Lantrak Holdings Pty Ltd v Yammine

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lantrak Holdings Pty Ltd v Yammine [2023] FCAFC 156

Appeal from:

Yammine v Lantrak Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] FCA 162

Yammine v Liemant [2022] FCA 1480

File numbers: NSD 309 of 2023
NSD 1158 of 2022
Judgment of: LEE, BUTTON AND JACKMAN JJ
Date of judgment: 26 September 2023
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – whether primary judge erred in finding respondents had proved words spoken with a sufficient degree of precision to enable Court to be satisfied they were misleading – where promise made to “honour the deal” or pay “the balance” between non-binding heads of agreement and sale agreement did not specify sum of balance – pleaded representation not proved – ground of appeal established

DAMAGES – whether primary judge erred in determining compensation payable for misleading or deceptive conduct – whether appropriate measure of damages the difference between real value of business acquired and price paid for it, or value of loss of commercial opportunity to sell business for a higher price – where no expert evidence led as to value of business – where damages for loss of chance not pleaded – appellants denied procedural fairness in a material way – ground of appeal established

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether primary judge erred in deciding to stay permanently related proceedings on the basis that their continuation would amount to an abuse of process – whether leave to appeal should be granted –primary judge did not impermissibly elevate overarching purpose of practice and procedure provisions in Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – two sets of proceedings inseparably connected – leave to appeal granted – appeal dismissed

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2, ss 4, 4(1), 4(2), 18, 18(1), 236, 236(1)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) Ch 2, ss 4(1)(b), 11, 27, 29(1), 192(2)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37M(1)(b), 37N(1)

Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW)

Cases cited:

AIO21 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 1105

Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Attila Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCA 269

Batistatos v Roads and Traffıc Authority of New South Wales [2006] HCA 27; (2006) 226 CLR 256

Belconnen Lakeview Pty Ltd v Lloyd [2021] FCAFC 187; (2021) 156 ACSR 273

Bienstein v Bienstein [2003] HCA 7; (2003) 195 ALR 225

CBRE (V) Pty Ltd v Trilogy Funds Management Limited [2021] NSWCA 316; (2021) 107 NSWLR 202

Commonwealth Trading Bank of Australia v Inglis (1974) 131 CLR 311

Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners (1949) 78 CLR 62

DOB18 v Ng in his capacity as a Registrar of the Federal Court of Australia [2019] FCA 1575

Dodoro v Knighting [2004] VSCA 217; (2004) 10 VR 277

Egglishaw v Australian Crime Commission [2007] FCAFC 183; (2007) 164 FCR 224

Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 22; (2007) 230…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lantrak Holdings Pty Ltd v Yammine and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCAFC 156
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Lantrak Holdings Pty Ltd v Yammine involved complex disputes between the parties concerning the dissolution of a commercial relationship and the terms of a business transaction. The primary judge found in favour of the respondents in both Lantrak 1 and Lantrak 2, leading the appellants to appeal the decision. The court had to decide several legal issues, including whether the primary judge erred in finding that the respondents had proved certain words spoken with a sufficient degree of precision, and whether the primary judge correctly determined the compensation payable for misleading or deceptive conduct. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the primary judge erred in deciding to permanently stay related proceedings.

The court's reasoning and outcome on these issues were pivotal. Regarding the precision of words spoken, the court found that the primary judge's decision was correct in not finding the respondents had proved the pleaded representation to a sufficient degree of precision. The court also determined that the primary judge's calculation of damages was flawed due to the lack of expert evidence and the absence of a pleaded claim for loss of chance. Furthermore, the court held that the primary judge did not err in deciding to permanently stay related proceedings, as the two sets of proceedings were inseparably connected, and the primary judge's decision did not impermissibly elevate the overarching purpose of practice and procedure provisions.

The final orders of the court were to grant leave to appeal, dismiss the appeal, and order the applicants to pay the respondents’ costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal. This decision underscores the importance of precision in pleading representations and the necessity of expert evidence in determining damages for misleading or deceptive conduct. Additionally, it highlights the court's cautious approach to permanently staying related proceedings unless there is a clear abuse of process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants be granted leave to appeal.

