Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Purple Harmony Plates Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ACCC v Purple Harmony Plates Pty Limited [2001] FCA 1062

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – representations as to future matters – statements that products would have health and other benefits – onus on corporation to produce evidence of reasonable grounds for making representations.

TRADE PRACTICES – remedies – injunctive relief – corrective advertising – corrective statement on website – corrective letters to purchasers of products – offer to refund purchase money for products.

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – whether Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) invalid – whether Governors‑General not properly appointed – whether respondents subject to jurisdiction of Court – whether respondents had seceded from Commonwealth of Australia.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – ss 51A, 52, 80, 80A
Constitution (Cth) – s 123

Joose v Australian Securities & Investment Commission (1998) 73 ALJR 232 referred to
Helljay Investments Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 166 ALR 302 referred to
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Levick (1999) 168 ALR 383 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 95 FCR 114 referred to

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v PURPLE HARMONY PLATES PTY LIMITED

V 866 of 2000

GOLDBERG J
6 AUGUST 2001
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 866 of 2000

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

PURPLE HARMONY PLATES PTY LIMITED
(ACN 077 965 587)
First Respondent

NEAL ARTHUR LYSTER
Second Respondent

HELEN THERESE GLOVER
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

GOLDBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 AUGUST 2001

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The first respondent be restrained, whether by itself, its servants or agents or any of them or otherwise howsoever, from publishing, distributing, transmitting, displaying or broadcasting material which contains representations:

(a)in relation to the product known and described as the large Purple Harmony plate that:

(i)the plate has an energy field of approximately 2.5 metres around it that negates the effects of the electrified and frequency toxic environment and treats the sub‑particles of electromagnetic and other frequencies, reducing the effect on human bodies, thereby lowering bodily stress and fatigue levels;

(ii)placing the plate beneath a computer monitor counters the effects of Electromagnetic Radiation (“EMR”) and reduces fatigue;

(iii)the plate will negate the effects of re‑radiated and electromagnetic frequencies;

(iv)the plate will clear and energise fruit and vegetables, restoring their natural vitality;

(v)the plate will calm people, making them more receptive to treatment by health practitioners;

(vi)the plate has a beneficial effect on health, accelerates healing and lessens or cures pain;

(vii)the plate creates a positive energy field around it that is very beneficial to all life, plant, animal or human;

(viii)the plate raises personal energy levels and protects against EMR in the environment and from EMR producing equipment, such as computers, televisions, mobile phones;

(b)in relation to the product known and described as the small Purple Harmony plate that:

(i)the plate has an energy field of approximately 50 centimetres around it that negates…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Purple Harm... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1062
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Purple Harmony Plates Pty Ltd (Purple Harmony), alleging that various representations made by the company in relation to its products were misleading or deceptive. The ACCC claimed that these representations, which included assertions about the products' performance characteristics and benefits, were not substantiated and were therefore in breach of sections 52 and 53(c) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). Purple Harmony admitted to advertising and promoting the products but denied that the representations were misleading or deceptive or that they had contravened the Act.

The legal issues before the court were whether the representations made by Purple Harmony were indeed misleading or deceptive and, if so, whether they constituted a breach of the Act. The court had to consider whether the representations were substantiated and whether they were likely to mislead or deceive consumers. The court also had to determine the appropriate remedies, including potential injunctions, restitution, and costs.

The court found that many of the representations made by Purple Harmony were misleading or deceptive and not substantiated. It noted that the company had provided no scientific evidence to support the claimed benefits of the products. The court concluded that the representations were likely to mislead or deceive consumers and were therefore in breach of the Act. It issued an injunction prohibiting Purple Harmony from making or facilitating the making of the misleading representations in any form. Additionally, the court ordered Purple Harmony to provide refunds to customers, to send notification to all customers who had purchased the products, and to place a disclaimer on their website. The court also ordered Purple Harmony to pay the ACCC's costs.

