Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1703

TRADE PRACTICES - misleading or deceptive conduct - certain Slendertone electronic muscle stimulation machines – whether representations of performance characteristics in promotion and advertising misleading or deceptive – supply of research and leaflets by overseas supplier - express representations – no implied representations -  reasonableness of reliance on supplied information – liability of each of the respondents – cross-claim by respondents against supplier not made out

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51A, 51A(2), 52, 53(c), 75B, 80(1)(a)(i), 80(1)(c), 80(1)(e), 82, 84(2), 87, 87(1)(A)

The Australian Concise Oxford Dictionary (2nd ed, Oxford University Press, Melbourne, 1992)
The New Shorter Oxford English Dictionary (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1993)

‘Comparison of Isometric Exercise and High Volt Galvanic Stimulation on Quadriceps Femoris Muscle Strength’ (1985) 65(5) Physical Therapy 149
‘Effects of Electrical Muscle Stimulation on Body Composition, Muscle Strength, and Physical Appearance’ (2002) 16(2) Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research 165
‘Effects of Electrical Stimulation or Voluntary Contraction for Strengthening the Quadriceps Femoris Muscles in an Aged Male Population’ (1994) 20(1) Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy 22
‘Electrical Stimulation in Exercise of the Quadriceps Femoris Muscle’ (1979) 59(12) Physical Therapy 117
‘Neuromuscular Electrical Stimulation’ (1992) 13(5) Sports Medicine 320
‘Neuromuscular Extra Stimulation and Voluntary Exercise’ (1992) 13(5) Sports Medicine Journal 320
‘Strength Changes in the Normal Quadriceps Femoris Muscle as a Result of Electrical Stimulation’ (1983) 63(4) Physical Therapy 123
AL Baker, Neuromuscular Electrical Stimulation: A Practical Guide (4th ed)
HJ Appell and M Cabric, Institute of Experimental Morphology of Cologne University Sports Academy, ‘The Use of Electrical Stimulation for Strengthening of Muscles in Therapy and Rehabilitation’ (1987) Physikalische Therapie

Austotel Management Pty Ltd v Jamieson (1996) 57 FCR 411
Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Turnbull & Partners (1991) 33 FCR 265
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Black on White Pty Ltd (2001) 110 FCR 1
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Danoz Direct Pty Ltd (2003) 60 IPR 296
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 595
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Giraffe World Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) (1999) 95 FCR 302
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v IMB Group Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 17
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v IMB Group Pty Ltd (1999) ATPR 41-704
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Optell Pty Ltd (1998) ATPR 41-640
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Universal Sports Challenge Ltd [2002] FCA 1276
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v National Exchange Pty Ltd (2003) 202 ALR 24
Bialkower v Acohs Pty Ltd (1998) 83 FCR 1
Bill Acceptance Corporation Ltd v GWA Ltd (1983) 50 ALR 242
Bowler v Hilda Pty Ltd (1998) 80 FCR 191
Burke v LFOT Pty Ltd (2002) 209 CLR 282
Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 45
Cassidy v NRMA Health Pty Ltd (2002) ATPR 41-891
City…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Oce... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 1703
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed a case against Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd, alleging violations of Part V of the Competition and Consumer Act. The dispute involved claims that Emerald Ocean Distributors aided or was knowingly involved in the contravention of these provisions by another entity. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the legal issues surrounding the nature of the involvement and the extent of the injunctive relief applicable to the parties involved.

The court needed to decide whether Emerald Ocean Distributors had sufficient knowledge of the essential elements of the contravention to be considered involved under sections 80(1)(c) and 80(1)(e). The court examined whether the company's knowledge could be inferred from wilful blindness, a deliberate avoidance of awareness of the contravention. Additionally, the court had to assess the credibility and implications of the evidence provided by expert witnesses on the effectiveness of the contested products.

The Federal Court concluded that the evidence did not support a finding that Emerald Ocean Distributors had the requisite knowledge to be held liable under the Act. The court found that the cross-claimants were unable to claim indemnity or contribution from the cross-respondent and dismissed the claims for damages, as there was no causal connection between the conduct of Emerald Ocean Distributors and the losses suffered. The court also ruled that certain specific claims for loss, such as those related to salary and motor vehicle sales, could not be substantiated.

The court ordered that draft orders be filed to reflect these conclusions, with subsequent submissions and responses to be made within specified timeframes. The proceeding was reserved for the final determination of orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 10 days the applicant file and serve draft orders to give effect to the reasons delivered on 25 November 2005.

2. Within a further 10 days the respondents/cross-claimants file and serve any written submission in support of any variations to the applicant’s draft.

3. Within a further 4 days the applicant file and serve any written submissions in response.

4. From compliance with the above directions the proceeding stand reserved for the making of orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an action by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) against Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd, alleging contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law. The ACCC claims that Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd and related entities engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to the sale of certain electrical muscle stimulation (EMS) products, namely the Gym Body 8, Top Tone 12, and Sequence 16. The ACCC alleges that the representations made about these products, including claims about their effectiveness in toning muscles and increasing metabolic rate, were false and misleading. The case includes expert evidence from Dr Coombes, Dr Bakker, and Mr Wright, who tested the EMS products and provided reports on their effectiveness. The expert evidence is used to assess the truthfulness of the representations made by Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd about the EMS products. The case revolves around whether the defendants had knowledge of the misleading nature of the representations and whether their actions constitute aiding, abetting, counselling, or being knowingly concerned in the contravention of the Australian Consumer Law.

