New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: FRUMAR v THE OWNERS OF STRATA PLAN 36957 [2010] NSWCA 172 HEARING DATE(S): 21/07/2010
JUDGMENT DATE:
16 September 2010JUDGMENT OF: Giles JA at 1; Macfarlan JA at 20; Handley AJA at 21 DECISION: (1) Appeal allowed with costs.
(2) Judgment of the District Court of 18 December 2009 set aside.
(3) In lieu thereof substitute judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $101,815.51 including pre-judgment interest with effect from 26 July 2010 and costs.
(4) The respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if qualified.CATCHWORDS: COSTS -- assessment -- certificate -- taken to be judgment when filed in Court -- certificate set aside on appeal -- effect on judgment - JUDGMENTS & ORDERS -- permanent stay of judgment -- effect - LEGAL PRACTITIONERS -- costs -- assessment -- certificate -- taken to be judgment when filed in Court -- certificate set aside on appeal -- effect on judgment - RESTITUTION -- moneys paid under judgment based on costs certificate -- certificate set aside on appeal -- costs respondent entitled to restitution of moneys paid pending fresh assessment LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act, s 135
Legal Profession Act 1987, s 208KF(1)CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Allanson v Midland Credit Ltd (1977) 30 FLR 108
Beswicke v Alner [1926] VLR 72
Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (No 1) [1980] HCA 41, 147 CLR 35
TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v Antoniadis [No 2] (1999) 48 NSWLR 381 CA
Production Spray Painting and Panel Beating Pty Ltd v Newnham [No 2] (1992) 27 NSWLR 659 CA
R v P (No 2) [2003] NSWCA 360
Re Marks ex parte The Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders Labourers Federation (1981) 55 ALJR 395
Stollmeyer v Trinidad Lake Petroleum Co [1918] AC 498PARTIES: A - Geoffrey Craig Frumar
R - The Owners of Strata Plan 36957FILE NUMBER(S): CA 2010/4387 COUNSEL: A - J Knackstredt
R - EGH CoxSOLICITORS: A - Geoffrey C Frumar & Associates
R - HWL Ebsworth LawyersLOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 3137/2009 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Curtis DCJ LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 18/12/2009
2010/4387
Thursday 16 September 2010Giles JA
Macfarlan JA
Handley AJA
FRUMAR v THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN No 36957
CATCHWORDS
COSTS -- assessment -- certificate -- taken to be judgment when filed in Court -- certificate set aside on appeal -- effect on judgment
JUDGMENTS & ORDERS -- permanent stay of judgment -- effect
LEGAL PRACTITIONERS -- costs -- assessment -- certificate -- taken to be judgment when filed in Court -- certificate set aside on appeal -- effect on judgment
RESTITUTION -- moneys paid under judgment based on costs certificate -- certificate set aside on appeal -- costs respondent entitled to restitution of moneys paid pending fresh assessment
HEADNOTE
The appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of an action in the District Court. The respondent's costs were reassessed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Frumar v The Owners of Strata Plan 36957 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NSWCA 172
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was the consequence of setting aside a costs certificate, which had been filed and taken to be a judgment of the court, on the judgment that had been entered. This also raised the question of whether the respondent was entitled to restitution of moneys paid under that judgment.
The Court of Appeal reasoned that once the costs certificate was set aside, the basis for the District Court's judgment was removed. Consequently, the judgment itself was vitiated. The court applied the principle that where a judgment is based on a document that is subsequently invalidated, the judgment cannot stand. Therefore, the court found that the respondent was entitled to restitution of the moneys paid under the original judgment, pending a fresh assessment of costs.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the District Court's judgment of 18 December 2009, and substituted a judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $101,815.51, including pre-judgment interest, with effect from 26 July 2010, together with costs. The respondent was also granted a certificate under the *Suitors Fund Act* if qualified.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Appeal allowed with costs.
(2) Judgment of the District Court of 18 December 2009 set aside.
(3) In lieu thereof substitute judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $101,815.51 including pre-judgment interest with effect from 26 July 2010 and costs.
(4) The respondent is to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if qualified.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appeal was heard, and the Supreme Court found that the District Court had erred in its assessment of costs. Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the District Court's judgment and the accompanying costs certificate. Following this decision, Mr. Frumar applied for an order that the defendants should be permanently stayed from enforcing the original judgment. The defendants, however, sought restitution of the moneys they had paid into court pending the outcome of the appeal. The defendants argued that since the costs certificate had been set aside, they were entitled to the return of the moneys paid under the erroneous judgment.
The Supreme Court considered these applications and determined that the appeal had been allowed with costs. The original judgment of the District Court was set aside, and in its place, a new judgment was issued in favour of Mr. Frumar in the sum of $101,815.51 including pre-judgment interest from a specified date. Additionally, the court ordered that the defendants were to be permanently stayed from enforcing the original judgment. Finally, the court ruled that the defendants were entitled to restitution of the moneys paid into court, as the costs certificate had been set aside on appeal. If qualified, the defendants were to receive a new certificate under the Suitors Fund Act.
The matter of Frumar v The Owners of Strata Plan 36957 originated as an action in the District Court of New South Wales. The proceedings were brought by Frumar against The Owners of Strata Plan 36957, concerning a dispute that primarily revolved around costs. The District Court entered a judgment in favour of Frumar on 18 December 2009, which included an assessment of costs certified by a solicitor. This certificate was taken as a judgment when filed in the Court, leading to the payment of a sum of money by The Owners of Strata Plan 36957. Following the entry of this judgment, The Owners of Strata Plan 36957 appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, challenging the costs certificate. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and set aside the original judgment on the grounds that the certificate was flawed. Consequently, the original judgment was vacated and a permanent stay of judgment was ordered pending a fresh assessment of costs.
