FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
ACCC v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 595
PROCEDURE – proposed cross-claim – proposed cross-respondent an overseas corporation – claim for indemnification – whether proper basis for claim – whether arguable basis under Trade Practices Act (1974) (Cth) – whether arguable basis in common law or equity – whether leave should be granted
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53(c), 75B(1), 87(1A)
Newave Investments Ltd v Complete Command SDNBHD [1999] FCA 1537, cited
Re La Rosa: Ex parte Norgard v Rodpat Nominees Pty Ltd (1991) 104 ALR 237, followed
Bialkower v Acohs Pty Ltd (1999) ATPR 41-685, applied
Lezam Pty Ltd v Seabridge Australia Pty Ltd (1992) 35 FCR 535, distinguished
Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661, followedAUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v EMERALD OCEAN DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD, SLEDERTONE HEALTH AND BEAUTY PTY LTD and SEAN O’DONOGHUE
W 118 of 2000RD NICHOLSON J
24 MAY 2001
PERTH
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
W 118 of 2000
BETWEEN:
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANTAND:
EMERALD OCEAN DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENTSLENDERTONE HEALTH AND BEAUTY PTY LTD
SECOND RESPONDENTSEAN O'DONOGHUE
THIRD RESPONDENTJUDGE:
RD NICHOLSON J
DATE OF ORDER:
24 MAY 2001
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The respondents’ motion to file a cross-claim be refused.
2.The respondents pay the applicant’s costs on the motion.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
W 118 of 2000
BETWEEN:
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANTAND:
EMERALD OCEAN DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENTSLENDERTONE HEALTH AND BEAUTY PTY LTD
SECOND RESPONDENTSEAN O'DONOGHUE
THIRD RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
RD NICHOLSON J
DATE:
24 MAY 2001
PLACE:
PERTH
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
By motion the respondents seek leave to file a cross-claim in accordance with a minute of amended proposed cross-claim. The proposed cross-claim seeks to join a company registered in the Republic of Ireland (Bio-Medical Research Ltd) as cross-respondent.
The entitlement of a respondent to cross-claim against any person “whether another party or a third party” for any relief which is related to or connected with the subject of the proceeding including, contribution or indemnity, is recognised by the provisions of O 5 r 1 of the Federal Court Rules (“FCR”). Order 5 r 8 provides that subject to r 9, a respondent may not cross-claim against “any other person not being a party” without leave of the court: FCR O 5 r 8(1). Rule 9 provides that the leave of the court is necessary where the cross-claim is made after the directions hearing.
Here it is accepted that the effect of the Rules is to require the leave of the Court for the respondents’ cross-claim to be allowed. For the applicant the position is taken that no opposition is mounted to the application for leave on any procedural ground arising from…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Oce... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] FCA 595
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the respondents could rely on section 87(1A) of the Competition and Consumer Act to claim indemnity or contribution against the proposed cross-respondent. The court considered the relevant provisions of the Act and the principles of equitable contribution. The court found that section 87(1A) does not provide a mechanism for the court to make orders for contribution or indemnity against other contravenors of the Act or persons involved in the primary contravention. The court held that the claims in the proposed cross-claim were ones for total indemnification, which is not permitted under the doctrine of contributions. The court also noted that if the respondents could provide evidence of the proposed cross-respondent's involvement in the contraventions, they should bring a separate action for indemnity or contribution.
The court held that the respondents' motion to file a cross-claim should be refused. The court found that the respondents could not rely on section 87(1A) of the Competition and Consumer Act to claim indemnity or contribution against the proposed cross-respondent. The court held that the claims in the proposed cross-claim were ones for total indemnification, which is not permitted under the doctrine of contributions. The court also noted that if the respondents could provide evidence of the proposed cross-respondent's involvement in the contraventions, they should bring a separate action for indemnity or contribution. The court refused the respondents' motion to file a cross-claim and ordered the respondents to pay the applicant's costs on the motion.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The respondents’ motion to file a cross-claim be refused.
2. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs on the motion.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Accordingly, it is said there is nothing to sustain any claim for co-ordinate liability imposed on the parties by the Act. It is submitted the claim by the respondents against the proposed cross-respondent is, in essence, a separate claim for separate relief from that claimed by the applicant.Consideration of contentions Section 87(1A) of the Act reads as follows:“(1A) Without limiting the generality of section 80, the Court may, on the application of a person who has suffered, or is likely to suffer, loss or damage by conduct of another person that was engaged in (whether before or after the commencement of this subsection) in contravention of a provision of Part IVA, IVB or V or on the application of the Commission in accordance with subsection (1B) on behalf of such a person or 2 or more such persons, make such order or orders as the Court thinks appropriate against the person who engaged in the conduct or a person who was involved in the contravention (including all or any of the orders mentioned in subsection (2)) if the Court considers that the order or orders concerned will compensate the person who made the application, or the person or any of the persons on whose behalf the application was made, in whole or in part for the loss or damage, or will prevent or reduce the loss or damage suffered, or likely to be suffered, by such a person.”That subsection is to be read together with s 87(2)(d) which provides that the orders referred to subs (1) and (1A) are:“…(d)an order directing the person who engaged in the conduct or a person who was involved in the contravention constituted by the conduct to pay to the person who suffered the loss or damage the amount of the loss or damage;…” In La Rosa the proposed third cross-claim was one for indemnification or contribution from two persons if the cross-claimants were found to be liable to a bank. The basis of the claim was reliance upon s 87(1A) of the Act or in the alternative the principles of equitable contribution. In the course of this reasons (at 242) French J said:“It was stated from the bar table that there is no authority on the question whether s 87(1A) can be invoked to provide for indemnity or contribution under the Trade Practices Act. In my opinion, the reason for that scarcity is that the proposition is untenable. Section 87(1A) contemplates an application by “a person who has suffered or is likely to suffer loss or damage by conduct of another person…in contravention of a provision of Part V”. Now it was contended that this would extend to a person who has suffered a judgment for contravention of the Act in which contravention another person was involved. But the Act contemplates that the applicant for relief under s 87(1A) is not the person who contravenes the relevant provisions of Part V. That becomes clearer when it is seen that before the court can make an order under this subsection, it must consider that the order or orders will compensate the person who made the application. And to the extent that s 87(2)(d) is relevant, it does not define the categories of person who may seek damages. In my opinion, there is no mechanism in s 87, nor in the Act generally, which would enable the court to make orders for contribution or indemnity against other contravenors of the Act or persons involved in the primary contravention. On this basis the third cross-claim could not succeed at all against Wheatley or Hughes nor, to the extent that it relies upon s 87, against Dolling and O’Neale.”He went on to consider the second foundation for the third cross-claim in equitable contribution. He found that against some proposed cross-respondents arguably a claim of coordinate liability existed which could be the subject of contribution proceedings. He did not consider that an indemnity claim was open or that any claim based upon s 87 of the Act was available. In respect of the indemnity claims he said (at 244):“So far as the indemnity claims are concerned, there is no tenable generalisation of the principle underlying the doctrine of contributions as enunciated in the Albion Insurance case that would allow one of two persons under coordinate liabilities to claim a complete indemnity from the other. A claim for contribution is, by its very nature, one to rateable relief. The very purpose of the doctrine where it applies, is to avoid throwing the whole burden of liability on one of those liable to the exclusion of others: Commercial and General Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1973) 129 CLR 374 at 380.”In its terms and as supported in argument to the Court the claims in the proposed cross-claim are ones for total indemnification.