Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 7)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 7) [2008] FCA 1364

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct pursuant to sections 52 and 53A Trade Practice Act 1974 (Cth) (the Act) – sale of citrus orchards – multiple alleged representations – written and oral representations – whether falsity of representations established on evidence – whether materiality in inaccuracy of trading figures a relevant consideration  – silence as misleading or deceptive conduct – possibility of employee resigning – non-disclosure of management records – non-disclosure of internal working documents – whether obligation to disclose

TRADE PRACTICES – representations with respect to future matters pursuant to section 51A of the Act – reversal of onus of proof – whether representations made – whether reasonable grounds for making representations – nature of budgetary forecasts – relevance of past performance to reasonableness of future representations

TRADE PRACTICES – accessorial liability pursuant to section 75B of the Act – test established in Yorke v Lucas – knowledge of the essential elements of contravention – adequacy of pleadings

TRADE PRACTICES – whether applicants suffered loss or damage by conduct of respondents pursuant to section 82 of the Act

TRADE PRACTICES – authority to bind body corporate pursuant to section 84 of the Act – whether third respondent’s conduct within scope of actual or apparent authority

EVIDENCE – expert agronomist – admissibility of expert opinion evidence – whether practice direction breached – reliance on unidentified third party data – existence of basis rule pursuant to section 79 Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – whether expert opinion hearsay – relevance of opinion evidence pursuant to sections 55 and 56 Evidence Act – failure of expert to visit property – discretion to exclude evidence pursuant to section 135 Evidence Act – weight attributed to expert opinion based on unidentified sources

EVIDENCE – assessment of witness credibility – weight of evidence given to witness – findings of fact influenced by credit – competing evidence by key witnesses – failure to call witnesses – whether negative inference drawn

EVIDENCE – unsigned statement – weight attributed to unsigned statement – witness not called

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – clarity of pleadings – whether pleadings have sufficient clarity for respondents to meet case

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interest on damages – correct rate of interest owing pursuant to section 51A Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Held: application dismissed – cross-claim allowed – no accessorial liability in second or third respondents

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Pt 5.3A
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 55, 56, 79, 135
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 4, 51A, 52, 53A, 75B, 80, 82, 84, 87
Supreme Court Act (Qld) s 47

Accounting Systems 2000 (Developments) Pty Ltd v CCH Australia Ltd (1993) 42 FCR 470 cited
Adelaide Petroleum NL & Ors v Poseidon Limited & Ors (1988) 10 ATPR 40-901 cited
Alphapharm Pty Ltd v H Lundbeck A/S [2008] FCA 559

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 7) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1364
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd and its associated entities brought proceedings against Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd and its associated entities, alleging breaches of the Australian Consumer Law in relation to representations made about the sale of certain properties. The case was heard over twelve months, with both parties presenting substantial evidence. The primary relief sought by the applicants was against the first respondent, Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd, for alleged breaches of sections 51A, 52, and 53A of the Act.

The legal issues the Court was required to decide centred around whether the respondents had made misleading or deceptive representations in relation to the sale of the properties, and if so, whether the applicants were entitled to any remedies. The applicants argued that the respondents had made misleading representations about the properties and that these breaches were significant enough to warrant compensation. The respondents, on the other hand, denied making any misleading representations and argued that the applicants had failed to prove their case.

The Court considered the evidence provided by both parties, focusing on the credibility of key witnesses, Mr Strahley and Mr Tracy. The Court found that Mr Strahley was an impressive witness who provided clear and comprehensive answers despite being confused about some aspects of the company’s financial reports. The Court rejected the submissions that Mr Strahley's evidence was evasive and unresponsive. The Court also found that Mr Tracy’s evidence was reliable and that he had a thorough knowledge of the citrus industry.

Ultimately, the Court dismissed the applicants' claims, finding that the applicants had not proven their case on the balance of probabilities. The Court held that the respondents had not made any misleading or deceptive representations that would entitle the applicants to any relief. Instead, the Court allowed the cross-claim filed by Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd, finding that the applicants were liable for damages and a loan repayment, along with interest. The Court ordered that the applicants pay the respondents $385,383 for breach of the Packing Shed Agreement, $150,000 for an outstanding loan, and interest at an annual rate of 10% on these amounts.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Amended Application filed 16 February 2006 be dismissed.