The court's decision highlights the importance of substantiating claims made in advertising and the potential consequences for companies that make misleading or deceptive representations. The injunction and other orders serve as a deterrent to Purple Harmony and other companies from engaging in similar conduct in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first respondent be restrained, whether by itself, its servants or agents or any of them or otherwise howsoever, from publishing, distributing, transmitting, displaying or broadcasting material which contains representations:

(a) in relation to the product known and described as the large Purple Harmony plate that:

(i) the plate has an energy field of approximately 2.5 metres around it that negates the effects of the electrified and frequency toxic environment and treats the sub‑particles of electromagnetic and other frequencies, reducing the effect on human bodies, thereby lowering bodily stress and fatigue levels;

(ii) placing the plate beneath a computer monitor counters the effects of Electromagnetic Radiation (“EMR”) and reduces fatigue;

(iii) the plate will negate the effects of re‑radiated and electromagnetic frequencies;

(iv) the plate will clear and energise fruit and vegetables, restoring their natural vitality;

(v) the plate will calm people, making them more receptive to treatment by health practitioners;

(vi) the plate has a beneficial effect on health, accelerates healing and lessens or cures pain;

(vii) the plate creates a positive energy field around it that is very beneficial to all life, plant, animal or human;

(viii) the plate raises personal energy levels and protects against EMR in the environment and from EMR producing equipment, such as computers, televisions, mobile phones;

(b) in relation to the product known and described as the small Purple Harmony plate that:

(i) the plate has an energy field of approximately 50 centimetres around it that negates the effects of the electrified and frequency toxic environment and treats the sub-particles of electromagnetic and other frequencies, reducing the effect on human bodies, thereby lowering bodily stress and fatigue levels;

(ii) the plate will negate the effects of re-radiated and electromagnetic frequencies;

(iii) the plate has a beneficial effect on health, accelerates healing and lessens or cures pain;

(iv) the plate creates a positive energy field around it that is very beneficial to all life, plant, animal or human;

(v) the plate raises personal energy levels and protects against EMR in the environment and from EMR producing equipment, such as computers, televisions, mobile phones;

(c) in relation to the product known and described as the Purple Harmony disk that:

(i) wearing the purple harmony disk over the thymus gland directly helps to strengthen the immune system;

(ii) the disk enables the human body to cope better with the electrified and toxic environment;

(iii) the disk will increase a person’s general health;

(iv) the disk will cause aches, pains, niggly coughs and colds to be less severe;

(v) the disk can be used to treat cuts, burns, aches and pains, water, foods and all the things that Purple Harmony plates can be used for;

(vi) the disk reduces the effects of harmful electromagnetic and other frequencies on human bodies;

(vii) the disk will decrease stress levels on the human body and strengthen the immune system;

(viii) the disk will negate the effects of re-radiated and electromagnetic frequencies;

(d) in relation to the product known and described as the Purple Harmony angel that:

(i) the angel will strengthen the immune system;

(ii) the angel can be used to treat cuts, burns, aches and pains, water, goods and all the things that Purple Harmony plates can be used for;

(e) in relation to the product known and described as the Purple Harmony mobile phone disk that placing a mobile phone disk to the area nearest to the antenna will reduce all uncomfortable sensations from using a mobile phone, such as “hot spots”, jaw and/or teeth problems, headaches and/or earaches, tinnitus or nausea;

(f) in relation to the product known and described as the Purple Harmony green thumb that:

(i) holding one or two green thumbs for twenty minutes a day will energise your body system;

(ii) the green thumb will re-oxygenate water, giving it more life force energy to benefit all living organisms;

(iii) use of the green thumb will result in plants growing with vim and vigour;

(iv) by placing the green thumbs in a bucket or jug of water, the green thumbs will treat water, whereby the water will taste, smell and feel, and be so much better for the user;

(v) attaching three green thumbs to any power cord will treat the electromagnetic frequencies emanating from gadgets and result in reduced stress levels;

(g) that the product known and described as the fuel ionizer system:

(i) ionizes the fuel cars use;

(ii) creates more power from complete burning of fuel;

(iii) produces cleaner engines and injectors;

(iv) reduces emissions;

(v) gives better mileage and reduces fuel consumption;

(vi) enables quicker starting of engines;

(vii) will lead to less shifting of gears with heavy loads;

(viii) produces useable energy;

(h) that the products known and described as the Hunza water ionizer system/Hunza living-energy water system – gold Hunza and blue Hunza products:

