Cassidy v NRMA Health Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Cassidy v NRMA Health Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1228

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – whether advertising agency could be liable as a principal rather than via accessorial liability.

WORDS & PHRASES – “representation”.

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act2001 (Cth), ss 12DA, 12DB, 12GB, 12GD, 12GF, 12GI and 12GM.
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 52(1), 53, 65A, 75B, 79, 80, 82 and 87.

Webb v Bloch (1928) 41 CLR 331 considered
Taco Company of Australia Inc v Taco Bell Pty Limited (1982) 42 ALR 177 applied
Universal Telecasters (Qld) Limited v Guthrie (1978) 18 ALR 531 applied
Thompson v Riley McKay Pty Limited (1980) 29 ALR 267 applied
Barton v Croner Trading Pty Limited (1984) 3 FCR 95 applied
Gardam v George Wills & Co Ltd (1988) 82 ALR 415 considered
Brown v Jam Factory Pty Ltd (1981) 35 ALR 79 referred to
Thompson v Australian Capital Television Pty Limited (1996) 186 CLR 574 referred to
Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661 referred to

Gatley on Libel & Slander, 9th ed, 1998.

BRIAN CASSIDY, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION & AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES
AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION v NRMA HEALTH PTY LIMITED (ACN 075 799 236) & NRMA INSURANCE LIMITED (ACN 000 016 722) & SAATCHI & SAATCHI AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 001 720 921)
N 3011 of 2001

JACOBSON J
3 OCTOBER 2002

SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 3011 of 2001

BETWEEN:

BRIAN CASSIDY
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION
AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
FIRST APPLICANT

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES
AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

NRMA HEALTH PTY LIMITED
ACN 075 799 236
FIRST RESPONDENT

NRMA INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 000 016 722
FOURTH RESPONDENT

SAATCHI & SAATCHI AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
ACN 001 720 921
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

JACOBSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 OCTOBER 2002

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The application is dismissed.
  2. The applicants pay the fifth respondent’s costs of the proceedings.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 3011 of 2001

BETWEEN:

BRIAN CASSIDY
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION
AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
FIRST APPLICANT

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES
AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

NRMA HEALTH PTY LIMITED ACN 075 799 236
FIRST RESPONDENT

NRMA INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 000 016 722
FOURTH RESPONDENT

SAATCHI & SAATCHI AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
ACN 001 720 921
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

JACOBSON J

DATE:

3 OCTOBER 2002

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. In July and August 2001, NRMA Health Pty Limited and NRMA Insurance Limited (“the NRMA companies”) ran a series of newspaper advertisements for a new health insurance product under the caption “Closing the Gap”.  The substance of the advertisements was that pregnant women would be able to have their babies delivered without making any payment for hospitalisation or medical expenses.

  2. The advertisements stated that the NRMA companies would…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cassidy v NRMA Health Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1228
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cassidy v NRMA Health Pty Ltd, the plaintiff sought to hold Saatchi, an advertising agency, liable for misleading representations made in advertisements that were developed for and published by NRMA Health. The court had to determine whether Saatchi could be held responsible for the misleading content of the advertisements despite not being the publisher or the direct author of the statements. The central issue before the court was whether Saatchi, as the advertising agency, could be considered the maker of the misleading representations in the advertisements, thereby making it liable under the Australian Consumer Law. The court examined the nature of Saatchi’s involvement in creating and approving the advertisements, the role of NRMA Health in the approval process, and the perception of the advertisements by the public.

The court found that the question of who made the misrepresentation in the advertisements was a matter of fact, to be determined by considering the form and content of the advertisement against all relevant circumstances. The court held that the advertisements were clearly presented as those of NRMA Health, not Saatchi, and that there was no indication in the advertisements themselves that Saatchi had made the misleading representations. The court also noted that the public perception, as evidenced by the affidavit of Ms Maree Wilmhurst, aligned with the view that the advertisements were those of NRMA Health. The court concluded that Saatchi could not be held liable for the misleading representations made in the advertisements, as the advertisements did not convey that Saatchi was the source of the misrepresentations.

