Mining Standards International Pty Ltd v Atlantic Nickel Mineracao Ltda (No 2)
Link copied
CaseCopied
48 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Mining Standards International Pty Ltd v Atlantic Nickel Mineracao Ltda (No 2) [2024] FCA 666
File number:
QUD 355 of 2021
Judgment of:
DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment:
24 June 2024
Catchwords:
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether proceedings ought to be permanently stayed as an abuse of process – where earlier proceedings had been brought against applicant by the cross-respondents – where complaints made that applicant did not bring claims now raised as a cross-claim in the earlier proceedings – where applicant was financially unable to pursue any cross-claim – where applicant was transparent about its intention to pursue further claims – where relief sought in earlier proceedings was confined – where two proceedings concern different issues – abuse of process not established
Convention on the Taking of Evidence Abroad in Civil or Commercial Matters, opened for signature 18 March 1970, 847 UNTS 231 (entered into force 7 October 1972)
Cases cited:
Aavelaid v Dental Board of New South Wales (New South Wales Court of Appeal, Mason P, Meagher and Beazley JJA, 16 October 1998)
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mining Standards International Pty Ltd v Atlantic Nickel Min... and more:
Mining Standards International Pty Ltd (MSI) brought proceedings against Atlantic Nickel Mineracao Ltda (Atlantic Nickel) concerning an agreement for sale of assets (ASA). The dispute arose from an earlier proceeding where MSI claimed against the cross-respondents for the purported termination of the ASA. The current proceedings concern MSI's claims against Atlantic Nickel for breach of contract, inducing breach of contract, and unconscionable conduct. The central legal issue was whether the current proceedings constituted an abuse of process. The court had to consider the facts and circumstances surrounding the earlier proceedings, the intentions and conduct of MSI, and the distinct nature of the claims in the current proceedings.
The court found that the current proceedings did not constitute an abuse of process. It held that the earlier proceedings and the current proceedings concerned different issues and parties. The court emphasised that MSI had been transparent about its intention to pursue further claims against Atlantic Nickel. The court also noted that MSI was financially unable to bring cross-claims in the earlier proceedings. The court found that the relief sought in the earlier proceedings was confined and did not prevent MSI from bringing the current proceedings. The court held that the weight of relevant factors led to the conclusion that no abuse arose.
The court dismissed the applications to stay the proceedings permanently. It held that the current proceedings were not an abuse of process and should proceed. The court also ordered that the parties be heard on the question of costs and listed the matter for a case management hearing. The court concluded that the current proceedings should not be stayed and allowed them to continue.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The respondent’s interlocutory application dated 9 June 2023 be dismissed.
2. The third and fourth cross-respondent’s interlocutory application dated 9 June 2023 be dismissed.
3. The parties are to be heard on the question of costs.
4. The matter be listed for a case management hearing at 10:30 am on 10 July 2024.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The determination of whether the present proceedings constitute an abuse of process requires a broad-based consideration of the facts of the case, taking into account the affected public and private interests. For the reasons that follow, the weight of relevant factors leads to the conclusion that no abuse arises and, for that reason, the applications to stay the proceedings should be dismissed.BACKGROUND FACTS Atlantic Nickel was formerly known as Mirabela Mineracao Do Brasil Ltda, and for that reason it is sometimes referred to in correspondence between the parties as “MMB”. It will be referred to as Atlantic Nickel in these reasons. The major asset of Atlantic Nickel is the Santa Rita nickel mine in Bahia, Brazil. Until about July 2018, more than 99.99% (being 1,284,076,317) of the quotas in Atlantic Nickel were held by Mirabela Nickel Ltd (MBN), and the balance (being 2 quotas) were held by Mirabela Investments Pty Ltd (MBI), which was, itself, wholly owned by MBN (together being the Sellers). As at 10 November 2017, Atlantic Nickel owed substantial debts, including AUD12.7 million and USD488.7 million to MBN pursuant to various loan agreements, and as at July 2018, it owed approximately USD47 million to Banco Bradesco S.A. (Bradesco), a Brazilian bank. Additionally, it appears that