Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Limited [2019] FCA 1039

File number: VID 231 of 2018
Judge: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 5 July 2019
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – representations of “biodegradable and compostable” made on labelling of disposable dish and cutlery products sold by respondent – identification of nature of representations – whether representations were as to “future matters” within meaning of s 4 of the Australian Consumer Law – consideration of meanings of “future matter” and “reasonable grounds” in s 4 – whether respondent had reasonable grounds for representations – application dismissed

CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct – whether representations of “biodegradable and compostable” contravened ss 18, 29 or 33 of the Australian Consumer Law – consideration of factors relevant to identifying “ordinary and reasonable” consumer – application dismissed

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2, Australian Consumer Law (Cth) ss 4, 18, 29, 33

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 56, 135, 136, 191

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 51A

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 34.50

Cases cited:

Ackers v Austcorp InternationalLtd [2009] FCA 432

AldiFoods Pty Ltd v Moroccanoil Israel Ltd [2018] FCAFC 93; 358 ALR 683

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ACM Group Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 1115

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Birubi Art Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1595

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Danoz Direct Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 881; 60 IPR 296

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dateline Imports Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 114

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1703; ATPR 42-096

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Giraffe World Australia Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1161; 95 FCR 302

Australian Competition and Consumer Commissionv Henry Kaye and National Investment Institute Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1363

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jones (No 5) [2011] FCA 49

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 992

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Purple Harmony Plates Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1062

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Safety Compliance Pty Ltd (in liq) [2015] FCA 211; ATPR 42-493

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2007] FCA 1904; 244 ALR 470

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v We Buy Houses Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 915

Bathurst Regional Council v Local Government Financial Services Pty Ltd (No 5) [2012] FCA 1200

Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Limited [2000] HCA 12; 202 CLR 45

Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 7) [2008] FCA 1364

City of Botany Bay Council v Jazabas Pty Limited (ACN 060 105 053) [2001] NSWCA 94; ATPR 46-210

Cummings v Lewis [1993] FCA 190; 41 FCR 559

Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria v Gibson [2017] FCA 240

Friends of Leadbeater’s Possum Inc v VicForests [2018] FCA 178; 228 LGERA 255

Gardam v George Wills…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1039
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) sought to establish that Woolworths Limited had contravened provisions of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by making misleading representations on the labelling of its disposable dish and cutlery products, which were advertised as "biodegradable and compostable." The court was tasked with determining whether these representations constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under sections 18, 29, or 33 of the ACL and if Woolworths had reasonable grounds for making such claims under section 4 of the ACL.

The primary legal issues that the court had to resolve included whether the representations Woolworths made about its products being biodegradable and compostable related to "future matters," as defined by section 4 of the ACL, and whether Woolworths had reasonable grounds for making these claims. Additionally, the court needed to ascertain whether these representations were false or misleading to a reasonable consumer under section 18 of the ACL. The court considered the evidence provided by both the ACCC and Woolworths, including expert opinions and test results, to determine the accuracy and implications of the representations.

The court found that the representations made by Woolworths were not as to "future matters" and were, in fact, accurate. The court was satisfied that the products could indeed break down into compost in a home composting environment within a reasonable period. The court also concluded that Woolworths had not proven that it had reasonable grounds for the representations it was alleged to have made. Therefore, the ACCC's application was dismissed. The court determined that Woolworths had met its burden of proving the accuracy of the representations, and the ACCC had not discharged its onus of proving the falsity of these claims. Consequently, the court dismissed the ACCC's application and ordered that the ACCC pay Woolworths' costs of the proceeding, to be fixed by way of a lump sum.

ORDERS:

1. The application be dismissed.
2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding, including any reserved costs, to be fixed by way of a lump sum.
3. On or before 4 pm on 26 July 2019, the parties are to submit proposed agreed orders as to lump sum costs, or alternatively inform the Court the parties have not reached agreement on the question of costs.
4. In the absence of any agreement as to the appropriate lump sum to be fixed for the respondent’s costs, the matter be referred to a Registrar for determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding, including any reserved costs, to be fixed by way of a lump sum.

