Kane's Hire Pty Ltd v Anderson Aviation Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kane’s Hire Pty Ltd v Anderson Aviation Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 381

File number(s): NSD 1161 of 2020
Judgment of: JACKMAN J
Date of judgment: 27 April 2023
Catchwords:

CONTRACTS – whether a contract for the sale and purchase of an aircraft contained express terms as to the dry empty weight, maximum take-off weight and airworthiness of the aircraft – where the contract incorporates a price list being an Excel spreadsheet – where the price list does not include weight figures for various components – whether a warranty as to a “certificate of airworthiness” should be construed as a warranty as to a certificate issued pursuant to reg 21.186 of the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) – whether terms concerning the weight and airworthiness of the aircraft could be implied in fact – whether the aircraft was purchased for a particular purpose within the meaning of the Goods Act 1958 (Vic)

CONSUMER LAW – whether misleading or deceptive representations were made as to the weight of an aircraft or its airworthiness – where there is competing evidence as to the occurrences of oral conversations – looking at the course of conduct as a whole, and not taking a price list in isolation, some representations found not to have been made – manufacturer’s statement of compliance misleading or deceptive

DAMAGES – claim for Potts v Miller damages – competing expert evidence as to the diminution in value of the aircraft – relevant date for assessment of damages is the date of acquisition of the aircraft – where any loss not caused by the misleading or deceptive conduct – no unreasonable failure to mitigate loss

EVIDENCE – where evidence of memories of the substance or gist of a conversation given in direct speech – no rule of the law of evidence that evidence of conversations to be given in direct speech – evidence should be given in direct speech only if the witness can remember the actual words used  

Legislation:

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 8, 9, 9A

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law), ss 18, 236

Evidence Act1995 (Cth) s 135

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A

Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth) ss 52, 82

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) regs 21.172, 21.175, 21.181, 21.186, 21.195B, Dictionary

Goods Act1958 (Vic) ss 3, 19

Cases cited:

Banco de Portugal v Waterlow & Sons Ltd [1932] AC 452

BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266

Brown v Jam Factory Pty Ltd (1981) 53 FLR 340

Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Ltd (2004) 218 CLR 592

Campbell v Back Office Investments Pty Ltd (2009) 238 CLR 304

Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64

Commonwealth v Riley (1984) 5 FCR 8

Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions v Country Care Group Pty Ltd (Ruling No 1) [2020] FCA 1670

Hamilton-Smith v George [2006] FCA 1551; (2006)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kane's Hire Pty Ltd v Anderson Aviation Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 381
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kane's Hire Pty Ltd v Anderson Aviation Australia Pty Ltd involved the plaintiff, Kane's Hire, seeking damages from Anderson Aviation and others for alleged misleading or deceptive conduct regarding the sale and purchase of a Bristell aircraft. The central dispute was whether the contract for the sale of the aircraft contained express terms concerning the dry empty weight, maximum take-off weight, and airworthiness of the aircraft, and whether any such terms could be implied. The court also had to determine if misleading or deceptive representations were made concerning the aircraft's weight and airworthiness, and to assess the appropriate quantum of damages, considering the diminution in value of the aircraft. The plaintiff claimed that Anderson Aviation made misleading representations about the aircraft's specifications and airworthiness, which were critical for the plaintiff's intended recreational and business uses.

The key legal issues addressed by the court included the interpretation of the contract, specifically whether the contract incorporated an Excel spreadsheet price list and whether terms regarding the aircraft's weight and airworthiness were express or could be implied. The court also had to consider whether the representations made by Anderson Aviation were misleading or deceptive under the Australian Consumer Law. Furthermore, the court needed to evaluate the evidence concerning the aircraft's diminution in value and whether the plaintiff had failed to mitigate its loss. The court had to assess the credibility and form of evidence of conversations between the parties, particularly whether evidence of conversations needed to be given in direct speech or if it was acceptable to describe the substance or gist of the conversation.

The court concluded that the contract did not contain express terms regarding the aircraft's weight and airworthiness, but such terms could not be implied in fact. The court found that some representations made by Anderson Aviation were not misleading or deceptive, particularly when considering the course of conduct as a whole rather than focusing solely on the price list. The court also determined that the manufacturer's statement of compliance was misleading or deceptive. Regarding damages, the court found that the diminution in value of the aircraft was not due to the misleading or deceptive conduct, and there was no unreasonable failure by the plaintiff to mitigate its loss. The court emphasised that there was no legal requirement for evidence of conversations to be given in direct speech and that evidence should reflect the actual recollection of the witness.

The court ordered that the originating application and statement of claim be dismissed as against the first and second respondents. Judgment was entered in favour of the plaintiff against the third respondent in the sum of $240 plus interest. The court also set a timetable for the submission of written arguments and affidavits on the question of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Originating Application and Statement of Claim be dismissed as against the first and second respondents.

2. Judgment for the applicant against the third respondent in the sum of $240, together with interest pursuant to s 51A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

3. The parties to file and serve any written submissions on the question of costs (not exceeding 3 pages), together with any affidavit in support by 4 May 2023.