Atlantic Nickel, MBN and MBI were indebted to Certes CT Pty Ltd (formerly AET Structured Finance Services Pty Ltd) (AET) as trustee for the Australian Mirabela Security Trust, in the sum of (at least) USD129.2 million, which debt was secured over all the property and undertakings of MBN and MBI (and is otherwise known as the “Noteholder Debt”). On about 28 October 2015, the Receivers were appointed by AET to the assets of the Sellers, including the quotas and the loan to Atlantic Nickel (the Assets). In late August 2017, the Receivers sought bids for the purchase of the quotas and the loan. Bids were subsequently received from, inter alia, MSI and Appian Capital Advisory LLP on behalf of the Appian Natural Resources Fund (Appian). At all relevant times, Mr Walter Milbourne Junior was the director and controlling mind of MSI. MSI was the successful bidder and on 1 November 2017, a written agreement was executed by the Sellers, the Receivers and Mr Milbourne on behalf of MSI for the sale of the Assets by MBN and MBI to MSI. Atlantic Nickel, which was also a party to the agreement, executed that agreement on 10 November 2017. For convenience, the agreement will hereinafter be referred to as the “ASA”. The terms of the ASA The terms of the ASA relevantly included the following: (a)On the Completion Date, as identified in cl 7.1, the Sellers were to sell the Assets to MSI for USD50 million and MBN was to assign the loan to MSI.(b)The Sellers’ obligation to transfer the Assets, and MSI’s obligation to pay for them, were subject to certain conditions precedent (the Conditions Precedent). They included:(i)by cl 2.1(b), MSI obtaining the consent of Bradesco, being a lender to which Atlantic Nickel was indebted (the Bradesco Condition); and(ii)by cl 2.1(f), MSI executing binding finance agreements for an amount equal to USD50 million, and satisfying all conditions precedent under those finance agreements (the Finance Condition).(c)By cl 2.2(a), each party was obliged to use all reasonable endeavours to ensure that each Condition Precedent was satisfied as soon as practicable after the date of the ASA and, in any event, before the “End Date”, which was defined to mean 90 days after the date of the ASA or any other date agreed in writing between the Sellers and MSI.(d)By cl 2.2(b), the Sellers and Atlantic Nickel were obliged to provide all reasonable assistance requested by MSI to satisfy the Conditions Precedent, including providing all reasonable access to the business and employees of Atlantic Nickel, and facilitating access by MSI to Bradesco.(e)By cl 2.5, any party was entitled to terminate the ASA by notice to the other parties if:(i)the terminating party had complied with its obligations under clause 2.2; and(ii)the Finance Condition was not satisfied by the date which was 14 days after the date of the exchange of signed copies of the ASA.(f)Clause 2.6(c) of the ASA provided:Between the date of this agreement and the earlier of Completion and termination of this agreement the Sellers and the Company must not, and must procure that any employees of the Company do not:(i) provide information regarding the Assets to any potential purchaser of the Assets other than the Buyer; or (ii) solicit any offers for the Assets from any person other than the Buyer.(g)Pursuant to cl 3, MSI was to pay MBN a deposit of USD100,000 within 7 days of the exchange of signed copies of the ASA.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
MSI later amended its defence to indicate that it did not intend to bring proceedings in the form of the draft statement of claim with the result that there was no issue between the parties, and the plaintiffs were not entitled to the negative declaration which was sought. The application to obtain evidence in Singapore On 12 December 2019, the plaintiffs in the WA Proceedings filed a summons seeking an order, pursuant to the Convention on the Taking of Evidence Abroad in Civil or Commercial Matters, opened for signature 18 March 1970, 847 UNTS 231 (entered into force 7 October 1972) and s 110(1)(c) of the Evidence Act 1906 (WA), that the Court issue a letter of request to the judicial authorities of Singapore. This was directed to obtaining evidence from a Mr Socrates Economou (who resided in Switzerland), or alternatively, the Proper Officer of Trafigura Pte Lte (Trafigura), being the entity from which MSI claimed it would have been able to secure finance for the purposes of completing the ASA. That application was refused by Hill J on 22 January 2020, who considered that it would involve “both parties incurring substantial costs and delay the resolution of the proceedings”: Mirabela Nickel Ltd (in liquidation) (receivers and managers appointed) v Mining Standards International Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 4. On 6 February 2020, the Receivers filed an appeal from Hill J’s decision. Before this Court, MSI