to a repudiation of the agreement between the parties.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the validity and application of the rules governing the dismissal of the Branch Secretary. It found that the rules were consistent with the organisation's constitution and thus valid. The court noted that the dismissal of the Branch Secretary was carried out in accordance with the established rules and procedures, thereby upholding the decision as properly applied.
In addressing the rule amendment issue, the court concluded that the amendment process, while not strictly mandatory, was within the organisation's authority to make such changes. The express general power to amend, as outlined in the constitution, did not contravene s.140(1) of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904, which pertains to the internal governance of organisations.
Regarding the failure to grant an adjournment, the court found that there was no evidence of bias or procedural unfairness that would constitute a breach of natural justice. The court emphasised that the decision-making process was fair and transparent, and the failure to adjourn did not prejudice the applicant's rights.
Lastly, the court examined the issue of holding incompatible offices and resigning by conduct. It determined that these actions, in themselves, did not signify a repudiation of the agreement between the parties. The court held that such conduct did not breach any specific terms of the agreement and therefore did not constitute a repudiation.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that rules governing the internal management and governance of an organisation are valid and enforceable, provided they are consistent with the organisation's constitution. Additionally, the court upheld the principle that amendments to rules and procedures can be made through express general powers, as long as they do not contravene statutory provisions. Furthermore, the court reaffirmed that procedural fairness and natural justice require a fair and unbiased decision-making process, but minor procedural errors do not necessarily invalidate the outcome if no prejudice is shown. Finally, the court clarified that holding incompatible offices or resigning by conduct does not inherently amount to a repudiation of an agreement, absent specific terms that define such actions as a breach.