3. On or before 4 pm on 26 July 2019, the parties are to submit proposed agreed orders as to lump sum costs, or alternatively inform the Court the parties have not reached agreement on the question of costs.

4. In the absence of any agreement as to the appropriate lump sum to be fixed for the respondent’s costs, the matter be referred to a Registrar for determination.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

THE COURSE OF THE PROCEEDING

[7]

THE PRODUCTS, THEIR SUPPLY AND SALE

[12]

Description of the Products

[13]

How Woolworths came to purchase and offer the Products for sale

[18]

Where and how the Products were displayed

[41]

LEGAL PRINCIPLES AND ISSUES IN DISPUTE

[51]

Issues in dispute

[51]

The s 4 issues

[53]

Were these representations as to “future matters”?

[53]

If future matters, did Woolworths have reasonable grounds for making the representations?

[59]

Do the representations have a temporal aspect?

[67]

Were the representations false or misleading?

[70]

The identification of the class of consumers and the attributes of members of that class

[71]

The time taken, and the circumstances needed, for the Products to biodegrade and to turn into useful compost

[73]

Legal principles

[78]

Relevant provisions

[79]

Authorities on “future matters”

[85]

The meaning of “representation with respect to any future matter”

[86]

The reason for s 4

[92]

The evidentiary onus

[113]

What does “reasonable grounds” mean in s 4?

[114]

The debate about Sykes and the need for actual reliance by the representor

[117]

The ACCC’s alternative s 18 case: particular points arising from the relevant authorities

[137]

The identification of the “class”

[140]

THE REPRESENTATIONS MADE ON THE LABELLING OF THE PRODUCTS

[145]

The section of the public to whom the representations were made

[156]

Determining what representations were made

[167]

Biodegradable

[177]

Compostable

[180]

What representations were conveyed by the whole phrase, in its context?

[188]

Did the representations have a temporal aspect?

[192]

Whether the representations were as to future matters

[196]

Whether Woolworths had reasonable grounds

[207]

Operation of s 4 of the ACL

[209]

The February 2014 material provided by Huhtamaki to Woolworths Hong Kong

[216]

The “certificates” and reports

[221]

The July 2014 material provided by Huhtamaki

[233]

The 2016 material provided by Huhtamaki

[235]

The “Sample Submission Specification” forms and “Product Specification” forms

[239]

The relevance of Woolworths’ bioplastics report and its 2009 Corporate Responsibility Report

[246]

The relevance of what was on the GreenGood USA website

[252]

The relevance of Woolworths’ Environmental Claims Policy and internal emails

[257]

Woolworths’ “reputable supplier” argument

[269]

Documents and information which cannot on any view provide reasonable grounds

[275]

Findings on the material, taken as a whole

[281]

Summary of my conclusions on the alleged representations and on s 4 of the ACL

[294]

WHETHER WOOLWORTHS HAS CONTRAVENED SECTIONS 18, 29 AND 33 OF THE ACL

[300]

Section 18: Were the representations false or misleading?

[308]

On the representations as the Court has found them: evidence of the Products’ capacity

[311]

Biodegradability

[312]

Compostability

[319]

Conclusion

[329]

On the representations as alleged by the ACCC, has the ACCC proved its case?

[331]

The Brosig test

[336]

The way Mr Brosig came to conduct his test

[341]

The conduct of the test and its results

[345]

The experts’ opinions about Mr Brosig’s test

[353]

Mr Leake

[353]

Professor Clarke

[356]

Mr Nolan

[359]

Mr Brosig’s evidence at trial

[374]

Conclusions on the Brosig test

[386]

Application of the test results to compostability of the impugned Products

[389]

The ACCC’s evidence and the arguments it made

[391]

The absence of a test by the ACCC

[392]

Mr Nolan’s evidence

[395]

A further issue with Mr Nolan’s estimates and the ACCC’s case

[406]

The evidence of other tests

[409]