submitted that had the Receivers’ appeal been successful, and discovery proceedings were commenced in Singapore, the WA Proceedings would not have been set down for some time. In the circumstances, that submission is self-evidently correct and should be accepted. An email from Russells to Mr Milbourne of 6 February 2020 reveals that MSI’s response to the plaintiffs’ appeal was that the relevant defence, which prompted the Receivers’ application to obtain evidence from Singapore, should be abandoned. The rationale given was that the defence would only arise if MSI was wrong about the date from which the Receivers were entitled to terminate the ASA, and that it was not worth the cost and delay associated with the appeal process. On 12 February 2020, MSI filed an amended defence in which it elided the allegation that the purported termination of the ASA was invalid and of no effect because the Sellers and Receivers failed to comply with their obligations under cl 2.2. This had the effect of removing the issue which might have rendered the discovery from Singapore relevant. The result of this was that the appeal was abandoned, and orders were made, by consent, to this effect on 4 March 2020. Public examination of Mr Milbourne A public examination of Mr Milbourne occurred between 24 and 26 June 2020. He was examined on a number of topics, including the financial position of him and MSI, MSI’s intention to seek specific performance of the ASA or damages, MSI’s litigation funding agreement in respect of the WA Proceedings, and several other matters. The WA Proceedings listed for hearing and late discovery
Decision
Reasons for decision
The hearing of the WA Proceedings then took place on 10, 11, 14, 15 and 23 December 2020.The decision in the WA Proceedings The decision in the WA Proceedings was handed down on 3 March 2023 and supported by very lengthy reasons. Although the central issue was whether the Receivers and the Sellers had validly terminated the ASA on 22 or 23 November 2017 for non-satisfaction of the Finance Condition, the reasons show that the parties raised an array of other issues which overly complicated the real issue in dispute — a tendency which repeated itself in the present application. In Hill J’s very careful and thorough decision, her Honour held that: the ASA was entered into on 10 November 2017, when the last party executed it, such that the Finance Condition needed to be satisfied 14 days from that date; the time for satisfaction of the Finance Condition was not extended by agreement between the parties; MSI was not estopped from denying that the date on which the ASA was executed was 1 November 2017; the ASA had not been validly terminated; and MSI’s request for repayment of the deposit was not an acceptance of the validity of the purported termination. In substance, the conclusion was that the notice of termination issued by the Sellers and the Receivers was not efficacious. As a result of those conclusions, it was unnecessary for Hill J to deal with a number of additional contentions which the parties had raised. Whilst this was recognised by her Honour, some obiter observations were made in relation to several issues. On 19 May 2023, Hill J made orders dismissing the plaintiffs’ claims. The current proceedings against Atlantic Nickel Whilst the WA Proceedings were reserved before Hill J, on 1 November 2021, MSI filed an originating application and accompanying statement of claim in this Court to commence these proceedings (which will be referred to as the “current proceedings”). In general terms, MSI makes claims against Atlantic Nickel for:(a)damages for Atlantic Nickel’s breach of contract;(b)further or alternatively, damages for inducing a breach of contract by the Receivers and the Sellers;(c)further or alternatively, damages under s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law (being Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) for contravention by Atlantic Nickel of s 21, namely the prohibition against unconscionable conduct; and(d)further or alternatively, damages under s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law for loss caused by Atlantic Nickel being involved in a contravention of s 21 by the Receivers and the Sellers. An amended statement of claim was filed on 18 March 2022. In substance, MSI’s allegations are to the effect that Atlantic Nickel, the Receivers and the Sellers failed to observe the obligations in the ASA to provide reasonable assistance to MSI or to act so as to give it the benefit of the agreed terms. It is specifically alleged that their conduct prevented MSI from securing finance to complete the purchase and, further, that they breached the obligation not to deal with third parties whilst the ASA was on foot. The pleading sets out, in some length, the terms of several letters, emails, text messages, and telephone conversations in support of the allegations.