4. The parties to file and serve any written submissions in reply (not exceeding 3 pages), together with any affidavit in support by 9 May 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have dealt below at some length with the form in which evidence of conversations was given by the principal witnesses. As I have stated in that section, I have not taken the form of such evidence into account in assessing the credibility of the witnesses.SALIENT FACTS In about 2014, Mr Kane and his son, Branden, who was then aged 20, became interested in having flying lessons and becoming pilots. In that year, they started having flying lessons with Central West Flying School at Bathurst Airport, where their main flying instructor was the principal and chief flying instructor of that school, Mr Chris Stott. Initially, Mr Kane’s flying lessons were undertaken in a 2-seater Australian-made aircraft called a Jabiru, but he soon switched to a plane manufactured by BRM Aero, a Bristell aircraft. At some point, which was not identified in the evidence, Branden Kane lost interest in flying, and he never obtained a pilot’s licence. In about the middle of 2014, Mr Kane began considering purchasing an aircraft, partly so that he and his son could fly together recreationally, and partly because he thought the aircraft could be used in the business of renting construction industry equipment conducted by Kane’s Hire. Mr Kane also considered that Branden could do his flying lessons in an aircraft with modern electronic flight displays. Mr Stott put Mr Kane in touch with Mr Brett Anderson of Anderson Aviation. Mr Anderson provided Mr Kane with a price list of Bristell aircraft valid from June 2012. Mr Kane received his pilot’s licence in May 2015. In about July 2015, Mr Kane and Branden travelled to the Osh Kosh Airshow in the United States. Mr Anderson and Mr Stott were also present, and they discussed the possibility of Mr Kane purchasing an aircraft for the above mentioned purposes, and both Mr Stott and Mr Anderson recommended a Bristell aircraft. Mr Anderson pointed out that BRM Aero would have a much more powerful plane with a new 915 turbo engine coming out soon. BRM Aero’s US distributor had a pavilion at that airshow, which Mr Kane and his son visited a number of times. At around this time, Mr Anderson sent Mr Kane a copy of an email from Mr Bristela of BRM Aero referring to the prototype of the 915iS turbo engine, which was said to be 10 kg heavier than the 912 ULS. The email foreshadowed that the new engine would be added to the price list in 2017. In September 2017, Mr Kane gained his Recreational Cross Country Pilot’s Endorsement. On 18 October 2017, Mr Kane sent an email to Mr Anderson saying that he was considering purchasing a Bristell, and asked for advice on the following when convenient:Up dated price list and weights like attached previously emailed. However I could not work out what goes with what New Rotax 130hp [horsepower] option Electronic Fuel InjectionWhat if we price up about three options including weightsOption 1 with full glass Garmin cock pitOption 2 semi glassOption 3 AnalogueI think will require the following as well depending on how weights work out. [sic]There was then set out a lengthy list of other features of the aircraft. The reference to the “New Rotax 130 hp option” was a reference to the 915 turbo engine which Mr Anderson and Mr Kane had discussed at the Osh Kosh Airshow.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, the amount of compensation payable pursuant to s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law by BRM Aero for its contravention of section 18, being $240 plus interest, is not reduced by reason of any failure by the applicant to mitigate its loss.THE FORM OF EVIDENCE OF CONVERSATIONS In the present case, the applicant and the respondents took markedly different approaches to the form in which evidence in chief of conversations was given. The applicant expressed his evidence in direct speech, and I have extracted a number of instances of that in the reasons above. That approach may be regarded as usual practice in New South Wales. Until about the mid-1990s (and occasionally still), courts in New South Wales rejected evidence in chief of conversations which was not expressed in direct speech (although this supposed rule of evidence was never insisted upon in cross-examination). That approach failed to accommodate the fact that people routinely remember only the gist of conversations, and perhaps also a particularly striking or important word or phrase which was used. In order to protect the witness against the challenge that the witness could not in fact remember the conversation verbatim, it became customary to preface the direct speech by saying that the conversation occurred “in words to the following effect”. That practice may well have made the evidence appear more precise and weighty than it really was, while allowing the witness some flexibility from verbatim accuracy if challenged on particular words in cross-examination. However, the practice must have struck many witnesses as most peculiar. Many witnesses must have instructed their lawyers of their memory of the substance or gist of a conversation, only to be told by the lawyer that it then had to be fashioned into direct speech, by a process of construction or reconstruction. Witnesses mindful of the duty of candour must have been most surprised by this practice. At the conclusion of Mr Kane’s oral evidence in the present case, I asked him whether in giving evidence of conversations in direct speech he was claiming that his evidence was of the exact words that were used, or whether he was saying that he recalled the substance or gist of the conversation and had then recreated that in direct speech. Mr Kane said very clearly that he was not “talking word for word” (T134.38-40) and said “it was more like the idea, what the conversation was about” (T134.40). Mr Kane said candidly that he did not have a photographic memory, “far from it”(T.135.10-11). The conversations in question were mostly about five years ago, and some were up to nine years ago. Mr Kane’s frankness on the issue exposes the flaws in what has continued to be the usual practice in New South Wales. It is impossible to ascertain from his evidence which words (if any) have been recalled by him as the exact words used in conversations some years ago, and which elements are the product of reconstruction. The appearance of a vivid memory of the conversation which is conveyed by the use of direct speech bears no resemblance to the state of Mr Kane’s actual memory.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established