Subsequent to the setting aside of the initial judgment and costs certificate, the matter returned to the District Court for a re-assessment of the costs. Following this re-assessment, a new judgment was entered in favour of Frumar, with a revised sum of $101,815.51 including pre-judgment interest. This judgment was then appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales by The Owners of Strata Plan 36957. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the District Court's judgment, and substituted a new judgment for Frumar. The Supreme Court also ordered that The Owners of Strata Plan 36957 be entitled to restitution of the moneys previously paid under the now set-aside costs certificate, pending a fresh assessment. The appeal was ultimately allowed with costs, and the respondent was directed to obtain a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if qualified.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does a certificate issued under the Suitors Fund Act, which is taken to be a judgment when filed in Court, retain its status as a judgment when set aside on appeal?
2. What is the effect on a judgment where the original certificate has been set aside on appeal, and how does this impact the subsequent assessment of costs?
3. Can a party who has paid moneys under a judgment based on a costs certificate that has been set aside on appeal claim restitution of those moneys pending a fresh assessment?
4. What are the implications of a permanent stay of judgment on the costs and restitution claims in this case?
5. How should the court proceed in issuing a new judgment and ordering costs in lieu of the previously set aside judgment?
Held
1. Does a certificate issued under the Suitors Fund Act, which is taken to be a judgment when filed in Court, retain its status as a judgment when set aside on appeal? The court concluded that a certificate set aside on appeal does not retain its status as a judgment; appeal allowed with costs.
2. What is the effect on a judgment where the original certificate has been set aside on appeal, and how does this impact the subsequent assessment of costs? The court held that the set aside of the certificate affects the judgment, necessitating a fresh assessment of costs; judgment set aside with effect.
3. Can a party who has paid moneys under a judgment based on a costs certificate that has been set aside on appeal claim restitution of those moneys pending a fresh assessment? The court ruled that the respondent is entitled to restitution of moneys paid pending a fresh assessment of costs.
4. What are the implications of a permanent stay of judgment on the costs and restitution claims in this case? The court determined that a permanent stay of judgment impacts both costs and restitution claims, leading to the issuance of a new judgment and order for costs in lieu.
5. How should the court proceed in issuing a new judgment and ordering costs in lieu of the previously set aside judgment? The court ordered the issuance of a new judgment for the plaintiff with specified costs, effective from a particular date, and allowed the respondent to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if qualified.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Frumar v The Owners of Strata Plan 36957, the court addressed several intricate issues surrounding the status and implications of a certificate issued under the Suitors Fund Act, which had been set aside on appeal. The central issue was whether the certificate, once set aside, retained any status as a judgment when filed in Court, and what consequences this had for the assessment of costs and the possibility of restitution for moneys paid under the now-set-aside judgment.
The court began by examining the nature of the certificate in question. Under the Suitors Fund Act, a certificate is treated as a judgment when filed in Court, but the court had to determine if this status continued post-appeal. The court held that when the certificate was set aside on appeal, it lost its status as a judgment. This decision was based on the principle that an appeal has the effect of nullifying the original judgment, effectively starting the proceedings anew. The court relied on established authorities that a set-aside judgment has no further legal force, which meant that the certificate could not continue to be treated as a judgment.
Moving to the second issue, the court explored the ramifications of the set-aside certificate on the original judgment and the subsequent assessment of costs. The court held that the original judgment was nullified by the setting aside of the certificate, and as such, any costs assessed under the now-defunct judgment were also nullified. This decision followed from the principle that costs follow the judgment, and without a valid judgment, there could be no valid costs order. The court’s approach aligned with precedents that emphasized the necessity of a valid judgment to support a costs order.
The third issue was whether the respondent could claim restitution of moneys paid under the judgment based on the now-set-aside certificate. The court determined that since the original judgment had been set aside, the respondent was entitled to restitution of the moneys paid under that judgment pending a fresh assessment. This decision was grounded in the principle of restitution, which seeks to prevent unjust enrichment. The court relied on cases that held that where a party has paid moneys under a now-void judgment, they are entitled to restitution pending a new assessment.
Addressing the implications of a permanent stay of judgment, the court concluded that such a stay had the effect of suspending all costs and restitution claims until a new judgment was issued. The court held that the stay effectively put the proceedings on hold, preventing any further action on the costs or restitution claims until the matter was resolved through a new judgment. This interpretation was consistent with the purpose of a stay, which is to halt proceedings until the underlying issues are resolved.
Finally, the court addressed how it should proceed in issuing a new judgment and ordering costs in lieu of the previously set aside judgment. The court issued a new judgment in favor of the plaintiff, specifying the amount including pre-judgment interest, effective from a certain date. The court also ordered that the respondent should be granted a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if qualified. This approach was designed to ensure that the proceedings were concluded in a manner that was fair and in accordance with the law, providing a clear path forward for the parties involved. The court’s decision was consistent with the principle that a new judgment must be issued to replace the set aside one and that costs should be assessed afresh to reflect the new circumstances.
In summary, the court’s reasoning and ratio decidendi in this case were that a certificate set aside on appeal does not retain its status as a judgment, nullifying the original judgment and any costs assessed thereunder. The court further held that a party who has paid moneys under such a set-aside judgment is entitled to restitution pending a fresh assessment. The implications of a permanent stay of judgment were to suspend all costs and restitution claims until a new judgment is issued. The court’s approach in issuing a new judgment and ordering costs was to ensure a fair resolution of the proceedings in accordance with the law.