The ACCC’s point about how many plates and cutlery could be composted at once, and whether this makes the representations misleading

[410]

The use of Australian standards

[412]

Other factors

[414]

Sections 29 and 33

[416]

Overall conclusion

[420]

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I accept that submission. Mr Brosig’s test had probative value for the time the impugned Products would take to turn into useful and usable compost outside an industrial composting system setting. Although that precise time cannot be derived from his test, given the comparatively quick decomposition into useful compost which occurred during his trial, I am prepared to infer that the impugned Products were, on the balance of probabilities, likely to turn into useful compost within a reasonable period of time – that is, within a matter of months rather than years. Of course, that finding is not necessary because the ACCC bears the onus of proof to establish the falsity of the representations as it alleges those representations were made. I am not only persuaded it has not discharged its burden of proof, I am positively satisfied that the impugned Products were capable of, and do, break down into useful compost, and will do so outside an industrial composting facility in a home composting environment. How long they take to break down will depend on how closely and properly managed the home composting environment is, which I explain below.The ACCC’s evidence and the arguments it made In this part of my reasons, I make findings based on the ACCC’s characterisation of the nature of the representations. I do so in case I am wrong in my principal findings about the nature of the representations made.The absence of a test by the ACCC I consider the absence of a test conducted by the ACCC is of some importance in assessing whether it has discharged its onus. It otherwise needed to rely on inferences from other trials and tests referred to in the evidence of Mr Nolan, and on discrediting Mr Brosig’s test and discrediting the evidence of Mr Leake and Professor Clarke. That is hardly a satisfactory basis for the regulator to discharge an onus. It might have been possible for the ACCC to discharge its onus in this way, but it was clearly a more circuitous route. No evidence was adduced about why a trial was not conducted by the ACCC: it would have been the most straightforward way to establish falsity. The absence of a test conducted by the ACCC means the only direct evidence about what happens to these Products when placed into a composting environment comes from the test conducted by Mr Brosig.Mr Nolan’s evidence In this proceeding, the experts did have different backgrounds and experience, and this is of some relevance to the weight I have given to their opinions. Where a choice needed to be made between expert opinions, generally I have preferred the evidence of Mr Leake, and Mr Brosig, over the evidence of Mr Nolan. I did not find Mr Nolan’s evidence as easy to follow or to comprehend as that of Mr Leake. His reports were difficult to follow, because of the numbering and the way they were broken up. I found Mr Nolan’s evidence lacked some of the practical approaches and insights which in my opinion are important to understanding the circumstances in which materials break down into compost, and the variety of ways in which compost might be used by consumers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The positive findings I have made about the characteristics of the impugned Products would also mean the alleged contraventions of these provisions must fail. This is the likely reason little time was expended by the ACCC on submissions about these provisions: they stand or fall with the s 18 allegations, at least at a basic level. More may indeed be required, but what this might involve was not developed by the ACCC, which had the onus of proof.Overall conclusion The ACCC has not proven that, by the labelling on the impugned Products, Woolworths made the representations the ACCC alleged it to have made. The representations that were made did not relate to future matters, were as to the inherent qualities or capacities of the Products, and were in any event accurate. If I am wrong in my conclusions, and the representations were as the ACCC alleged, and did relate to future matters, then Woolworths adduced evidence to the contrary for the purposes of s 4(2) of the ACL, so as to disengage the deeming effect of that provision. However, the ACCC has proven that Woolworths did not have reasonable grounds for the representations which it alleges were made. If I am wrong in my conclusions, and the representations were as the ACCC alleged but did not relate to future matters, the ACCC has not proven (on its alternative s 18 case) they were misleading or deceptive or false. Indeed, I have found they were accurate, on the basis of Mr Brosig’s test and the evidence of Mr Leake and Professor Clarke. Accordingly, the ACCC’s application must be dismissed. It is appropriate to make orders for lump sum costs and to give the parties an opportunity to agree on what the lump sum figure should be. Failing agreement, the question of costs will be referred to a Registrar for determination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.