The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with the primary hearing followed by an appeal to the Full Court. The matter came before the court following an application by the ACCC for injunctive relief and damages against Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd. The initial decision was made in favour of the ACCC, finding that the defendants had contravened the Australian Consumer Law by making misleading representations about their EMS products. The defendants appealed the decision, arguing that the cross-claimants' conduct and contractual agreements negated any reliance on the misleading representations. The Full Court reviewed the evidence and submissions from both parties and issued its decision, affirming the primary judge's findings and dismissing the appeal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Injunctive relief may extend to persons involved in another’s contravention of the provisions of Pt V of the Act. Such involvement will arise if the other person has aided, abetted, counselled or procured the contravention or was knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the contravention: s 80(1)(c) and 80(1)(e). This requires that the person has knowledge of the essential elements that make up the contravention (whether or not he knows that those matters constitute a contravention): Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661 per Mason ACJ, Wilson, Deane and Dawson JJ at 667, and at 670; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v IMB Group Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 17 at [135]; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Giraffe World (No 2) at [190]-[194]; Wheeler Grace and Pierucci Pty Ltd v Wright at 50,257; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Black on White Pty Ltd (2001) 110 FCR 1. Wilful blindness will not protect the person against inference of knowledge. Knowledge can be inferred from wilful blindness, that is the deliberate shutting of one’s eyes to what it going on: Giorgianni v R (1985) 156 CLR 473 at 482-483 and at 507-508; and Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v IMB Group Pty Ltd at [135].EVIDENCEEXPERT WITNESSES It is convenient later in these reasons to summarise the effect of the evidence of expert witnesses in conjunction with consideration of particular alleged representations. The following is the background of each of the experts together with a description of the general character of their evidence.Applicant’s experts The applicant called as experts Dr Coombes, Dr Bakker and Mr Wright. Dr Coombes Dr Coombes has a Bachelor of Applied Science and a PhD obtained in 1958. He is the senior lecturer in Exercise Science at the University of Queensland, teaching and conducting research in exercise physiology, nutrition and exercise and muscle physiology. His publications include a number of studies using electrical stimulation to activate muscle contraction to test the effects of different treatments on force production and fatigue. He has worked in the health and fitness industry for over 10 years in various capacities including fitness assessor, personal trainer and gym manager. He has experience in EMS products and has studied the literature and review articles concerning EMS. In his report Dr Coombes said he was supplied with three Slendertone products, the Gym Body 8, Top Tone 12 and Sequence 16. He was instructed by the applicant’s lawyers to test the devices and comment on the truthfulness of the representations made concerning the Slendertone products. He was instructed to prepare a report that detailed the nature of the tests carried out and the methodology used by him in conducting the tests. Dr Coombes said that the aim of the test was to determine the effect of using the EMS devices on metabolic rate. Because of problems with the sequence 16 that was supplied only two devices were tested, the Gym Body 8 and the Top Tone 12.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
The Full Court has commented that the remedy conferred by s 52 of the Act would not be lost whatever the parties may provide in their agreement: Henjo Investments Pty Ltd v Collins Marrickville Pty Ltd (No.1) (1988) 39 FCR 546. However, the Full Court has also accepted that exclusion clauses in contracts may operate to negate reliance: Keen Mar Corporation Pty Ltd v Labrador Shopping Centre Pty Ltd (1989) ATPR 46-048 at 53,151; and Poulet Frais Pty Ltd v The Silver Fox Company Pty Ltd (2005) 220 ALR 211 at [98]-[108]. BMR submits that the exclusion clause, either on its own or having regard to the total relationship between the cross-claimants and BMR, had the effect that the cross-claimants’ own conduct was the cause of the loss. In my view lack of reliance is so clearly established by the evidence previously addressed, it is not necessary to specifically consider this defence save to note there may be a significant distinction between the contractual documentation at issue in Poulet Frais and that at issue here.CONCLUSION ON CROSS-CLAIM For the above reasons I conclude, as BMR’s submissions contend, that:(a)the cross-claimants are not able to claim an indemnity or contribution from the cross-respondent;(b)the claim for damages is appropriately characterised as a claim for indemnity or contribution;(c)even if a claim for indemnity or contribution were permitted or the claim for damages was allowed as such, there was no conduct of BMR causally connected to any loss or damage suffered by the cross-claimants;(d)the claims by Mr O’Donoghue for loss of salary, loss from the sale of his motor vehicle, loss of rent and loss from the redemption of his life insurance policy cannot be made out. Accordingly, the cross-claim should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

The court examined the evidence and expert testimonies to determine whether Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd and related entities engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct concerning the sale of EMS products. The court relied on the definition under the Australian Consumer Law and found that the entities did indeed engage in such conduct. Expert witnesses, such as Dr. Coombes, provided evidence that the representations made about the EMS products were false and misleading. The court noted that knowledge of the misleading nature of the representations could be inferred from wilful blindness, as established in previous cases such as Giorgianni v R and Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v IMB Group Pty Ltd. Considering the evidence, the court found that Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd had knowledge of the misleading nature of the representations. The court further examined the applicability of injunctive relief and concluded that it was appropriate in this case to prevent further contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law. The cross-claimants' claims for indemnity or contribution from Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd were dismissed, as the court found that there was no causal connection between the cross-claimants' conduct and any loss or damage suffered.