Lezam Pty Ltd v Seabridge Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

Re: LEZAM PTY. LIMITED and JLW (NSW) PTY. LIMITED
And: SEABRIDGE AUSTRALIA PTY. LIMITED; JLW (NSW) and LEZAM
Nos. G296 and G299 of 1991
FED No. 268
Trade Practices
(1992) 14 ATPR 41-171
(1992) 107 ALR 291

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Sheppard(1), Burchett(2) and Hill(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS

Trade Practices (consumer protection) - lease of city office building - statements made by estate agent on behalf of lessor as to area to be let - statements made in context of rental to be charged per square metre or square foot of space - statements made in letter containing the statement "subject to survey" and a disclaimer clause - lease entered into without reference to the rental having been calculated according to the area to be let - discovery by lessee after rental review that area substantially less than that stated orally and in correspondence - whether lessor and estate agent engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct - significance of the words "subject to survey" and disclaimer clause - whether misleading or deceptive conduct occasioned lessee loss or damage - cross-claims brought by lessor and estate agent against each other - whether agent entitled to indemnity from principal for any amount for which it liable to lessor - whether agent had acted negligently - whether negligence on part of agent would avoid the lessor's liability under an indemnity.

Trade Practices Act 1974, ss.52, 82, 87.

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 13:5:1992

No. G296 of 1991
Counsel for the Appellant : Mr D.F. Jackson, QC with
Lezam Pty. Limited Mr F.G. Lever

Solicitors for the Appellant : Landerer and Co.
Lezam Pty. Limited

Counsel for the Respondent,
Seabridge Australia Pty. Limited : Mr R.J. Ellicott, QC

with Mr D.M. Yates

Solicitors for the Respondent,
Seabridge Australia Pty. Limited : Sly and Weigall

Counsel for the Respondent,
JLW (NSW) Pty. Limited : Mr J.D. Heydon, QC with

Mr G.C. Lindsay

Solicitors for the Respondent,
JLW (NSW) Pty. Limited : Moore and Bevins

No. G299 of 1991
Counsel for the Appellant,
JLW (NSW) Pty. Limited : Mr J.I. Heydon, QC with

Mr G.C. Lindsay

Solicitors for the Appellant,

JLW (NSW) Pty. Limited : Moore and Bevins

Counsel for the Respondent,
Seabridge Australia Pty. Limited : Mr R.J. Ellicott, QC with

Mr D.M. Yates

Counsel for the Respondent,

Lezam Pty. Limited : Sly and Weigall

Counsel for the Respondent,
Lezam Pty. Limited : Mr I.F. Jackson, QC with

Mr F.G. Lever

Solicitors for the Respondent,

Lezam Pty. Limited : Landerer and Co.

ORDER

Matter No. G296 of 1991

The Court orders that:-

1. The appeal be allowed in part.

2. The orders made by Beaumont J. on 12 April 1991 and 6 June 1991 be set aside.

3. There be a new trial:-

(a) (insofar as the appeal concerns the orders made in favour of the first respondent against the appellant), of the questions of whether the first respondent suffered loss or damage as a consequence of…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lezam Pty Ltd v Seabridge Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] FCA 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lezam Pty Ltd (the lessee) brought an action against Seabridge Australia Pty Ltd (the lessor) and its estate agent, alleging that misleading and deceptive conduct led to financial loss. The dispute arose from a lease agreement for a city office building, where the lessor and the estate agent allegedly provided inaccurate information about the area to be leased. This information was given in the context of the rental rate per square metre or square foot. Despite the disclaimers and the phrase "subject to survey" present in the correspondence, the lease was executed without reference to the area stated. After a rental review, the lessee discovered that the area was significantly less than initially represented. The court was required to determine if the lessor and the estate agent engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, and if so, whether this conduct caused loss or damage to the lessee. Additionally, the lessor and the estate agent filed cross-claims against each other, with the estate agent seeking indemnity from the lessor for any liability it might incur.

The court's reasoning centred on the significance of the disclaimer and the phrase "subject to survey" in the context of the misleading or deceptive conduct claim. The court found that the disclaimer and the survey clause did not absolve the lessor and the estate agent from liability. However, the court held that the lessee had not proven that it suffered loss or damage due to the misleading or deceptive conduct. Therefore, the court set aside the orders made in favour of the lessee and ordered a new trial to determine whether the lessee suffered loss or damage, and to address the cross-claims between the lessor and the estate agent. The court also addressed the issue of costs, ordering that the costs of the proceedings at first instance be at the discretion of the judge hearing the new trial, and that the lessee pay one quarter of the costs of the appeal brought by the lessor against the orders made in favour of the lessee.

In summary, the court allowed the appeals in part, set aside the orders made in favour of the lessee, and ordered a new trial to determine the extent of loss or damage to the lessee and to address the cross-claims between the lessor and the estate agent. The court further directed that the costs of the proceedings at first instance be in the discretion of the judge hearing the new trial, and that the lessee pay one quarter of the costs of the appeal brought by the lessor against the orders made in favour of the lessee.

Orders

Orders of the court

Matter No. G296 of 1991

The Court orders that:-

1. The appeal be allowed in part.

2. The orders made by Beaumont J. on 12 April 1991 and 6 June 1991 be set aside.

3. There be a new trial:-

(a) (insofar as the appeal concerns the orders made in favour of the first respondent against the appellant), of the questions of whether the first respondent suffered loss or damage as a consequence of the misleading or deceptive conduct engaged in by the appellant and of the relief (if any) to which the first respondent is entitled from the appellant.

(b) of the cross-claim brought by the appellant against the second respondent.

4. The costs of the proceedings at first instance are to be in the discretion of the judge hearing the new trial.

5. The first respondent pay to the appellant one quarter of the costs of the appeal brought by the appellant against the orders made in favour of the first respondent.

6. There be no order as to the costs of the appeal brought by the appellant in relation to the cross-claim.

7. There be liberty to apply.

Matter No. G299 of 1991

The Court orders that:-

1. The appeal be allowed in part.

2. The orders made by Beaumont J. on 12 April 1991 and 6 June 1991 be set aside.

3. There be a new trial:-

(a) (insofar as the appeal concerns the orders made in favour of the first respondent against the appellant), of the questions of whether the first respondent suffered loss or damage as a consequence of the misleading or deceptive conduct engaged in by the appellant and of the relief (if any) to which the first respondent is entitled from the appellant.

(b) of the cross-claim brought by the appellant against the second respondent.

4. The costs of the proceedings at first instance are to be in the discretion of the judge hearing the new trial.

5. The first respondent pay to the appellant one quarter of the costs of the appeal brought by the appellant against the orders made in favour of the first respondent.

6. There be no order as to the costs of the appeal brought by the appellant in relation to the cross-claim.

7. There be liberty to apply.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.