2. The Cross-Claim filed 5 June 2007 be allowed as follows:

(a) the Cross-Respondent pay the Cross-Claimant damages in the sum of $385,383 for breach of the Packing Shed Agreement;

(b) the Cross-Respondent pay the Cross-Claimant the sum of $150,000 for a loan which remains due and owing; and

(c) the Cross-Respondent pay the Cross-Claimant interest at the annual rate of 10% on the sums ordered to be paid in sub-paragraphs 2(a) and 2(b) herein pursuant to section 51A

Background

Background to the litigation

The hearing in this matter took place over twelve months, and resulted in the parties tendering a substantial amount of material as evidence. As is common in proceedings involving claims pursuant to Part V of the Act, the success or otherwise of the applicants’ claim turns on the facts before the Court. For this reason, it is appropriate before moving on to a more detailed consideration of the claims of the applicants to outline the background facts.BACKGROUNDThe parties The applicants in these proceedings are the first applicant, Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd; the second applicant, Mr Peter Michael Tracy; and the third applicant, Sunstate Citrus Pty Ltd. At all material times the first applicant was a company duly incorporated according to law, was the sole shareholder in the third applicant, and was the trustee of the Sunstate Orchards Unit Trust. The second applicant, Mr Tracy, was at all material times the sole director and shareholder of the first applicant, and the sole director of the third applicant. In his statement of 17 November 2006, Mr Tracy said that he held tertiary qualifications, namely an Associate Diploma of Arts, a Post Graduate Diploma of Management, and a Masters of Business Administration. Mr Tracy also stated that his work experience was primarily in human resource management with particular emphasis on the mining industry, and that he had no experience, either professional or practical, concerning the citrus or horticultural industries. However it became apparent during cross-examination of Mr Tracy that he was also a director and principal of a company known as The RT Group Pty Ltd, which specialised in assisting the small to medium sector with business turnaround and management techniques (exhibit R21). Under cross-examination from Mr Bell QC, Mr Tracy conceded that he was in fact a “corporate doctor” whose role was to make badly performing operations perform better (TS 309 ll 31-32). The third applicant was at all material times a company duly incorporated according to law and was the trustee of the Sunstate Citrus Trust. It was incorporated by Mr Tracy on 8 February 2005 for the purpose of being the operating entity for the business which was to be conducted on the orchards and Packing Shed (Peter Michael Tracy statement sworn 17 November 2006 at [97]). The third applicant entered voluntary administration on 23 June 2005. It is clear that Mr Tracy was, at all times, the directing mind and will of the first and third applicants. The respondents in these proceedings are the first respondent, Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd; the second respondent, Mr Andrew Strahley; and the third respondent, Mr David Breed. The first respondent, formerly Sunstate Acquisitions Pty Ltd, is a wholly owned subsidiary of Hancock FARM Company Pty Ltd (Hancock). It had originally acquired 80% of the properties in January 2001 for the sum of $5.6 million plus the cultural costs of growing the 2001 crop prior to the purchase (Andrew Colin Strahley affidavit sworn 12 July 2006 at [11]-[14]), and later acquired the remaining 20%. The primary relief sought by the applicants in these proceedings is against the first respondent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In essence, the case of the applicants was that the respondents had acted in breach of s 52 of the Act in relation to all representations, and in breach of ss 51A and 52 in relation to the future representations. Both parties made extensive submissions on this basis. However, although the subject of these proceedings was “land” upon which orchards and a Packing Shed were located, other than pleading that:·the first respondent has acted in breach of s 53A in para 20A Further Amended Statement of Claim; and·Mr Strahley and Mr Breed had accessorial liability in relation to s 53A in para 20B Further Amended Statement of Claim,no issue was made of s 53A in these proceedings by the applicants, and no submissions were made by either party with respect to this section. I shall return to this issue later in the judgment.EVIDENCE OF MR STRAHLEY AND MR TRACY: CREDIT Mr Strahley and Mr Tracy were, obviously, the two key witnesses in these proceedings, an importance reflected in the nature of their evidence and the amount of time each witness spent subject to cross-examination. Indeed Mr Tracy was the only witness whose evidence was adduced by the applicants as to the factual events relevant to the applicants’ claims. Both parties made extensive submissions as to the credit of Mr Tracy and Mr Strahley. The applicants also made submissions concerning other witnesses whose evidence was adduced by the respondents. I will deal with the credit of other witnesses during the course of the judgment.Mr Strahley Counsel for the applicants described the evidence of Mr Strahley as, in summary, uncertain, evasive and unresponsive, and submitted further that Mr Strahley was not an impressive witness. I reject these submissions. In my view Mr Strahley was an impressive witness, who:·clearly had a thorough knowledge of the citrus industry, the