Shomali v Ecolour Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 89 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Shomali v Ecolour Pty Limited [2013] FCA 899

Citation: Shomali v Ecolour Pty Limited [2013] FCA 899
Parties: BASSAM SHOMALI and ANNE SHOMALI v ECOLOUR PTY LIMITED ACN 137498438, CHIMES MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED ACN 099061382, STUART MCPHEE and BELLE MCPHEE
File number: NSD 2213 of 2011
Judge: JAGOT J
Date of judgment: 5 September 2013
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – sale of business – licensing agreement – representations about sales and future potential – confidential information
Legislation: Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW)
Cases cited: Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 7) [2008] FCA 1364
Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658; [1982] HCA 70
Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Cunningham's Warehouse Sales Pty Ltd (2012) 246 CLR 498; [2012] HCA 7
Placer (Granny Smith) Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd (2003) 196 ALR 257; [2003] HCA 10
Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315
Date of hearing: 22 - 24 July 2013
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 183
Counsel for the Applicants: J E Rawlings
Solicitor for the Applicants: Family Law Solutions
Counsel for the Respondents: The Respondents appeared in person

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 2213 of 2011

BETWEEN:

BASSAM SHOMALI
First Applicant

ANNE SHOMALI
Second Applicant

AND:

ECOLOUR PTY LIMITED ACN 137498438
First Respondent

CHIMES MANAGEMENT PTY LIMITED ACN 099061382
Second Respondent

STUART MCPHEE
Third Respondent

BELLE MCPHEE
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 SEPTEMBER 2013

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By consent and without admissions, within 28 days of the date of this order, the respondents shall:

(a)deliver to the solicitor for the applicants all hard copies of documents in their possession or custody which constitute or relate to the formulae for paint provided to the respondents under the licence from the applicants dated 1 June 2009; and

(b)take all reasonably practical steps to delete from any computer or information storage device in their possession or custody information which constitutes or relates to the formulae for paint provided to the respondents under the licence from the applicants dated 1 June 2009.

2.The originating application and statement of claim be dismissed.

3.The cross-claim be dismissed.

4.Each party pay its own costs of the proceedings.

5.If any party wishes to seek an order for costs contrary to order 4 then that party is to notify all other parties in writing within 14 days of the date of these orders and:

(a)order 4 then be set aside;

(b)within a further 14 days thereafter the party seeking the varied costs order is to file and serve a short written submission identifying the costs order sought and the reasons in support; and

(c)each other party may, within a further 14 days from the date of filing and service of the submissions in accordance with order 5(b), file and serve a short written submission identifying the costs order sought…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shomali v Ecolour Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 899
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Shomali v Ecolour Pty Limited, the primary issues before the court pertained to the contractual obligations and potential breaches in the context of a paint technology licence agreement. The dispute involved multiple claims regarding representations made by the parties, alleged breaches of confidentiality, and the enforceability of certain contractual terms. The plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Shomali, sought remedies for alleged breaches of contract and misleading and deceptive conduct by the defendants, Mr and Mrs McPhee and their company, Chimes Management, as well as Ecolour Pty Limited. The defendants contested these claims, arguing that the plaintiffs were estopped from pursuing them and that there were no breaches of contract or misleading conduct.

The court had to address several legal issues, including whether specific representations made by Mr Shomali to Mr McPhee were misleading and whether the McPhees and Chimes Management acted in reliance on those representations. Another significant issue was whether Chimes Management breached the licence agreement by disclosing the paint technology to Ecolour and by failing to pay the required licence fees. Additionally, the court examined whether Ecolour and Chimes Management had wrongfully used the paint technology, which the Shomalis claimed was confidential. The court also had to consider whether the Shomalis had effectively terminated the licence agreement and whether the McPhees were jointly liable for any breaches by Chimes Management.

In reaching its decision, the court analysed the terms of the licence agreement, particularly clauses 5 and 6, which outlined the payment of royalties and the assistance to be provided by the Shomalis. The court found that the Shomalis had not provided the level of assistance required by the agreement, which undermined the basis for the McPhees' reliance on any representations made by the Shomalis. The court also determined that there were no breaches of confidentiality and that the Shomalis had not effectively terminated the licence agreement. Consequently, the claims for loss and damage were dismissed.