2. The appeal be dismissed.

3. The applicants pay the respondents’ costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In my view, for the reasons which follow, leave ought to be granted and the appeal allowed.Background facts The primary judge set out the relevant background facts concerning Lantrak 1 and Lantrak 2: PJ [6]–[56]. No issue was taken with the accuracy of his Honour’s summary. To put what follows in context, it is necessary to set out some aspects of the background, which was more fully set out by the primary judge.The parties and the claims advanced in the two proceedings Lantrak 1 concerned the terms on which a business venture involving Mr Yammine (and his corporate interests) and Mr Liemant (and his family’s corporate interests) came to an end. The parties to Lantrak 1 were Mr Yammine and NJA Pty Ltd (NJA) as trustee for the NJA Family Trust (a family trust of Mr Yammine). NJA held 50% of the shares in Lantrak NSW. The other 50% was held by Lantrak Holdings, a family vehicle of Mr Liemant and his brother Mark Liemant. In Lantrak 1, Mr Yammine and NJA claimed that, in addition to the sum of $13 million which Lantrak Holdings agreed to pay to purchase the Yammine interests’ shares in Lantrak NSW pursuant to a written agreement entered into on 12 November 2018 (ie the SPA), Mr Yammine had agreed with Mr Liemant that the Yammine interests would be paid an additional $22 million, being the balance of what was said to have been the original price ($35 million) agreed under non-binding Heads of Agreement entered into in September 2018. The first claim advanced in Lantrak 1 was for breach of that alleged oral collateral contract. The second claim advanced in Lantrak 1 asserted that the Liemant interests were estopped from resiling from a promise to pay the Yammine interests the further sum of $22 million. The third claim advanced in Lantrak 1 asserted misleading or deceptive conduct on the basis that, prior to entry into the SPA, Lantrak Holdings and Mr Liemant represented to the Yammine interests that they would honour the earlier Heads of Agreement and would pay the balance of the original price attributable to the Yammine Interests’ shares, namely $35 million. The fourth, and final, claim advanced in Lantrak 1 was an alternative claim that, on or about 11 October 2019, Lantrak Holdings and Mr Liemant agreed to pay Mr Yammine $10 million for entry into a “non-compete” for a period of 10 years. As the primary judge observed (PJ [35]), the claims advanced in Lantrak 1 related to the “dissolution of the commercial relationship between the Yammine and Liemant interests that found expression in the business of Lantrak NSW”. Whereas Lantrak 1 concerned the dissolution of the commercial relationship, three of the four claims advanced in Lantrak 2 concerned the commencement of that relationship, and the fourth concerned the operation of that relationship. The applicants in Lantrak 2 were Mr Yammine, NJA and Recycling and Transport Solutions Pty Ltd (RTS), which was another Yammine corporate vehicle. Prior to late 2016, RTS operated an earthmoving and landfill business in New South Wales. The business of RTS was transferred to Lantrak NSW — the 50:50 Yammine/Liemant vehicle — in early 2017.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicants advanced six grounds of appeal, as follows:1. The primary judge:[(a) and (c) were deleted](b) erred by applying too broad a test when considering the circumstances necessary for an abuse of process, in particular by elevating to a determinative factor the question whether the conduct of the Appellants in commencing the second proceeding was inconsistent with the objectives expressed in s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia 1976 (Cth). 2. The primary judge:(a) erred in finding (at [35] and [71]) that in the first proceeding the alleged terms of the dissolution of the commercial relationship between the Yammine and Liement interests were based in part on the profits earned by the Lantrak NSW business;(b) erred in finding (at [70]) that there was “significant overlap” in the material facts, being the profits of the Lantrak NSW Business, between the Appellants’ breach of fiduciary duty and unjust enrichment claims in the second proceeding and the Applicants’ claims in the first proceeding (other than the non-compete claim);(c) should have found that:(i)in the first proceeding, the alleged terms of the dissolution of the commercial relationship between the Yammine and Liement[sic] interests were based in part on the EBIT (earnings before interest and tax) of Lantrak NSW; and (ii) in the second proceeding, it will be necessary for the court to determine the net profits of Lantrak NSW (or its business), as opposed to its EBIT, in order to determine the Appellants’ entitlement to dividends from Lantrak NSW, their claim for the $3 million component of the $5 million purchase price for the RTS Business, their breach of fiduciary duty claims, and their account of profits claims.3. In considering whether to stay the second proceeding on the grounds that it constituted an abuse of process, the primary judge erred in not placing any, or sufficient, weight on the following circumstances:(a) the parties in the first proceeding and second proceeding were different as set out at [6] to [8];(b) the Appellants’ claims in the second proceeding, and the relief they seek in the second proceeding, as set out at [14] to [27] are substantially different to the claims of the Applicants in the first proceeding and the relief the Applicants seek in the first proceeding as set out at [30] to [36];(c) the Appellants’ claims in the second proceeding as set out at [14] to [27] will not be determined in the first proceeding;(d) the Appellants’ claims in the second proceeding do not arise from precisely the same facts as the claims in the first proceeding as the court found at [69];(e) in the second proceeding, the Appellants will need to adduce evidence not adduced in the first proceeding and will need to adduce evidence from witnesses who did not give evidence in the first proceeding;(f) insofar as there will be an overlap in the evidence in the first proceeding and the second proceeding, the overlapping evidence was relevant only “by way of context” and to “witnesses’ credit and [the First Appellant’s] stated usual or common manner of doing business” in the first proceeding as referred to at [71] but will be directly relevant to the facts in issue in the second proceeding;(g) the Appellants did not obtain a “forensic advantage” by not bringing their claims in the first proceeding or by not commencing the second proceeding in sufficient time for the first proceeding and the second proceeding to be heard together as the court referred to at [94];(h) the Appellants did not engage in “tactical manoeuvring” in a “pejorative sense” by not bringing their claims in the first proceeding or commencing the second proceeding in sufficient time for the first proceeding and the second proceeding to be heard together as the court found at [95]; and (i) before the first proceeding was brought to completion, the Appellants had informed the Respondents that the claims the subject of the second proceeding were yet to be resolved as referred to at [56].4. The primary judge erred in finding at [99]:(a) the second proceeding constituted an unjustifiable oppression of the Respondents to the second proceeding;(b) the second proceeding serves to bring the administration of justice into disrepute;(c) the second proceeding constituted an abuse of process; and (d) the second proceeding should be permanently stayed.5. Having regard to the matters in paragraph 3 above, the primary judge should have found:(a) the second proceeding was not so unfairly and unjustifiably oppressive, or did not involve unacceptable injustice or unfairness, to the Respondents to the second proceeding as to constitute an abuse of process;(b) the second proceeding did not constitute an unjustifiable oppression of the Respondents to the second proceeding;(c) the second proceeding did not serve to bring the administration of justice into disrepute; and (d) the second proceeding should not be permanently stayed.6. Alternatively to paragraph 5 above, the primary judge erred in finding that, on the facts before the Court:(a) the Appellants bringing their $5 million claim in the second proceeding set out at [21] and [22] constituted an abuse of process; and (b) that claim should be permanently stayed. Whether leave to appeal is required: interlocutory or final decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.