operation of the relevant properties as a business, and performance issues relevant to those properties; and·gave responsive and frank answers in the course of rigorous cross-examination over several days. In written submissions the applicants submitted that Mr Strahley gave the impression of being a witness who was “looking for the trap” in every question rather than a witness who was genuinely concerned and enthusiastic to assist the Court to determine the truth of the matters before it. I reject this submission. I find that, while Mr Strahley endeavoured to be careful in his answers, he was nonetheless attempting to properly answer questions put to him and was not attempting in any way, either in his demeanour or his oral answers, to be evasive or unhelpful. Overall I found Mr Strahley’s answers clear and comprehensive over the significant length of time during which he was subject to cross-examination. In their written submissions the applicants further invited me to make adverse findings as to Mr Strahley’s credit in relation to evidence given by Mr Strahley as to contents of Hancock’s financial statements which Mr Strahley had signed as a director, and referred me in particular to an exchange between Mr Perry SC for the applicants and Mr Strahley during cross-examination (TS 992 ll 1-44). However as I indicated to Mr Perry SC during closing submissions, in my view that the evidence given by Mr Strahley in that context indicated no more than the confusion of a company director who, when confronted unexpectedly with the need to explain and justify financial reports he or she may have signed, which reports had been prepared by an expert accountant, is unable to do so properly without a briefing from that accountant. I note that the respondents tendered evidence of an accountant who had participated in preparation of the relevant financial reports, which they submitted explained the relevant financial details and Mr Strahley’s confusion. While it is perhaps regrettable that Mr Strahley as a company director was not able, during rigorous cross-examination on wide-ranging issues over five days, to properly explain the company’s financial reports from several years earlier, I consider that it is not surprising in the circumstances, and that it would not be unusual for many directors in similar circumstances. It does not, in my view, necessarily mean that I should make adverse findings with respect to Mr Strahley’s credit.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
The Packing Shed was located just outside Maryborough (Strahley affidavit sworn 12 July 2006 at [15]-[17]).The decision to sell the properties According to evidence of Mr Strahley, in around May 2004 Hancock decided to consider various options as to the future of the relevant properties because they were not performing in accordance with Hancock’s return criteria (Strahley affidavit sworn 12 July 2006 at [48]). Mr Strahley deposed further that in the ordinary course of business the Hancock properties were re-valued every 2 years, and in June 2004 a valuation report (“1 June 2004 Valuation Report”) was sought from Mr Rex Neubecker of Herron Todd White Valuers (“HTW”) (Strahley affidavit sworn 12 July 2006 at [49]-[55]). Mr Peter Douglas, a real estate agent with Ray White Rural, was engaged from September 2004 to market the Bundaberg and Tiaro orchards and the Packing Shed for the first respondent (Peter Colin Douglas affidavit sworn 6 July 2006 at [13]). The property went to auction on 26 November 2004 and was passed in on a vendor’s bid (Strahley affidavit sworn 12 July 2006 at [60]-[61]).The preliminary discussions between the parties The negotiations between Mr Tracy and the first respondent commenced in November 2004. Mr Tracy had had no previous involvement in either the citrus or horticultural industries, however his attention was drawn to the relevant properties by Mr Douglas in late November 2004 (Douglas affidavit sworn 6 July 2006 at [13]; Tracy statement sworn 17 November 2006 at [1]-[2]). Mr Tracy and Mr Douglas had known each other for several years at that time. Mr Tracy deposed that he expressed an interest in the relevant properties and Mr Douglas suggested that he would arrange a meeting between Mr Tracy, Mr Strahley and himself, and provide Mr Tracy with an information package (Tracy statement sworn 17 November 2006 at [2]-[5]). In late November 2004 Mr Strahley was informed by Mr Douglas that Mr Tracy might have an interest in looking at the properties. Mr Strahley subsequently provided Mr Douglas with the 1 June 2004 Valuation Report, and information and historical data about the performance of the orchards in the form of Block Summary data (which had been created by Mr Breed for internal management purposes) (Strahley affidavit sworn 12 July 2006 at [62]-[67]; Douglas affidavit sworn 6 July 2006 at [17]). Mr Douglas gave evidence that during a telephone conversation with Mr Tracy on 1 December 2004 the prospect of a meeting with Mr Strahley was discussed as well as a proposal he had received from Mr Strahley containing broad terms of sale. These broad terms of sale included:·a purchase price of $4.5 million plus cultural costs;·progressive payment with due dates in January-March 2005; and·the current management team remaining to operate the properties (Douglas affidavit sworn 6 July 2006 at [18]-[19]).The first meeting Throughout the proceedings it was clear that the key players in respect of negotiation of agreements for sale and purchase of the relevant properties were Mr Tracy and Mr Strahley.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J