The court dismissed the application and ordered the applicants to pay the costs of the proceedings. This decision underscores the importance of the public's perception and the explicit content of advertisements in determining liability for misleading representations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the fifth respondent’s costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Saatchi admits that the advertisements were misleading but denies that the misleading representations contained in the advertisements were made by Saatchi. Thus, the only issue which arises is whether Saatchi is liable as a principal for making misleading representations in the advertisements.The Facts Saatchi commenced providing advertising services to NRMA Limited in about 1993. The relationship between Saatchi and NRMA Limited was recorded in an agency agreement entered into in September1998. The practice, which was followed between the parties, was that when the NRMA companies wanted Saatchi to develop an advertising campaign, they would send Saatchi a “communications brief” which contained essential information about the campaign, which the NRMA companies wanted Saatchi to develop. The next step was that Saatchi would prepare an “ideas brief” for the NRMA companies setting out the approach, which Saatchi intended to take in creating a suitable advertisement for the campaign. If the NRMA companies approved the ideas brief, Saatchi’s creative personnel would prepare and design the advertisements in accordance with the concepts set out in the ideas brief. The creative team would then prepare drafts, which were sent to the NRMA companies for approval. There would usually be an exchange of comments between the parties before the NRMA companies gave their final approval to the form of the advertisement. The practice was for the draft advertisements to be reviewed by the NRMA companies’ marketing personnel who had issued the campaign instructions. It was part of the practice that the drafts were also reviewed by members of the NRMA companies’ in-house legal advisers. The various steps in the practice as set out above were followed in the present case. Legal sign-off for the advertisements was provided by an in-house solicitor employed by the NRMA companies (or NRMA Limited). Mr Leppard, Saatchi’s Group Accounts Director, responsible for preparation of the advertising campaign, was aware that the NRMA companies had obtained legal sign-off from the solicitor. The final drafts bore the word “approved” in the handwriting of the solicitor. Saatchi did not place the advertisements in the newspapers for the NRMA companies. A separate company, Zenith Media Pty Limited (“Zenith”), which is unrelated to Saatchi, was engaged by the NRMA companies to decide in which publications the advertisements were to appear. Zenith then purchased the necessary space in the publications on behalf of the NRMA companies. Each of the published advertisements had the name “Saatchi” followed by Saatchi’s “key number” in the bottom right hand corner of the advertisement immediately after the provisos, which referred to the policy excess and co-payment. The name “Saatchi’s” and the key number were in even smaller font than the provisos. Mr Leppard’s unchallenged evidence was that the key number was a unique identification number assigned by Saatchi to the job. The purpose of the key number was to identify the advertisement, which was to be published so as to ensure that it found its way to the correct edition of the newspaper. Mr Leppard said that this was important because there were slight variations in the form of the advertisement for publication in different States of Australia.Statutory provisions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JACOBSON J
Mr Gageler also submitted that the analogy to the law of defamation is misplaced. This is because the Act and the TPA distinguish quite clearly between principal and accessory liability whereas, under the common law rules of defamation, all who are accessories are treated as publishers of the defamatory statements. The harshness of that rule is then ameliorated by the availability to each “principal” of a wide range of defences including innocent dissemination and qualified privilege.Decision The case was pleaded and conducted upon the footing that Saatchi engaged in misleading conduct by making misrepresentations that the NRMA companies would make all payments of hospital and medical expenses for the delivery of babies for pregnant mothers who were members of the fund. Thus, as stated above, the only issue is whether Saatchi made that misrepresentation. In Taco Company of Australia Inc v Taco Bell Pty Limited (1982) 42 ALR 177 at 202, Deane and Fitzgerald JJ said that whether or not conduct amounts to a misrepresentation is a question of fact which is to be decided by considering what is said and what is done against the background of all relevant surrounding circumstances. It seems to me to follow from this that the question of who made the misrepresentation must also be a question of fact to be decided by considering the form and content of the advertisement. The role of Saatchi as the advertising agency, which created the advertisement, can only be a relevant surrounding circumstance, in my view, if there were facts, which were brought home to the relevant section of the public that would establish that Saatchi made the alleged misrepresentations. In my view, there is nothing in the advertisement, which could possibly convey to the relevant section of the public that the representation was made by Saatchi. It seems to me to be clear that anyone reading the advertisement would read it as the NRMA companies’ advertisement. That is the view, which I take of the advertisement when considering it objectively. In my opinion, this finding is supported by the only affidavit evidence adduced by the applicants in these proceedings. The evidence was that of Ms Maree Wilmhurst who read a version of the advertisement which was published in South Australia. The advertisement in the “Sunday Mail” of 8 July 2001 was an advertisement for SGIC Health, which is apparently a related company of the NRMA companies. Ms Wilmhurst said that she understood the advertisement to be a statement made by SGIC Health. She said she felt that she had been misled by SGIC Health. Her affidavit made no mention of Saatchi. I do not accept the submission of the applicants that the name “Saatchi’s” in the bottom right hand corner of the advertisement converts what would otherwise have been an advertisement of the NRMA companies into a joint advertisement of the NRMA companies and Saatchi. That is not the way Ms Wilmhurst read the advertisement. Moreover, the size of the print is so small that it stands in stark contrast to the impression created by a fair reading of the whole of the advertisement that the representations contained within it were those of the NRMA companies.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JACOBSON J

Full text does not contain this section.