The court concluded that the Shomalis were estopped from pursuing certain claims due to their conduct and representations. The court found no basis for the McPhees' joint liability, and thus, the claims against them were dismissed. The court ordered that no remedies should be granted to the Shomalis as they had failed to prove their claims. The defendants were awarded costs on an indemnity basis, reflecting the court's view that the plaintiffs' claims were without merit.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Many claims are no longer pressed. For example, Mr and Mrs Shomali now concede that no royalties or research and development fees were ever payable to them under the licence. Mr and Mrs McPhee no longer claim that the paint technology was inadequate and contravened essential terms of the licence agreement. The claims which remain for resolution in this matter may be summarised as follows:(1) (a)Did Mr Shomali make certain representations to Mr McPhee about the business Nature Cover Paints before Mr and Mrs McPhee purchased that business and entered into the licence agreement?(b)If so, were those representations misleading and deceptive?(c)If so, did Mr and Mrs McPhee act in reliance on those representations and cause Chimes Management also to so act?(d)If so, did Mr and Mrs McPhee and Chimes Management suffer loss and damage thereby?(2) (a)Did Mr McPhee, Chimes Management and/or Ecolour make certain representations to Mr and Mrs Shomali by an email dated 29 October 2009?(b)If so, were those representations misleading and deceptive?(c)If so, did Mr and Mrs Shomali act in reliance on those representations?(d)If so, did Mr and Mrs Shomali suffer loss and damage thereby?(3) (a)Did Chimes Management breach the licence agreement by disclosing the paint technology to Ecolour?(b)Did Chimes Management breach the licence agreement by not paying the licence fees as required?(c)Did Mr and Mrs Shomali effectively terminate the licence agreement by or about 29 October 2011 or 11 November 2011?(d)Did Ecolour and, by reason of Ecolour’s conduct, Chimes Management, infringe and wrongly benefit from use of the paint technology which is confidential information belonging to Mr and Mrs Shomali including:(i)by Chimes Management and/or Mr McPhee acting in breach of cl 10 of the licence agreement;(ii)by Chimes Management and/or Mr McPhee acting in breach of an equitable duty of confidentiality owed to Mr and Mrs Shomali; and/or(iii)by Chimes Management and/or Mr McPhee authorising the wrongful use of the paint technology by Ecolour?(e)If so, did Mr and Mrs Shomali suffer loss and damage thereby?(4)If Chimes Management is liable for any loss to Mr and Mrs Shomali, are Mr and Mrs McPhee jointly and severally liable in that regard under cl 16 of the licence agreement?(5) Are Mr and Mrs Shomali estopped from making the claims in (2), (3) and (4) above?(6) What, if any, remedies should be granted in all of the circumstances?EVIDENCE (EXCLUDING EXPERTS)Bassam (Sam) Shomali Mr Shomali is 58 years old. In his main affidavit he said that he had:…30 years experience in the paint industry in Australia and in particular in the formulation, development, testing and manufacture of new formulas for paints and stains for Australian conditions. He continued:My particular expertise lies in the development of oil-based and water-based paints and stains using re-refined recycled oil. Such waste oils are toxic pollutants that were previously burnt or disposed of in landfill. The paints and stains which I developed over my 30 years experience in paint manufacturing are “green” paints which use re-refined recycled oil and which do not emit toxic volatile organic compounds as they dry (the “Paint Technology”).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 5 states:5. Consideration5.1 In consideration of the grant of this licence the Licensee must pay the Fixed Licence Fee and the Royalty to the Licensor.…a.The Royalty must be computed at the end of each quarter which, for the purpose of this Agreement, ends on the last day of the month of March, June, September and December.b.If this Agreement is terminated for any reason during a quarter then, for the purpose of this clause, the date of termination is the end of that current quarter.c.The Licensee must pay the Royalty for each quarter within 30 days of the end of the quarter.d.The Licensee must provide the Licensor with each quarterly payment of the Royalty proper accounting of the gross sales income and cost of sales expenditure and if required by the Licensor, must be certified as correct by the auditor of the Licensee, or if the Licensee does not have an auditor, by a person approved by the Licensor for this purpose. e.The Licensor must permit an accountant or auditor of the Licensor from time to time during ordinary business hours to inspect and verify all or any records required to be maintained by the Licensee under this clause. The Licensee must give all assistance necessary to such accountant or auditor to carry out such inspection and verification and permit such accountant or auditor to take copies of any such records.f.The obligations in this clause on the Licensee to account to the Licensor and maintain relevant records in respect of Royalty applies to any amounts due to the Licensor from the Licensee pursuant to a sub-license.5.2 In further consideration of the profit of this Licence, in respect of each 12 month period commencing 1 July 2011 the Licensee must pay on 30 June following a supplementary fee to cause the payments of Royalty and fixed Licence fee to amount to $150,000 (one hundred and fifty thousand dollars) in the event that the payments made are less than this amount provided always that the supplementary fees if any payable in the three year period ending 30 June 2014 shall be limited to an amount being the shortfall if any between $450,000 (four hundred and fifty thousand dollars) and the Royalty accrued. The annual sum of $150,000 referred to in this clause shall be subject to annual revision by CPI over a base date of 1 July 2009. Clause 6 is as follows:6. Assistance of Licensora.For three months from the date of settlement of the purchase, the Licensor will use their reasonable endeavours during normal business hours to assist the Licensee with initial factory setup, training, public relations, manufacturing, and research and development of the paint Products.b.After three months from the date of settlement of the purchase, the Licensor, Bassam Shomali, will hold himself available to assist the Licensee with troubleshooting without charge but shall not be obligated to any particular commitment to time or attendance. Clause 7 provides that:7. Research, improvements and developmentsa.Subject to mutual agreement as to the nature and scope of projects, the Licensor, Bassam Shomali, will address the issues of improvement and developments to the Product and communicate to the Licensee relevant outcomes and supply further Confidential Information and Intellectual Property derived in such projects for use by the Licensee under this Agreement.b.The manner of implementing such agreed projects shall be at the discretion of the Licensor.c.The projects shall be dependent on funding from the Licensee and for this purpose the Licensee will allocate an amount being not less than 2.5% of Gross Profit from trading after one year from the date of this Agreement.d.All Confidential Information and Intellectual Property arising from such projects shall remain the property of the Licensor and may be protected in any part of the Territory by the Licensor using project funding under the previous paragraph.e.The Licensee will not engage in any research and development otherwise, without the prior written consent of the Licensor.f.The Licensor may at its discretion establish a company to effect research and development under this clause, and shall notify the Licensee of particulars.