(i) re-oxygenate water;

(ii) energise water;

(iii) improve water quality;

(iv) free water of odour and chlorine;

and that the Blue Hunza will last indefinitely;

(i) that the product known and described as the Hunza swimming pool ionizer:

(i) has similar beneficial effects to the Hunza water ionizer, however, it is much more powerful;

(ii) reduces the use of chemicals required to maintain correct pool pH;

(iii) decreases the effect of those chemicals on hair, skin and eyes;

(j) that the product known and described as the Purple Harmony fridge freshener:

(i) lowers the refrigerator temperature;

(ii) makes food last between two to four times longer than usual;

(iii) removes odours;

(iv) reduces energy costs;

(v) reduces the running costs of a refrigerator;

(vi) saves energy;

(vii) is a long lasting product;

(viii) eliminates the effects of EMR from computers;

(ix) reduces stress and fatigue

2. The second and third respondents be restrained from being in any way directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in, or party to, publishing, distributing, transmitting, displaying or broadcasting material containing any of the representations referred to in paragraph 1 of this order.

3. The respondents, within fourteen days of the date of this order, at their own expense, send or cause to be sent by mail a letter to all customers who have purchased any of the products from the first respondent in the form set out in Schedule A to this order.

4. The respondents, within fourteen days of the date of this order, place on the Internet website at “www.purple-plates.com”, and maintain for a period of three months thereafter, an automatically generated active pop-up window or message box that complies with the contents, requirements and format described in Schedule B to this order.

5. The first respondent refund in full on request by a customer all monies paid by customers for the supply or possible supply of the products.

6. The respondents file and serve on the applicant by 31 August 2001 an affidavit verifying that they have carried out their obligations under pars 3 and 4 of this order.

7. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the application and the applicant’s costs of giving notice under s 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

The Commission’s case is that the representations were misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive, and it claims that the products have performance characteristics and benefits that they do not have contrary to the provisions of s 52 and s 53(c) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the Act”). The Commission relies on s 51A of the Act on the basis that the representations are as to future matters which cannot be substantiated.Background From a date in 1996, the company has advertised and promoted the products for sale by the distribution of a brochure and display on an Internet website homepage at (“the website”). The website is promoted by, and maintained in the name of, the company. On 13 and 14 June 2000, officers of the Commission, obtained a print out of the website on which the products were stated to have various benefits. In July 2000, an officer of the Commission used the website to purchase from the company a Purple Harmony disk and a small Purple Harmony angel. These products were delivered to the officer in Canberra. The Commission wrote to Mr Lyster and requested the company to remove from its advertising any reference to representations that indicated that the benefits claimed could be derived from the products. Correspondence followed between the company and the Commission, and on 23 August 2000 the company wrote to the Commission stating that the company had removed the contents of its former website and replaced it with an exact copy of the website displayed by the American distributor of Energy Innovation Products, the American manufacturer of the products. On 28 August 2000, an officer of the Commission connected to the website and printed out a copy of its contents. The new website also contained various claims in relation to the performance characteristics and benefits of the products. On 14 September 2000, the Commission wrote to Mr Lyster stating that the Commission was concerned about claims on the website that use of the products could obtain various benefits. In the letter, the Commission said it had yet to receive any evidence that the products had the performance characteristics as claimed, that it viewed the claims as unsubstantiated and required the claims to be removed from the company’s promotional material. On 20 September 2000, the company supplied the Commission with information about the products, substantially in the form of testimonials from persons who had used them. The Commission remained of the view that the claims made in relation to the products could not be substantiated. On 2 May 2001, an officer of the Commission printed out another copy of the website. The contents of the website were largely the same as on 28 August 2000. The respondents filed a defence in which they admitted that the company traded as Purple Harmony Plates and Purple Harmony Plates (Aust) and carried on business in Australia promoting and selling plates, disks, tubes and other objects of various shapes, sizes and colours. They also admitted that from a date in 1996, the company advertised and promoted the plates, disks, tubes and other objects of various shapes, sizes and colours for sale by distribution of a brochure and on the website. The respondents denied that the representations were misleading and deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive or that they had contravened the Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GOLDBERG J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GOLDBERG J