Girchow Enterprises Pty Ltd v Ultimate Franchising Group Pty Ltd (Final Hearing)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Girchow Enterprises Pty Ltd v Ultimate Franchising Group Pty Ltd (Final Hearing) [2023] FCA 420

File number(s): NSD 395 of 2020
Judgment of: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 5 May 2023
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – misleading and deceptive conduct – whether three corporate franchisees entered into gym franchise agreements because of misleading conduct on the part of franchisor and its directors – whether individuals gave guarantees because of misleading conduct – alleged representations with respect to future matters, mostly concerning likely future income and likely establishment costs –held that franchise agreements and guarantees entered into because of misleading conduct

DAMAGES – appropriate quantification of losses where establishment costs expended on setting up unprofitable businesses – whether value of businesses when set up equalled costs incurred in setting up the businesses – whether referee report should be adopted – referee report adopted in part

EVIDENCE – discussion of difficulties caused by cutting and pasting evidence from one affidavit to another  

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 139B, Sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 4, 18, 236, 237

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37P(2), 54A

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Woolworths Ltd [2019] FCA 1039

Bathurst Regional Council v Local Government Financial Services Pty Ltd (No 5) [2012] FCA 1200

Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 60; 218 CLR 592

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; 238 CLR 304

Chocolate Factory Apartments Ltd v Westpoint Finance Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 784

City of Botany Bay Council v Jazabas Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 94; [2001] ATPR 64-210

HTW Valuers (Central Qld) Pty Ltd v Astonland Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 54; 217 CLR 640

I & L Securities Pty Ltd v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd [2002] HCA 41; 210 CLR 109

Kane’s Hire Pty Ltd v Anderson Aviation Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 381

Kizbeau Pty Ltd v WG & B Pty Ltd [1995] HCA 4; 184 CLR 281

McGrath v Australian Naturalcare Products Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 2; 165 FCR 230

Murphy v Overton Investments Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 3; 216 CLR 388

Potts v Miller (1940) 64 CLR 282

Shah v Hagemrad [2018] FCA 91

Sykes v Reserve Bank of Australia (1998) 88 FCR 511

Tour Squad Pty Ltd v Fifth Amendment Entertainment Inc (No 2) [2021] FCA 546; 151 ACSR 607

Wardley Australia Ltd v State of Western Australia [1992] HCA 55; 175 CLR 514

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 665
Date of hearing: 3-4, 6, 11-14, 21 April 2023
Counsel for the Applicants: Dr A Greinke with Mr S Lamb
Solicitor for the Applicants: Lodhia Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr D Moujalli with Mr N Olson
Solicitor for the Respondents: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 395 of 2020
BETWEEN:

GIRCHOW…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Girchow Enterprises Pty Ltd v Ultimate Franchising Group Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 420
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Girchow Enterprises Pty Ltd v Ultimate Franchising Group Pty Ltd was a case before the Federal Court of Australia, where Girchow Enterprises sought to set aside gym franchise agreements and guarantees made by its directors. The dispute centred on whether the franchisees entered into the agreements due to misleading conduct by the franchisor, Ultimate Franchising Group Pty Ltd, and its directors. The case also addressed the appropriate quantification of losses incurred by the franchisees. The franchisees claimed that they relied on misleading representations concerning future income and establishment costs when entering into the franchise agreements and signing guarantees. The court had to determine whether the franchise agreements and guarantees were entered into because of misleading conduct and, if so, what compensation should be awarded for the losses.

The primary legal issues involved whether the misleading representations constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under consumer law and, if so, whether the franchisees had relied on these representations when entering into the agreements. The court also had to consider the appropriate method of quantifying the damages for the losses incurred by the franchisees due to the misleading conduct. The franchisees argued that the value of the businesses at the time of setup equalled the costs incurred in setting them up, and they sought to rely on a referee's report to determine the losses. The franchisors contested the reliance on the referee's report and argued that the losses were not as significant as claimed.

The court found that the franchise agreements and guarantees were indeed entered into because of misleading conduct by the franchisor and its directors. The misrepresentations concerning future income and establishment costs were considered misleading and deceptive, and the franchisees had relied on these when making their decisions. Regarding damages, the court adopted parts of the referee's report but made adjustments based on its assessment of the evidence. The court concluded that the value of the businesses when set up did not equal the costs incurred, and it ordered compensation for the losses along with interest. The court also noted difficulties with the evidence presented, particularly concerning the reliance on identical or almost identical terms in the affidavits.

The final orders included declaring the franchise agreements void and setting aside the guarantees. Compensation was awarded to the franchisees for their losses, along with interest from a specified date until the date of judgment. The court directed the parties to confer and agree on appropriate orders for quantifying net operating losses and borrowing costs for one of the franchises. The proceedings were listed for a subsequent hearing to resolve any remaining disputes regarding the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer with a view to agreeing by 4.00pm on 11 May 2023 orders:

(a) giving effect to these reasons; and

(b) with respect to costs.

2. The proceedings be listed at 9.00am on 12 May 2023 for resolution of any dispute as to appropriate orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The reliability of Mr Mirdjonov’s evidence varied, although I generally preferred his recollection of events over Mr Hagemrad’s recollection.THE EVIDENCE The witness evidence was largely given by affidavit. There are two aspect of the affidavit evidence which warrant mention. First, the affidavits contained numerous accounts of conversations, often in direct speech. It is fair to say that attention was not given to the sorts of considerations recently emphasised by Jackman J in Kane’s Hire Pty Ltd v Anderson Aviation Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 381 at [123] to [129]. Further, some of the accounts of conversations contained in the affidavits may have been affected by the matter referred to next. The applicants’ affidavit evidence on reliance was criticised by the respondents as being “rudimentary, formulaic and given by each of them in identical, or almost identical, terms”. It is the reliance on affidavit evidence in identical or almost identical terms which is the second matter which warrants mention. Mr K Girgis’s first affidavit dated 29 September 2020 contained the following (text in strikethrough was not read): 22… I read the disclosure document in particular, and I noted:(a)the knowledge and experience of Maz Hagemrad and Sam Husseini regarding the UFC Gym franchise operations at item 3.1; and(b)the establishment costs at Table 1 of Schedule 5.…32 In deciding to enter into the Balcatta franchise agreement and agreeing to be a guarantor, I relied on:(a)the cashflow forecasts regarding the future income of the franchise; and(b)the forecast start-up and fit-out costs provided by Maz Hagemrad and Sam Husseini, as set out above in this affidavit.33Had I known the actual startup costs would be much larger that the forecasts (as they were in fact), or the income project[ion]s would not be realised, I would not have agreed to the Balcatta Franchisee becoming a franchisee, and I would not have agreed to be a guarantor of the franchise business. Mr S Girgis’s first affidavit dated 29 September 2020 contained the following:12At the time I read this disclosure document in particular, and I read about:(a) the knowledge and experience of Maz Hagemrad and Sam Husseini regarding the UFC Gym franchise operations at item 3 .1; and (b) the establishment costs at Table 1 of Schedule 5.…21 In deciding to enter into the Balcatta franchise agreement and agreeing to be a guarantor, I relied on:(a) the cashflow forecasts regarding the future income of the franchise ; and(b) the forecast start-up and fit-out costs provided by Maz Hagemrad and Sam Husseini, as set out above in this affidavit.22 Had I known that the actual income would not grow as projected, or had I known the actual startup costs would be much larger than the forecasts (as they were in fact), or that the income project[ion]s were unreliable, I would not have agreed to the Balcatta Franchisee becoming a franchisee, and I would not have agreed to be a guarantor of the franchise business.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The claim in respect of MSA fees was abandoned in closing submissions. It follows that Issues 14 to 20 do not require determination. CONCLUSION The Court should adopt parts of the referee’s report as indicated earlier.Balcatta Franchise The franchise agreement should be declared void. The guarantees given by Mr K Girgis, Mr S Girgis and Mr Chau should each be declared void. An order should be made against each respondent for compensation for losses in an amount of $1,744,816 and interest from 31 December 2022 until the date of judgment.Blacktown Franchise The franchise agreement should be declared void. The guarantee given by Mr Kim should be declared void. An order should be made against each respondent for compensation for losses in the amount of $1,906,783 and interest from 31 December 2022 until the date of judgment.Castle Hill Franchise The franchise agreement should be declared void. The guarantee given by Mr Mirdjonov should be declared void. An order should be made against each respondent for compensation for losses in the amount of $1,448,264 and interest from 31 December 2022 until the date of judgment. I will hear further from the parties in relation to appropriate orders for quantification of net operating losses and borrowing costs in relation to the Castle Hill Franchise.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established